Not just the best pizza in Agawam, but the best pizza I've ever had hands down. These guys are as legit as it gets

Good pizza. Reliable timing. Reasonable price.

This is the best pizza in town. Dario is very accommodating and he will make sacrifices to deliver the best quality and service. I highly recommend this place for anyone that's new or hasn't heard about it before. A true hidden gem in our community. read more

Really good pizza one of my top 3 in an area filled with superb pizza shops. The staff/employees are fantastic and delivery is quick. Love the wings they're always very saucy. Grinders are also excellent. read more

Great pizza at a great price! They really care about their customers and go there extra mile to make sure they're satisfied.

Great pizza. I usually like a thin crust but this light and airy mid-crust had a buttery texture I really enjoyed and the large is BIG. 3 tables in a strip mall, hole in the wall but I'm done being surprised that great joints hide in these places read more

I've ordered a grinder from at least 5 different pizza shoppes around here and this is by far my favorite. (I'm pregnant-it's a craving.) Prices are great also. Can't wait to try more off the menu ! read more

Great pizza, probably the best I've had in a while, I live in ct but I'll definitely be back next I'm in the area....

After reading all the good reviews I figured it was time to check this place out. Peppos makes a legit pie and I'm a huge pizza snob to say the least. So far we have tried the house special, buffalo chix, cheeseburger special, and a plain cheese pie along with some others. This little unknown place is on par with Frank Pepes and some of the other big boys here in New England. read more

Had the privilege of Trying Peppo's for the first time Friday 6/8/18. We ordered a large 'Roni and a cheeseless veggie pizza. Both were fantastic. Very fresh tasting and both pizza's were huge for being larges. The best part of the visit was meeting the owner Dario. His professionalism and friendliness will bring him very far if his qualtity remains as good as it is currently. Thanks Dario. read more

This is my go-to pizza delivery place. Having just recently moved to Agawam I haven't tried much else but that's because I'm so happy with Peppo's. I've tried a variety of pizzas and all are good. The ones I'll mention are the few I order most: Alfredo pizza with chicken and extra broccoli, chicken bacon ranch pizza WITH the cold lettuce and plain old cheese. Their delivery time is pretty consistent usually around 40 minutes - once it came in like 25! Longest I've waited is an hour but that's not typical. The staff are nice. read more

There is simply no better pizza in western Massachusetts. Period. Peppo is so friendly and whether we order for delivery or carry out, you know you're getting quality and amazing taste down to the last piece. Their sauce is truly addictive. The crust has just the right crunch and chew. In summary, pizza perfection. I can't write a review without recommending the wedge salad as another must have. You'll never be disappointed. Unless they're closed! read more

My family tried 3 pizzas: the house special, buffalo chicken, and meatball & sausage. All were delicious! They have the best crust and their toppings are fresh and flavorful. The house special was simple, yet, as the name suggests, special. Fresh tomatoes, herbs, parmesan cheese, and a bit of olive oil make for a tasty pizza! We will be returning! read more

Peppo's Pizza - House special, buffalo chicken, and meatball & sausage - Pizza Near Me - Agawam, Massachusetts

First off, the crust is really, really good - not sure what the secret is. We called and ordered our first pizza from Peppo's and when I went to pick it up, Peppo himself overheard me giving my name. He came over to introduce himself, realizing I was a new customer. We had a nice conversation and he said to let him know how we liked the pizza as he seemed eager to please. We loved it and went back the next day for another one. He recognized me and seemed genuinely happy that we liked the pizza. I love that he is hands-on in the kitchen with the rest of his staff. They seemed really busy both days we went, with the phone constantly ringing and the orders coming in. You can eat there, but it's not a big place, not too much for seating, so if you have a larger party, best to order it and take it home with you. But definitely worth it! We'll be visiting again! read more

One of my favorite places to get take out food! Peppo is the sweetest guy and he really appreciates all of his customers. The grinders, pizza, appetizers... everything tastes fresh and delicious. I absolutely recommend. read more

Come here after Six Flags! We did and we were not disappointed. The cheese pizza and chicken parm were delicious and reasonably priced. They had a cheeseburger pizza with french fries on it, SO GOOD. Better than the food was the service. Peppo was adorable. When he found out we were eating there, he had us sit down and brought everything over to us. We didn't have to ask for anything, he made sure we had exactly what we needed. He also brought over a basket of warm bread and butter while we were waiting for our pizza. He was such a friendly and nice guy. The pizza shop looks normal from the outside, but was cute on the inside with nice pictures and centerpieces on the table. Unfortunately, being from the Boston area, we were only in town for Six Flags but we told him with service and tasty food like that, we would be back next time we're around. read more

Pizza is delicious and extremely filling, haven't had anything else on menu yet but expect to. I normally order meat lovers or Hawaiian and everytime it's been cooked well and heavy on toppings read more

This place was fantastic and who I believe was the owner, maybe even Peppo himself, was at the counter and very friendly. Definitely give the mozzarella triangles a try with the marinara sauce. If you need a traditional slice of pizza this is the place to go. The crust was a fluffier crust with nice amounts of cheese and delicious sauce. I just wish we lived a little closer to them! read more

Really good pizza which is hard to find it seems, family owned, I was greeted by the owners son and he was very friendly, introduced me to his father, they are into four wheeler as am I, nice people, only downfall is it's a bit of a hike from my house, but if you are in the area I highly recommend read more

The food is delicious, the service outstanding! I met Peppo, his wife and even his Mom. This is what a truly authentic family pizza shop is all about. I've bough a ton of pizzas in my life, but none better than Peppos; you won't be disappointed! read more

I am new to western Mass and will admit that I am very picky with my pizza. So far, I've not been impressed with the local pizza joints. However, Peppo's Pizza may be western Mass's saving grace. After much research and a bit of a drive, I must say this pizza was 100% worth it. Not only was the pizza good, but the service was excellent as well (not to mention the meatballs were outstanding!) I will definitely be back for more! read more

tried this small good for take out casual pizza place in Agawam and would definitely order again. I ordered for a personal size veggie pizza with extra bacon and was raving about it! the crust was just right-med. thick and had a nice extra crunch to it. the toppings were not overwhelming and it tasted good! they even have old fashioned cream sodas which I will try next time and maybe their other choices (the usual chicken tenders/mozzarella etc... read more

Recently we have started to go here quite often and there is a great reason why! The pizza is cooked to perfection every time, the crust is so crispy and delicious as well. If you go to pick it up you will most likely meet the owner who couldn't be any friendlier! Highly recommend this place. read more

This is one of my favorite pizza places! The owner and staff treat you like family! I love their pizza! And their buffalo chicken grinder is really good. My family and I get Peppo's every Wednesday. We've always had great service and amazing food here! Highly recommend! read more

Love the Chicken Broccoli Alfredo Pizza ! Peppo's has the best crust in the area. Quick and friendly service.

I always recommend Peppo's to everyone that says they want to order a pizza!! I love how it's such a fantastic balance between the cheese and savory flavors. The crust is great too! And my favorite feature is the bread crumbs on the bottom of the pizza...I love their pizza and it is always my go-to pizza place! read more

Was going to Nicky's after Six Flags but it was mobbed. Checked Yelp and found Peppos and boy are we glad we did. Amazing Pizza and probably the best Hawaiian Pizza we've had in a long time. This New Yorker highly recommends Peppos. read more

"The Best Pizza in Agawam" argument is settled in my mind. Peppo's does something to the underside and crust of their pizza that is just awesome. I don't know exactly what it is, but damn it's good. Sauce and cheese are both quality as well. The staff is great. I think they are mostly family and all very nice. Do pick up at least once to say hi, it's a friendly spot. Delivery is fairly quick, about the same or maybe a minute quicker than others in town. Overall, when someone says "let's get pizza" I get the Peppo's menu without a second thought. read more

Peppo's Pizza is a great choice for anyone living in Agawam, Feeding Hills, or West Springfield. This place consistently turns out an outstanding pizza pie! Never a greasy bottom! When I take a middle slice and there is no wet spot of grease on the box you know it is going to be good. We also really like Peppo's French fries. He understands what few do. Serve your to go fries in a cardboard container not Styrofoam. Keep up all the great work guys!! Our #1 Choice for Pizza in town! read more

Peppo's has the best pizza I have had in years. I'm from NYC and have lived in the Boston area, and perhaps keeping this place a small Mom And Pop pizzeria will keep it great. Recommend eating pizza at this small place as thin crust pizza never taste better than when it is fresh out of the oven. I do wish that Peppo would make the eating area a little bit cozier and add carbonated water to the selection of drinks. read more

This place is amazing!! The owner was super nice and the food was so good. Best pizza I've ever had thank you Mr Peppo!!

Garden specialty pizza was absolutely delicious. The crust was thin and crispy with excellent flavor. You could really taste the ingredients--excellent sauce, just the right amount of garlic and seasoning. Thoroughly enjoyed the meal!. read more

Thin pizza, but good. The medium size looked huge but two of us ate it up! Drinks are bottled not fountain drinks. Nice folks serving

Food is always hot on delivery. Owner takes phone calls. Box taped shut and extra care taken on each order. With that being said, it does take an hour to get an order delivered, weekdays and longer on weekends. Same delivery driver each time. read more

Love there pizza. Hamburger n cheese , all the way!! Nice family owned pizzeria!!! Friendly n clean.

Bad business practice. 3 times in a row I have called to order a large order between 830 and 845 and it says they are open. No answer no return call. It's 849 now as I write this. I changed my review. I was a weekly buyer plus including my office and so on. Time to find a new place if you're to rushed to get home instead of honoring the hours you state that your open. Again bad business and probakly a 3000 a year loss read more

First time trying Peppo's tonight. We have a new pizza place. The whole family loved it. Great crust, house special excellent. Nice people too. read more

Love love love this place!!!!!! Fresh bread for the grinders, perfect roast beef and amazing golden BBQ wings!

Great pizza and family run business. So friendly and the food is delicious.

This place is pretty solid. In a pretty nondescript location next to a Fedex/UPS shipping store. Their pizza crust is awesome, and their house special is definitely a household favorite. They do have a couple of tables to eat at, but I'm assuming 95% of people pickup or get it delivered. I've yet to see anyone eating inside in my 5+ visits to this place. I've also had their calzone and their cheesy garlic bread. The calzone is good, but no different than any other calzone you can find at any local pizza place. I would avoid the garlic bread they simply cut a grinder in half, load it with olive oil, garlic, and cheese. It's not bad, but a little more attention to the bread would be nice. Based off of distance and quality this is our go to location when we want to pick up a pizza. Always consistently delicious with the best crust in the area. Definitely try out the house special and if you like it sliced into wedges make sure to tell them because everything gets cut square, even if the pie is round. read more