DO NOT BELIEVE THE NEGATIVE REVIEWS! Welcome to Peppino's, a warm inviting atmosphere where you will be served great food by a nice old Italian man and his son. It is a true father and son business. The place is always amazingly clean and the service is fast and professional. There is no Italian food in the mahopac/somers area that can compare to it. The place never fails and the father and son are both very talkative and genuinely nice people. There is a large eating area and a good amount of drinks to choose from. read more

Worst service ever! Waited 45 minutes to find out my pizza wasn't even in the oven yet after being told it would be ready in 30 minutes. When I questioned if my pizza was in the oven the "gentleman" behind the counter was rude and disrespectful. Asked what I expected, they were busy. I guess they don't need my business. Would NEVER recommend this place to anyone read more

We LOVE Peppinos - the Pizza is awesome; the entrees never fail to please, and my personal favorite - the Protein Salad is a real meal! In fact, I often order extra so I can have some of their delicious food later in the week read more

Was placing an order for pickup and person taking my order was very rude and very rude when picking up

Its nothing like the original Peppino's pizzeria on 241st Bronx, they made great pizza, and great calzones. I use to order the veal,peppers and mushrooms calzone...it was great but like the boss said, he had a big change in his clientele...lol read more

My family and I find the drive to this pizzeria convenient. Unfortunately, (even after all the times we have it another chance) app good things end right when we walk in through the door. The service is okay. The guys behind the counter are completely pissed at selling pizza whenever we go there. Even when we try our best to be nice. The waitresses are nice to us. The pizza however, is inconsistently mediocre at best. At first, we enjoyed it. Wanting more. Next time we went, everything changed. The pizza was soggy and oily. The caesar salad was by far the best item there. But we didn't go there for salad. Don't recommend. Hope for improvement. read more

Moved up from Da' BRONX so I know Pizza, PEPPINOS is a blessing in Yorktown Heights, I use to order from Yorktown Pizza but I have now been told I'm technically .2 miles out of thier delivery zone...Pizza was nothing to rave about anyway just close... PEPPINOS has good food & great service. They serve many different slices and they are all delicious, Mozzarella sticks are FRESH (not that frozen garbage), Heroes and calzones are full of FLAVOR.... Glad I found ya' PEPPINOS :) FYI - THEY WILL ALWAYS DELIVER...RAIN, SLEET, SNOW read more

Very unfriendly. I called in an order and when I walked in to pick it up they didn't acknowledge me standing at the counter for 2 min. When he did acknowledge me he was very rude. May I add it wasn't busy and the server was just standing around and didn't even greet me. Not to mention 6$ for a small Caesar salad, and it was very small. Ridiculous. If you are going to be over priced at least be friendly. read more

Best pizza I have had in upstate New York! Delicious crust, cheese, and sauce. And perfect amount of oil!

Stopped in today for the first time. I have to eat lunch on the fly, so it has to be quick and simple. The pizza was quite good. I had a regular cheese slice and a chicken slice. It was later on in the lunch cycle (about 2:30pm), but the pizza was reasonably fresh. I am very fussy about pizza, but any pizza snob knows that pizza degrades rather quickly once removed from the oven. It becomes soggy and the sauce thickens. My personal preference is oven-fresh and so oven-hot that it burns your mouth. This pizza was was crisp and tasty, despite being reheated. I also like that they had all of the usual seasonings right near the counter. Service was quick, if not overly cordial. Now, I have seen other comments here complaining about how unfriendly they are. I did not encounter this at all. They were polite enough and were just running their business. Besides, I just want a couple of slices, I am not looking to make new friends or have my butt kissed over a whopping $8 lunch order. I placed my order, paid, ate, and left. Works fine for me. The place is nice and clean, very modern and tasteful, with nice booths to sit and eat your lunch. When I am in the area again, I will probably return. I might even try a chicken or veal parm wedge, calling it in ahead of time. read more

You know a good pizza place from their regular plain slice, and theirs is absolutely perfect....extremely thin, yet crispy, sauce to cheese ratio is on point, it's as close as you can get to an Arthur ave. Pizza. The specialty slices are great too, honestly everything I've ever ordered is delicious. As to owner and his son, they have always been pleasant, after all you are there to get good pizza/food not marry the guy. read more

This place has horrible people working there. The food is generally good, but the men working behind the counter are awful. They give all the customers the old stink face. Very cranky and rude if you ask any questions about their food. It is not friendly at all. Never again. No more. You can get pizza anywhere, but they have been rude to me and my wife for the last time. read more

Yeah, I get it - the owner's son isn't fawning all over me, but I'm there to eat pizza not to make friends. Once you get that, you realize that they've got tasty pizza and their catering is really great for a decent price. I've got no hesitations ordering from them when I'm in the mood for pizza. read more

The slice is a 5/10, mediocre at best. The Sicilian is better, maybe a 7/10. The attitude of the owner's son, 0/10. A robot would have better people skills. Was this kid raised by wolves? read more

We used to order delivery from Peppino's Pizza quite often. I really like the pizza. I really don't like the customer service. The delivery order is wrong at least half the time. The owner's son is unfriendly to the point of being rude. read more

Peppino's knows how to make sauce. They make tasty dinners and delicious meatballs though I have not yet tried the pizza.

The most arrogant and rudest place I have ever spent my money at. Been there a few times. The owners son it truly one of the most obnoxious people I have met. How about an attempt at a smile or a simple thank you.? We are fortunate that we have some great pizza restaurants in our area and this place isn't even close to being one of them. I almost forgot, I have never had something microwaved in a real pizza place ( they pre-heated my chicken parm roll in the microwave) but I can't say never anymore. Spend your money at other places in the area where they APPRECIATE and THANK YOU for your business. Personally I would go a couple miles down Route 6 to Gino's Trattoria, awesome food and service, that being said just go anywhere other than here!!!! read more

I switched to ordering here. They're quick to deliver and care about customer. Careful of Friday's, they run out of slices, but still offer pies and entrees. read more

Consistently good. Salad pizza and wings are some of our favorites! They are quick and you don't have to wait for 45 minutes to an hour for pick up. read more

The best pizza around and the slices are always fresh. I think some of these other reviewers need to stop being so sensitive! It's a pizza place, not a white glove establishment. The owners seem to really know how to make pizza and charge a fair price. That's all that matters to me when it comes to pizza. read more

Peppinos it excellent whether you're taking out or eating in. I love the huge chicken parm dinner that comes with bread, salad and pasta. As the ultimate guilty pleasure I highly recommend the cheeseburger pizza. It's worth the calories! read more

This place has awesome Italian food, great pizza as well. My favorite dish is the fried calamari. The staff is always friendly and they get the food out really quick. Definitely recommend read more

Don't listen to the reviewers who complain about the attitude of the people working there because they're way off. Not everybody goes through their day with a cheesy smile on their face (pun intended). never had a bad slice or experience at this place. Pizza is consistently awesome. Service is fast. Price is fair. I don't know the kids name behind the counter but he's the son of the owner or maybe they own it together idk. Give him a friggin break. Imagine you had to work next to a hot oven with your father everyday. Kid deserves a metal. To give the business a poor review because he didn't kiss your butt because u bought a pie is not fair. Give this place a try. You will Be back. read more

I'll start with saying that the pizza here is very good. I'm giving this 2 stars because the staff is beyond rude. I've been here a lot over the past few years and it's always been this way. They make it seem like they are doing you a favor by giving you what you ordered. Never once have I heard them say hello, or thank you, or even crack a smile. It takes little to no effort to do all of those things. read more

Never had a problem here. Not the friendliest people but far from the way others describe them. Its a pizza shop not Carmines in the city for crying out loud. The pizza tastes like pizza. and better that whats around here. The wedges are good and I had a couple of decent salads here. You want fine dining, you are in the wrong place and if you cant tell the difference, then you don't deserve to make a complaint. Place is good pizza. period. read more

The food here is good, and I think prices are reasonable. I would give it four stars if their customer service didn't absolutely suck. I agree with all the other reviews-- they are never friendly, not even a simple "hi" when you walk in or "thank you" when you leave. Not sure if it's the owners but if so, that makes it even more sad. I will go here when I am in the area and want good pizza or chicken parm, but I really would rather not give them business. read more

If you are looking for a slice of pizza or good Italian food, take your money elsewhere. I will never give the man who owns Peppinos a single dollar ever again. The staff was very friendly and working very hard during a busier night. The owner was SCREAMING at the poor girls and reprimanding them in front of the restaurant. I felt uncomfortable and very sorry for his employees. The man is a jerk and I will never give my money to anyone who speaks to his workers like he does. read more

Alwzus great pizza. Never had a bad meal. We're from Brooklyn and were picky. People could be friendlier. Great combo with szlad and soda included. read more

Best Pizza in Putnam/Westchester. Try the "Grandma Style", out of this world.

overall great hard working place. Your review is beaming with potential, but it's currently shorter than most reviews on Yelp. Consider adding a few more details to help other Yelpers learn more about this business. read more

Came here a couple of times and I don't understand how. The owners son is so beyond nasty I don't know how anyone can go here. He basically threw the pizza at my friend and I and never said thank you! He acted like us being there was an inconvenience to him. So I thought it was just me that he was nasty to but every customer that walked in that door he was so rude to! I'll be shocked if they stay in business any longer with him being in charge. Disappointed. read more

Best Pizza around! Great customer service. They catered my wife's birthday party and they were right on time with the delivery. Our guest raved about the food all night. This is real Bronx pizza. Love this place read more

We've been ordering from Peppinos for years and we love it. When I walk in they put my order on the counter without me having to say a word! People say the owners son is rude. I say he's focused on keeping things moving in a very busy restaurant. He always thanks me and calls me hon. We are regulars and that won't change! read more

Went there for lunch with my girlfriend and when ordering the young man gave us such an attitude. Like we were bothering him. Anyway got our food and it was good but when we went to refill our drinks they have a sign saying REFILLS $1. Are you kidding. We just spent $30 on food and you want to charge for refills. When we went to pay the young man who we later found out is the owners son, didn't even say thank you. If your. To happy working there go get a job somewhere else. If he would loose the attitude the place would be 4 stars. The $1 refill is ridiculous. What's it cost them, 8 cents. Come on now. read more

Food is insane. Pizza is the best mammoth amount of toppings. Also buy pizza dough and make your own. This has good Italian food and good service read more

Food is just ok. Pizza is very good. Biggest problem I have with this place is the owners son. How bout a smile and a thank you once in awhile. Its not my fault your working in a pizza place. Be proud of it and make it yours. Your father (whom I've know from way back in his Bronx days) at least makes you feel welcome. This isn't the only pizza place in town. Scheeesh!!! read more

Definitely will not be going back to Peppinos any time soon. Called today at 4 o'clock and ordered pies to be picked up at 6. When I arrived they said they didn't even out the pizzas in the oven yet. They took my money as soon as I walked in but didn't put the pizzas in until 6 30. I had 25 people waiting at my house. In addition to not having them ready the men behind the counter were extremely rude to everyone. There are enough pizzerias in the area that are just as good and the people are nicer. It won't be necessary to go back there again. read more

I have lived in the area for about a year now and on some Friday nights I work late and I drive past 3 pizza places including this one. I usually stop here because its the closest to my house. The pizza isn't really anything to talk about but I went here for the convenience factor. The men behind the counter are never nice which is surprising since they are a customer service based business. I have NEVER been greeted with a Hello, Hi, smile or a simple friendly acknowledgement and I have been here atleast 10 times. I understand they are a busy place and probably have a large customer base but by now I should be somewhat familiar. I usually get a plain slice to go, nothing fancy. The prices at this place are ridiculous and honestly not even worth it. Tonight when I was charged 50 cents for a side of Parmesan cheese that is normally free they lost my business. It wasn't just the cheese it was a culmination of poor customer service, mediocre food and price gouging. If I was to eat in then it would have been free. The guy " cut me a deal" because my usual ~2.65 every other time I have came went up to $3.34 and I brought three dollars with me. Its a shame that they are not more customer driven. I love supporting local businesses. I guess I will have to try the other places on my home now. read more

Absolutely disgusting.. order delivery got my wedge bread was gross and meat balls were microwaved... got another wedge with the same order and there was nothing on it.. I would give them no stars but that's not an option.. never eating their food again.. read more

Moved up from the city. It's hard to find good pizza around here. There grandma pizza , well done is good. My issue is, it's hard for me to give them my money because the kid who works there ...I think the owners son- he is so rude and nasty. Makes you feel like you're this huge bother, really nasty personality. Makes it hard to frequent the place read more