Wow wow wow! This restaurant had the most amazing food and the best pizza I have ever had! We started with the green chili cheese dip and then had the wings. We were practically licking the bowl to get every last drop. Then we moved on to the Hawaiian pizza. 100% I will be back. I didn't take any pictures because the food didn't make it that long lol. read more

Great place to eat! We had the wings and pizza. Both were delicious. We also had a the orange bitters drink and the pickle tickle. Really good read more

Old County Inn - Wood fired wings - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

We stopped in for lunch right as they opened. It was empty but filled up as we ate. Some of our food was disappointing. The buffalo cauliflower was soggy. The AZ Greens salad was huge but only came with one tiny black cup 1/2 full of dressing. Not nearly enough for the size of the salad. They charged for additional dressing (even when it's for the salad). The roasted veggie pizza was bland. The green chili beer cheese was runny but tasty. My husband loved the Meat Pie. Our waitress was super busy and never had time to check on us so we had to find someone to bring us silverware, refills on our drinks, etc. Overall, it was disappointing. Based on the other reviews that is not what most people experience so maybe it was an off day. read more

"What's a dazzling pizza like you doing in a rustic setting like this?" With apologies to Mel Brooks, this is ridiculously good pizza (and salads) in lil' ol' Pine AZ. I am super picky, and most other pizzas suck. This is one of these reviews to hesitate to write because they're already so busy. My good buddy hit the lottery- he lives walking distance from here. We absolutely devoured and Arizona Greens salad and a Pancho pizza. Both delicious. Plan your Payson / Pine / Strawberry visit around at least one meal here, ideally mid-week at off hours to ensure that you get seated and fed promptly. Spoke to the manager and he told me that the owner is friends with Chris Bianco (of PHX fame). That's a good friend to have in the pizza biz! read more

You will need to wait, but the pizza is all that!!! We celebrated my husband's birthday here and waited for a very long time, but the wings were the best I've had, and the pizza!!! I loved their burrata pizza the best. They also have the gluten free option which was extremely import for our daughter. Thank you for a great experience. Glad the patio had heater because it was chilly!!! If you're in Pine or nearby... YOU MUST try it! read more

Old County Inn - Pizza menagerie. - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

Pizzas were delicious, patio views were beautiful, and service by Travis was amazing!

Just when I thought I could not find good food in the middle of nowhere. I stumbled upon this amazing pizza place with the best margarita 2023!!! Wow! The pizzas and salad were amazing and it is a great place to relax have cocktail or wine with some seriously great pizza. The blood orange Prosecco was amazing as well. So if you're ever in Pine, Arizona this is a must!!! read more

See all

The food is amazing- pizza is better than anything I know of in Peoria/phoenix. I would recommend this joint to anybody- amazing read more

See all

Service was great! Pizza money like usual, green chiles+ bacon. It's our go to place when we have company at cabin. Grandkids always love seeing the Elk! Jeff G read more

If you are up north visiting the payson/mogollon rim area you have to stop and try this place. I saw the good reviews and was a bit skeptical because of the location but wanted to give it a try. I was visiting pine with a group of friends and decided that this was the perfect time to give it a try. After a hike we stopped in at the tavern for a beer. Great vibes in there I can't recommend enough. My buddy had a great conversation with the bartender about the local sasquatch lore. Because of this great interaction we decided to come back for dinner. A bit skeptical we walked down to eat. We had a large party of 8 and it was a 30 minute wait. Usually this would be an issue but with a beautiful patio, cornhole, and bar access we enjoyed a beautiful sunset waiting for our table. Once the table was ready we sat down swiftly and were ready to order. The waitress was great accommodating a large group. We ordered 4 pizzas for the table and they were all amazing. The clam was the best pizza and is a must try. Pesto, lemon, calabrian chili is a party in your mouth convo. The crust on the pizza is well structured but still has a flop. 40% half chub vibes. The whole group agreed that it was a great decision to eat here. Great food, great drinks, and great vibes. Overall I would 100% recommend coming here if you are in the area. The wait is worth it and you will not regret it. read more

See all

Food was yummy. Place was very family & dog friendly. They were busy for Mother's Day weekend and the staff were so friendly still.

We were seated fairly quickly, but after that things went downhill. We ended up waiting about an hour and a half just for a Caesar salad and a couple of pizzas. The pizza was decent, but overall it just wasn't worth the long wait. read more

Always the best pizza the one with ricotta is the best!!! The drinks are great too and it's a fun atmosphere for kids! read more

Old County Inn - Three fabulous cocktail from the menu - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

Fantastic food, fantastic, outdoor setting, great service, I can tell why everyone calls this place a five star in the middle of nowhere!! Pizzas are what they are known for & they can customize to GF. Live band on Friday and Saturday nights at 6pm. Highly recommend this spot if in pine/strawberry read more

Old County Inn - Veggie cauliflower crust - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

See all

Food 5 star service 3 star I have never seen such chaos at a place before . People going all over the place. chaotic. It took 1 hour to be seated took 1 hour to get the pizza . With all the people - 1 mens restrrom and 1 woman's both with a line. They do have porta John outside. read more

Parking is tight for 23 foot long vehicles but they make up for that by having a dog friendly patio. Parmesan shakers did not equal the number of tables, a common problem for restaurants. The number one restaurant in town according to Pine residents. Surprisingly finished third with residents of Strawberry though. 5 stars read more

Amazing wings and pizza. Coming in from out of town, and it was great experience to grab some grub. Nice people, good food. Beautiful surroundings. read more

Severely disappointed. My husband and I saw the great reviews and were looking forward to trying the pizza and wings. We ordered a pizza and wings at 5pm and was told it would be an hour and they would call us once our order was done. It was cold and rainy so we decided to go back to our cabin and wait. By 6:30 we still had not heard from them. Me being hangry and pregnant decided to go down there to see what was going on since no one was answering the phone. When we arrived they said "oh it's ready I haven't had time to call". I understand being busy on a Saturday evening but we paid $60 for a cold and soggy pizza and wings that had been sitting there for god knows how long. Would not recommend. read more

LITERALLY....the best pizza and bread sticks of our lives! All four of us agree this we've never had better pizza. The burratta pizza was from another planet! Orgasm in your mouth! I would drive to Pine from Gilbert just for this pizza. Our waitress Simone was wonderful. Great, friendly and fun service. We'll be back without a doubt! read more

Old County Inn - Burratta Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

See all

We finally were able to check out this spot, the pizza was fantastic, and service was great. Dog friendly!

I absolutely had a time, the wait was long but that's expected for a Saturday. The staff were super friendly and prompt. We did wait a while but when I spoke to the staff he was FULLY apologetic about the long wait an competed us some of our food since we had ordered at 2:01 and didn't get it until 2:40ish. The ticket didnt go to the kitchen. But we were not upset because they were upfront and honest. The food was delicious, came out hot and fresh. The pizza toppings were pretty good and the mixtures were delicious. We got chips, breadsticks, also the chicken strips but it was all good! I would definitely recommend trying out the hawaiian pizza and the chips they were seasoned really well. The dipping sauces were good too! We sat outside there were fans but there is a fireplace. But it was super clean, I noticed people brought their dogs to the outside patio which wasn't thay bad. They were very well mannered. I recommend if you go to try the cast iron cookie also the adult rootbeer float... omg! All of it was delicious. You'll thank me later. read more

This is always a stop for us when we head north. It is the best food in the area by far. Great pizza and we really enjoy the freshly baked chips and breadsticks. Can't wait to visit again soon. read more

It's really good food! If you like pizza and or just quality food then it's a NO BRAINER. Plus, they have a GREAT tasting room.

What a terrific establishment...if you are into excellent service, food, atmosphere and ice cold beer. Love this place!

We adventured to pine Arizona to old county inn just to get one of my favorite pizzas (pepperoni, this time for a simple pizza . Also, the meat pizza is amazing as well) and the green chile beer cheese dip with breadsticks (it has a little kick, but i, who can't handle much spicy, loves it, you will too). The dip is also good for dipping your pizza crust. It's all so fresh and good! Joyce, our server was great! She seemed to serve for many tables but was so attentive to all that we never seemed like we waited long for anything. It's such a cute little restaurant that has a small bar and indoor seating area with the majority of seating outside with heaters/fireplace for winter and fans for summer. It's also dog friendly, which is a bonus for us while traveling with dogs. The only downside it's a one bathroom stall type restaurant, which is kinda crazy when they are super busy and on the weekends they stay pretty busy none stop but don't let that stop you from trying out this amazing little firewood style pizza place in pine Arizona. Let us know if you go ! read more

See all

Just finished hiking Tonto National Bridge and needed to refuel. This place hits the spot with their wood fired pizzas and beer. We ordered wings and they were the full size ones. I wonder if it came from their chickens in their chicken coop... The outdoor patio is spacious and also really dog friendly. They had some outdoor games near the taproom next door. Our server was busy but efficient, and food came out quickly. This definitely was one of the better spots we ate at while visiting Pine, AZ. #supportlocal read more

Old County Inn - Hawaiian BBQ Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

Although it was pretty busy, we were sat within twenty minutes. Pizza took a bit, but it was understandable given the fact that it's wood-fired. My wife and I split the Pancho pizza and it was delicious. The staff were very friendly and accommodating and the establishment itself was pretty family friendly. There was music playing, but was at a volume that you could easily converse with those at your table. We came at night so the string lights were turned on - giving a relaxing mood. I would definitely recommend this place to those staying or passing through Pine! We will absolutely be coming back here! read more

The Pizza was very good. Loved the bread sticks. our daughter loved the buffalo cauliflower app. We also shared the cast iron cookie dessert. Server Garret was very busy and still was able to make sure everything went well. The hostess, bussers as well as the food runners were all friendly and did a great job. Ambiance is casual and family friendly. Was referred by a work associate and we will be back. read more

Busy place but the servers were on it! Food served quickly despite the crowd and hot too! I was so surprised to find the chef was a CIA graduate hiding up in this little town. The chicken wings are to die for. Smoky, spiced, moist, and huge. We opted for the classic Meat Pie which had a delicious crust but we wish we'd opted for something more adventurous. read more

See all

Giant and super delicious chicken wings. Burrata pizza is some of the best pizza to ever bless my mouth! It was pizza perfection! We drove 1.5 hours to eat here and it was very much worth it. read more

Old County Inn - Burrata pizza is phenomenal - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

See all

Great food! We were in from Scottsdale for a long weekend and this was our one meal out. The wood fired pizza was amazing (burrata was our family's fav), and we loved the buffalo cauliflower too. Good selection of beers on tap and dog friendly. Adding this to our must go list when in Payson or Pine. read more

This place was delicious! The pizza is about 8 slices. It was so flavorful and cooked perfectly! I enjoyed a blood orange beer too! Customer service was great! read more

The place appears to be busy all the time. Why? Because they have good food and many repeat customers. Because it is so busy, wait times could be long with the slow service. If you are in the mood for some good and tasty pizza, definitely try this place, but be prepared to wait up to 40 minutes or longer to get your pie. read more

Old County Inn - Lefty Woodfired Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

The pizza at Old County is top 3 in the state in my opinion. The ingredients mesh so well together and it always comes out fresh. This most recent visit, the pizza was exceptionally greasy, literally dripping with grease so I had to take a star off. That being said, this pizza is immaculate, a MUST TRY if you happen to find yourself in the Payson/Pine/Strawberry area. The cheese dip is good and the breadsticks are meh. The breadsticks are merely a vessel to guide the cheese dip to your mouth, and thus they serve their purpose well. FYI, ranch is on the sweeter side. read more

Old County Inn - Green Chile cheese dip and Breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

See all

Great little spot in the area! They have space heaters, fireplace, and blankets to help keep you warm on the patio. The kids loved the outdoor space. Our server had lots of tables, but was still very attentive and friendly. Had the beet salad, wings, portobello mushrooms, and a pepperoni pizza. All were deeeelish! Good beer and cocktail selection as well. read more

Old County Inn - Just Beet It - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

See all

Definitely a must eat at when visiting Pine. Food came out hot and fast. Can't wait to visit Pine again so I can eat there again. Loved everything about it. read more

My brother and I enjoyed the good food and service. The burrata pizza and chicken wings were delicious. My brother and I agreed that the chicken wings were probably the best we had ever had. Yami, our host and server, was personable and had us laughing. read more

Everyone raves about the pizza, so we had to give it a try- and would definitely recommend it! However, what really surprised me was the drink menu, everything from loaded Bloody Mary's to lavender gin spritzers- and they do it up! The outside patio is dog friendly, and most of the large tables outside are communal, so while you aren't right up next to someone, they are technically sharing the same long table. The upside is that most people seemed to be up for the day and as people on vacation tend to be, were quite friendly :) read more

Old County Inn - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

Such a nice place! We enjoyed the food and the setting very much. The staff was very friendly

We had a great experience here! We sat at the middle bar next to the pizza oven and loved watching them work! The drinks were spot on and the food was amazing. The beet salad was very, very good. read more

Old County Inn - Tappers! - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona