I'm not a New Yorker or New Jerseyan but I've had my fair share of NY style pizza and Secret Pizza took me back to the 212. I saw them take out a whole cheese pizza from the oven and immediately requested that fresh slice. Let me tell you, when I picked that bad boy up, folded it in half, and it kept that glorious and perfect stance (IYKYK) I knew it was going to be a heavenly pizza experience. Each bite was crisp with the right chew, and perfect sauce to cheese ratio. How cool that we have this gem in the NELA hood! And one more thing, do not leave without their incredible chocolate chip cookie! read more

Pride dictates that I point this out whenever I write this kind of review for pizza: I'm born and bred in NYC. I love pizza, and this pizza was EPIC. The ambiance is fun. 80s, east coast kitsch. Service was great, too. Friendly, informative, and proud of their work. Loved that. But the pizza was the SUPERSTAR. Amazing. Easily top three in Los Angeles which, for me, means Sonny's and Apollonia's, too. The crust was divine. Perfectly crisp. Perfect chew. The cheese and sauce were perfection. Phenomenal pepperoni. Loved the chocolate chip cookie. It was excellent, as was the vodka sauce we got for dipping. However, if you live and breathe, you owe it to yourself to eat this pizza. read more

See all

Definitely on my top 5 in LA list. Great vibe with an outdoor patio and a cute zen garden setting. Street parking isn't rough. Service is always friendly and helpful. You order at the counter and sit outside. Limited counter seating inside. The best part is they offer slices, so you can try many of their NY style thin crusts. Check the case for what's available as a slice. Tip: They also have square pies a la Detroit style. Tip: The pizza transports well and is great the next day. They have a decent cookie as well. Try their cheese, vodka, margherita, or pepperoni/sausage if you are feeling meaty. Kid friendly, and has a restroom on site. Definitely worth the pilgrimage. Tip: Combine with a visit to Hot Tongue pizza to make a great pizza crawl. read more

I had heard many good things about this joint and I finally tried it for myself. To be honest, this is just an average pizza for me - it sorta reminds me of something you would find at a fair. There's only one size available so that's a problem if it's just you. As you can see, the pizza is huge! Yes, you can buy slices but it makes more financial sense to buy a whole pizza. Next, this is not a "cheesy" pizza. So, if you like all that gooey cheese on your pizza, you're going to be disappointed here. The cheese is so minimal you may ask yourself if there's in fact any cheese on the pizza. The cheesy bread, however, will satisfy your desire for gooey cheese. Highly recommend you pick up a side of the bread. It reheats up nicely too. As pictured, there's inside and outside dining areas. I went when it just opened so there were only a few people dining. Parking here will not be easy. I was told that if you pass the residences, there is ample parking on a vacant lot. This is not the safest neighborhood so if you're a female and you're by yourself, you may not want to park that far and make that walk (especially at night). There is a Dollar Tree across the street with a lot, however, that establishment also tends to draw sketchy characters. So, if easy parking is one of you're requirements, you may want to pass on this place. All in all, this place was more hype and it left me craving that satisfying cheesiness that should be on a pizza. I definitely won't have this place on rotation when I get that pizza craving. No hate, I just love my pizza cheesy. ‍ read more

Secret Pizza - Photo of a pizza offered - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

See all

Have heard great things about Secret Pizza as it is our neighbors go to spot for NY style pies. Decided to head here on a Saturday evening as we were coming back from LAX. I've forgotten how bad traffic was on the 101 and took us about an hour from Hollywood. Parking here was also pretty bad as we didn't realize how tight Browne Ave was. Found a spot up front although part of my car was in the red zone. Opted to order 2 slices of pepperoni and garlic knots to eat there while we waited for a sausage/pepperoni and double mushroom pie to take home. Slices of pepperoni were good and thought the garlic knots were just ok. I prefer the garlic rolls at Tarantino's in Pasadena more as they are really garlicky and buttery. Both pies travelled well and we ended up eating another slice of each at home. Will definitely be back but will have to find a better spot to park so that we can dine without worrying about getting a parking ticket. read more

See all

Absolutely delicious pizza. I particularly loved the white, vodka, and regular cheese pizzas. Outstanding cheese, crust, sauce, herbs and spices, and baked to perfection. A must-try pizzeria! read more

Secret Pizza - Yeah, we couldn't wait - had to start eating this delicious pizza ASAP! - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

I was really looking forward to trying Secret Pizza, especially after hearing all the great reviews. As a pizza enthusiast and a devoted fan of Prince Street Pizza, I felt compelled to see how the two compared. I decided to go with the Thick Vodka pizza. Unfortunately, my experience fell short of my expectations. At $37 for the box, I would have preferred a Little Caesars pizza instead. I can't speak for the other flavors, but the one I had definitely didn't live up to the hype. True to its name, it was thick--too thick, in fact. All I got was a mouthful of dry bread. On the bright side, the staff was fantastic and the ambiance was pleasant. Maybe I just got an off batch, but I left feeling disappointed on my first visit. read more

Secret Pizza - Thick vodka pizza - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

See all

Secret Pizza specializes in New Jersey style pizzas. Pizzas by the slice are by walk in only and are an average of $5 per slice. Otherwise, you can order full 18" round pizzas or 12" square pizzas. They have their own website where you can schedule a pickup order ahead. Pro tip that if its your first time ordering ahead, once you create an account on their website, you'll get a 25% off discount! I did mine this way and chose their regular round pizza as the base and added pepperoni, mushroom and onions. The toppings were free of charge. It's only an additional $2 if you want half pepperoni. Secret Pizza is definitely now one of my go to spots when I'm craving NJ pizza. The crust is cooked to a slight crisp perfection and still keeps its chewiness. The sauce is a trifecta of tangy, sweet and savory. I found that the toppings were spread evenly as well. I ate 3 slices in one sitting and it was an overall addictive experience. Street parking only but it wasn't too difficult to find. They have seating indoors and outdoors. Staff was so sweet and welcoming! Secret pizza is a must try and maybe it's a great thing that the secret is out. read more

Secret Pizza - Regular round pizza slice with pepperoni, mushroom and onion - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

I finally had the chance to try Secret Pizza, and it was delicious. It really hit the spot on a cool evening while sitting out on their patio. The place fills up quickly, so we were glad we arrived early enough to grab a seat. The crust was amazing--thin, crispy, and full of flavor. My husband usually leaves the edges of his pizza untouched, but this time he ate every bite. It was that good. read more

Secret Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

Secret Pizza is hands-down the best pizza in LA. As a fellow former New Jerseyan, it is so great to have some Jersey representation out here. Yes, the prices are higher than what I am used to in Bergen County NJ, but the prices are fairly typical for LA (I think to how Halal Guys here is also quite more expensive than what I am used to in NJ-area). The most important thing for me is that the pizza tastes great like at home, which it definitely does. From the plain, to the pepperoni, to the vodka, and to the Sicilian, the pizzas here taste like the classic, no-frills pizza I love. And to be honest, the pizza here is even better than the places I grew up with back at home in NJ too. This is great pizza, period. Fyi, this is also not the place for some boutique or neapolitan pizza, for which there are plenty of other places in LA. The restaurant is counter service, with some casual outdoor patio seating to quickly eat or to hang out. Lastly, the staff here are all so kind and great. It was so nice meeting owner Sean when I was there, and you can tell he loves doing what he does. Definitely check out Secret Pizza if you are looking for some good NJ/NY style pizza in LA! read more

See all

tl;dr this El Sereno slice shop is no longer the LA pizza scene's best kept secret, but the excellent New York-style slices are a godsend for those of us on the East Side Like many trendy fast-casual spots today, Secret Pizza originated as a pandemic-era pop-up. The name refers to the hush-hush nature of the pop-up's location (i.e., the Hollywood apartment of the Jersey-born Sean Lango), which was only shared with patrons after they had reserved a pie. Quickly, Lango's pop-up earned praise from news outlets from Eater LA to the LA Times, and rabid demand meant planning well in advance for a pizza. But now, Secret Pizza has moved its residence to a proper brick-and-mortar in Sean Lango in El Sereno, and diners can easily order directly from the website or in person. The shop is tucked away behind a sign-less, whitewashed picket fence barrier just off Huntington Drive. Prepare for street parking on the twisty, inclined road to be at least a mild headache. Enter into a comfortable courtyard, illuminated by twinkle lights beneath an olive tree canopy. Pumpkin-orange plastic chairs and both umbrellas and industrial heaters are pressed up against stainless steel tables. Inside, the harsh lighting, worn concrete floor, and offwhite letterboard menu feel decidedly retro. A cubical glass display is filled with shelves of available slices. The narrow laminated-wood sitting is also decked with pizza seasonings. We arrived at Secret Pizza for weekend dinner and faced no wait. We picked out a couple of slices, and the staff member popped them into the oven for a few minutes. The signature New York-style round pies each featured a flavorful and thin-yet-sturdy crust to pair with a mozzarella and pecorino cheese blend. Our favorite was the extra-rich, slightly spicy Vodka pizza, but our Pepperoni slice featured a generous portion of pepperoni rings and a tangy red sauce. Meanwhile, the Sicilian Thick square slice was thick and poofy, leaving it feeling overwhelmingly bread-heavy against the toppings, The service was equal parts friendly and generous -- the staff gave us a free side of homemade Ranch and even offered another tentative customer a slice on the house. The extra-large (18" diameter) pies are each cut into 8 slices; a moderate appetite can tackle 2 slices, and singles run for ~$5. Overall, I was impressed by the genuinely caring service. I left feeling that Secret Pizza stacks up reasonably well against even some of New York's most popular slice shops. By LA standards, Secret Pizza is a true diamond in the rough. read more

Secret Pizza - Pepperoni (left), Vodka (right) and Sicilian Thick (back) Slices - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

This place really lives up to its name! My GPS took me to the Dollar Tree parking lot and it took me a long time to figure out where the location was because there is no signage. I figured since it's "secret" that was part of the theme. Contacting them is text only, no calls. I got a response within a couple of minutes and they were very polite and helpful. The building is quite cute with white fence, patio lights and outdoor seating with very pretty olive trees. They are New York style slices. I personally found the slices on the small side but it was still filling. I believe I tried the white and the vodka flavors. They give you some dipping sauces on the side and I really liked the light pink slightly spicy one. That may have been the vodka sauce. I normally don't eat much of the crust but I found the crust quite tasty. read more

See all

Sean and Madonna, Thank you for sharing your gift of amazing pizza. I absolutely enjoyed the time we had yesterday and I would definitely come back again because everything was just great, The pizza I cannot even explain how good it tasted. read more

Secret Pizza - The legend herself Lili Hayes - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

Pizza, both the Sicilian and the thin crust were very good. Overall taste was also very good. Had a pepperoni and a Vodka with sausage and jalapeño respectively. Quickly and beautifully prepared. Cookies were awesome. Not an easy spot to find. A nit picky thing but all toppings are the same price onions or sausage. And very stingy portions of them. A shade below pizzanista. read more

Secret Pizza definitely lives up to its' name. The location was hidden and you definitely have to be vigilant while navigating towards it. My boyfriend and I were lucky to score one last parking spot on the street. Their hours are limited with it only being open Wed-Sun from 4-9pm. Upon entering you walk into their outdoor patio seating. There are heat lamps but it wasn't turned on during the night we came. There was also a few seats inside but very limited and cramped. We came here for the pizza by the slice. They have a limited selection of pizza by the slice compared to other pizza shops with similar concepts. We both went with Pepperoni ($5.25/slice). We waited a bit for the pepperoni since they were out when we arrived. The tables in the patio area was really dirty and not well maintained. I didn't see staff come around to clean the whole time we were there. When the pizza was ready, we found that the crust was thin and crispy. However the toppings were lacking. I would have liked both more cheese and more pepperoni. Especially considering how other pizza shops sell the same pepperoni slice for a lower cost and better toppings. A fun novelty visit, but I can't say I'm in a rush to come back. read more

See all

I like that the pizza here isn't too greasy compared to other pizzas I've had. It's thin sliced, but not floppy. I initially got 2 slices because that's usually my go-to number when I buy pizza by the slice, but wasn't yet satisfied, so I got a 3rd, but I think I could have easily eaten a 4th. For thin sliced pizza, the portion does run pretty small at more than $5 for a slice, so for 4 slices you'd be looking at well over $20. We got 1 slice of each flavor and we thought overall, the amount toppings felt a lot less compared to other places and the flavors are kind of subtle in the tomato sauce, vodka sauce and the shredded basil on the Margherita. The mushroom and jalapeño were fresh especially the jalapeño which was very thinly sliced but still packed a lot of flavor. We agreed the Pepperoni was the best when it comes to flavor. Crust runs more crunchy than chewy. We also tried their garlic knots, and again the flavor was very subtle, and didn't taste that garlicky. The sauce that came with it was great though. read more

Secret Pizza - Pepperoni, Jalapeño, Mushroom, Margherita, and Vodka Sauce - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

The base pie is lovely and enjoyable. But I do think, given the hype and the TOO MANY handful of "good" pizza in LA, at the end of the day, it's just a decent pizza. It's overpriced by $2+ a slice, at a location that makes it unaffordable for the locals, and perpetuating the bad parking/not our problem behavior- it isn't worth the bite for me. This city has too many of this trope and if this is the brand, then this is what youre measured for and so yes it is just average compared to said market. read more

What a gem! It's far too good to be secret for much longer. The tree shaded outdoor area (with heat lamps) serves to hide it but it's worth finding for sure. We had both vodka and jalapeño sausage pies. Delicious thin crust just like back in our home state of New Jersey. Perfection. Or so I thought until the owner Sean brought out homemade chocolate chip cookies and a giant homemade ice cream sandwich that made me wish I hadn't eaten quite so much pizza! Fantastic. Go. Parking on the street. Worth it. read more

See all

Never been here before and I frequent the area since my mom lives in walking distance. This pizza was so good. This was our first time here. I'm not even into pizza and I was taken back. So good and crispy sauce is perfect. The pizza came out fast also. They have a cool little spot with outside seating. Oh and wifey loved the pizza as well and the their cookies. We will be back read more

The secret is out--there's a new(ish) pizza place in town, and it's cooking up mouthwatering pies that has reinvigorated my love for the cheese and dough. A few things worth noting: - Sign-up for an account and get a deal on your order - Closed Mondays and Tuesdays - Check their insta @secretpizzala for deals - Single slices available at the shop - Street parking only If you're a fan of thin crust pizza, stop wasting time and check out Sean's creations. The crust is perfectly crisp, light, and subtly flavorful. The toppings are modest, and the cheese is creamy. The pizzas may not look like much, but boy, has Sean and his team hit it out of the park. read more

See all

Pizza was good but I paid for extra cheese and didn't get it. Also, the pizza was very pricey. read more

Secret Pizza - Pepperoni, sausage, and extra cheese Sicilian Thick pizza. 9 slices in this pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

This spot is so good every time that I could've sworn I dropped a review ages ago, but then I remembered I didn't, and then I swear that I will...but then fall into pizza coma. El Sereno is incredibly lucky to have Secret Pizza. Delicious pies, genuine service, and a cozy patio make this the perfect pizza night out. Absolutely worth it. read more

The secret is out! Secret Pizza is some of the best pizza in LA. I devoured their pepperoni pizza and plain cheese tonight. I can't wait to go back and try something else! I took mine to go, but the patio looked pretty cozy and family friendly. read more

Really love the slices which are some of the best in LA. To be honest, that's the reason to go. The square pizza wasn't as good - a bit soggy and lacked depth of flavor (sauce maybe under seasoned?). We've gotten garlic knots a couple of times and the first time they were over cooked and weirdly the second batch was exactly 50% burnt and 50% still cold in the middle (not sure how they achieved that!). Cookies are definitely good. But again, those slices are the star of the show - particular recommendation is the onion jalapeño which is truly outstanding. read more

Sooo good! Flavor was definitely there and the pepperoni was crispy. For some reason the crust had a funny after taste but maybe it's just my weird senses. It was my second time coming and we got a square pizza this time around. Friendly staff as always! read more

Secret Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

10/10. no complaints. the staff is very nice and friendly the pizza was the best i've had in a minute. Definitely returning when I have the chance again. Thank you!! read more

Secret Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

We had cravings for some pizza and was curious to see what the New York style pizza would be like at this hidden gem. It was almost closing time and they had a lot of customers in the patio area enjoying their dinner. We ordered three different slices and a big cookie. We ate in the patio area on a nice cool evening. The pizza was delicious and the dough was great too. Every pizza place around here makes their pizza different and you will be satisfied with what they offer here. read more

Secret Pizza - Dee Lee Cioso MAY2025 - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

Another excellent pizza spot in Los Angeles. It really is secret, the location is easy to miss--but if you manage to find it, you'll be pleasantly surprised! They've got a pretty simple menu, but everything is really dialed in. I even like their white pizzas,which usually aren't my thing. read more

Secret Pizza - The Margherita and jalapeño cheese slice. - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

On my first visit a few friends and I ordered a few pizzas and picked them up to go and share at home along with a bunch of beers. On my most recent visit, I came by on the way home from work to grab a couple slices and try their ice cream sandwich. This is my first time actually eating here at the location . Since it was the middle of the week, the vibe was really chill. It wasn't busy at all. It was also right before closing. The slices were great. A great contrast between getting a thick and a thin slice. And if you can, definitely go for the ice cream sandwich. I thought the cookies and the ice cream was really good. read more

See all

A tier above! Straight forward, no gimmicks! Will drive over an hour everytime! Thank you guys, I appreciate you! read more

Secret Pizza - Half & half - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

Pizza was good, but not a lot of selection and ingredients. Also when we picked up the pizza, it was cold. Not sure why that was. We ordered a plain cheese for the kids. It was good, other than cold. read more

I've driven by this place numerous times and had no idea that it was here. Guess that is why it's called Secret Pizza. Founded by Sean, a New Jersey native, Secret Pizza's pies are reminiscent of what you'll find on the East Coast. Most of their business is pick up, and you have to place your order online. However, they have a variety of slices available in the shop, which you can eat there or take to go. I stopped in to pick up a few slices - a plain square ($4.25) and a slice of the white with onion & jalapeño ($5.75). The crust on both had a nice flavor. The marinara sauce on the square was good. The bottom crust was crispy and a tad doughy in the center. I wish it would have had a bit more cheese. The white slice was very tasty. The jalapeño gave it just the right amount of heat and I like that the onions were thinly sliced, so the flavor wasn't overwhelming. The crust was just right - foldable. I would definitely order a whole pie in the future. For dessert they have freshly made cookies and ice cream sandwiches. Beer & soft drinks are available and wine coming soon. Inside is fairly small with two tables but the outside patio is spacious. Street parking can be tough but it's worth it. read more

See all

This place has delicious east coast style pizza. First off the cheese slice is perfectly balanced with sauce that actually tasted good and the crust is perfect. The vodka slice was perfect and didn't taste heavy. I highly recommend this place and would rate it first place for nyc style pizza over the appolonias etc. IMO this place is way better. read more

Secret Pizza - Cheese and vodka slice - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

Great spot that serves really good pizza! Varied beer options and a kick ass patio with heaters. And most importantly, their side order of jalapeños are fresh, not soaked in vinegar!! read more

Secret Pizza - Sliced order of jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - Los Angeles, California

Oh my god! Like sitting in little Italy Manhattan!!!! Love this pizza? Buy the pie or by the slice. Sooooo good! Thank You, read more

See all

The garlic knots are a great addition to the meal I would recommend. Especially if you're waiting for your pizza. Not much seating inside but there's a lot of seating outside. Great service. read more

See all

OMG!!! Best mouthwatering pizza that I can't get enough of. My kids love it, my neighbor's love it and I can even enjoy a beer in their eclectic patio while I wait. Or even inside when its raining and watch them make pizza art. To top it off, they have some slices available if you don't want the whole pizza. Slice of mouthwatering pizza along with a HELLO LA? COUNT ME IN! Let's talk about the workers! They are hard at work throwing the dough around and creating miracalous pizzas and even a vodka pizza that is to die for. And there nice so that's the icing on top, It's made super thin and maybe its the crust, the sauce, but in totality its just plain delicious. My only complaint is that I wish it was open more so I could enjoy it for lunch when I'm at work. Keep doing what your doing guys!!! read more

There is no way of contacting them...terrible Also they charged me for the food and delivery and I never received my food read more

If you want proper New York style pizza in Los Angeles, look no further than Secret Pizza. Tucked away in El Serano, Secret Pizza is a strong contender for the best NY style pizza in LA. The owner, Sean, is a New Jersey native who moved to the Los Angeles in 2019, and brought the flavor, texture, and East Coast charm with him. He greeted all of his patrons as they came in, happily answering any questions and chatting with pizza loving folks. The rest of the staff were equally as kind and the place radiates a cozy, family-owned vibe that makes you feel that you're living in one of the five buroughs. There's plenty of seating available, both indoors and outdoors, so you can walk in and order by the slice. I ordered three classic NY slices: a pepperoni, a cheese, and a jalapeño white slice. Each was charred to perfection with that signature crispy crust. The dough had a firm undercarriage with no flop, making it ideal for folding and eating. The tomato sauce was zesty and flavorful, and the cheese-to-topping ratio was perfect. With every bite, I forgot that I had driven here, not taken the subway in a walkable city. By the time I finished my third slice, I was still craving more and went back for a square slice. It was close to closing time, so I hesitated, but Sean assured me it was no problem! He even gave me an additional cheese square slice on the house. It's rare to have that kind of service, and made me feel right at home. There's not many pizzerias that rivals the ones in New York. Apollonia's, Prime, and Prince Street Pizza are all excellent iterations, but Secret Pizza stands apart thanks to its authenticity and Sean's east coast roots. If every pizza spot in LA, had the quality of Secret Pizza, this city would no longer be the butt of pizza jokes, but would be right up there with NYC as a pizza capital of the world. read more

See all

I've been wanting to try Secret Pizza for a very long time, so I was so excited I was able to stop by and pick up a pizza for the family as a surprise. Found parking easily and there wasn't much of a line, score! I chatted with the young man taking my order, he was explaining the menu to me since it was my first time there. I knew what I wanted and put the order in. When he was finished ringing me up, he swings the monitor around and says "you just need to sign". Ok great, did as he said as we continued to chat. When I went outside to wait for my pizza I reviewed my receipt because the final price seemed higher than I was expecting. I noticed that there was a 20% tip added, well that's strange I wasn't asked about giving a tip. That's when I started to think back about the transaction. The young man who rang me up had already selected tip amount for me and that's why he said I just needed to sign. I didn't realize at the time because we had been chatting, but after thinking about the interaction it was a huge disappointment. I feel like I was taken advantage of, scammed so to speak because I did not choose the tip myself, he was being 100% sneaky. I would've never known had I not sent the receipt to myself. As I sat waiting for my pizza, I was taking it home so not even dining in, I had such an uncomfortable feeling in the bottom of my stomach. I didn't say anything and maybe I should have, but after 15 minutes they called my name to pick up my pizza and at that point I just wanted to go home. The pizza was delicious, I have nothing bad to say about the pizza, absolutely delicious! Pepperoni & mushroom, my favorite! I'm giving the 3 stars because overall I did not like the experience I had. Money is tight as it is, so going out to eat is a treat, to feel like I was being taken advantage of left a really bad taste in my mouth. I'd like to have this pizza again, but if I do I will have to pay more attention when I'm being rung up. read more