The food is very good old-fashioned comfort food The service was very nice. I like and enjoy going on Wednesday nights because they do bingo and that's a lot of fun. The ambience reminds me an old-fashioned diner, quaint, good food nice people read more

Thank you so much to Polly's and Lori specifically for putting up with our crazy group of elderly family members with strange dietary preferences. The food was delicious, service was great and her patience was praiseworthy! She liked talking to everyone more than I did read more

I came in to order a slice of their apple pie: saddest slice I've ever seen. The crust is dry AND soggy. The filling is too sweet for me personally. The service was okay since it was a pickup but the quality of the food is so sad. Most disappointing slice I've tasted in my life. read more

Polly's Pies - Apple Slice - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California

Food: Tasty and affordable. French toast was fluffy in the middle and crispy on the outside (just how I like it), sausage was tasty without having to be too salty and the eggs, well they were eggs but there is nothing wrong with that. Coffee was most acceptable as well. (Boysenberry) Pie was super tasty and not too sweet, I wish it had been a little warmer though but that could be the ice cream's fault (yum). Service: Super friendly! Showed up on Christmas Eve 2025 and everyone was dressed festively and didn't look upset at all about having to work this morning which I find extra delightful. Ambiance: As advertised! Cozy and inviting for singles, couples, friends and/or families. Two birthday celebrations while there and it was fun to see them walk out with the special treat then sing their song. read more

See all

I purchased a applie pie and a pumpkin pie, it was my first time try the pumpkin pie, and oh my, it was so good! Our family all enjoyed it!

I went to another Polly's and had a good experience so I went here for breakfast today since I was in the area. The parking lot is sketchy but inside the restaurant is nice and clean with a totally different vibe than outside. I ordered the Country breakfast special so I could try their biscuits and gravy. It was just OK. The gravy didn't taste homemade. The biscuits were soft bread-like mounds. The eggs were a soft scramble. The fresh fruit cup was delicious strawberries perfectly cut and large green grapes on top of canned peach pieces. The service was excellent and so was the price (value) since their approx $10 breakfasts also come with coffee. I will be back but it won't be for the gravy :-( read more

Polly's Pies - Country breakfast - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California

I bought a Lemon Meringue pie to bring home this evening. When I ate a slice at home, the meringue layer tasted underbaked, with the egg white still tasting raw. I promptly called the restaurant and asked if I could return the pie and exchange it for a different one. They were very accommodating and apologetic about the quality of the meringue. I went ahead and paid the $3 difference to get an Apple Crisp pie instead. After all these years, this is the first time I had been disappointed with a pie at Polly's. I'm sure this was just a one-off. They still remain as my go-to for pies. read more

Polly's Pies - Lemon meringue - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California

Ambiance - family style restaurant. I really liked their wall decors and the homey ambiance. Service - was excellent. Our server checked on us often and answered all our questions regarding the menu. Food - I had the prime rib sandwich and my hubby had the cheesesteak plate. My sandwich had lots of caramelized onions which I loved and packed with thin slices of prime rib. My hubby's cheesesteak was dry, hard and tasteless. It came with corn bread (soft and delicious but did not have the grit you usually get and had no corn) and mashed potatoes which was good. I had a choice of French fries or Cole slaw and opted for the latter. I did not like the Cole slaw at all. It tasted old, like it has been sitting in the fridge for a long time. We ended our meal with a boysenberry pie which was delicious. The crust was flaky. They have the best pies. read more

See all

This Polly's is actually the very first location established in 1968. It's attached to a strip mall with a grocery store at one end. I've never seen one like this before. Inside it's nice and big with two unisex restrooms. I love their burgers and sandwiches. You can have your meal as a combo option too, that includes a slice of pie. Along with pies, they also bake huge cinnamon rolls. We had to get one of those too! You definitely can't leave without a Polly's dessert. read more

See all

Upgrading my rating from two to four stars. I was contacted by management to give them another shot and I took the fam and they didn't disappoint. The food quality looked to of improved and service has never been an issue. Love the ambiance here and hope they stay doing well in business. Will be back! read more

Polly's Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California

See all

We Love Polly's Pies Restaurant. Friendly staff and delicious food. Not a fast food type, but instead a cozier, warmer and a healthier option for our families meal needs. The kids love French dippers for breakfast (French toast, cut into strips and they dip into their soft cooked egg yolks). It's the holiday season and they have specials that are delicious like turkey dinner, turkey sliders and pumpkin pancakes. Yummy!!! read more

The kiddo and I ended up at Polly's Pies in Fullerton today because she was performing just down the way in her barbershop quartet, and we had some time to kill between shows. And really--what better way to fill a gap in the schedule than with food someone else cooked? We both went for the Lunch 'n' Munch special, which sounds like a Saturday morning cartoon but thankfully delivers real adult sustenance. We each had the Comeback Chicken Sandwich with a side, drink, and cookie. I got extra pickles like a civilized human; the kid got none because she's still young and hasn't discovered the true meaning of flavor. She sipped a strawberry lemonade, I stuck with a Diet Coke, and we congratulated ourselves on our excellent life choices. The food? Surprisingly good--actually good--especially considering my previous Montebello experience, which felt more like a plot twist. The cookie, however... Let's talk. It wasn't terrible, but it definitely lacked that homemade magic. A snickerdoodle should show up warm, with crunchy edges, a soft center, and an aroma that whispers "your diet starts tomorrow." This one was more "packaged at the speed of efficiency" than "baked by someone who cares." A missed chance for cookie glory. Of course, we still grabbed a four-pack of blueberry muffins on the way out, because clearly we cope with waiting-between-shows by hoarding baked goods. The place was clean and quiet, the staff was friendly, and the whole experience felt like Polly's saying, "Hey, forget Montebello--we're the cool sibling." So, final verdict? Polly's in Fullerton has officially staged its comeback tour. Now if they could just tweak the cookies, they'd go from "pretty good" to "grand finale encore." read more

See all

We placed a special order for a whole pie for Mother's Day - it was fabulous and fresh and it was ready on time. A perfect experience! Thank you! read more

This place is a gem. I just found out accidentally on the way home. Love the pie! So delicious! Can't wait to try out more pies. The food is not bad. But pies are really good- I mean very good! God bless us all! Numbers 6:24-26 "The LORD bless you and keep you; The LORD make His face shine upon you, And be gracious to you; The LORD lift up His countenance upon you, And give you peace." Jeremiah 29:11 For I know the plans I have for you," declares the Lord, "plans to prosper you and not to harm you, plans to give you hope and a future. read more

Polly's Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California

See all

The food at Polly's was wonderful and service even better. Allanah was a great server and the prime rib was cooked to perfection. Allanah recommend the pie with several different fruits in it and it was great. I recommend Polly's if you are looking for some great comfort food. read more

Visiting Polly's pies for breakfast was a great first time experience. Janet was amazing. She was friendly and attentive. Our breakfast came to the table promptly and still hot. I had the prime rib skillet. It was one of the best I've had at any diner. I enjoyed their Mango tea with a side of biscuit and jam. The restaurant seemed that it is kept clean and spacious. I would love to come back for lunch next time. read more

See all

Wanted to give DULCE a shout out!! She was very kind and patient as she waited on us. She was cheerful and very pleasant to us Thank you for your kindness and patience towards us. !! read more

Polly's Pies is the same feel type of a country style American diner as compared to Marie Calendars or Carrows. I do prefer Polly's Pies because of the much larger variety of food options and bigger portions. Also, they serve complimentary homemade corn bread while you wait for your food! My party and I came on a Sunday night and there wasn't too many patrons. We got seated right away. I love the fact that they have the Oktoberfest seasonal menu - because I missed good ole German food. I ordered the pork Schnitzel. The food came out in roughly 15 mins and it was well worth the wait. It was juicy on the inside and crispy on the outside, yum! We also ordered chicken tenders but it wasn't as good. It was not as crispy and dry on the inside. Don't forget to get a slice of pie if you have room! Banana cream pie is my go to! read more

See all

When you walk in the place smells like cinnamon. For Christmas my dad and I got the French toast special. The service is five stars. Our waitress was super friendly. The ambience is very cute. read more

Polly's Pies - French Toast Combo - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California

First time here this review is for Elvis . GREAT CUSTOMER service . Thank you for your kindness . The ladies with the custard pie. read more

Went to Polly's and had a piece of their fresh strawberry pie. It had a boatload of strawberries and was covered with a strawberry syrup. It was outstanding. I would highly recommend it. read more

Polly's Pies - Strawberry poe - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California

Food was much better than expected. Loved the corned beef and cabbage for March. Would give 5 stars but service is very slow and had to wave down the waiter several times. They need to have the server check in at least twice during your meal. read more

We have been eating at the Fullerton location for years. It's not as good as it was a few years ago. We ate there a week ago. We stood there waiting to be seated for over 10 minutes. A group of servers were standing around in the kitchen and didn't say we will be there in a minute. Finally a server came from the back and seated us. It took a while before our order was taken. Our coffees were barely warm and our food was the same way just warm. I ate my cornbread because it was hot and delicious. My husband also ate his cornbread. We went to pay and had to wait again before anyone came to help. We used to go to many locations and they had some really nice ones and some a little less but we have noticed that they only have a few locations and this one we will not be dining there anymore. read more

First time at this Polly's. Great diner feel with a bakery and counter seating as you step in from the parking lot. Love the seasonal menu and it's Oktoberfest. Ordered the Brats and Eggs and the Schnitzel. Super tasty mustard served with the dishes added a perfect complement to the pork. Service is excellent at this location. No wait to be seated. Fast service for ordering and my coffee cup never went empty. Food was delivered hot and a great breakfast is always an awesome way to start the day. read more

Polly's Pies - Schnitzel - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California

Hit or miss the fish surprisingly and patty melt was good as I can remember. People have always been very friendly. This is the kind of place to take your grand parents. Almost all of my family reviews it positively. I don't like how they remodel the seats. read more

See all

Slowest service ever. I've given this place far too many chances. We enjoy the food, but it is not worth the ridiculously long wait.

So I've been here a couple of times in the last 6 months. And don't know why I had not been here before. I've only been here for breakfast. But if they serve tier lunch and dinners like breakfast then I recommend this place there food is delicious. It wasn't fancy I got eggs, sausage hash browns and pancakes but gotten bread or dessert on the way out. Since they have a full on bakery. Their giant cinnamon roll looks so good. Everyone was getting it made me want to get it also. But didn't want to give up on my pancakes. They were a big serving that's why I didn't get it on the way out. But looking to get it next time. read more

IM STILL WAITING FOR MY FOOD AND ITS BEEN A HOUR. There's only like 3 people working I'm so hungry help I'll update when I get my food read more

Polly's Pies - Uh - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California

This review is for their staff during the Thanksgiving season. I tried to walk-up and get pies the day before Thanksgiving and was told the only pie they had available for walk-ups were pumpkin and apple and anything else needed to be ordered ahead of the time online, or in-person. I tried ordering online via my phone while I was in the parking lot and the ordering function wasn't working so I walked back and waited in line to order. I ordered barberry, apple and custard pies for pick-up at 6 a.m. on Thanksgiving day. The staff and their manager were all working hard making pies, boxing them and sorting/organizing them. The next day I got there early and was 3rd in line and again, the staff were so nice and welcoming and ready to get the pies out. I observed nothing but teamwork both days I was there. The pies were good too. My favorite is their banberry pie and I'd recommend it to anyone! read more

Polly's Pies - Thanksgiving 2024 6:24 am - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California

Very good service and food ànd you can choose pie.slice of your choice happy to be done

Update: After contacting their email the PR manager of the restaurant was kind and offered us replacements on top of our refund. We truly appreciate this gesture and for that my rating will be bumped up. However, I still stand by my story and the dangers behind giving out moldy pies the day of pickup. Original: I ordered a sugar free pumpkin pie and banana cream pie for Thanksgiving. My family and I decided to celebrate the day after for Native American Heritage Day, which was the day we picked up the pie (Nov. 29). The pie was MOLDY the day of pick up. And only two days after (Dec. 2) it looked like this (second image). I called and spoked to JOAQUIN the manager. Told me to bring in the pie and honestly gave an attitude. My boyfriend returned the pies today just for a little apology and a refund. They didn't even offer something to compensate for the fact that my family had no pie this year. We were all too scared to touch the banana cream pie. The mold could have KILLED someone. read more

Polly's Pies - Sugar free pumpkin pie the day of pick up. Horrible, disgusting, moldy appearance. - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California

See all

Could have been better heavily describes my visit. The service was an absolute nightmare. I saw families get up and leave due to the lack of preparation the staff had. One family waiting 45 minutes for their food had it delivered cold, so they split as well.. I can only assume the restaurant was heavily understaffed for the unusual crowd. Our waitress (receipt says Ashley) was focusing 90% of her attention on a table of old people that I assume are regulars. When she did come through for us (and her other tables), she was very friendly and handled our orders. Sadly, leaving us hanging for 20+ minutes at a time doesn't support the dine-in experience. We were one of the lucky tables whose food came out at proper temperature and tasted basic but good. And of course the pie was nothing to skip on... A stronger staff that is customer driven would be all the support this location needs. read more

My family and I ate dinner at Polly's Pies on a Friday night. Without a crowd, we got seated after the staff cleaned up a table for us. The ambience felt calming with holiday decorations near the entrance, pies on display, and quiet music in the background. Our waiter, Ivan, provided excellent customer service because he kindly took our orders and answered our questions about the menu. I ordered the Sausage & Pepper Penne ($13.99), which came with one half-slice of garlic bread. The ingredients were grilled Italian sausage, sliced red and green bell peppers, sweet onions, Momma Polly's Marinara, and parmesan cheese. The pasta tasted solid and met my expectations. The sausage had a peppery flavor that brought diversity to the pasta. Overall, I'd rate it an adequate pasta as the marinara sauce didn't bring out any noteworthy taste. However, the garlic bread tasted good, and I wish I had another slice with the meal instead of the two dinner rolls. I also ordered one cup (small bowl) of the backburner soup as my grandpa recommended. Although I had no idea what kind of soup I ordered (I assumed it had spice because of the "burn" part of the name), I chose to eat it blind. Backburner soup didn't have a spot on the menu, but we confirmed with our waiter that they served it. The soup had a generous assortment of vegetables with penne rigate. However, my grandpa and I agreed that it tasted a bit cold upon receiving the soup. I believe it would've tasted better than if the broth thickened so as to bring out a hearty texture. I also wouldn't recommend it for people who like savory soup as it lacked spices to liven up its flavor. Also for the dinner rolls that came with the meal, I wish they had more warmth. Overall, Polly's Pies served good food at competitive prices compared to other American chain restaurants. At the end of the day, I'm glad that my family and I had a good time eating good food together. read more

Polly's Pies - Sausage & pepper penne with garlic bread - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California

I am a big fan of Polly's Pies and eat there often. Today, however, I was there for lunch at the Fullerton restaurant with my wife and since they are having a St. Patrick's month special from 17 Feb to 17 March, I decided to order the Reuben sandwich. As I bit into the Reuben, I realized there was no sauerkraut or Thousand island dressing, both of which are advertised on the menu. The waitress promptly went to get those for me (she offered to have the sandwich remade but I declined). She came back with the Thousand Island dressing but told me the kitchen did not have any sauerkraut available at all. I can understand running out of an ingredient (that doesn't explain the lack of Thousand Island on the sandwich to begin with) but to just make the sandwich and send it out without some of the advertised ingredients and not tell the customer beforehand in pretty incompetent. This was very poor form. I gave them 3 stars because the waitress was very good and quite attentive considering the kitchen's abject failure and my wife's turkey sandwich was very good, as always. Remember to ask beforehand if they have sauerkraut before ordering a Reuben sandwich - assuming the kitchen staff know what sauerkraut is to begin with. Or, just order the Turkey sandwich. read more

First time at this Polly's Pies location in Fullerton. It's a complete different vibe and indoor atmosphere than my usual location in Montebello. The interior feels more spacious and has nicer decors. Our server was very friendly and attentive. We ordered the turkey dinner which comes with cornbread and banberry pie. Food was pretty good, but wasn't a fan of the stuffing. The cornbread is the best thing about this place tho! They're located inside the same business plaza as Planet Fitness and Grocery Outlet. There's plenty of parking. At night time, their sign really stands out in the parking lot. read more

See all

We really like eating here, it's one of my daughters favorite places to go and it's close to our home. That being said, the service is always extremely slow. You have staff "not on the clock" just standing behind the counter putting on their apron while people are waiting to be sat and or pay. Get ready in the back if you're not ready to help anyone. I think they are short staffed or don't put enough servers on. I'm worked in the restaurant business for 10 years so I'm very forgiving but literally this place is sooooo slow. Also the bathrooms are gross read more

Mega Grilled Cheese and a cup of Creamy Tomato Basil Soup is by far the best thing I've had at Polly's Pies. It's near the top of my list of favorite dishes to order at among all restaurants. Great service, friendly staff and atmosphere was comfortable. Been coming here for years. However, the quality of the pies have been slowly going down. The last pie I had was just awful. I paid $20 for an apple pie that was completely sunken in, had burnt edges, the bottom crust was soggy and the filling was watery. If I come here again it will only be for the food and definitely not the pies. read more

Polly's Pies - Paid $20 for an apple pie. Edges were burnt, the bottom was soggy, filling was watery, and the whole pie was sunken in. - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California

Banberry Pie: Not even like it used to be. The place is overcrowded, help is to busy on the phones to help and location is a cesspool. Not going in there again. read more

A group of women came in friday night and we were served by armando, who was very polite and understanding of us being rowdy, we appreciate you or mandel, thank you for being a great server read more

I saw the sign advertising peach pies are here and decided to stop in. I got the homemade biscuits (bag of 6) - absolutely hearty, fresh and delicious. The banana cream pie was soulfully good, not too overtly sweet. The pumpkin pie (yes, in season already in July!) was also very good. The blueberry muffin and strawberry lemonade muffin were moist and perfect pairing with my morning coffee. I am glad they have multiple locations for fresh bread. I look forward to going back for dining in for breakfast or lunch. read more

Polly's Pies - Freshly made biscuits to go - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California