Went to them a month ago. Good was good. Service was ok. When it came time to pay they changed the price by 50 bucks and said they must have made a mistake. Was not professional at all. The counter guy almost laughed at me which also was unprofessional. Having no choice as the party started in an hour I just paid them. Cash to boot. read more

This place is just downright disgusting! The new ownership ruined this staple in Farmingdale! They put out food that is obviously DAYS OLD! I ordered a standard bacon egg (over easy$ and cheese. My eggs were way over cooked. When I told them I got an attitude and grabbed my sandwich, threw it out and made a new one. They precut all cold cuts so that's also not fresh! The back room where they used to have tables to eat is a complete disaster! Filthy bathroom. I will never go back here again. I'd much rather go to Main Street Deli up the block and get better quality food and better service. The only good thing about this place is Jesus! read more

Pete's Deli - Delis Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

i took over pete's deli about 4 months ago and i have non stop worked towards making the quality, consistency,appearance and service better than before we have been working around the clock making renovations and improvements without closing doors.i request anybody and everybody who has a bad experience at pete's to give us a second chance and come see for urselves how far we have come al9ng.i guarntee that u will have a pleasant experience and while ur there ask for al and i will personally greet u.i love being part of this farmingdale community. daler strong read more

Pete's Deli - Delis Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Someone bought out Pete's Deli in Farmingdale. This is second time we ordered egg sandwiches w/extra Boars Head ham, sliced thin and paid premium price for the upgrade in ham This is the second time the toast was burnt, no butter on toast as we ordered, cheap deli ham was riddled with fat and nerve, sliced as thick as and tasted like cardboard. Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. We ordered from original Pete's Deli all the time as food was great. Now with new owner and unpalatable food he provides to customers, we, our extended family and friends are experiencing lack of quality and won't order from this deli again. See the pics for yourself. All that's left of my sandwich is disgraceful. Paid a pretty penny to get an egg and 1/8 bread out of this sandwich. read more

Pete's Deli - Pete's Deli Farmingdale, NY Under New Owner - Delis Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

See all

Terrible food and the lady who answers the phone is downright rude and has a bad attitude. When you arrive she is normally smoking in the parking lot and gives you a nasty look as you enter... Go to Main St. Deli a block away- they are much better and friendly owner operated. read more

Woman who works the counter needs to calm down. She is so aggressive and rude. I have been in there 3 times and every single time I have cringed from hearing the way she talks to customers. On top of that, my order has been wrong twice. The quality of the food has gone down since new ownership. Skip ur visit here. read more

Great food selection. Much of it is redone and the rest is underway, but the food is the best reason to go. Reminds me of the original Pete... many years ago. read more

Pete's Deli - the front of a deli and cat restaurant - Delis Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Staple for farmingdale sandwiches. Hungry man and the american are always good choices.

Got a tuna melt...the worst I've ever had! they burnt the bread and tried to scrape off the burnt bread. Yuk!!

They were nasty when I asked the dressing of the salad ,I didn't know and asked them to give me a mix of dressing. And took my salad and told me to leave forcefully read more

I made the move to Farmingdale recently and it's been very difficult to find a great deli. I stumbled upon Pete's one afternoon, and it's been my go-to ever since! They ALWAYS have hot food ready, which is something you can't say about most delis, they are fast with your order, and have great prices-- which in today's day and age is increasingly important. Everyone who works there is super friendly, it's my favorite deli on the Island. read more

Went here after a long time, used to be my favorite deli. So happy to see it is under new ownership, looking cleaner and updated! food was great! read more

Nice deli ..im very picky when it comes to delis.. im happy to have found it my boyfriend recently moved in the area and it will be our go to spot read more

we had catering from here. We got a tray of shrimp in garlic sauce, chicken parmigiana, ziti , house salad and mixed fruit salad. food was decent. read more

I've been going to Petes for years. The people who answer the phone are always rude. They act like it's such an inconvenience that you're calling. In person they're friendly so I'm not sure what their problem with the phone is. The food is very good with lots of options. It's the reason why we deal with their rude behavior via telephone. Quick delivery service. I would recommend them to my friends but advise not to call. read more

Stopped by here to grab a sandwich. Stood at the counter for a while until someone finally came up. I started stating my order and halfway through my 1st sentence the guy looks at me and just walks away. I stood there in disbelief for about in a minute and then realized that my hard earned money will be better spent at a place that actually appreciates my business. read more

I like Pete's deli but the way there make their burgers are killing me who use sandwich roll In place of an hamburger bun it doesn't even taste good with the roll is overly chewy and just tuff to eat please get some hamburger buns please and stop using those rolls read more

I went into pete's deli in Farmingdale expecting the same quality service I always receive while I'm there. The woman working the counter was very rude and reaked of vodka, I asked for ketchup hashbrowns and pepper on my hungry man and she gave me peppers without ketchup and homefries instead of hashbrowns, very dissapointing experience. read more

Highly recommend this spot for lunch. I usually get a hero and half pound of some type of side salad. A fresh side salad in itself is worth the 5 stars. Alot of the time the side salad at other places will taste like it has sat out for a while or maybe even refrigerated for a couple of days. All in all the lunch always hits the spot and I will continue to come here a few days a week for lunch. read more

Live up the block And come every morning Foods good and staff is fast and helpful Always has good coffee Great breakfast Awesome lunch 4 Delis in the Area My go to spot all day!!! Ty!!!! read more

The food is good (when they actually have it in stock) it's their service that could really use an improvement. After being placed on hold for a solid five minutes the guy picks the phone back up and goes "hello?" With an attitude, when I tell him I was placed on hold he goes "well we don't have what you asked for". read more

Called this morning to place order for pick up. Gentleman who answered was extremely nasty on the phone, and proceeded to hang up the phone prior to stating the total how long, or even a DAMN GOOD BYE.... Called back and said he was done with the conversation. Thankfully the sandwich I purchased was good minus the cold cheese on a hot sandwich... read more

Great deli with good hot food and breakfast specials. Clean always friendly and fast. We order from them everyday at work and as long as you tell them exactly what you want there isn't any problem. Portions are great for the price. read more

Pete's Deli - Delis Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

See all

Pete's deli is a very good local deli that delivers all over Farmingdale. Their hot dishes are home made dishes and are quite delicious. They also make nice sized sandwiches on fresh Italian bread they also have some tasty desserts. Pete's is a good deli for the neighborhood. read more

Worth a shot. pretty good.. Significantly better than some, but not the best... good specials from time to time though... make sure they get your order right before you leave though, and remember that delivery takes a long time. read more

You can't expect a better deli around here. They're professional, have an amazing selection of items both hot foods, deli meats, cold salads, and breakfast stuff at great prices. Make sure to come by before 12 to enjoy their amazing breakfast sandwiches. The staff is amazing and are great behind the counter. HEAD THERE NOW! You won't regret it. read more

Pete's Deli - Chicken cutlet hero with mayo, lettuce, and American cheese ... so good - Delis Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Pete's deli is a great spot to grab a sandwich in Farmingdale. They also have a decent selection of hot foods for lunch which is a big plus. I have been going to this deli for the past few years because other delis just seem to skimp on sandwich meat. The prices are a bit high but I'd rather spend an extra dollar or two and receive a sandwich that is going to satisfy me. Another big plus is they deliver for free as long as you meet the 10 dollar minimum which I just found out so I shall be ordering from here to my job. read more

Been going there for the potato salad for 25 years. I can eat a pound of it by myself. Excellent hot food as well. One of last remaining legit delicatessens left in the area. I have always thought they make the best potato salad on the planet. read more

Pete's deli is the best. I Go there for lunch often. I was having a bad day the other day and the blonde behind the counter cracked a joke which brightened my spirits up. Little things like this keeps customers loyal. read more

I want to make management aware of an issue that occurred during my recent visit. One of your employees (Mary, if I'm not mistaken) took my order and then proceeded to prepare my food with no mask and no gloves. I looked around and saw that all of the other employees had masks and gloves, but she obviously doesn't care about following the rules or have any regard for the health and safety of your customers during a global pandemic. I ended up walking out without my food because I was so disgusted by what I witnessed. I have been a loyal customer of your deli for many years and I am extremely disappointed and upset about this blatant disregard and unsafe behavior, to the point where I would rather not return if your employee is going to selfishly put customers at risk. I hope that this will be addressed to avoid more similar complaints and a loss of customers. read more

Yummy yummy yummy! Only have tried a couple of things thus far and everything had been on point. Breakfast is good but Lunch is great! I recommend their subs and sandwiches. The service is exceptionally quick and they have enough seating. read more

See all

Pete's is the local Farmingdale deli that just about everyone in the town goes to. The sandwiches are good to great, the staff is friendly and competent. They have a nice variety of choices, including a fruit section, a wall of different chips and a ton of drink selections. Prices are a tad high but nothing to complain about because these guys can crank out a sandwich in under a minute where other delis take over 5 minutes. And they always have lots of help too, there's always at least 4-5 guys behind the counter ready to help you, whereas at other delis the employees are hiding in the back or day dreaming. Pete's is great and definitely try the Godfather sandwich. Mmmmm. read more

It's all about the customer service. The minute the lady/man picks up the phone she is rude. You feel like she's doing you a favor by ordering from them. She rushes you to order then hangs up on you. Doesn't even say bye. And if there is a long delivery wait she tells you with an attitude. I guess this company doesn't need the business. She must be a family member because no owner would keep someone like her. Very rude. Try a different deli. Stage Door in Farmingdale is great. Food and customer service. read more

I'm stuck out here in Farmingdale with my girlfriend for the day and we were both equally starving.. somehow we managed to both agree that a good deli sandwich would hit the spot. And oh man, after looking through Yelp, I found Pete's and hah we weren't disappointed attttt allll. Fast, easy, and friendly service provided by three guys behind the counter made this experience extra special. She ordered a "Who's afraid of Virginia Ham?" Which is hot Virginia Ham with melted American cheese, lettuce and tomato on a hero with honey mustard. I ordered a "Godfather" with is ham cappy, Genoa Salami, pepperoni, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, peppers, oil and vinegar on a hero. Both tasted extremely FRESH and AMAZING. They also offer hot food, grill, and ready to eat servings. I'm currently taking a break before devouring the second half of my sandwich, but even typing this review took a lot out of me.. But again, we weren't disappointed one bit.. we're full, but not a bad full. Thanks Pete's for satisfying a deli sandwich craving couple! read more

Pete's Deli - The Godfather - Delis Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Bring an extra kidney. You'll need to sell it to pay for your lunch. $12 for a turkey sandwich and Gatorade. I haven't been here in years and now I remember why. read more

while seaqua deli in massapequa is still my #1 go to deli in the area, when in Farmingdale Pete's is a solid substitute...super friendly service, generous portions, every sandwich concoction you could ever imagine - and if not they'll make whatever you'd like of course...only complaint is that the prices are a little steep, but the quality of the product makes it pretty well worth the cost read more

I've been going to this deli for the last 15 years and every time is just spot on, very consistent, and always good.

Love this deli! I only go there for one thing: their chicken Caesar wraps. They're amazing. Service is always good and the prices aren't too bad read more

Great spot that I randomly found on my way to the beach. I ordered the grilled chicken panini togo. I just took a bite of my panini and it was delicious. Highly recommended and the staff was super helpful in picking out the bread and toppings. read more

I work in Farmingdale and we order from here a lot. Always good and consistent. Good breakfasts, quality salads and sandwiches for lunch. Never had any problems. read more