Ordered a medium pepperoni pizza (extra sauce and well done because that is the best way to eat a pie) with some hot boneless wings. The cheese in the middle of the pizza wasn't melted all the way and was very gummy. Crust was not crispy at all. Overall, a mid pizza but not the worst I've ever had. Now the boneless "wings" were the real disappointment of the order. I understand the gamble I'm taking when I order boneless instead of regular wings at a restaurant but I've been surprised before. We received 8 chicken nuggets with some spicy coating on them. They were not sauced but rather had a coating that was spicy but the chicken itself was spongey and tasted like they were simply frozen and were heated up in the microwave. Maybe their normal wings are where it's at but I wouldn't know. read more

Pizza is was great but the service really sucks here. The hours say they are open at 10but the lobby doesn't open until 3pm they never have the door unlocks to carry out need new management and lobby hours read more

Everything we had here was amazing. Seriously great pizza. For an appetizer we had the pizza poutine and I am still dreaming about it. I would have been completely satisfied to have an entire order of that for my meal. We also ordered a pepperoni, ham, and black olives pizza. We got a large and still had several slices the take-home. Everything about the pizza was incredible. The sauce was slightly sweet and just the right amount. The cheese was thick and gooey. The meet was plentiful and tasty. I literally want to drive to Chicago to have some more, right now. In the immortal words of Homer Simpson, "Hmmmmm, pizza...(drools)" read more

See all

Fye. The best thin crust in the city tbh. I love their pepperoni Pizza, but I'm curious about their deep dish and pan pizza

Truly great and unique specialty pizza combinations with incredible wood fired crust. The staff here- many of which are long-timers know how to treat you right as well inside this authentic family run joint read more

The pizza was good, excellent thin crust and it's not that expensive. The large they tell you over the phone feeds 3 people comfortably but it's really more like two, so if you want leftovers get a larger one. When you go to pick the pizza up they have you wear a mask inside. The guy who brought my pizza out from the kitchen though was very much not masked up - in the midst of the delta variant part of the pandemic - and that made the pizza let's say slightly less appetizing and ruined the whole "we're keeping you and your food safe" vibe. read more

Solid tavern style, but I like Pat's better. Bacon and pepperoni are good, I'd skip the sausage. Close so I'll be back.

I always love their pizza. This is based off my Grubhub order. My order came really early. I ordered the large pizza with sausage, mushrooms onions and green peppers. It was delicious and I always love their crust. Even though it's thin, it holds the ingredients well. Their crust is crispy and has a nice bite to it. Their fries were huge! Crispy and salty :). read more

Pete's Pizza - Sausage, mushroom, green pepper and onions pizza with fries. - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Delicious wings and superb pizza. Great service... All in all wonderful experience.

Love this place. Moved to the neighborhood a year ago and can honestly say this is one of the best places around. The staff is so friendly and the food is always on point. We love coming here for birthdays and celebrations because it just has that old-timey family pizza place feel to it. We have never had a bad item here. Love that they have parking and the prices won't break the bank. This time around we got a pepperoni and ricotta pizza and some potato skins. Definitely get more than what you pay for, this meal was only $35! Finally remembered to take some pics! Keep doing what you do, we will always come back! read more

See all

Just ordered from Pete's and am very unhappy . I love their pizza and it never disappoints, but this time I ordered fried chicken dinner and fried shrimp dinner. I asked for a substitute on the chicken, as I wanted 2 thighs. The order was placed with the kitchen correctly (sub a thigh for a leg) but instead I received 2 drumsticks and NO THIGH. (Fortunately, when I called back after delivery, I wasn't charged extra and the young lady who took my order was very apologetic.) Beyond that, the chicken pieces are so tiny, they almost look like Cornish hen pieces. I understand prices have increased everywhere, but 14$ for this type of entree is unacceptable. The same with the shrimp. Advertised as Jumbo shrimp but they are one step larger than salad shrimp. They were, at best, medium size. And the price is $14.+ for the dinner. Both dinners include salad or coleslaw and fries or spaghetti and bread (no butter). Been a loyal customer for over 20 years but this experience has changed my mind about ordering again. The entrees are excessive in price and there are plenty of pizza places that are comparable if I want pizza. I wonder if ownership will react to a bad review and a dissatisfied customer. Somehow, I doubt they will... read more

I've been a customer for 15 years. That will probably come to an end tonight. I was told my delivery order would be there in an hour. After 70 minutes, I called and told it was a few minutes away. Fifteen minutes later, it still wasn't there and called again. After explaining how late it was, so late I had to make dinner for my 11 year old, I was put on hold for five minutes. Someone else picked up, and explained they were swamped. Then why did they tell me it would take an hour when I ordered. The man told me the pizza would be there soon. I asked to have it comped. I was offered $5 off on my next order. Ruining someone's dinner is not worth just $5. I told him to cancel the order and he hung up on me. Yeah, there are plenty of other pizza places out there, and Pete's apparently wants me to try them instead. read more

I had to put my thin crust cheese pizza with pepperoni in the air fryer for five minutes for 380° for it to be a nice crispy pizza. it was just plain it was barely fully cooked. It looked pale.... told my dad this and he said "I shouldn't have ordered pizza here" "It's Cheap" read more

Good pizza and we loved the Italian beef egg rolls. The atmosphere was fun and staff was nice. read more

Waaay downhill. Been eating there ever since it was in a small shoebox of a storefront on Western across the street and closer to Lane Tech. Went Saturday and ordered a stuffed pizza (with ingredients) and it was bland. The cheese was tasteless which used to be their best pizza feature even before their sauce. Ordered a small thin crust as well and that was a "little" better (for whatever reason) but looked like it was thrown together as quickly as possible and the cheese didn't even cover the whole pizza. Sad to see how the quality of so many great Chicago restaurants have changed after the "pandemic". read more

After YEARS of loyal service to Pete's, I am afraid that they are now BLACKLISTED. An understandable mistake sending the wrong pizza ended up me being gas lit for 3.5 hours waiting for the correct pizza to be sent. The manager was unapologetic and refused to refund me, so I was left with no other choice but a replacement pizza. If I hadn't called 4 separate times to make sure my pizza was coming I would never have received another pizza. A cash cow such as Pete's being too cheap or owning up to a mistake that is SO EASILY FIXABLE is pathetic and mind boggling. Poor customer service and business practice. read more

To me it's a very average and serviceable Chicago style pizza place. Tavern style square cut. Healthy size and proportionate cost. Toppings are good but too many can over shadow the pizza if you don't add extra cheese. Not my favorite but much much better than something like Jimmy John's Dominos Sarpinos or Little Caesar's. Also better than everything I found in Austin except for My Brothers Pizza. It's just very competitive pizza wise in Chicago. To be fair I have not tried their deep dish offerings and I should do that to better compare them to some of the other players. read more

Amazing attentiveness by the waiters. They were very good. Food was absolutely wonderful.

Love the pizza here- the service wasn't that great- the Mexican gentleman was very lazy and not very nice

A friend recommended this spot and I was glad I stopped in. Pizza and wings were amazing!

This is my go to pizza delivery spot, always on point and always comes hot make sure to order your pies well done to get that extra texture profile read more

We used to frequent Pete's for years. Celebrated many occasions here and have always loved the staff and of course the pizza. We moved away several years ago and did not return until today, to my surprise walking in was a WOW factor ....They underwent a makeover and it's amazing. Visually I could not stop noticing all the great details. New windows, artwork, seating, lighting and the beautiful brick oven. Now when I sat down I was handed a new looking menu. Well remember we came for the pizza so I didn't know if I was going to be disappointed because the look and items were different and when I saw the brick oven I was like oh dear.. now i love love love brick oven but that every once in a while I absolutely crave some old school traditional pizza. YES it was in the menu!!!! Ok so we also chose to try their bruschetta and did not disappoint. Score !!! Emily our server was in line with the way we ALWAYS felt coming here.... WELCOMED ! Emily was super friendly and accommodating. Checked in on us but not overly. The pizza.... delicious and consistent as we always remembered. The crust is thin with just enough crunch, the sauce is not very sweet it's plenty and delicious flavors. As one of their wall lite signs states " "it's the SAUCE". but the cheese did not disappoint. It's fresh ! I LOVE LOVE the makeover. It's beautiful, well thought out, visually i just wanted to look and photograph every corner of this place. But I am so happy that it's the same vibe , and the same tasing pizza Kudos to Pete's read more

See all

The one word that I find that best describes the take out from this place is INCONSISTENCY! It's like the one order I recently placed which consisted of a philly cheese steak sandwich and a pizza. Outside of the no steak in the sandwich (i didn't know a vegan version existed) and the weird tasting tomato sauce on the pizza dinner and a movie night was a complete success! Seriously the cost of eating out has increased exponentially unfortnately the quality has taken a serious hit. I will admit when they get it right there pizza kicks some serious arse! But then again the following week the ribs were tasteless and unedible. You know when you're blowing 40 to 50 bucks a shot I don't believe its too much to ask for an enjoyable meal. read more

The crust tasted under done and everything slid off the pizza when trying to pull the pieces apart. Delivery was good

Love their thin crust pizza. Always comes out piping hot which I love. Also love the spaghetti & meatballs. Service is consistently good.

This will be a delivery review and my first time having it. Pete's pizza is a tavern style thin crust pizza joint. A friend of a friend told me that this was his favorite thin crust pizza place in Chicago so I had to give it a try. I thought the pizza was very good and one of the better thin crusts in Chicago! The pizza was very crispy and the sauce was sweet. It was super cheesy and I thought the toppings were amazing! We got a sausage and pepperoni pizza and I thought the toppings were as good as Pequod's and Lou's. The sausage and pepperoni were that good! The pizza wasn't overly greasy either. I will have to dine in sometime and give it a try. I live near there and the place looks like a nice bar and has open air seating, which would be nice for summer! read more

Pete's Pizza - Sausage and pepperoni family pizza for two people. - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Been ordering from Pete's for some time. Quality has been suffering recently. Delivery took for ever and pizza arrived ice cold. I will never order from here again. read more

I'll be honest this is probably the most forgettable pizza I've ever eaten. Cheese 2/10 Sauce 1/10 Crust 310 Toppings 2/10 read more

Pete's used to be good for those of you not from here. Ordered fries with no salt, got a phone call from manager shortly after stating that their fries already come with salt so they couldn't make them. So, like..do you get boxes of hot salted fries every morning for service? If they don't, then do the fries come out of your frier magically salted as soon as they're done? Honestly the dumbest conversation I've had in a while read more

Waiting another 30 minutes for a pizza that I asked not to burn the first time. This is not the first time. read more

We got dinner here on tuesday after bowling They closed at midnight We order beer Mule Wings Steak sandwich And pizza Pretty good We take leftovers Service on point only guys no woman See you soon again read more

See all

We used to order from here years ago. We even had our rehearsal dinner here back in '95. Unfortunately, I can't even think about giving a good review. They got 2 stars for quicker delivery but that's where it ends. The food was ice cold. Not even warm. Cold. The fries were soggy, which I understand. We don't live as close to them as I'd like but ugh...it was so bad. Fries were all cold. Not even just the top half but all the way through to even the WHITE AND UNCOOKED french fries on the bottom. Also, I have no respect for a pizza joint that puts its pepperoni UNDER the cheese. Pizza cold. Ribs cold. Fries cold. Boneless chicken wings cold. Not warm. Cold. Not ordering again. read more

Lasagna was absolutely appalling. completely inedible. took one bite and gave it back. still appeared on the check. won't be coming back.

Good pizza and great big juicy wings (especially the Buffalo and teriyaki) BUT only get them in orders of 8. Getting a dozen or more will result in completely different and smaller wings that are not breaded. They will change the wings so the increased amount will fit into the same size container. Also completely avoid the regular fried chicken--scrawny, dry little pieces to the point where a jumbo wing has more meat than their fried chicken breast. There is a famous fast food chicken place about a block south that would be way better if you want a 4pc. meal. read more

See all

I ordered pizza and ribs (and other stuff) from Door Dash and initially I was a little concerned because the order kept being pushed later and later, about 20 minutes. But then it just showed up because Pete's drivers are not Door Dash. The food was EXCELLENT and exceeded my expectations. Ribs were tender, pizza was generous and flavorful. I will gladly order from this spot again. read more

Pete's is the perfect spot for carry out. We have been ordering here for over 15 years. Throughout the years they have updated the place, and they have quite the trendy restaurant-bar area. The pizza is a classic Chicago tavern style, and consistently delicious. The prices aren't cheap, but not overly expensive. They have a pickup window so you don't have to go through the restaurant. read more

The food was great! I ordered a pizza and it was spot on! The service was awesome and the waiters were so attentive! The restaurant itself was so cute and festive. read more

The pizza here is amazing, I LOVE Pete's! It's probably the closest I've gotten to NY Style pizza, with that being said they just changed their prices and everything went up and they haven't updated their online menus or their paper menus. I ordered a small 10in. Cheese pizza, add ham add pineapple and I was expecting a pre tax subtotal of $15.90 and ended up with a subtotal of $17.48. Small cheese pizza went up from $12.90 to $13.58, and additional toppings on a small went up from $1.50 to $1.95. So with taxes I just paid $19.36 for a tiny pizza. read more

Pete's Pizza - Ham and pineapple pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I've been a long time customer. Pizza is good and delivered fast. The last 5+ times I've received a delivery, I've noted "Please leave food in lobby. No Contact" due to the pandemic. It's on my receipt. They constantly come to my door asking for a tip (which I call in with on every delivery). The restaurant can't figure out how to receive a tip over the phone and give it to their driver. When I call I get "I guess I'll just have to start firing drivers" from the manager. No. You didn't accept my tip over the phone and give it to the driver. "You ordered online. If you ordered over the phone this would not happen." I guess it's my fault. I order from lous, art of pizza and many others. They all figure it out. Sad for a good pizza place to blame their staff for their own issues. Honest review. read more

I've been eating this pizza for over 30 years. Its the most consistent pie in the city with the best sauce. Hands down. Delivery has always been on point and when I ask for extra sauce I actually get it, unlike just about every other pizza place in Chicago. Pete's for life fam. read more