Standard Greek family restaurant and overpriced for what you get. A la carte pancakes for 2 for $6.45...yes they're big, but I only wanted one...got two...good? Yes, but not every Saturday. Still hunting for best and most affordable breakfast joint on Saturdays. read more

Late night goodness!!! Total diner food! Everything was well cooked and priced. Our waitress is amazingly efficient for 2:30 in the morning!!! Totally uninterested in messing with us table of monkeys! read more

The service is amazing but the food not so much I'm use too... let's just say that my grandpa would love this restaurant!

I've been here several times and had several entrees, but the breakfast is by far the best. Don't waste your time going to McDonalds or George Webb.....come to a place like this for breakfast. read more

Food was horrible. I order her often but this is the last time. I specifically asked for something and it was not done. Food was cold and to spicy. It should not be. I feel this was done on purpose. I've worked in that field and know what's what. I couldn't eat any of it. read more

Very rude management/ownership. I am a Grubhub driver who happens to have had a couple of orders to deliver from Pegasus. Yesterday, Grubhub messed their timings up, meaning I was late (through absolutely no fault of my own) to pick up the orders I needed to deliver from the restaurant. I was greeted by an incredibly rude lady who told me she expected me to tell the customers that their order was late because of me - she said "she needed me" to tell them it was my fault. A quick note on how Grubhub works - they send us orders based on their ideas of timing. I had been sent to one restaurant to pick up and deliver an order, when I got sent another offer for Pegasus. We only get sent another order from Grubhub when the company expects that the food from the original restaurant will be ready, we can deliver, and then get to the new restaurant in in time to pick up the next, fresh order. So, we accept the next job (or risk losing the whopping $9 hourly guarantee that we are offered as drivers, and lose access to signing up for future delivery blocks). So, when I get to the original restaurant, I am told that the order is going to take longer than expected. I tell the app this then means I am going to be running late to the next restaurant. Long story short, I am late to pick up from Pegasus because of the delay at the original restaurant and get an incredibly rude reception. Please be aware Pegasus: we drive like crazy, often necessarily dangerously, to get from one restaurant to another and to our customers in order to get to delivery spots on time. We rely almost exclusively on our tips, so we put ourselves (and our cars) under a great deal of pressure to get from one place to another. Grubhub essentially often pushes us to be unsafe. Do not, absolutely do not, assume I am being lackadaisical. Also, we are the face - albeit temporarily - for your business. Making us upset by offering us no respect reduces the likelihood that we can be cheery to the customer. Luckily, I'm always professional and courteous with customers, but you might not be so lucky with another driver. I can guarantee that you make more money from these deliveries than we do (please take into account we make basically nothing from each delivery, plus we have to pay our own gas/take care of our own vehicle maintenance). It could well be that the next driver decides that the low money isn't worth your rudeness. I live in the area and have been to your restaurant a number of times. You may not have lost the customers I delivered to for you (yes, I was apologetic and polite, though no, I did not tell them it was "my fault"), but you have certainly lost the patronage of myself and my partner. read more

Great Sunday night dinner value. Ordered half rotisserie chicken and ribs. Came with veggies, soup and choice of potatoes which can be served up to 7 different ways. Lastly includes free beer, wine or dessert. Chicken was flavorful and ribs was tender off bone. Service was super friendly. read more

As a Greek from Chi who grew up in a restaurant family, I can tell you this place is great. My buddies got steak & eggs and a gyro sandwich & said they were delicious. They looked it. I usually don't order big salads at diners but I was on a diet so I went for the Cobb. It was awesome, including the freshly grilled chicken breast on top. Id come here anytime. read more

Went there last night with the Miller Valley Amateur Radio Club (meetings every Tuesday 6:30 to 8:30 and then Pegasus afterwards). The management was very accommodating with our group (about 15 guys?), our server, Rosa, was very friendly and very prompt with taking our order. There was even a minor mix up where one of the club members ordered something and got what he ordered, but... I guess in his mind it was going to be different than it was. Instead of saying tough luck, you ordered it, Rosa immediately took it back and did a custom order for him. Definitely looking forward to going back. The prices are very reasonable too! read more

Have never had a bad meal here, any day, any time. They're on point, friendly, efficient, and affordable. Great fish fry!

Your classic avenue Greek 24 hour restaurant . The pork Chop meal was excellent and this is a cool and safe environment to be at late hours. The place is clean and well kept and it has a wide variety of menu items for all to enjoy. The skillet meals are pretty decent as well. read more

This is my 'go to' place for a quick breakfast. Are they open yet? YES! 24/7! Also a good spot for lunch and dinner. Diner food, nothing fancy, but consistently good. Friendly staff, even the bus boy is a winner. read more

Lunch with a coworker in town. Had gyros, BLT and Italian wedding soup. All was delicious. Good service and prices were average. Will be back! read more

Stop in here during plowing snow, great food and very fast! Very friendly service, we don't get a table though we belly up to the front by kitchen. Would recommend to anyone! read more

Just want to give a shout out to Danielle who was our waitress on Tuesday 11/27/18! It was refreshing to have a waitress who was very attentive and seemed genuinely happy! No matter how many times my mother and I kept asking for attention. It's been awhile over a year I believe the last time I was there the waitresses who were there at the time could learn a few things from Danielle in customer service! She was great! read more

larger restaurant with cool fish aquarium. booths and tables are comfy. the restaurant is clean and bright. my ham and egg onion skillet was great! the green peppers, onions, eggs were well cooked...topped with melted cheddar. the ham was smoked which was good. great place for sandwiches and breakfast meals!! nice staff and good location. A + + + + read more

Great, calm late night diner. Our waitress was very kind, and you get a lot of food for what you pay for! Was definitely better than I expected! read more

This is my go to breakfast place! It is awesome! The pancakes are very good and the bacon is always crispy! I keep trying new places but always end up coming back here. Great service and prices! My boyfriend also would like to add they always have watermelon on demand! read more

Your typical Greek restaurant. Nothing special just good filling food at cheap prices. Come here often when needing a quick early morning or late night bite to eat read more

My daughter and I decided to try it for lunch on a Friday before going to the Salvation Army to "treasure hunt". The best thing I can say about this restaurant is that our waitress was very friendly and attentive. When she asked how my pulled pork sandwich was, I said it was okay except for the rather large and sharp piece of rib bone I found in it. She was genuinely concerned and took it to the kitchen to make them aware. I could hear the owner say, "Well, we make it fresh" in reply to the waitress. That's great, but you still need to check that major chunks of bone aren't being served to your customer. Also, try serving fresh buns rather than stale toasted ones. The piece of bone is not my biggest complaint as these things happen. My biggest complaint is the sour-faced older woman (owner or mother of the owner?) who rang us up at the register. She hardly spoke to me. When I asked if I needed to sign the credit card receipt she put on the counter, she said "Right there" and handed me a pen. Isn't it usually older people (me included as a mid-40's woman) who usually complain about the lack of courtesy and manners in the younger generation? How about "I hope you enjoyed your meal despite the big chunk of bone. We hope you come again soon!" or simply "Thank you"? The bar-time crowd might be oblivious or not care, but this daytime diner will find another place to spend her $25 plus tip when in that area again. read more

I have never had a bad meal there. Period. It may see like your basic carbon copy Greek family restaurant, but seriously, the food is really good. The salads are generous. The dinner specials are a great value and the pie is terrific. Service is always great! read more

I used to go to this restaurant frequently, the last time I went I had a horrible experience when I went to pay my bill they asked how everything was and I told them I was very disappointed and then they ignored me they were not interested in what the problem was very very poor customer service I will not be back. read more

YUCK! Back of house is not clean, stores product in the basement coolers and freezers which are dirty, lays meat on the dirty basement floor prior to cutting and they have roaches. Would not recommend this restaurant to anyone. read more

Not a fan at all!!! Used to come here almost every weekend as a kid. Now its like a disappointment! Wont return!

Very good. Very large portions. Went there at 5 am and the staff was very friendly and fun. The food came out fast with a larger variety of comfort food to choose from. Will definitely stop back on our way out of town read more

Ordered NY steak 8oz, baked potato, salad, and nachos. All excellent, great food! Steak was tender cooked to perfection, beaked potato, creamy. Bread was awesome, sides very good. Tons of food for reasonable prices. DEFINITELY have plenty of leftovers! read more

I mean, ok sure. If you're in the neighborhood. It's your standard Greek diner fare, nothing exciting.

Great food, always great service. Staff is on the spot with refills and orders. Our go to spot great breakfasts, lunches and dinners. You won't be disappointed. read more

I have never felt so uncomfortable eating at an establishment before in my life. I left a bar to eat with my friends but it was 12:30am so I decided to have another beer. Not only did the manager study my I.D. asking me to take off my glasses because they are not in my I.D. but he looked me up and down. After that interaction, the waitress asked me what I wanted to drink. I had already ordered a beer. Thankfully the waitress was paying attention when I had mentioned the manager getting my drink. The Manager then looked at me the entire time I was in the restaurant. He even went as far as walking behind my booth to stare down my shirt. Due to him being the only manager in the place I couldn't very much ask for one. He HAD to bring me my food. My food was the last plate to come out. We said no food to come out until it was ALL ready. My two friends had gotten their food before myself. With that being said, my food was good. I had the kierestaurant skillet. It was very well made. Our waitress was nowhere to be found. My friend had to go and flag her down to get our check. So over all, if you enjoy good food with no service, while being a woman and having a man stare inappropriately at you while you're trying to eat, and then having to walk to your waitress at the other end of the restaurant, then this is an awesome place. If you aren't keen on having your wife, girlfriend, or even just friend want to leave the whole time you're there, then this won't be your type of place. My 1 star is for the food alone. read more

My favorite neighborhood Greek restaurant. Been going here through its many iterations. Always good classic diner food, good soups, good breakfast, fast service. Nothing spectacular, just consistent decent food, better than most similar restaurants in the neighborhood (and 100 times better than disgusting Johnny V's.) A good choice for late night drunk food, or Sunday breakfast. read more

Best "pro" about this place is that they serve food fast. Though I like that.... I can't help but wonder why it comes out so quickly... many chefs or lots of microwaving? Anyhow, go here for breakfast because it'll most likely be fresh and quick. Very good prices. Looks clean, but feels a little grubby. For instance, the plastic covered menus and even the backs of the chairs themselves seem a bit sticky/grubby. I made sure to use the restroom and wash my hands right after I ordered/right before I ate. It's Stallis... what do you expect? I wouldn't come here for any special date, but maybe come for breakfast again. The rest of the food is "eh." read more

We eat here about four times a month. The food is always great, the service wonderful. They have a extensive menus plus daily specials.

I would like to say I'm a big girl who loves food, but I wold not go back hear again even if they payed me to! The place looked like it need an huge upgrade. The costumer sieves was not good at all, they asked me if I wanted anything to eat, but however did not even ask my boyfriend who was their if he needed anything. Giving the the benefit of doubt I still waited for my food. I got chicken Alfredo. The chicken was dry and had no flavoring. It was like if they put it on a George Forman without seasoning. The needles and sauce taste like microwave leftover. I also got cheesy broccoli soup. The soup had no broccoli in it, it just had the top shaving of broccoli in it with a lot of oil and just melted cheese. I also got a pice of cake that was so dry I cold defiantly tell it was not fresh. If you want fresh good food this is not the place to go! I personally fell like this is a true kitchen nightmare! They need help badly! read more

mexican cooks. solid food, always good food. waitresses are sometimes drug addicts and are gross. but overall never lets you down. you'll get good food fast. very consistent. the night manager is named marty also. he is a big time baller. i watched him berate a group of waitresses who were screwing around. my type of leadership. fire those buck tooth skanks if they are not up to snuff. all about customer service. marty makes a bomb manhattan also read more

Ordered a delivery thru Grub Hub on 3 separate occasions and they were all messed up. Between putting gravy on items that were ordered without, missing food from the order, failing to deliver any drinks and then saying that the chicken tenders didn't come with fries even though their menu says they do. When we called to tell them we spent $70 dollars and they were missing items they basically did nothing about satisfying our complaint. $8.00 for 3 tenders is quite outrageous. read more

Such slow service. Never coming back again. They give a good amount of food but considering the service and disorganization when I came for my take-out order I will not go there again. read more

Pegasus is a totally legitimate diner, always o.k. But most likely never, ever better. Open 24/7/365 (sad for those employees that have to work major holidays), that's my first thought, having worked in restaurants all my life). And having owned one. I ordered two eggs sunny side up with Jimmy Dean sausage, passable. My wife ordered a Reuben-it really sucked. I keep trying to tell her don't order deli sandwiches in diners, order them only in delis! Even in delis they might suck. The corned beef was sliced 4 times thicker than it should have been. Plus, of course it sucked. Once you've had a really great Reuben it ruins your ability to tolerate a bad one. Anyway, fast, polite service, pleasant server (the hostitute was ornery, but overall, just what you would expect. Would I go back? Maybe, for breakfast only. They have one of those "we have everything" menus, gyros, Italian, Asian...but nothing is really good. read more

I am giving a star only because our waitress was clearly upset, yet remained kind and attentive to us, and was very apologetic about our wait (when she didn't have to be because it was not her fault). My fiancé and I came in for dinner around 6:15 tonight and ended up waiting almost two hours for our food. We got our appetizer and our soup/salad but ended up having to take our dinners to go because I work very early and had to go home to sleep. I work in food service and could tell it was the kitchen and NOT the waitress that was at fault - I have been there and done that countless times and feel very bad for the waitress, whose other customers may not be as understanding. We have never had a bad experience here before, but this one is enough for us to permanently cross Pegasus off our list. It's never a good sign when the back of house is willing to throw the front of house under the bus like that. read more

Yummy, yummy, yummy. If you are looking for good price, good food and good service. This is the place. Very kid-friendly! Will go when I'm in the area. read more

Pegasus is amazing! They have THE best chicken in all of Milwaukee. They are consistently amazing and their service is great. They must pay close attention to detail because we are never disappointed when we eat there, and we eat there often. Their rotisserie chicken and breasted chicken are so flavorful! I've had plenty of chicken which tastes good close to the skin, but becomes dry and bland after the first layer. This chicken is flavorful down to the bone. I have no idea how they do it other than having made a pact with the devil haha. Order just the chicken or soup and you won't be disappointed! Go Pegasus!!! read more