We decided to stop in here for a bite after the work day and we were very delighted! The restaurant itself is awesome. Great lighting and lovely colors. The guacamole and salsa were both delicious - as well as our margaritas. Our food came out fast and it was SO tasty. We are not from the area, but we will definitely be back! read more

One of the best Mexican restaurants in the area. Freshly made guacamole table side, traditional offerings as well as your usual Tex-Mex offerings. I prefer my food very spicy and they don't quite hit that mark but plenty of flavor overall. Wish they had fresh made tamales but alas no. Great service, good selection of tequilas and tasty margaritas. Not quite as good as some of the local Hispanic owned places, but much better than the likes of Los and the chain joints. read more

The food is amazing! Get the table side guacamole it is wonderful. The staff is always very polite and attentive. The carne asada tacos are the best I have had since moving here from SoCal. Highly recommend!! read more

After being told that my food would be ready in 15 minutes we saw that they had messed up the order. (It was a allergy) That wasnt a big deal. I ended up waiting about an hour for our food to come out. When I took it home to eat, I was shocked to find mold on my taco shell that could clearly be seen by the chef, on my second order! I am extremely disappointed. I don't recommend this restaurant to anybody for the safety of their health. read more

Old Mexico - Moldy tacos - Mexican Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

Best authentic Mexican restaurant on the West side in my opinion. Always get the fresh guacamole made at your table. Cool "Old Mexico" atmosphere. Efficient staff. read more

Easily the best place in the Green Bay Area. Drive the extra 20 min out of Green Bay it's worth it

I don't know when this little gem popped up, but I'm sure glad it did! Hands down the best Mexican food in Green Bay, finally! The salsa is the perfect amount of heat and flavor and the chips don't come out of a great value bag, a true rarity for the area. I had the lunch portion shredded beef chimi and it was easily a good size dinner portion in most places. The meat was seasoned perfectly and tasted like it had been slow roasting for days, to perfection! The service was absolutely impeccable and the decor makes you feel right at home in an authentic Mexican environment. My new go to spot! You won't be disappointed! read more

Best table side Guacamole we have ever had! Decent steak tacos. Overall nice atmosphere. Bright,vibrant colors attentive owner! Best Mexican restaurant atmosphere in greater GBay. I wish they could reflect that appeal on the exterior! read more

Very good food & service, still need to work a few kinks out but other than that it's a great restaurant.

We were visiting our family in Suamico and decided to order a pick up from this restaurant . I have eaten a lot of Mexican food in my lifetime and this had to be the worst Mexican food that I have ever eaten. I ordered a combination plate and I couldn't recognize any of the food that I ordered. Fortunately they didn't screw up the two tacos that I ordered for my granddaughter . When we ordered they told us 29 minutes. We waited 45 minutes . I would have rather have gone to Taco elk. At least they're consistent and you know what you're getting . This place was pathetic . I don't like to rip on a place, but they deserved it. read more

Food is decent. Queso is very good. Service is very poor. Some employees are very nice, others are not. Seems like it's very poorly managed. When I order takeout I get something different every time. Such as Queso includes chips sometimes and sometimes it doesn't. (How does queso ever not include chips) read more

A lot of staff training going on so a bit unorganized yet. Huge menu. Salsa, white cheese sauce & chips are served when you sit at your table. No spice to salsa but good flavor. I had the fajita quesadilla with steak. Was good flavor. My companion had the enchiladas verde with chicken. He wanted flour tortillas and we were charged $2 extra for that. Don't know why his plate had a lot of water on it also. Boiled chicken not drained? Asked for hot sauce and they brought out a salsa that had no flavor but had a bit more heat. That cost an extra $2 also. read more

Old Mexico - Fajita quesadilla with steak - Mexican Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

See all

Excellent food and drink. Friendly staff and owners! Love the Texas Margaritas! Clarify the size you want because he large is VERY large. Very good! Been here 2 nights in a row! read more

No authentic. Tex mex fair. Combination platters not include beans or rice. There are better places for Mexican fair.

It was really good I didn't like the rice as much but that's just because I am picky but over it's perfect.

I feel the food was not as fresh or flavorful as it could have been. The salsa is bland and the fajitas came out of kitchen without the sizzle. The ambiance is nice, but people come for good food. The kitchen needs to improve the food. I will try maybe once more and if no improvement, then I will stick with the other local joint. read more

Worst place ever! Literally so gross. There was a dead rat under my table and I'm pretty sure my server had a boner when he was taking my order. I think his name was Cody but I don't remember. My food was cold and had hair in it... Only reason I'm giving 1 star and not 0 is because the dishes were spotless. Give those dish washers a raise!!! Overall Terrible time wouldn't waste ur money there...fajita republic is right down the road though and their food is great! read more

Old Mexico is one of my favorite restaurants. The staff are always welcoming as soon as you walk in. The service is amazing, you can expect your food to come out fast even when it's busy. The menu has many food options to choose from, including many vegetarian options. They also have the best guac! read more

Food is excellent but a little pricey! Service is fast and servers are super nice! Been there on multiple occasions and wouldn't hesitate to go back. read more

My favorite Mexican restaurant. The guacamole is excellent and made to order, staff is friendly and prompt, even when busy and food is excellent. Can be very busy at peak times so reservations are recommended. We had to wait 45 minutes for a party of six. read more

This was our first time here and we thought it was excellent. It was very busy, but the food came out very fast and was delicious. I had the steak and chicken fajitas, which were very flavorful and had a generous amount of meat. The table side guacamole is a nice touch and we enjoyed the chunks of avocado and tomatoes. My only complaint is that it took around 15 minutes to get our first drink, but in their defense, it was very busy and there was only one bartender. Marco, our server, jumped in to help the bartender and then she was able to catch up. I would recommend Marco, as a server, as he has a great personality and is very attentive to his tables. We will definitely be back. read more

I only rate this a 4/5 because they don't have cow tongue, beef head, or cow intensities tacos but everything else was delicious. We got the burrito grande and the quesadilla fajita. Make sure to get the tableside guacamole, best guacamole in town! If you're a fan of hot and spicy make sure to ask for the hot salsa. It's a spicy chipotle habanero salsa that'll knock your socks off. Highly recommend and will come back for more! read more

Staff is friendly. Food is amazing. Margaritas are top notch. Homemade guacamole! Doesn't get better than that!

Food was good. BE AWARE THE TABLE SIDE GUACAMOLE IS NOT FREE!! Does not say on the cart that it costs extra nor does the individual making it tell you. Confusing because they provide free salsa and he has a tip jar. Otherwise we had the grande burrito and enchilada. Would have been 4.5 stars if it wasn't for a shady business practice that seemed to be done to all customers. read more

The restaurant was busy, but still got our food out in a good time. Had some options for picky kids. My wife and I both very much enjoyed our food and drinks. Will definitely be back! read more

Don't go here! Bad service and food. Will not be going back. The waitress forgot about us and took for ever before a waiter came to our table and took our order. Had 3 people and had to ask 3 different people for napkins and then only brought 2. read more

The food was OK. Definitely not the best or worst I've ever had. Very cute restaurant and decent service but mediocre food.