We had this pizza on my daughters recommendation for take out! We had the Tipsy Roni, a cheese, and Chicken Bacon ranch and they were all delicious. The wings were great as well, not drowning in sauce which I appreciated so much! Sometimes they are drowning and hard to transport. I can't comment on the restaurant itself because we did a pick up. But I will say it was quick (on UAlbany grad weekend!) and delicious and we would eat from there again. read more

Paesans Pizza & Restaurant at 289 Ontario St delivers a strong 4-star experience, especially if you're a fan of great crust. The pizza stands out with a perfectly balanced base--crispy on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside--making every slice satisfying without feeling too heavy. The sauce has a nice, classic flavor and the toppings are fresh and well-portioned. The atmosphere is casual and comfortable, making it a solid spot for both quick takeout or a relaxed sit-down meal. While service can vary slightly during busy times, the quality of the pizza--especially that crust--keeps this place a reliable go-to. read more

Pizza was very subpar, and the staff gave off an unfriendly vibe. The owner was also spouting some political stuff in the background which I don't appreciate when I go to grab a slice. Stick to spinning dough buddy read more

Very disappointing experience. The food was below average and the staff came across as rude and dismissive. What bothered me most was the way I was treated compared with other customers. Based on my experience, I felt I was treated differently because of the color of my skin and it left me feeling unwelcome and uncomfortable. I won't be returning and cannot recommend this place. read more

The pizza has good flavors. Perfect amount of sauce and cheese but it's on the doughier side for me. The pizza still had a good crust even if it was a little thick. Pick up order was easy. Customer service was also great. read more

Paesan's Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Albany, New York

See all

Pizza was pretty awful. Was recommended by a local while here for a sports tournament. Very oily pizza and I had less than a good night because of this. The crust was crispy and they had some creative pizzas. The problem was it just wasn't good. read more

Ordered the sub "specials" today. 2 subs and small drinks cost about $30. I had the chicken parm sub and it wasn't very good. I was super disappointed. It was extra crispy like I asked but the chicken and sauce lacked flavor. Won't be back. read more

Quick delivery, good pizza, salads and appetizers. Their Italians meals and subs are also good. Perfect for a take out dinner, lots of variety. read more

See all

The pizza wasn't good at all and the service was somehow even worse, not sure if it was the owner or just staff but definitely don't recommend. There are better options in the area. read more

Owner is extremely rude it's almost comical. I legit thought he was joking when he came over 30mins into us eating and acted like we were taking a super long time. Guy is an Ahole, don't give him a dime read more

I think this company has the best pizza in the city of Albany. If you haven't tried them, I'd wish that you would continued success to Paesans Pizza and Restaurant. read more

Pizza Margareta thick Sicilian is the best. Delicious! It's just like my Nonna used to make!

called at 8:20 someone picks ups says we're closed stop f@&$ing call and hangs up when theyre website says they're open 930. have had more than one bad experience with their east greenbush location and will never spend another dollar at any of their locations ever again read more

We were Visiting my mom and Aunt in Albany and took a shot and ordered Pizza and some pasta dishes (Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana with Spaghetti , Stuffed Shells and Manicotti) . WAS NOT DISAPPOINTED That was my first time ordering but they have gotten food before and raved about it . Wish you were on Long Island !!! Will be ordering again when we visit next . read more

If you like lukewarm oily cardboard, you are going to LOVE the gluten-free pizza here. Big props to them for having a gluten-free option, but the gluten free pizza is not an enjoyable eating experience. That said, I only hear positive things about the regular pizza here, and they have good service. They are a local go-to for event catering thanks to their reliability and good (gluten-full) food. read more

Awesome, awesome, awesome. Best pizza I've had in a LONG time. Cooked to absolutely perfection, it's what NY pizza should be everywhere. You guys are great. The pizza is delicious. Thank you so much for having such an amazing pie!!! read more

They deserve another star for continuous customer satisfaction, and improvement. I tried to order delivery other day, and it was chaos, probably due to World Cup. I called my go to Pizza directly (Paesan's), they answered, took my order lickety split, and delivered the best deluxe pizza there is around here. They never skimp on the cheese, and the dough is perfect. Wife also wanted to try their Philly cheese sandwich, which I sampled one, two, three, maybe four bites. Not bad. Finally got a chance to add photos. read more

Paesan's Pizza & Restaurant - Deluxe Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Albany, New York

See all

Honestly would never come again. Super overpriced for no god damn reason, charged for things that should come w the meals. Plus they f'd up the order & made getting a refund complicated & wouldn't deliver the food that THEY F'D UP. Disappointed & dissatisfied to say the least. read more

Solid pizza place that was pretty fast and delivered exactly what I expected. The crust wasn't "bubbly" and was a bit harder than I like, but I really enjoyed the pizza and there's not much else to say. They use fresh mushrooms and not canned (can't believe I had to specify this but I've had places with sour mushrooms that obviously came from a can) and the chicken was a little dry. read more

Paesan's is my go-to for pizza whenever I have an event with my staff. The food is always hot, fresh and delicious. My only complaint is that, when you order for delivery, they charge a delivery fee that they TAX. The sales tax is not just on the food. I would add a much larger tip if there was no delivery fee and taxing that fee makes it even more difficult for me to justify a large tip. My recommendation would be to pick up your food whenever you're able. read more

Excellent frozen pizza! We live on Saint Simons Island, GA and there is nothing locally as good as this. Just placed my second order with Goldbelly with more to follow. read more

Paesan's Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Albany, New York

Might be my all time fav pizza. So simple so perfect I love everything about it. Deliver frozen through gold belly arrives perfect and cooks the same. Love!!! read more

Stopped on the way back from Killington made a decent margarita and white pie , will return .

I enjoyed a paesan pizza with a meeting at work the other day. nothing like a free lunch with pizza which was was very good. The cheese slice was salty but savory and I had a slice of pepperoni which was also good and they are always very greasy but heck that gives it a lot of flavor right!. Then just the other night against by better judgement because I remember not liking their hot subs previously when I've have had them before; Well I went for the hot eggplant parm sub not ever again because it's too simple for me, no herbs or flavor whatsoever. Stick with the pizza which is sooooo good and the guy who was working was very friendly and helpful. read more

My boyfriend and I came to visit Albany for the week and we wanted to explore the local eateries and stumbled over this place it was a great experience friendly staff great food in a timely manner read more

This is for a frozen order sent to California. This pizza has been my favorite. True New York style sauce, taste and cheese. We not only loved the Cheese pizza but the spinach pizza blew our socks off. Crust is crispy and full of flavor. Arrived thawed but they said this is normal so we just refroze before cooking. Very reasonable shipping rate too. HJighly recommend. read more

Ordered delivery tonight (pizza, wings, beef patties) and honestly, my husband and I both agree it was the best pizza, and overall takeout order, we have had in a while. Parsons is our go to for pizza locally and we were not disappointed tonight. Thanks for the deliciousness! read more

I was checking out the spot imy first time in there slice was pretty decent for three dollars that were regular slice so if I want another one six Dollars I'm a pretty decent slice I wish I can get in deep with another slice anchovies load it with everything on it that's what I want next regular sliced was all right I go back in there yes read more

One star for non-compliance with COVID-19 . It's my favorite local pizza take-out, but I won't be going back for a while. Only mask was on the cashier, and she only put it on when I approached the counter. If I didn't live close by, I'd have gotten it delivered, and never been the wiser. read more

It's hard to put into words just how disappointing this pizza is. I recently ordered a medium BBQ chicken pizza in honor of the first football Sunday of the year. What was delivered sure looked like pizza but that's where the good stuff stops. The pie arrived warm, not hot, and the rubber-ization of the cheese had already begun. The pie was overcooked, but not burnt, with the top portion almost completely baked away from the bottom. What was left was a dry and chewy pizza. The chicken that was used as part of the topping was clearly cooked at a time long before my pizza made it to the oven for my order. Granted, Paesan's primarily caters to drunk college kids who cannot decipher between good and bad pizza in their various states of inebriation. However, this isn't the case for us all. This was a bad pizza. I cannot identify a single redeeming thing about it. With that, I give Paesan's my very first single star review. read more

My memories of this place are very profound. When I attended college in Albany, (St. Rose in da house) Paesan's was the closest to city pizza I've had. This statement still stands on all counts. From the looks of the other reviews, Paesan's seemed to have slided down a bit. I can tell you that the two best things on their menu other than the pizza were the Shrimp Parmigiana & Philly Cheese Steak heroes. These were excellent sandwiches. I can't speak on them now. I haven't been to Paesan's since the 90s. That was the spot though. I'm not talking like pulling a "dine & ditch" in Denny's on Central Ave (guilty MANY times, good laughs though). You respected Paesan's back in the day. Nothing like hanging with the brothas, playing ball in that playground across the street and getting some "NYC" pizza. Many of my hammered friends spent fortunes there every weekend. FYI - The park had their full court rims at 11 feet. If you can dunk or rain 3s on those, you OWNED that place read more

Best pizza in Albany? That might be a stretch. Best crust in Albany might be a little more fitting. I don't know what it is about the sauce or the cheese they use, but their cheese slices always taste odd. They are very very thin and greasy also. However, their broccoli tomato slice is delicious and the crust is nice and crisp. I'm not sure if Paesans came under new ownership since the last time I've been there but it is has definitely improved but until they get their cheese slice to my liking, this probably won't be in my top choices for pizza in the area. read more

Saturday night tried calling multiple times around 10 pm with no answer. Says they close at 1 but no one answered. Disappointed.

They have the best spicy Buffalo wings I've ever had, and the stuff tastes excellent--even cold the next morning... BUT .... if Paesan's or the delivery guys screw up your order in any way (ex. accidentally cancels your order instead of someone else's, forgets one of your items), they will never compensate you! they have good food, but terrible customer service, and seem to forget that you PAID for your food. read more

Still searching for the best pizza that will deliver to our place. The pizza was totally meh. Not enough flavor. My husband tells me that getting a slice in the store is wayyyy better than a whole pie delivered. The mozzarella sticks were super breaded with not very much cheese inside. They reminded me of the grocery store brand that I prepare in the oven. Fries were good though. The search continues... read more

Paesan's was, and probably still is, an institution in the student ghetto of Albany. There was a period of a few days where some guy was running through the playground across the street from Paesan's and randomly assaulting people on the sidewalks nearby. One night my roommate and I were getting a slice when the guy who had been routinely assaulting people decked a frequent Paesan's costumer in the back of the head. He ran into the store bleeding while everyone emptied out and chased down the perpetrator. Shit was always out of control. So if you're not coming here for the occasional knock-out blow to the skull, you probably should at least try for the pizza. The crust sometimes seemed a tad undercooked for my taste, but the sauce and the cheese usually made up for it. The reason why Paesan's was the best on the Ontario & Madison block was due to their ability to custom make basically anything that you could think of. A few roommates and I would commonly order buffalo chicken ranch pizza without any sort of problem whatsoever. Costumer service in the store was decent enough, but I never had to deal with delivery since I lived right nearby. I mean, really though, who doesn't want to live in the student ghetto? read more

Spend your money somewhere else! Bad customer service, rude staff, delivered cold, yelled at for asking for a refund or future discount for waiting 90 minutes for cold soggy food on a busy night they had. Understood the rush and appreciate they're open during the pandemic, but paid for hot food within an hour, not cold food in over an hour. Called to ask them to make it right and was yelled at and told I must be mistaken...no refund, no discount, no correction made. Still can't believe I was talked to like that on the phone, busy night or not. I've worked in customer service and this guy has no value of customers. read more

Paesan's on Ontario is by far the best pizza in Albany. Not sure about the other Paesan's locations. This stuff is worth the extra 30 seconds it takes to walk over from Madison Pizza and I Love NY Pizza across the street. I'm from Long Island, so I am familiar with GOOD pizza. Unfortunately, most pizza in Albany is pretty bad. Paesan's is definitely my go-to pizza joint in Albany. Second only to Marisa's Place in Guilderland... but that's a bit of a drive. read more

Ugh. Why did I trust the reviews? Ordered a BBQ Chicken pizza and had high expectations for it, seeing as how you pizza-illiterate Yelpers claim this to be the best pizza in Albany. Oh, how bitterly disappointed I was. The crust was chewy and tough, somewhat reminiscent of gnawing on a soggy piece of beef jerky. But the real issue I took with this pizza was the complete lack of BBQ sauce--I ordered a BBQ Chicken pizza and expected to actually taste the BBQ sauce in every bite, but the fine owners of Paesan's Pizza obviously think otherwise. So, as hard as I tried to overcome the thick layer of tasteless, poor-quality mozzarella and chunks of "chicken" glued onto a tanned-leather crust by just enough BBQ sauce to hold everything together, my boyfriend and I just couldn't get through our first slices. The kicker is that the manager/owner we voiced our concerns to actually *BLAMED US* for the poor quality of the food--apparently we should have known, as first time customers, to order the BBQ Chicken pizza with extra BBQ sauce. Although, even then, I doubt that pizza would be anything more than a circular disc of crap. read more

Paesan's Pizza & Restaurant - The "BBQ" Chicken pizza. Note the near complete lack of BBQ sauce--if you actually want to TASTE the sauce, that will be extra. - Pizza Near Me - Albany, New York

I'm tempted to give this place a 2, but I thought, that rating is reserved for places like Papa John's. First off, I deduct a point off of Albany because it seems like you do not have any awesome pizza joints. I wanted delivery and found 2 places in the Troy area (DeFazio's and Mick's) that wouldn't deliver down to the Albany. The pizza tastes like any other decent pizza places. It honestly sort of just tastes like the frozen pizzas you get from grocery stores. So in that mindset, the pizza is probably too expensive. I paid 25 including tip for a large with 3 toppings. The order came in 15 minutes so that was a star deserving quality. They also take card over the phone so if you don't have cash, you can do that. In short, if you're lazy and want someone to cook for you and get it done quickly (besides your other better half), I'd say go for it, but just expect mediocrity. I would rather spend that 15 minutes nagging to get that other person to cook me a steak. read more