TLDR: Place is amazing still. I first started going to Pitch back in 2012. I loved the chicken panini with truffle fries and a Tecate with the fixings. I'd also order a burger, yes, a burger at a pizza place, and it was still one of the best burgers I've had. I moved away in 2014. Fast forward 11 years to 2025, I'm back visiting Omaha and made sure to stop by Pitch. Consistency is key, and Pitch absolutely has it. The food was just as good, if not better, than I remembered. This time around, we ordered two meatballs with focaccia, truffle fries, a classic burger with avocado, bacon, white cheddar, and fries, Pitch's "VIP" smoked cheddar mac and cheese, a cheese pizza, a margherita pizza, and crème brûlée. The meatballs were tender and well-seasoned. A little ricotta would take them over the top, but they were excellent as-is. The focaccia was perfect for soaking up the tomato sauce. The truffle fries were outstanding. The truffle flavor wasn't overpowering or weak, just right, and the fries held up well without getting soggy. Crispy, well-balanced, and easy to keep going back for. I ordered the burger medium well. The patty was thick, juicy, and well-balanced with the toppings. The brioche bun made a difference and held together nicely without getting soggy. Easily a must-try. The smoked cheddar mac and cheese was rich and creamy with a smooth, velvety texture. The smoky flavor came through without overwhelming the dish. It's filling enough to be a main, but it worked perfectly as a side. We had to try the cheese pizza since it's the most basic and tells you a lot about a kitchen. The crust was soft, the sauce and cheese were well-balanced, and it was simply done right. The margherita pizza stood out with a good amount of fresh basil that added brightness. I prefer pizza with no flop, but even so, this held its own. Having had great pizza in New Jersey and New York, this definitely competes. For dessert, the crème brûlée leaned more toward vanilla, with a smooth custard and a nicely caramelized top. A great way to end the meal. To top it off, the service was superb and tied the entire experience together. I'll definitely make a point to stop by again the next time I'm in Omaha. Sorry I didn't take any pics of the food. I got too excited. read more

The meatball appetizer is our favorite. A little pricy for non happy hour. We did have to remind the server to provide us with plates there were 5 of us she provided 4. We ordered two pizzas Mia and Doc. We received the first pizza but the second was not placed for some reason but server did comp that one for us. This place is so dark especially where they sat us towards the back. The front is much lighter read more

I've been meaning to try Pitch for quite a while now, and it did not disappoint! I started with the Orange Blossom cocktail and it was delish, not too sweet or strong. We ordered the mozzarella sticks and they were HUGE! Much larger than we expected, but really good! We ordered the chicken pesto pizza, which was good but very very oily. I know that can partially be because of the pesto, but i've had lots of other pesto pizzas that aren't this oily. It was still good just a little soggy because of the oil. Overall, really good, just probably wouldn't order the pesto pizza again. read more

See all

Super delicious, pizza was a bit greasier than I expected, even from a pesto topped pie, but still extremely good. Definitely going to get the mozzarella sticks the next time I'm back! read more

Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria - Mozzarella Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

Grilled cheese was amazing! Boyfriend had a meatball sandwich and the tomato sauce was amazing! Sauce was good enough for him and he's a picky Italian. read more

Lunch service is disorganized and I couldn't get an order taken for 15 minutes so I had to leave. I've had good service during dinner in the past. Things may have gone downhill. read more

**Service: 0/5** The service was disappointing. The waitress was messy, throwing a rug on the table after a customer left. They didn't know how to clean properly--it was disgusting. I had to call them to get rid of an extra dirty plate or ask for a clean one. There was a lack of professionalism. To make things worse, I overheard a waiter saying, *"I don't know how to sing; I can't sing happy birthday."* Is she okay? She could've just said, *"Happy birthday."* It's sad--it's a good restaurant, but the waitresses mess it up. **Food: 5/5** The food looks great and tastes great, except for the beef, which is tough, and the noodles, which are dry. **Ambiance: 5/5** It's a good spot for a date or a group date. read more

See all

Had pitch for the first time in a while for lunch. Still as good as it always is. I had 2 slides of pizza. The tin man and shrooms. Both are great! Have always loved the shrooms pizza. The truffle flavor is awesome! The tin man was Pepperoni, sausage, jalapeño and mushrooms with a pepper aioli on it. Great lunch ! read more

Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria - Shrooms slice - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

The food here is solid. We tried the Tin Man pizza along with the "pick two" starters, truffle fries and Brussels sprouts. All three were enjoyable. The pizza stood out the most, flavorful, unique, and with just the right kick of jalapeño for anyone who enjoys a bit of spice. The fries and Brussels sprouts were good, though not the best I've had in Omaha. Still, they made for a tasty pairing with the pizza. The restaurant has a nice atmosphere, casual and fitting for a simple dinner date or a family meal. That said, it can get a bit loud, so conversations might be tricky. Our waiter was friendly and suggested a few pizzas we hadn't tried before, which I appreciated. He was reasonably attentive throughout the meal, adding to the overall positive experience. read more

See all

Value | taste | wings Value - Plenty of lunch options are available with good portions, providing a satisfying meal. Taste - The restaurant is known for its distinct and delicious wood fire grill flavor, which sets it apart. Meals are brought to the table as soon as they are ready, rather than all at once. This may result in a unique dining experience as you can expect your dishes to be served at different times. Wings - The wings I had were absolutely mouthwatering. They had just the right amount of seasoning and were the perfect size for a satisfying lunch without being too much. Pro tip: There is not a lot of parking, so give yourself another 5-10 minutes when traveling. Pro tip 2: The place is much bigger than it looks outside. It is a bit dark, but it has a great vibe for a lunch meeting, family gathering, or first date. read more

Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria - Bread - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

Great food service and atmosphere. The menus voices are plentiful and delicious. J in keep going back.

We called in an order (my neighbor's wife had surgery..so it's for her husband and son) they said 15 minute ...it was ready when we arrived! Quick and easy...beautiful Margarita pizza pie ...location and parking was great..and right by UNMC..for delivery ...It smells and looks delicious...I hope they enjoy it read more

See all

This was definitely a style of pizza I was not used to to, but it did not disappoint! The servers were super chill and helpful. It was a little dark but I think it added to the ambiance. Have already been back again. read more

Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria - Glass of water - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

We had a dinner two weeks ago as a group of four.The food is okay but the service was very strange. The waiter clearly was trying to kick us out of the restaurant when we still had food and drinks. He was so annoying that we left and went to another bar to continue our conversation. I am not sure if I will choose this restaurant in Dundee. There are so many other good options. read more

28 dollars for chicken satay! 4 little tenders of chicken on a bed of greens. Not even good!!! Do not order. Way over priced!!!

Great vibes, not too loud, and options for seating. The food comes out as it's ready, so there was a 10 minute delay between me getting the salad and Nate getting his wings, but I appreciated this since they don't use heat lamps or let the food sit and get stale. The salad was amazingly flavorful, would definitely get it again! read more

Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

Love the vibe and pizza! Adison was great, attentive and friendly!! He noticed we did not eat the prosciutto in our salad. Most waiters do not notice or mention if you leave something uneaten on the plate. We love the arugula, apple, walnut salad, but not the prosciutto. (No big deal!) We ordered the gluten-free pizza light pepperoni -delicious!! read more

Came here on a Friday night during happy hour with a reservation. We shared an appetizer combo of truffle fries and brussels sprouts. Truffle fries with the aiolis are a must when coming here! I got a slice of the bianca verde pizza. It was very delicious. Service was alright. read more

See all

Ordered to go from here and it was AMAZING! The fries were so good with parmesan and trying all of their different dip options was fun! I honestly really liked all of the ones I tried (I didn't try their spicy option). The pizza was really tasty. I loved the combination of the pesto, chicken, tomato, fresh mozzarella, balsamic vinaigrette all go perfectly together. I also got their brussel sprouts, but didn't take a picture. I ate them so fast. They were delicious! I had great service on the phone to order and when I went in to the bar. I loved the atmosphere inside and really want to go eat there in person. I definitely recommend the Truffle fries (someone on here said they were their favorite fries ever and I get it)!!!!!! So so so good! Very thin like Freddy's fries, but elevated with the parmesan and truffle with the seasonings. I loved everything I got. Can't wait to come back! :) read more

Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria - Truffle Fries - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

Pitch is absolutely one of my favorite restaurants in Omaha. I love both the Dundee and West locations! As much as I love all the fun and gourmet pizzas, I think their entrees and apps knock it out of the park. I honestly just want to order all the appetizers as my meal sometimes! If you get one thing though, it has to be the truffle fries with the 3 aiolis. Best french fries i've ever had in my entire life. And don't forget about the drinks! Pitch has a ton of fun cocktails to choose from and if you are a moscow mule fan then you'll love the huge variety of fun mule flavors. Tiger's Blood is my favorite mule on the menu. They also have a great happy hour! Pitch is always on my list of restaurant recs for people new to Omaha! read more

When I sit down and am greeted by server Jack M, I know my meal is about to be extraordinary. He is always extremely knowledgeable about the food, and has the best recommendations. He provides outstanding service, always going above and beyond. Thank you for curating the most epic dining experiences for me!!! The ahi tuna dish was so good -- we had to stop ourselves from ordering three more! read more

Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria - Ahi Tuna - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

The place was packed, but we were seated quickly and had amazing service from Emma and incredibly tasty food! It felt like a holiday dinner at Grandma's - the place was packed, everyone was happy and chatty and an incredible vibe! I wish more places had figured out this mix of fun, food, festiveness, and family! read more

The food is odd but okay... the service rocked! But do not expect to see well. The lighting cool but absolutely sucks. Bring a flashlight to read the menu. The pizza crust was a bit soggy, the flavor was present. No one like a droopy pizza, the crust sucked. Not worth the price in total. They add a restaurant tax and an extra $1.37 for using a card. Would've given 1 star but server was awesome. I give fair reviews of all, my reviews. Local or chain, if you were a rockstar, then you get rockstar response. If you suck, you shouldn't be in business. That's the nature of reality. Has potential, maybe an off night? However, to try to play off in Jest and say "how dare you leave a truthful review of a local business owner...." Yawn, no as stated the server was great. The food taste was present but the pizza was soggy and droopy. Not many people want soggy droopy pizza. I owe the people Truth on my perception. I owe the business nothing. Do better and get better reviews. read more

Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

Walked in on a Monday evening, it was busy but there was ample seats open, the hostess without hesitation says "we're fully booked. Maybe some bar seats." Then I pointed out the open tables and seats, so she proceeded to say ok you can sit there. We didn't feel comfortable so we got up and left. Not a friendly environment. We could have been wrong, but when we saw the outdoor says mainly opened, we knew something was fishy about this establishment. Poor staff, likely due to poor management We went to Five Guys instead, they had fantastic service. Happy we made that choice to leave read more

If you eat at pitch, you gotta ask for Nancy. She will make sure you order right and keep your drinks full. She was so kind and a great server. read more

Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

I don't as in Omaha for a trade show and I live trying new pizza places. Do yourself a favor and try Pitch!! The Mia pizza was really terrific. The fennel sausage is fantastic the cheese is top notch and the pepperoni amazing. This was a great pizza and a cool spot. The ambiance was great and the service attentive and helpful. I will for sure come back if I'm ever in town. read more

Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria - Mia pizza - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

Food was great. Service was great accept they bring each entree at different times so one person almost done when last meal was served. Not the servers fault but maybe the kitchen. Ambiance good. I liked the vibe. We were there for an important celebration, they lost or reservationbut luckily they had a table in the perfect spot. We enjoyed our night. read more

We had a good lunch on a hot afternoon at Pitch. It has a very casual vibe and the acoustics are pretty good for conversation. Bookguy had a fried chicken sandwich, a Caesar salad and the soup of the day. He was underwhelmed by the sandwich and the soup. I had a taste of the soup and thought it had a nice, spicy kick. Bookguy was disappointed that it was blended soup with no bits. He said it tasted like corn and I asked what it was but forgot to write it down. The waiter brought him three sauces to enhance the chicken, which helped add flavor. I had a Margarita pizza which was fairly standard and tasty. I also had a mixed greens salad that was better than average with garbanzo beans and oven roasted tomato. I liked it a lot. Both salads had grated mozzarella cheese piled on top which spilled over on the table when we dug in. Pitch has a wall full of what appears to be wine bottles. The alcohol menu has a lot of offerings besides wine. The menu is quite eclectic with more than just pizza and I loved the sturdy napkins. There's something for everyone here. read more

See all

I love the pizza at pitch but honestly my favorite thing on the menu would have to be the goat cheese stuffed peppadews. One of my favorite appetizers in Omaha! read more

Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

I love pitch! There food is top tier! Always an explosion of flavors. My go to spot when I'm in Nebraska. read more

See all

Upstairs bartenders seemed to thrive off of bad service. Pretty sure one of them told me attitude is their middle name. They were extremely slow to my party and acted like we weren't present, I guess their phones had bigger priorities. Lastly my alcohol seemed to be under poured with extra ice. Being this stingy when charging +8 $ is CRAZY. read more

One thing about pitch is they always get us right with their pizza and drink options! We love coming here for date night because of beautiful and cozy the restaurant itself is & we know we are going to eat good! We usually do the proteína pizza & it's always warm and fresh. Truffle fries are a MUST. The garlic & chipotle aiolis are my faves- I always take them home with me if there's leftovers. We always order a drink when we visit, the pomegranate margarita has been my favorite in the past but I try to switch it up since they removed it from the menu. Anything on the menu is a win from my experience, however. Pitch is an Omaha must try! read more

See all

My friend and I (both Muslim) had a deeply upsetting and offensive experience at this establishment on Friday the 18th (in the evening). From the start, we made it very clear that we could not consume any alcohol and specifically requested a 0.0% non-alcoholic drink with absolutely no traces of alcohol. The staff assured us that the drinks were safe, but then brought us a different drink than what we had ordered. After taking a sip -- which tasted off -- we checked the label and discovered it contained up to 0.5% alcohol. This was not only a serious violation of our religious beliefs, but also extremely upsetting because my friend is currently pregnant. When we calmly raised our concerns, we were met with aggressive and dismissive behavior, and were told that "all non-alcoholic drinks have some alcohol" -- which is completely false. We specifically asked for 0.0%, and that's what we should have been served. Things got even worse. I ordered a Buffalo Chicken Pizza with NO BACON, and repeated this request four times. I asked the waitress to please double-check and confirm. She assured me the pizza would not have bacon. Yet halfway through eating, I found a huge chunk of bacon in my mouth -- I spit it out, and saw bacon pieces all over the pizza. We asked to speak to a manager, but instead the same waitress came back, and tried to gaslight us, insisting there was no bacon on the pizza -- as if we couldn't clearly see or taste it ourselves. There was no apology, no accountability, and no attempt to make the situation right. To top it off, instead of removing the alcoholic drinks they wrongly served us, they just charged us for Sprite -- as if we should be grateful for that. They didn't remove the starters or anything else, despite this being a very distressing and disrespectful experience. We remained polite and respectful the entire time, but were treated with negligence, dishonesty, and a total lack of regard for our dietary restrictions, our religion, and our well-being. This wasn't just poor service it was a serious violation of trust and potentially harmful, especially for someone who is pregnant. We are strongly considering taking legal action. This was not a minor mistake it was deeply upsetting, dangerous, and discriminatory.Avoid this place at all costs if you expect to be treated with honesty, safety, and respect. read more

Hmmm Bland Pedestrian Lack luster Service... was there any - the unfriendly hostess took us3 ladies to the way way far back where no another person was seated- no thank you- went to set at the bar an no one acknowledged we were there. So we left. This no service - service seems to be a trend for pitch as a company, and I say that because this same kind of service was given at there elkhorn location too. read more

Stopped in at Pitch on an early Sunday afternoon. I am huge fan of the Scottsdale location. This location is in Dundee/Benson area. Not very far from where my parents stay so wanted to check it out for drinks with my college buddy. We grabbed drinks and an appetizer. Their drink menu is expansive. Also lots of options for appetizers. We decided to get the buffalo cheese dip. The dip was very good and the foccacia was delicious. Wished we got maybe one more slice of the bread. We did try to get some more but the waitress forgot. No big deal. Props to the bartender for making a special request for my margarita. All in all I would go back in town. I truly miss the atmosphere of the Scottsdale location but this location was convenient and prices very reasonable. read more

See all

Dundee is a nice and relaxing place to hangout, and that includes Pitch. We got the pepadew peppers stuffed with goat cheese, pepperoni and veggie pizza, and chocolate milk. . The pepadew app was drizzled with pesto and balsamic vinegar. Love this flavor profile. This may be the best app that I have eaten this year! . The pizza is right down my alley. The crust is very thin and crispy, just the way I like it. The toppings seem to be of very good and flavorful quality. . I don't normally drink chocolate milk, but I got chocolate milk only because the day I went, it was National Chocolate Milk Day. So I decided to celebrate. Additionally, There is a full bar. There is limited outdoor seating (while the weather is good and we are still in pandemic). Pitch is open Monday and a great day to go to Pitch. read more

See all

I've been to Pitch during their brunch and dinner hours. I'd really like to try their brunch and pizzas again because I think there are better things on the menu than what I picked to eat those days. During their brunch hour, we ordered their truffle fries (of course) with all of their dipping sauces. It's way too much condiments given for the amount of fries. I always feel bad for wasting so much of it, but I do get that a lot of people are just "saucy". Their chantilly whipped cream on their waffle was really good, just wish there was more of the whipped cream since I don't care of syrup. When I came in for dinner, it was for a big birthday party. They did a really good job being attentive to all of us. I shared a chicken and pesto pizza (I think) with one of my friends. It was okay, I'd really like to try something else next time. read more

Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria - a waffle on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

Awesome food and drinks! Had Charcuterie tray and Pasole verde soup and it was the bomb! Add focaccia bread. Oh my, yum!! Had a Black Heart drink. The bomb! Highly recommend this place. Atmosphere conducive and inviting. The service excellent! Ask for Michella!! read more

I've been to this location of Pitch once before and loved it! Things seem to have gone downhill since last time. The bagel was flavorless, as was the cream cheese spread in it. The texture was not good, and cucumbers in the bagel sandwich was not a nice addition. The truffle fries were amazing as always! Not served as hot as I remember from last summer. My husband got the pork skillet casserole which tasted like basil soup. Not at all a skillet or a casserole, I'm not sure why it was titled as such. Our group also ordered the chicken and waffles, the monte cristo, and the protein omelette. I heard that the chicken was flavorless, the omelette was too salty, but the monte cristo was great. Overall not a good experience, but I will always stand by their truffle fries! No issues with service/atmosphere, etc. read more

See all

The atmosphere here is great, you can get Irish coffee, their brunch menu is superb, their pizza is fantastic, they have cocktails and beer, and the service is always great. Overall, it's a great to place to go for brunch, lunch, or dinner. I dropped a star because they have a bad habit of forgetting to put in orders, which has happened several times with our group. They are usually great about it where they give a discount, or one time they even brought out an extra pizza (wasn't the pizza we ordered, but still a free pizza), but it still kills a lot of time waiting for the one we ordered. And their gluten free crust is an $8 up charge, which is a bit high. You won't be disappointed with the food here and I definitely recommend you give it a try! read more

See all