The kids love it and we love how easy it is to go, order and eat in or take out. All employees are amazing and very friendly. The kids love the pizza and even the garlic knots. Good pizza and a friendly staff always make going in a pleasure. read more

Pinocchio Pizza - Cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - New Canaan, Connecticut

We've only done take out so I don't know about the ambiance. But I can tell you that they have the best pizza in New Canaan and it's always ready within 20 minutes! read more

Delicious pizza! Choose from one of their specialty pies or create your own. Pizza arrives hot. Great delivery service.

Just too darn expensive - not worth the money. This is a below average pizza place at best and it's ridiculous. What pricing they charge per slice of plain pizza. Haven't been there for a year or two ran in for a quick slice, but grab two one plain and one margarita which almost cost $10. Quality wise - they were a bit dry, pasty tasting I'd give a 6/10 About both. Keep in mind you can get a full pie for 12 to 14 bucks which is a hell of a lot better and quality. New Canaan rip off. read more

Pinocchio Pizza - Box came in new Canaan. - Italian Near Me - New Canaan, Connecticut

See all

Best pizza for 10 miles. Incredibly friendly service. I always leave happy and pleased.

Alright, I have to update my review from 9 years ago. Yes I remember it was bad way back then but I have to say latest order I had from someone else who ordered me a meal here was quite good. The workers were also so incredibly kind to my elderly relative and really it is that kind service that keeps us going back. Thank you Pinocchio. read more

Great pizza. Great staff. It's not a fancy sit down place. This is a pizza shop that makes quality food that won't break the back. I look forward to my next pie! read more

I've tried all the pizza places in New Canaan and this one has the best quality ingredients and real New York style pizza. Must try read more

Pinocchio Pizza - a pizza in a box - Italian Near Me - New Canaan, Connecticut

See all

Fantastic place. Pizza was epic, NY style thin crust, but better quality than 99% of what is currently being served in NYC. Great family atmosphere, staff was really attentive. Empire strikes back on TV for the kids. read more

Some of the best pizza Ive ever had. Crispy crust, thin and flavorful. Definitely coming back here. Owner led.

I just ordered a chicken pesto wrap it was the worst wrap I've ever had I explained to owner how bad it was he told me to get out nobody complains please leave charge me full price The chicken was so chewy you could not eat it read more

Ordered mozzarella sticks, got fries. Ordered a Caesar salad, got one without any dressing. Ordered garlic knots, they were like bricks- stale and flavorless. Pizza is not bad, but there's much better out there. No attention to detail. It's my second order, figured I'd give them another chance after the first disaster. Large pizza with onion extra cheese was a bit undercooked, and all the toppings had slid off to the side and partially out of the box. Driver must have done some hella Indy laps! At least this time the pizza was relatively intact and had one of those plastic protectors on top. I'll order from someone else going forward. read more

Visited 1st time. Pizza was very good, and service was fast. Not too great for dining in but perfect for takeout. read more

I've had some really bad quality pizza before, but this one takes the "pie". Normally when we go there we get it by slice and it's ok, but when we ordered for delivery; it was awful. Dough was not fully cooked and cheese slid in the middle of the pie, sauce was dripping off the slice, it was just bad. One star for fast delivery. read more

We ordered two pizzas for the road recently and they both were pretty great: mushroom and meatball. I only had the mushroom but based on the silence from my fellow passengers the meatball was great. Cold for breakfast the next day, the mushroom was equally enjoyable. That is the true mark of a good pizza. read more

Rated as worlds best pizza. not sure on that. But, it is spectacular as are all their dishes. I order delivery now. B/C th4ey unfairly called the meanie police on me to ban me unjustly. they are prejudice against mentally ill people. but great restaurant. place is clean as a whistle. people who work there are well groomed and great cooks and friendly to all (except me) I would for sure though recommend it to those who like gourmet pizza fare. read more

I Orderd on GrubHub around 5:30 pm and it it said it will be here between 6:15- 6:45 so I wait and wait and I call them the lines were busy and busy so I called your sister restaurant in Wilton I ask them to call this Place and they said "They Are really Busy" the Wilton person said to me so when the lines cleared here i Tell the New Canaan Person I want a manger or the owner and the NC person the manger isn't Here and he said " I'm sorry about this" so then I call 10 minutes later and asked how long until the Driver came the guy put me on hold for a second to call the Driver "he just left a few moments ago" then he came back on and he said "10 minutes" when the divvied comes so then the driver finally arrived and the Mac& cheese was Dry but the Mozzarella sticks were good I hope the Manger -Owner- franchisee reads this and fix this problem. I will never order from here again. read more

Has moved to Main Street. Best pizza in town. White pizza to die for 2 times over. Hot as hell during summer. Take out best. Great value. Check your order....Free delivery. 115 Main St New Canaan, CT 06840 Phone: 203-966-8805 read more

Slow delivery service. Over an hour and a half for a salad with chicken. Dull food overall.

Stopped by here on the way through town for a quick lunch during a road trip. Service was great, pizza was excellent and the bathrooms were clean. The slices were huge, especially for the price. Had such a good experience I stopped back here again on my way home and grabbed a pie to go. read more

This pizza is a mess!! Under cooked, too much grease and cheese. Too many toppings. Ridiculous. Eggplant topping tastes like it was made 3 weeks ago. read more

Pinocchio Pizza - a pizza in a box - Italian Near Me - New Canaan, Connecticut

This is some good pizza. We stopped here on our way up to Boston, and were so pleasantly surprised at finding this place. Good pizza in Connecticut? Who knew? Slices were huge but not soggy, the cheese/sauce ratio was just like I like it. It was so good we stopped here on our way back home too! read more

Tried this place out again knowing it's not my favorite, but at the time it was the only place to get a slice. As usual the pizza was dry with barely any marinara sauce as well as tasteless and expensive for the quality. However, my girlfriend got the white pizza, and we also got a chicken wrap with pesto and sun dried tomato, which was their saving grace. Also, the staff was really nice. Not the best, but not the worst I've had. read more

Are we sure we're all talking about the same place? Been getting pizza from here since I moved to town a few years ago. It's always busy, but I always get my order in a reasonable amount of time. If the staff isn't all sunshine and rainbows 100% of the time it's because it's insanely busy all. the. time. I don't really care tbh. No one has ever been rude to me. My favorites are the buffalo chicken and Hawaiian pizza, but I've never been disappointed by anything. The toppings are copious. The crust is crunchy. It's my favorite. No place this popular could be as crap as these yelp reviews. Give it a try! read more

Pizza and food is very bland and over priced. Won't be going back. The staff is very loud and very chattery. Do not dine in.

So I am completely mystified as to how they won so many of those awards for "worlds best pizza". Really, the pizza is well, kind of less than spectacular. And if they hadn't hyped themselves up so much, maybe I would have given them 3 stars. Probably not. Way too many great, really good, and good pizza places for me to go back there. If anyone figured out the deal with how they won so many competitions and awards, please let me know. I just can't piece it together. Just my humble opinion. read more

Not impressed... Lacking hospitality, professionalism, and flavor. Called in and was told 20 minutes for a pie. over heard them say they gave mine away when I arrived, had to wait an additional 5 minutes. read more

Good, quick takeout pizza and sandwiches. Have ordered different kinds of pizzas (pepperoni, sausage, chicken/bacon) as well as a few subs. The French fries are okay (should be a little crispier). Will go again! read more

Live in town but they don't deliver but they do GrubHub! Good salad and decent pizza and the food got here so fast I barely had time to set my table! Try it. read more

Always a top notch pie. I've read lots of reviews, and all of the negative ones are from customers of their competitor Joe's just trying to steer you away from here. But don't pay attention to that - if you enjoy Italian pizza, you'll love this place. The Bronx Special, which I'm reviewing here, is amazing. An extremely filling high quality meal read more

Best pizza in New Canaan! The competition in this town is very poor though -- so it's not 5-star quality. In order to get really good pizza, within an hour or two, one has to go to NYC or to New Haven. read more

My review is strictly related to the delivery service as we have not eaten in the restaurant. Having said that my family has had delivery from Pinocchio at least once a month for the last year or more. We like it a lot. While this place is not on par with the best full Italian restaurants in the area - that is not the right comparison. What you get here is good Italian that is head and shoulders above any other pizza delivery in the area. Pizza is done well and with a healthy amount of toppings. I like the Sicilian while rest of my family prefers the regular crust - but if you like the really thin crust style you will likely be disappointed with either. I like a healthy amount of sauce but if you are not a big sauce fan you should ask for it light. Crust style, sauce & topping ratios and amount of cheese are very subjective items - I find if I tell them what I want it arrives correct (crust excepting) I totally disagree with other reviewers that say the pizza and pasta is bland. We find it very flavorful with fresh ingredients. We also like the Italian dinners which have a flavor you would normally expect from a restaurant and not a "pizza place". The red sauce in particular is not the bland "ragu style" you get from the majority of pizza places in Stamford area (we have tried them all). We like the chicken and eggplant parm as well as the Tuscan chicken. Delivery is generally quick and the food arrives hot. I'd say the "miss" here about 1 in 10 times but that is as good or better than I see with most delivery. read more

This is a pizza shop run by guys who know how to make pizza. Dino is one of the world pizza champions..legit. Their slices are massive, chicken parm heros delicious, and calzones cheesy. The place is small, maybe 3 booths and 2 tables so take out would be your best bet. And you won't be breaking the bank. Affordable! read more

I am really really surprised to see the low Yelp rating for this place (2.5 stars as of my writing of this review). The pizza here is the best New York style pizza I've had in the area. We live outside of Pinocchio's delivery radius, so I can't comment on the delivery service, but my family and I often drive to New Canaan from Stamford whenever we have a pizza craving. The white pizza is amazing. My wife loves the salads too, and they are huge. The place isn't anything fancy, just a hole in the wall pizza parlor in the main shopping area downtown, and the seating is a little cramped, but I don't know of a better pizza in the Stamford/New Canaan area. read more

We just had our organization's monthly meeting up at Waveny and this time we had Pinocchio's pizza delivered. Excellent pies. We had 4 large cheese, 3 large meat lovers and 2 large veggie pizzas. They were great ... excellent flavor, just the right amount of oil and cheese, cooked just right. Delivered on time and still piping hot. We've just started a tradition ... read more

ordered pizza/veal parm grinder at 5:30 for delivery at 6pm a 3 minute walk away from new canaan location . at 6:10 pizza was not delivered. called was told pizza was on the way. at 6:20 pizza still not delivered. told on the way. delivered about 6:30. ice cold and cheeses slid of pizza and was on side of box. pizza was cold. grinder was a grey dark grizzle meat of some sort and was un edible. called again. no apology and in fact was hung upon. suggest ordering from any other pizza place in new canaan. very dissatisfied former customer read more

I order pizza here every month or so. It is consistently excellent. Always done on time, and ready to pick up. I highly recommend Pinocchio Pizza! read more

I am surprised too at the bad reviews. I can't speak for delivery but I've eaten here several times while shopping nearby and I've found the staff friendly and pizza really good! There's usually a game on on TV overhead and people are busy watching but it never takes anything away from getting good service. I will be going back! read more

Good food, but rude, rushed service. They don't want to hear about substitution requests. Not a pleasant or friendly environment in which to wait for your order. read more

Only get the pizza or calzones they are excellent ! But anything else on that large menu will be a waste of your time and money but worst of all is the unprofessional and rude customer service my pet peeve ! It really is better as just a take out pizza only place. read more