I wanted to update all on this review Although Polly's pie did answer my review they did send my wife a customer feedback survey as well. She let them know that we were disappointed in not only the pie but also the service received. They came through and gave her a complete refund We will definitely give them another try now. Just not a banana cream pie read more

Polly's Pies - Banana cream pie less than 17 hours after purchase - Bakeries Near Me - Huntington Beach, California

See all

Not sure what has happened to this restaurant that i've gone to forover twenty years, but the service has really declined on weekday afternoons... Perhaps they've cut back on staff.... Tables aren't getting clean promptly, and neither are the windowsills. You're just standing there.When people need drink refills and they have only one waitress on. I don't know, it's just not what it used to be. Management needs to pick up the ball. read more

Great pies! It's been a minute since I've been to a Polly's. I've never actually had any of their hot foods, only ever visited for the pies. All made fresh daily and free of preservatives. You'll see signs such as the bananas oxidizing quickly once exposed to air. You can slow it down by covering the exposed parts when you take a slice from the whole pies. The oxidation doesn't really affect the flavor or quality of the pies. I think it's a small trade off to have to deal with versus them using chemicals just to prolong visual appeal. Never an issue for me though since I finish them so quick. I've always been a big fan of their Banberry Pie. Banana cream filling with fresh slices of banana, fresh sliced strawberries on top, a ring of whipped cream all on top of their buttery and flaky crust. The combination is so good together. Slammed the whole pie myself in two days and felt less guilty about that because they offer it in a No Sugar Added option which substitutes sugar for Splenda. I also noticed they occasionally list their unsold or slightly damaged pies at the end of the day on the Too Good To Go app at a steeply discounted price. I was luckily enough to snag up two of them. I got a custard and a pumpkin pie! I was stoked for the pumpkin pie. I didn't even know they made that outside of the fall season and it was delicious! read more

Polly's Pies - Pumpkin Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Huntington Beach, California

See all

I am the Duke at Polly's, but I have been remiss in not reviewing the place. After a couple of recent visits I wanted to remedy my oversight. I ordered CFS that comes w/ eggs, hash browns and toast. First of all, the CFS was nicely seasoned and the gravy was creamy. All the other items were good, and I was very full after eating the in-house sourdough bread. Regarding the ambiance, Polly's remodeled recently. The decor is bright, and the space is more open. For lunch, they serve items you might see on Marie Callender's menu. Sirirat, the waitress I had on my last two visits is super friendly. She has a lot of regulars based on her interaction w/ customers. There are 3 Polly's in the area, and I have heard nothing but positive feedback. I personally have had all positive experiences. You can obvi buy pies here, but they also sell cookies and bread. All the bakery items are at the cashier when you exit, making it convenient to pick something up on your way out. read more

Polly's Pies - Chicken Fried Steak & Eggs ($16.99) hearty and very good - Bakeries Near Me - Huntington Beach, California

Stopped by Polly's for the first time. I ordered the Comeback Chicken Sandwich combo, which included fries, a drink, and a cookie (I opted to upgrade my cookie to a slice of pie for an extra $3). The sandwich was 2 out of 5. While the chicken texture was fine, the breading lacked flavor and the bun was average. The fries were ok (3/5). The highlight of the meal was the pie. I tried the fresh strawberry pie (4/5) and the blueberry pie (3.5/5) with ice cream. The strawberries were fresh and I appreciated that the pie wasn't stuffed with cream. read more

See all

Ordered takeout so cannot comment on service or ambience. Got the chicken fried steak! Portion was the bigger side and I think it was good as a first time try-er. read more

Polly's Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Huntington Beach, California

This is my favorite Polly's location! The others are fine, they just have a more 70's old school vibe, while this one is a bit more modern with the simple black and white stripe upholstery to the back of the booth seats. It's also got a little patio to the side that is completely covered. I will definitely be sitting out there next time! This chain has an awesome birthday deal every year when you sign up. Not only do you get a free meal, but you get a free slice of pie too, and there's no purchase necessary. But if you take people, everyone who orders an entree gets a free slice of pie too! And their pies are deeeeeelicious! All of the fruit pies are amazing! And not every diner makes custard pie, but Polly's does! I also have to mention that their burger is phenomenal! Super juicy and super flavorful! Just be careful you don't spill any on your pants like I usually do:P read more

See all

We recently came to Polly's Pies after moving to the area a couple of months ago -- we always passed by it and finally decided to try it. We went on a Sunday around 1 PM. It didn't seem too busy, but service was still a bit slow. Even though it was later in the day, we still ordered breakfast. My fiancé got the chicken pot pie and said he would definitely order it again. I ordered the French toast combo and it was delicious. We were planning to try the pies in-house, but we were too full, so we ended up taking them home instead. I got a slice of banana cream pie and my fiancé got the chocolate cream pie -- both were so good, now we understand why it's called Polly's Pies. We would definitely come back and recommend it. Also, if you sign up for their rewards, they give you a free slice of pie, which is a nice bonus! read more

Polly's Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Huntington Beach, California

Polly's Pies May special is a double crusted Peach filling pie and we couldn't resist. As long as we were at Polly's we decided to have our lunch. The lovely missus had her sandwich and what she liked was the cup of tomato basil soup. My lunch special chicken sandwich was a good portion which included French fries and a chocolate chip cookie. Ofcourse we got the Peach pie to go as well as a couple orders of the Mother's day Pie Bites. Interesting bite sized apple, boysenberry and cherry filled morsels at $6.99 in a present see-thru top pink box. We had a good lunch and we'll have dessert later at home. We also want to thank Jorge for his attentive friendly service... he was pretty busy tending to many other patrons. By the way, I just had a slice of Polly's Peach pie and it is a thumbs up. read more

See all

A friend had told us about the tomato soup and the $3/15 deal. We felt like we needed to try it. We felt like it was blow back of a Seinfeld episode going for the early bird special. We were pleasantly surprised , the restaurant was very clean, nicely decorated from Valentines Day and the staff was warm and friendly. We upgraded to the Salmon and it was very good. The tomato soup was excellent and glad to hear it is a recurring menu item. The included pie was Banana cream which was excellent. We will be returning to try other items. What a nice surprise!! read more

See all

Work gave us a gift card for the holidays and decided to check this spot out cause why not. I got their HUGE cinnamon rolls and Dutch apple pie! I am very pleased with on how soft the cinnamon roll was and I also asked for extra icing on the side which was perfect! Most places the icing goes away when heating up and you never have enough icing. But the extra icing on the side to top off after heating it up was soooo good! I also love a Dutch apple pie and no complaints! So good! Definitely be coming back for a meal read more

Polly's Pies - Cinnamon roll!! Dutch Apple BOTH SO GOOOOOD - Bakeries Near Me - Huntington Beach, California

Dude best cinnamon rolls ever. The portion was huge, it was nice and fluffy, warm, and had lots of frosting and for only $5.50. Now I know where to go when i'm craving cinnamon rolls! Elaine was our waitress and she was amazing. So sweet and got us whatever we needed. I was here needing comfort food for a broken heart and Elaine made sure we had everything we needed and was so sweet. Thanks Elaine! The restaurant is clean, there's lots of seating, and lots of parking. read more

Not great. The restaurant is clean and welcoming. The eggs, bacon and hash browns were good. The coffee tasted like instant. The French toast was raw. The biscuits with sausage gravy were cold. They had no sausage and the gravy tasted like it came out of a packet. Our server was nice but she was new and didn't know the menu. My order was incorrect and we had to ask for syrup. I won't be returning. read more

So, I ordered the double the clams clam chowder... Big mistake-- Huuuuge! There's hardly any clams and I swear I tasted chicken remnants lol Granted, it's a bit later but c'mon man! At least put some real canned clams in there! Let's see how the rest of the meal goes. read more

Polly's Pies - Prime Rib dinner - Bakeries Near Me - Huntington Beach, California

See all

Met with my gal pals for some breakfast before going next door to the head spa. We were seated right away on a Sunday morning at 10:30am. Had the Rueben Sandwich special they are currently advertising. It was tastey, I asked for more thousand island sauce. The corned beef was a little fatty and tough. The place was empty when we arrived but was busy by noon. Would come back again. Next time some pie! read more

See all

I decided to give this spot another chance, last night. How could the experience get even worse? This time we were treated as an afterthought, and our server never checked on us. We completed our meal, and didn't have a check-in or dropping of the check. We heard the staff be friendly with other patrons, but perhaps they only like the "usuals/regulars". My son's fries were so dark, I thought they were sweet potato fries. His grilled cheese wasn't even melted all the way. However, no one came to ask how we were doing. I definitely won't be coming back. read more

See all

Polly's on Adams Avenue HB has always been my favorite location. I feel at home whenever I get breakfast with my family here. The service is always prompt and kind. The clock somehow feels slower and kinder as soon as you step in. And in a good way. The food comes out quickly but we never feel rushed. The pancakes and skillets here never fails to satisfy our palate. Everything always comes out perfectly no matter when we visit. I know of no other place I like eating my eggs and pancakes in SoCal. Pancakes always tastes fluffy, eggs perfectly cooked and not rubbery. The bacons are crispy and sausages tastes great. I don't even like eating processed meat but I gladly gobble them up if it's from Polly's! I let the cashier know during checkout that we're glad to revisit even if it's a bit of a hike from Aliso. She told me there are customers who come from Long Beach and Los Alamitos saying the same thing. I agree with them and think they too are on to something!! Parking is free here and plenty outside. One can sit indoors or outdoors. Checkout is completed out front and they take Amex. I'm looking forward to revisiting again in the near future. read more

Polly's Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Huntington Beach, California

See all

Consistently wonderful courteous responsive efficient service combined with tasty fresh food. We enjoy backburner soup and delicious fruit pies. read more

My husband and 20 month old son were seated for lunch today. 4 other tables were seated after them. They waited 10 minutes and no server approached. 3 of the 4 other tables, that were seated after them, were served water/drinks. My husband and son left. Absolutely disorganized. read more

ONIONS MUST BE ON SALE OR BREAKFAST BURRITO NEEDS TO READ~~~ "flour tortilla stuffed with 5 onions and for the most favorable mouth feel we leave the peel intact. For color and to keep the regurgitated food look we throw In what we are gunna call egg and pepper" This place sucks the manager was anything but helpful. Worst 40 bucks spent so far today. I guess the only good thing is my day can only get better from this total disappointment. read more

See all

Came by on a Saturday for some lunch food during breakfast hours (before 10 am). I ordered their Prime Rib French Dip only to find out that it was not available. I then ordered their Pollymelt and a slice of banana cream pie. Food was delivered timely and at the right temperature. Pollymelt was good as well as the pie. Pollymelt came with fries but they were not provided well done as requested. Service was friendly and efficient. read more

See all

Waitress was nice. Mgr had no personality, was not really apologetic for the bad French dip I had. It was so fatty, I couldn't even eat it. I told the waitress & she agreed it was fatty. Called Mgr. over & he didn't apologize for the disgusting sandwich but I ordered a small hamburger instead. Looking around, it didn't look like the Polly's Pies I went to about 5 yrs ago. Turned off by the service, food & Mgr. attitude, I'll never go back. Waitress Monet was very nice. It was 4pm & there was only one other table occupied. Huntington Beach Polly's is usually full & food & pies are great. read more

Beware! We recently had a frightening experience at Polly's. My wife found shards of glass in the pie we ordered for her birthday. She managed to spit out a few pieces and had a burning sensation in her throat for several days. Thankfully, our three-year-old didn't have any before we discovered the glass. Polly's didn't seem overly concerned about the incident. We received a refund for the pie and had to fill out an incident report. I would appreciate it if they could offer us something to compensate us for this frightening experience, ruined birthday celebration and encourage us to become repeat customers again. read more

Polly's Pies - This is a shard of glass my wife was chewing on in her pie - Bakeries Near Me - Huntington Beach, California

See all

Stopped by after being out and about today for a quick solo meal. The service was great - Mike was very attentive and accommodating. My meal was solid, appetizing and swift. I ordered the new chicken sandwich with the spicy sauce and it was great. The side salad was fresh and the atmosphere was quiet for a Tuesday afternoon before dinner time. Also, I love their Mango Black tea! Always refreshing! read more

Polly's Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Huntington Beach, California

Came here for the first time with my mom and sister and we are DEFINITELY COMING BACK! The food was delicious and the service was amazing. Shoutout to Jorge!! He was so sweet and took care of us so well. I loved the interior design. It felt so homey and welcoming and gave me a 60's vibe and I loved it! I got the big kahuna BLT with fries and a strawberry lemonade and it was amazing. The lemonade has fresh strawberries in it and had the right amount of sweetness. Don't even get me started on the pies!! We got the apple crisp pie and it was so delicious. All the employees were so nice. The prices are very affordable and the food was soooo good. I can't wait to come back. read more

Polly's Pies - Strawberry Lemonade - Bakeries Near Me - Huntington Beach, California

See all

after years of not going after a bad visit we went yesterday. The new remodel and menu were great. The food was very good and the prices are very fair. We really liked the new patio that's dog friendly and will be going more often now read more

I've been to Polly's Pies before and had great experiences, which makes this visit especially disappointing. I brought my daughter for breakfast and we had our small Yorkie with us, so we sat on the outdoor patio. We were the first table seated outside, and shortly after, two other tables were seated near us. Despite this, no one ever came to greet us, offer water, or take a drink order. What made it worse was watching the table next to us get served while we were still completely ignored--not even a simple acknowledgment. After waiting long enough, we got up and left. Customer service goes a long way. Even if staff is busy, acknowledging a table makes all the difference. Unfortunately, today's service was unacceptable. I didn't see the usual manager on duty, and it showed. Very disappointing experience. read more

There are few things in this life quite as wonderful as being served by Jeanie as she sings and dances her way through breakfast. The food is good but I go for Jeanie. read more

Spontaneous decision to eat at Polly's as we were shopping nearby. So happy my mom-in-law and I made that decision as it was quite a positive experience overall. Food, service, ambience. Very warm, friendly welcome up front and I really enjoyed my lunch options and choice. Mom was truly enjoying her palate pleaser chicken pie meal and made sure to bring her leftovers home as the portion was mighty. Very happy accident!!! read more

See all

I decided to try Polly's Pies one Friday afternoon. I bought a boysenberry pie and a cherry pie. I heated them up a little later that night and they were both delicious. The crust was light and flaky and the berries were amazing, not too sweet. I will definitely be buying more pies there! read more

What an interesting concept on take and bake pies where is no traditional brick and mortar store. But to my surprise and delight, the pies were delicious! I'll test them again! read more

Good old-fashioned food in a comfortable homey atmosphere. Friendly service is a given, and don't forget the world-class pie! I love the patty melt! But I also love the chicken salad on raisin bread! That is what I ordered, with the shoes string fries, to share with my girl! She had the half avocado sando with the tomato basil soup. The key lime pie is almost irresistible, but we were very brave and declined the sweet treat. There is loads of free parking, lots of fresh and tempting bakery items, and nice clean rest rooms! They remodeled the interior recently and the new look is light and bright and clean and cheerful! read more

Polly's Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Huntington Beach, California

See all

Came here to redeem my birthday coupon and it didn't go smoothly. When I printed the email, for some reason the coupon code didn't come out but the coupon to get a free slice of pie did. I didn't want to just pay for my entree because the whole reason I drove there was to get my free entree. They asked to see my email originally, and of course, i couldn't pull it up. I was so sad but the manager made up for it. I showed her how I tried to look for it and i had my actual printout and she decided to just give it to me. I was so relieved. And I'm so happy I finally got to see the newly remodeled restaurant because it looks amazing. They have a side patio with a complete covering over it. Reminds me of how Hof's Hut is set up. I was disappointed with my food however. I ordered the salmon and it was so salty. I had to add butter and it calmed it down a little bit. read more

See all

Live nearby, decided to stop by for breakfast. The breakfast was decent, their cinnamon roll was on point, and their cold brew hit. Our server Megan was extremely nice and attentive. She gave solid recommendations and ensured everything was exactly how we ordered. The restaurant was recently remodeled. It is a lot brighter now. read more

Polly's Pies - Cinnamon Roll - Bakeries Near Me - Huntington Beach, California

My boyfriend and I come here every Friday morning, it's such a wonderful way to start the weekend. The food is consistently delicious and you really can't beat the prices! Now the part that matters: the service is amazing! They're always running around busy but never too busy to take care of you properly. Jeanie is what brings us back every week whether she's our server or not. She makes us feel part of the family. Jorge is often times our server and he's so professional and respectful. Thank you so much Polly's. read more

Been coming to this Polly pies location HB for the longest time. Over the years they have remodel and it looks really nice. The banberry pie is still my favorite and go to pie. I always bring it for events and parties and it's always a hit. You can always order a head of time online or just come by and pick one up. Banberry pie is pretty popular so there's always a bunch ready for pickup. The other pies are pretty good as well, bumbleberry, Apple pies. They also sell homemade jelly as well. read more

See all

Always So Impressed! My visit here included all the good stuff one could expect. Greeted and seated immediately, noticeably sparkling clean, service was very friendly and fast, and the food was not only fresh and tasty, but also nicely presented. ( I know that "presentation" isn't necessarily something one is normally too concerned with or expects at this type of restaurant ). I interacted with 3 associates here and each one was very pleasant. It's literally hard for me to believe that these low prices are real. In May of 2025... soup & salad, a beverage, plus a big delicious cookie- $11.99 !!? It' isn't really common for me to feel "appreciative" after dining out, but that happens every single time I eat at this location in Huntington Beach, as well as the ones in Orange and Santa Ana. Thank you very much to everyone at Polly's. read more

Polly's Pies - Tomato basil soup and salad with extra excellent blue cheese dressing. - Bakeries Near Me - Huntington Beach, California

The food was ok. Service was not the best. Had to ask for refills and forgetting requests. Forgot to apple pie to go and presentation of strawberry pie was no bueno. Was sat outside on a hot day n due to size of party. Was not that busy and plenty of room. Casher was rude when I informed her about missing pie and strawberry pie with no crust. Rudely said that's how it supposed to be. Wanted a new pies but was rejected. Assistant looked unhappy being there. read more

Polly's Pies - Strawberry pie with no crust - Bakeries Near Me - Huntington Beach, California

See all

A really fun place to go for Bingo Wednesdays 4 pm and 6:30 PM seating . Get there early! The Staff is great and pretty hilarious!

I love the remodeled location and it looks great, but sadly my positive experience stopped there. When I walked in, three staff just stared and didn't greet me - so strange. I had to tell them I'm here to pick up and they still looked confused. No one asked "name?" "oh, you're here to pick up"... Very odd. Then they proceeded to give me a pie that was correct but mislabeled, which caused massive confusion as I drove to a family event. The apple crisp was also too sweet, and it sat unfininshed. I'll be going back to other pie places to get my pie in the future. read more