After a night of shopping, my toddler and I came here for a quick bite while Mommy kept shopping. They had 7-8 different types of pizza slices still available at 9PM, though all looked a little bit stale. But, they had Hawaiian (our favorite) available so we got a slice. Even reheated it wasn't the best, but I knew going in what to expect. Their store was clean with tables and chairs and TVs. The staff were extremely friendly to us, and even gave my son a free brownie after. While the pizza might not have been the best we have ever had, sharing a memory with my son and enjoying decent pizza (and avoiding shopping) made up for it. Hopefully we can come back and enjoy a fresh pizza right out of the oven. read more

Today I ordered a pizza online, through the app Slice. I ordered a pizza with half peppers and onions. I picked it up within 30 minutes and got home. When my family and I opened the box for dinner....it had onions and olives on it. I called the restaurant and explained that my order was wrong. To my surprise the owner called me and offered to make a fresh one and have it delivered to our home even though we were outside of range. I told him "my sister yelled at me because I didn't check the box before leaving!" And he said "no you should NEVER have to check before leaving" The new pizza arrived within 30 minutes and they even included a free slice of chocolate cake! Both were delicious. Top notch customer service. Thank you so much! read more

Visiting the grands ordered pizza and other stuff. Prices reasonable. Food was delicious! Was a steady other pizza place when I lived here. But no more of them. The eggplant Parm sub---ah man so good. read more

Worst customer service ever, I made an order on uber eats for over 150 dollars worth of pizza and wings for a few family members and I to enjoy. A driver picked up the order and evidently stole it so when Uber assigned another driver to come pick up my order, the restaurant refused to make it over, throughout an hour and a half of back-and-forth phone calls between Uber and the restaurant. The restaurant still refused to make the order insisting I had to pay them another 150+ for the order I had never received. After canceling my order through uber and ordering it again the restaurant still refused to make it and I ended up getting charged a cance fee of 60 dollars and still haven't gotten my order. I feel robbed, wish I got to taste the pizza's they neglected to make on Sunday December 29th. read more

Pretty decent. Price is typical and you get a good amount of food.generic jalapeño and fries but fresh mushrooms in my pasta flavorful Alfredo and very cheesy! Wish I realized this place was so close sooner Edit 2019 I really love this place. Came in for a quick slice with my son. The owner gave him a huge brownie and chatted with him for a bit. We still love this place, we even decided to order dinner since it was so nice and we were doing yard work. No disappointment. Arrived extremely hot and well prepared read more

See all

Pizza! My Love is located in Columbia Plaza next door to Double Dragon. There used to be a Domino's Pizza in this very plaza not too long ago, which closed and is now located inside the Mobil station on Route 4 across from Target/Home Depot. This pizza place serves up thin crust pizza by the slice (several varieties on display) or whole pie (14"-16"-18"), plus calzones, garlic knots, salads, subs, wings, pasta, gyros, and cold drinks from the cooler. Their Mashed Potato Pizza has very similar toppings as Uno's Pizza Skins, which has mashed potatoes, bacon, mozzarella, and cheddar cheese. Several pizza meal edals are offered including a pickup only special $7.99 Large Cheese Pizza (16"). Pizza! My Love is also great place to grab pizza slices and a drink, $4.50 for 2 cheese slices and a can of soda and $6.50 for 2 specialty slices and a can of soda. I like the pizza here, the thin crust is crispy & firm and soft around the edges, good sauce, and right amount of cheese. The counter service is efficient and there's table seating for eating-in. PSA: BE CAREFUL when crossing the access drive between the parking lot to the plaza since vehicles really "haul a-s" not stopping for anyone including pedestrians. A Town of East Greenbush DPW worker noticed I had NH plates and stopped me in the parking lot as I was leaving telling me my state has a good law: Vehicles must stop for pedestrians in crosswalk, referring to busy Ocean Blvd in Hampton Beach, NH. Also, on hot summer weekends there's so much gridlock that it's fairly easy to cross Ocean Blvd. I do have double digit Yelps in Hampton, hehe. read more

Pizza My Love - the front of a pizza shop - Pizza Near Me - Rensselaer, New York

See all

We got the Sicilian cut pizza. The dough and crust were not as fluffy and was tough/hard to eat. There are much better pizza places in the area for around the same price. read more

Great pizza on a road trip back to Cleveland! So good we bought an extra to take home and the guys working were awesome with our kids.

Has been my go to for wings and wraps in the area for years. Folks at work wanted slices and I knew just what I was getting-my usual. BBQ boneless and Buff Chic wrap. But this time unfortunately the wings were terribly burnt and the wrap was limp. I had to discard both halfway through. The wrap also had ingredients I asked to leave off (dairy). Also, I placed the order online which was seamless, only issue; I asked for a pick up time and arrived 10 mins early and the food was done. This is a pet peeves of mine. I would rather wait a min for them to be finishing when I arrive not have it ready 10+ mins early. It was all warm and stuff but I think that is why the wrap had the consistency of soggy cardboard. Sorry not my go to anymore. read more

I stopped in to grab a few slices after work I was starving. Not much left this time of night but totally understandable. I picked a slice of sausage and a white broccoli slice. The good - it looked like pizza, thin crisp crust The bad - everything else this was the most flavorless pizza I have ever experienced. I couldn't tell you in the dark which one was sausage and which was the white broccoli from a taste standpoint. It wasn't that it tasted bad it all tasted like nothing! The only thing to tell the difference was the broccoli chunks which really had no flavor. How do you do that no cheese taste no sauce taste no sausage taste just texture and nothing. read more

If nothing else...Margarita pizza is fresh and delicious...I won't order anything else...its just that good

I just ordered chicken Parm pizza with the garlic crust from Pizza My Love and it is superb. No grease like Nelson's and the crust was perfect unlike that card board crust you get from Slider's pizza. Pizza My Love is definitely the best pizza in Rensselaer NY. read more

I work next door from them at the hotel.I ordered cheese pizza and garlic parm wings the pizza was very old and nasty looking the cheese looked old I never ate it just took a picture of it. The wings were not how I ordered them. I actually tried two of the wings I couldn't eat no more they were old tasting and nasty it's crazy because my job send them a lot of business you would of thought I would of gotten that on the house instead I paid for garbage and still was hungry . thanks for nothing .... read more

I love it here! The staff is super friendly and I just had their gluten free pizza for the first time and it was EXCELLENT! Pizza My Love is an East Greenbush Staple imo. read more

Between moldy tomatoes on my sub and a melted container from putting too hot of food in and onto of it, I won't be ordering from here again. read more

Pizza My Love - Moldy tomato - Pizza Near Me - Rensselaer, New York

See all

I got a cheese pizza here. The price was good and it was ready in 15 minutes. The sauce was bland, the cheese was tasteless and not at all "stringy". The crust was OK. There are better choices in the area for pizza. read more

The pizzas, pasta dinners, hot subs, wings, and gyros are all outstanding. I don't recommend the cold subs. I have tried only a few appetizers, including the mozz stix and garlic bread w/ chz - the GB+CHZ was outstanding, the mozz stix were industry standard but prepared as best as possible. The BC dressing and veggies for the wings are always nice and proper. Actually really good garlic knots, and i'm super-picky about those. Delivery is always prompt and courteous, please tip well. read more

I have been here several times for a slice at lunch, so I recently stopped in and ordered three pies for take out. Prices are fair for quality/taste of take out. The extra large is much smaller than the house pies that they make for the slices. My biggest disappointment was the crust on the take out pies. Tasted doughy and under-cooked. Toppings were good and so was the cheese. Unfortunately with the 'basic' sauce and lack luster dough turned it into a disappointment. Stick with the slices and the variations that they offer, they generally taste much better. Yes.. I will return for the lunchtime slice No... I won't be ordering take-out again read more

I moved to the area recently and have been having a very hard time finding good pizza. Today, I finally found this place! Best pizza in the area, by far. They have a great selection of slices at the counter and each one I've tried so far has been amazing!!! read more

This is our favorite pizza place. The margarita is the best, so fresh! Their crust is perfect and I love their sauce. This has become our weekly Friday night dinner. Prices are decent and the pizzas are pretty big. We've tried pretty much all the non-meat specials and have enjoyed them all. We make the trek from North Greenbush, it's that good! read more

Excellent pizza & friendly service! Several unique varieties to appeal to any taste; Bruschetta, Chicken Parm, Hawaiian, etc. highly recommend. read more

Pizza My Love - Bruschetta Pizza is Great! - Pizza Near Me - Rensselaer, New York

First Yelp review I've ever left, and I have to do it after reading some of these reviews that I can't fathom about the pizza taste (the other food I can't speak to). This might be the best pizza I've ever had, definitely in the top 3. My parents live near Pizza My Love and every time I visit, I get it, and then I always stop there on the way home to bring some back home. My wife and son are also amazed by how good it tastes. That this place doesn't have more rave reviews for the pizza taste is astonishing to me - it really is that good. That some have left reviews about blandness, or even a just "it's kind of typical" - well, I don't get it. (Although of course they're entitled to their opinion and to express it). I would add that the place has a real family feel and the owner - I think he's the owner - is friendly. Try this pizza! read more

Had the gluten free pizza. was not too bad toppings seemed ok. But it went downhill from there. Got wings and Salad also. The wings were pre-cooked and reheated. If anyone knows anything about wings, they suck reheated. Over crispy and dry as a bone. Just a bad way to do wings. Salad was where it got worse. Bad tomatoes with it. Also the meat on the chef salad, was the cheapest they apparently can get. Was the sort of stuff you get at walmart labeled great value. The salamie was not even real salami but that fake, pressed stuff. And worse, it seemed hard and old, questionably so, that it could be bad. Lettuce was ok. And only one tiny thing of dressing for a large. Just horrid for a chef's salad. Overall, a very bad experience and would not recommend this place to anyone! read more

I got delivery on a Friday night. Pretty quick and the driver didn't have to hard a time finding my place. I got chicken tenders and onion rings. I thought the quality wouwasld be at least good, but greasy food+time reduced the quality. Overall I was happy with the taste of the food. The weird thing was giving me marinara sauce and not ketchup, but I just used my own. I also ordered cheesecake with "strawberries". It was not fresh or frozen or some overly sugared mixture. I got strawberry jam. I was not happy to pay extra for jam. The cheesecake tasted good on its own though. read more

Not sure what all the bad reviews are about. Despite the fact that one of the pizza in my order was wrong, I think this is some of the best tasting in the area. I get mine with light cheese and it's perfect. Had people over last night and they also raved about it. I order extra and freeze the slices because my daughter loves it! I have it on hand for her to snack on and bring to school for lunch. So easy and tasty! read more

This has GOT to be THEE BEST pizza I've ever had...and I'm full-blooded Italian! Just everything about their $7.99 cheese, thin-crust pizza is delectable! The dough is flavored well, the sauce is SO tasty, and it's baked to perfection! The people are always extremely friendly and everything is FRESH! We never go to Pizza Hut anymore, and why would we when we have Pizza My Love! Give it a try - for the money, you cannot go wrong! read more

It's nice people and good food . Their pizza is crust and and has a lot of topics read more

Pizza My Love - Pizza Near Me - Rensselaer, New York

The quality of the food at this place is spotty. I've ordered here and have ad great food, but my most recent order was a big turn off. I recently ordered a slice of buffalo chicken pizza, a beef gyro, and boneless wings with garlic parmesan sauce on it. The buff-chick slice was just a plain cheese pizza with pieces of buffalo chicken on it. It was terrible. The meat was not even baked into the pizza, it was just thrown on top. I couldn't believe it. I actually laughed because I couldn't believe they think they could get away with that being a buff-chick slice. I should have taken a photo of it to show you, my fellow yelpers, how ridiculous it was. The gyro was good, but the last time I ordered it, the meat was chopped up, and there were more fillers. The wings had very little sauce on them, and were just filled with batter. I don't think I'll be come here again. There needs to be consistency with the quality of the food they serve, which do not seem to have a control over. read more

Bland, tasteless, and soggy pizza like the kind you can get in a mall in a crappy neighborhood. I ordered two slices for my daughter which they packed in a box while still on the paper plates, the soggy pizza merged with the cheap paper plates and there wasn't much left. What was left was barely edible. The people who work there are idiots, the owners run 4 shops right next to each other in the strip mall. Mass produced, cheap, and low quality. read more

Stick to the pizza. Ordered Chicken Caesar Salad and the chicken was so dried out it wasn't even edible. When I called to speak to the manager I told him the chicken was so dried out that I couldn't tell what was chicken and what was croutons! He didn't understand my comparison - kept asking what was wrong with the croutons. read more

My fiance and I had moved up here in May of this year. We have ordered from Pizza My Love off Grub Hub a few times. We absolutely love this place. We have not had the chance to eat inside but we cannot wait for that day. We love their mashed potato pizza, chicken parm pizza, extra cheese pizza, and chicken Alfredo pizza. All of that was amazing. Their boneless chicken wings were amazing. Their salad and eggplant parm dinner is great too! If I might add their delivery service is outstanding. Grub Hub let's up know it might take 45 minutes but we always get it under 35 minutes, sometimes twenty minutes at best. I would recommend this place and the bad reviews on these place I am shocked by. But we all have our own opinions I believe you should try it and figure it out yourself whether or not you like their food or not. On the other hand more for us then! :) read more

The food here is OK tasting but if you ever have any issues the staff is very rude, to an inappropriate level. Management is even worse. I'd rather grab a frozen pizza that tastes just as good and not have to worry about them messing something up and then arguing. There are a lot more better options in the east greenbush area. read more

Not sure why this place is getting negative reviews. The wings are ok but stick with the pizza. They have several types. Staff is friendly. Its located near Price Chopper. read more

I've stopped in a few times to order a take out pie for my family. We're a large family so I always have to do either cheese, or half pepporoni. Pretty standard. Anyway, I love the dough (it is a bit chewy, but that is how I like it) and they don't over do the sauce. The sauce they use is the only one that doesn't give me eye watering hearburn. Wings are good too, crispy and made to order, not soggy. Definitely recommend if you are in the area!! Not an "eat in" place for a family. Definitely take out. read more

I don't know what these other positive reviews are talking about. I ordered a pizza, breaded mushrooms, and garlic knots. All of them were severely lacking in flavor. I've never had sauce on a pizza that didn't taste like anything at all. When I ordered they told me 55 minutes at 4:30 on a Friday. read more

Total shit food and shit employees and shit customer service. Waited an hour for my pizza and wings and everything was cold, my wings had wing tips in them and were the smallest wings I've ever gotten from a pizza place. I called and complained (obviously) after I paid $30 some odd dollars and tipped the driver well and the man I spoke to hung up on me after being a total jerk when I was calmly explaining what my food came as. Don't order from here. You'll be disappointed. read more

Food was delivered in time promised and was absolutely great! My son's ordered calzones and they were huge. The garlic knots & Chicken Caesar salad were great! Great price. read more

So I ordered a 24 cut pizza half pepperoni and half cheese. They delivered to 12 cut pizzas, both pepperoni. I tried picking the pepperoni off two slices to feed to be hungry kids. I failed. Called to complain, they said they would send one out in 40 minutes. They wanted the wrong pizza back. 40 minutes later my new cheese pizza for my kids comeI gave him the wrong pizza minus the two that I tried picking pepperoni off. I needing my dinner and my kids and I receive a phone call. It was the manager of eight years asking where are the other two slices? I responded my hands were all over him so I figured you didn't want them. He interrupted my dinner to ask about two slices of pizza that he screwed up. He proceeded to blame me that it was my fault that his pizza was wrong because my kids were yelling in the background. Really???? read more

I ordered the Margarita Pizza for take out with my friend. The pizza was epic and the Medium wings were cooked to perfection. There isn't much to say, hands down this place is great! read more

Pizza lovers can eat any pizza and be okay with it. That being said I have honestly had better frozen pizza. This place is mediocre and only worth while if your vehicle breaks down in the plaza. Just not good, slices were dry, not enough cheese and sauce and I do not think quality ingredients were used. read more