The pizza was ok. Sauce was tasteless thank God we had pepperoni on it for flavor. We did order the small Greek salad. Wow it was so large we got 4 servings out of it. Fresh and delicious. I'm going back just for that. Ambiance is picnic tables. It's roughing it. read more

I stopped by Pizzano's Pizza today to grab some pizza for lunch. While I was waiting for my pizza I had a great conversation with Juan. He not only took my order but also kept me entertained while I waited. Pizza was great! read more

Pizza was really good. The garlic knots were exceptionally yummy. Great place to bring the kids.

Delivery driver was very nice. The pizza was great, the sauce was delicious. We had pineapple on ours. There was a nice ratio of cheese to sauce. Their crust was nice and thick. read more

We only live about an hour away, so we visit AMI pretty often but we normally pack a cooler full of soggy sandwiches. We came on a whim yesterday and ordered pizza. We couldn't have made a better choice. We got 2 speciality pizzas and we were shocked at how delicious they were for the value of the price. The woman at the counter was so kind and helpful when I asked for disposable plates. It looks like they also had some desserts on display but I didn't have time to check them out. We were really pleased with this pizza and the service we received and we can't wait to come back! read more

Ordered pizza by the slice and all the options were hot and fresh. Friendly staff and convenient inside or outside seating. A must stop when on AMI. read more

I really wanted to like this place. Not sure where the rave reviews are coming from but this was disappointing. Overall good flavor but literally no crisp to the crust, it truly reminds me of the Sam's club/ Costco $1.50 slice and theirs includes a Coke. I now understand why they insisted I have a fork/knife with this pizza. Maybe their dough lacking any crisp is purposeful but just not my preference. They get an extra because of their super friendliness and exceptional service, if nothing else I'd maybe return for someone who doesn't like a crisp dough. I didn't try the garlic knots but they looked really good. read more

See all

Great pizza!! Greek salad was great & garlic knots were top notch! Did pickup & food was ready when I arrived.

Tried the chicken bacon ranch pizza at Juan (the manager) suggestion. Delicious!! Came out hot and fresh with a nice balance of flavor. This restaurant has been completely redone post the hurricane and it looks great - clean fresh and open! Indoor and outdoor seating - good for families or just grab a slice! read more

The pizza is pretty good. We ordered for lunch because we knew how busy the evenings could get and we definitely made the right move. My kids loved the cheese pizza, so that's a win for my family. read more

First time visiting and was extremely disappointed. One reviewer said it reminded them of NY so I was eager to try, but wow, this couldn't be further from the truth. I am sure they take great pride in making their pizza but the ingredients are sub par. Frozen pizza crust, cheap toppings and not fresh cheese. Honestly it tasted like dominos only double the price. No criticism to the owners and stuff, but the quality of food is just not what we were expecting. We waited 90 mins for pick up for it to be disgusting and cold. Not worth it. Perhaps try something else they make, just not the pizza. read more

I have no idea how they have 4 star reviews. I'm being gracious with 2. Baked ziti had both ziti and corkscrew pasta which is just gross because it speaks to sloppiness in the kitchen. Cheese pizza was burnt. Chicken Parmesan was frozen chicken breast, mealy breading, and dry pasta (in fact both pastas we got were dry and sticky. Mozzarella sticks were burnt on one side, cheese was hard and not melty. Cannolis weren't fresh and my daughter said the filling tasted like blue cheese. Just gross. Two stars because the meatballs were good and they open late. $122 and I tossed probably $100 of it directly in the trash. Ugh. read more

Pizzano's Pizza - Burnt dry cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

Yumalicious! Staff - I think owner who took our order was so nice. Got the 20" pizza and it served us (4) perfectly. read more

Been here several times. Probably best pizza on the island. This is not the typical New York style....which I am sick of IMO. Flavorful crust, generous toppings, and the veggies are NOT so overcooked it comes out gross. Salads are huge as well. Easily a meal, or share with 4 people as a side. People are always friendly, and have not had a messed up order to date.....which is rare around here. Highly recommend. read more

See all

My family and I stopped in for some pizza after a day of fun in the sun. Let me tell you one of the best pizza and cheese bread I've had in a long time! Tasted fresh and not a long wait. The service was great. Girl in the front new the menu like the back of her hand. The store when you first walk in was nice and clean but would benefit from some new covers on the seating inside. Recommending to everyone that is visiting AMI should definitely stop in and give a try. read more

Pizzano's Pizza - Ice cold Dr Pepper - Pizza Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

Been to AMI several times. First time trying and it did not disappoint. Great pizza and friendly service.

I don't understand the higher ratings, maybe because it's open late and if you've had a few it might be better than nothing. MARGINAL to sum it up. Got the 2 pizzas for $24 with 3 toppings per pizza special. One was full of toppings the other had far less. It just wasn't good. read more

Pizzano's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

Great wings, great service great prices! Place was clean and welcoming. More of a hole in the wall but excellent food!

Great pizza & garlic knots! Walking in it seems like a nice little local spot, would recommend! read more

Pizzano's Pizza - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

Pizza was delicious! My kids couldn't get enough of it!We also tried their Mediterranean place next door and it was fantastic! Definitely worth visiting read more

Pizzano's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

So I am a very honest reviewer. I/we were very disappointed in this place, we got the deluxe Supreme, and it resembled a molten mess, did not resemble/look like the picture at all. I have had what's usually called a "combo pizza" from Cali, AZ, even in Italy several times. I am sure other people enjoy this place, which is fine. But not us. Just keeping it real. read more

Stopped in on a whim and ordered a medium cheese and pepperoni. SO glad we did. Crust was crunchy, buttery perfection. Cheese, sauce and pepperoni were all stellar. Perfect ratio of all 3. Even the Parmesan in the table shaker was kicked up a notch with dried herbs! Nothing fancy just amazing! PS The 2 of us polished off the whole pie read more

Pizzano's Pizza - Cheese and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

The Mexican pizza on the menu claimed it came with salsa. I asked for extra and sour cream which they did not have available. The pizza was disappointing. It did not have salsa. They use marinara sauce instead. Just not the same. They did put extra on side but again was not salsa. read more

Service was really fast! The owner was very friendly, and provided great customer service. Pizza is delicious, and smells amazing. If you're coming to Anna Maria island, don't forget to stop by and get some delicious food. read more

Pizzano's Pizza - Large pepperoni pie - Pizza Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

Went last night- first time since the storms. Expanded dining room, remodeled- all nice. Wait time was less than 30 min (pizza social was almost 2 hours). Pizza is very good, imo. Will be back. read more

Wow! Outstanding! Drove all day, got here late. Y'all were 1/2 mile away. Order was filled promptly and politely. The pizza was delicious! Happy Happy! Joy, Joy! Love finding good local places! Thanks again! read more

Wow! Just Wow! You get so much delicious food. Ordered a small Greek salad and got enough for three people! Don't order cheese bread if you ordered a pasta as you will get as you will get a huge amount of bread and about a quart of Mariana. Pizza was delicious. We ordered desserts and are waiting to eat those. We are full. Recommended for hungry teenage boys. read more

We vacation in Anna Maria Island every Spring. This is the second time we visited this restaurant. We usually get an extra large pepperoni pizza, which we did this past Friday. Just want to say it was great and we will-be back again! read more

We ordered takeout on a Friday night. Pizza, pasta, and breadsticks. It was ready on time. The staff was friendly, and the food was delicious. Pizza had great flavor. The chicken fettuccine Alfredo, was not what I would call a typical Alfredo sauce but it was fantastic. It had mushrooms and chopped chicken breast in a delicious cheese sauce. read more

Love the people here, great service, amazing food, cozy and fast. If you staying at Ana Maria Island, it is hidden gem! Come and check them out, will guarantee you will love it! read more

Food was amazing! Pizza is great. I had a Hawaiian, cauliflower crust! Friends got salads and they were huge. Also got a garlic knot for 1.50 and it was HUGE they actually gave me 2 lol. They are very generous, they ended up giving us an extra sub they made midway through our meal. Love the environment and staff was friendly. Will be coming back on family vacations!!! read more

When I visit the island every couple of months I eat here every other day, nicest staff I've experienced, great food, fast, good seating and a wonderful experience every single time. Will continue to come back! read more

We had a delivery after the end of a very long day...... Delivery of a new fifth wheel RV, decided that staying home was the best thing to do..... We were quoted 1 hour.... Pizza was here in 30 minutes. Yummy, yummy, yummy. We will definitely be repeat customers!!!!! read more

This pizza was one the best we've had. And the delivery guy came upstairs to deliver to us. Excellent pizza and service!

Quick. Pizza was good. Garlic rolls were good. Nice staff Restaurant was clean. Large menu.

We ordered hand-tossed pizza and a salad. Asked for the crust to be crispy. It was delicious! Pizza was cooked perfectly with tasty herbs on top. Crust was very good. The salad was a generous portion that easily served 4. Lettuce and veggies were fresh and had a good flavor. Generous with mozzarella. We plan to go back and try their pasta dishes. Very good value. We have had pizza from several places on the island and this has been the best. read more

My wife and I had Pizzano's pizza tonight and were very surprised and pleased! Sometimes new pizza is taking a chance! We were both blown away with the flavors! The salad was also good! Excellent ! I must admit I mistakenly left my wallet with A considerable amount of money! A very nice woman called and I received my wallet! I'm absolutely a satisfied customer and would definitely return! Great new business to AMI with excellent pizza and service! Our pizza was the deluxe minus the green peppers and instead add pineapple! Incredible!! read more

Well managed place with great food that isn't expensive. I'll come back soon. Juan does a good job

First time here and the pizza was amazing! We will definitely come back for sure. If you like taco pizza you most definitely need to try the one here! My family had 3 different types of pizza and they were all delicious. read more

Pizzano's Pizza - Mexican pizza - Pizza Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

Ordered a grinder and chef salad, received an e mail stating our order was ready for pick up. When my wife arrived she noticed the grinder was sitting on the counter. The employee was chatting it up with other customers and the chef salad was still not made. When my wife realized this she said she was going to be late for work, the employee responded with,"that's not my problem". I would have made it his problem by canceling the entire order. Hopefully this shlub doesn't last to much longer. He is lazy and very rude. read more