Really classic pizza. Crust is thin and crunchy, sauce is flavorful without being too sweet. A slice cost me only $4.60 after tax. Would absolutely recommend!! read more

Pulcinella Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

One of the best pizza restaurants in town. Dine inside or on their patio or take out. read more

Pulcinella Pizzeria - Storefront - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

I got two slices of pizza that had veggies and cheese on top. Both my husband and I couldn't eat more than one bite because it was way too salty and couldn't taste anything else. I purposefully chose veggie one because I didn't want too much salt and it was very disappointing. read more

Worst pizza in Fort Collins, wings were soggy and flavorless. Pizza was thin and cardboard like texture, with minimal flavor. Overall not worth the price, extremely disappointing and a waste of good money. read more

Shocked by the lower ratings. Tried cheese and pepperoni slices. Both were far above average, great crust. The staff was super nice. The place was clean, had a nice beer and wine selection and before taking a lasagna to go, my husband and I tried a bite. All their pastas are made in house and are delicious. Absolutely would return. read more

I used to love this place bc I'd get a small pizza durning my Landry and it was good pizza and then I tried to call ahead one day and they kept throwing me on hold for over 30 mins and when I came in and tried to ask about it they were very riding saying they've were super busy and there's only 3 tables of people including myself. I work hard so I get it but then to laugh at me and sake their head because I asked is uncalled for. I was very nice when I asked and didn't deserve that and I still bought my pizza. If you go here enjoy the food but the people are terrible. read more

Easily top 5 places I'd go to for some great slices or pizza in general. I've gotten the slices throughout the past few weeks and enjoyed everytime. Crust is a balance between crunchy and thin. Dough isn't overpowering or heavy on the stomach. Right amount of cheese etc Customer service on point as well, everyone on staff those days grind and cook with love read more

Pulcinella Pizzeria - Demolished each slice - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Absolutely delicious calzone! I am so surprised by the Yelp score of this restaurant. We stopped in for lunch and were not disappointed. The service was helpful and let us know you can add as many toppings for $3.99 a slice. The inside has pictures from Italy and gives a traditional pizzeria feel with a wine bar too. You can turn any pizza into a calzone for a slight discount. Today we tried the pesto chicken calzone and it was delicious. Bursting with pesto, chicken, cheese and tomato's it was everything I could have hoped for. Be sure to get an extra side or marinara for the crust and a pop of acid to cut the cheese. It took around 20 minutes and we were the only ones in there so if you're in a rush be sure to call ahead. I can't wait to come back again and have another one soon! read more

Gives you that old school Italian pizza place that you would see in the East Coast great pizza thin crust just flat out good food service was excellent. read more

Totally shocked by low reviews, but let me start at the beginning. My wife went to school here and this was her go to place for real NY/NJ pizza. As we grew up on opposite ends of the George Washington Bridge, pizza matters... and real NY/NJ pizza is hard to find out here. As we are moving back to town, we've been trying different places. Some are very good, but nothing so far has been authentic. Then we came here. We picked up a "Two for Tuesday" special (large pizza, two free toppings) with meatball and mushroom. Out of the park excellent. I truly thought I was back in NY. Meatball especially was spot on. Could have used a bit more cheese, but it was delicious. Will definitely be back for Margherita Mondays (25% any Margherita pie, my wife's favorite). Again, people were nice, pie was ready when they said it was, and it was delicious. Ambiance was, well, like a pizzeria. Can't wait to find ourselves back there! read more

Our 1st visit. The BEST AMAZING pizza. We will be back just for the pizza. We ordered medium King and Specialty Spinach; both are awesome! The house italian tomato sauce is to die for! A small place. pretty much self service. You order pizza at the counter, order drinks at the bar, and wait with a table number. Beautiful homemade italian desserts are available. Housemade Tiramisu is sold in a lobby cooler. BUY IT! Eat it in or take home for breakfast. Fantastic! If you are lucky enough to dine on the right night, an angel Heather will take your bar order and make your visit exceptional. She tends bar, conveys the exceptional italian wine list with expert knowledge, and attends to all other needs necessary while you are dining. She's glad you are there, gets to know you, and is genuine. We will be back just for Heather. The people in the pizza prep area were courteous. read more

So bummed, when I lived there , this was my go to place. Pizza slice was barely edible and the meatball sandwich wasn't any better!

Best pizza so far the Fort Collins has to offer! Pulcinella pizzaria better than jj's better than pizza cashbah better than all other pizza places I've tried here that I may not remember The crowed favorite ... wait for it ... wait for it ... TRIGGER ALERT TRIGGER ALERT ... THE HAWAIIAN!! I think it's because it was sweet and probably the most like New York style pizza we have had here. It is still not an Ecco Domani and doesn't hold a candle to pronto pizza back on the good old east coast and hey east coast, least coast but they got pizza figured out in a way that the western latitude and longitudes do not understand. Maybe it's the way that dough rises or something?? I mean where are my Colorado Italians at?! Amirite?! The wait staff at puli in Ella's were pretty cool .50 for ranch LOL com'on man. Also don't ask anyone to pronounce the name correctly but hey mama Mia pizzaria get me some spaghetti pleasa! read more

See all

We had the best time here! The pizza is literally the best in Fort Collins! The owner Mary and bartender Heather made us feel right at home. They also have extensive wine knowledge which was such a surprise for a pizza place! Definitely check it out! You won't be disappointed! read more

Food was good. Has great flavor and a good crust to pizza ratio. Service was lacking. All the teenagers there seemed extremely unthrilled to be working/talking to us/to be existing in general. But food was too tasty to give a lower rating. Ambiance was lacking as well. read more

Great caprese sandwich- it's huge! Calzone was alright but the sauce was amazing. Ambience was better than expected for a local pizza place. Friendly staff & good value. Would recommend read more

Pulcinella Pizzeria - Caprese Sub - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

This was the best pizza in Fort Collins. Not up to par. Pizza by slice it not what is used to be. They only had three cheese pizza for by slice. Weak!!! Not how I wanted to kick off my time in Fort Collins read more

Poor service, pizza was even worse. Been coming here for over 20 years as this WAS our favorite pizzeria in FC, but recent experiences have been thoroughly disappointing. Orders messed up (ordered lasagne and meatballs and forgot the lasagne), pizza undercooked despite ordering the crust "crispy" as I've been doing for years. We even rec'd a pepperoni pizza last winter with the pepperoni in the shape of a smiley face - total mockery of what was once a great pizzeria. This place has clearly "lost the sauce", don't waste your money. read more

Terrible experience today with Pulcinella. Called in a pick up, guy was rude and said "sure" in a negative tone when I asked if I could place the order. Should have known at that point to go somewhere else. Picked up the $28 medium pizza that's completely under cooked, toppings tossed on like they don't care. I miss the Harmony location, that at least gave a shit about the over priced pizza they made. Save yourself the coin and get pizza elsewhere I called in for a refund, was transferred to a manager who hung up on me after he said the refund processed. Owner called me shortly after to have my review updated and wouldn't give me a chance to talk. Just kept saying over and over that running a small business is tough.. I get it. I try to support small business by spending $28 on a pizza instead of ordering from one of the big companies and saving money. Very disappointed in this business. read more

Hands down the best pizza in FC!! We picked up last night, and even the gluten free pizza was great. I've never had a bad experience at this place, always our go-to for pizza. read more

Paid for a pizza tonight was told 20 minutes... I show up in 20 minutes and the pizza that I paid for is "not even started yet " according to staff. "We will have it right out" the guy said. I left. To ownership... teach your employees to set the correct time expectation by better communicating with your staff. IT IS NOT THAT DIFFICULT TO ASK FOR A TIME FROM YOUR PIZZA MAKER IS IT? keep your pizza... refund my CC under "Wells" and let's move on. Your location has turned into a disaster and if you are unwilling to refund my money I will contest it with the bank. read more

Pizza was decent! Person on the phone sounded like they hated being alive and working there.

The dood here is amazing and they somehow always get the order right with tens and tens of students coming through there everyday around noon. read more

Great pizza and cannoli! I've eaten here many times over the years and have never been disappointed. I've been eating their Hawaiian pizza lately cooks crispy and it's been spot on. Generous portions of Canadian bacon and pineapple cooked perfectly!! Best pizza in Ft. Collins in my opinion. read more

Luckily I was starving so I sucked it up, but wow this is a pretty bad job, a heads up that the pizza being this badly burnt would've been nice to know read more

Pulcinella Pizzeria - Double pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

This used to be my favorite pizza place. My most recent visit was disappointing. The calzones are soggy and the crust is hard to chew. The pizza rolls barely had any cheese. Also too expensive Two calzones, medium cheese pizza, and 8 pep pizza rolls was $65 for pick up. Not worth it when there are so many other choices in the area. read more

I repeatedly get fantastic food and service at Pulcinella. The wine bar selection is fantastic and ever revolving/evolving. Great food, wine AND service? THIS is why we eat out. read more

Great pizza. Easy to take out. Ordering online is easy, service was quick and timing was accurate for pickup.

Has the Harmony restaurant changed owners? The last 2 pizzas I got there have been really bad. The dough has no glutton and was like flour and water mixed for a minute or two. This has been my goto pizza for years. I will give it 1 more chance, but have very low expecataionss read more

I moved here in October from New York. A friend told me about this place since I couldn't find any pizza worth eating. It wasn't New York pizza but it was the best Colorado pizza in Fort Collins. Now it's Aug and it went down hill fast. They never have slices of regular and when you order a pie they started to use cheaper ingredients.Very disappointed. 2 stars might be to many but I'm wishing on a star they go back to the old ways. read more

Absolute garbage. This was dough that either sat at room temperature for a couple of hours before baking or they just don't bother to roll their dough. Who would put this in a box and send to a customer read more

Pulcinella Pizzeria - The worst pizza i have ever had. The photo says it all - Pizza Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Tried to order a pizza on the phone and the line was busy. Called back and the guy on the phone was rude and accused me of being rude when I did not say a word to him because I got a busy signal. Staff is horrible. Used to be a great restaurant. read more

Overpriced, burnt, and huge air bubbles cover 1/2 of the pie. On multiple occasions I had to trash half of the pie because it was so poorly made. I'd take frozen supermarket pizza over this garbage. Stay away unless you enjoy throwing money away for burnt bread. read more

What am I supposed to do? Drink the sauce? I got the lasagna and the sauce was so watery it just spilled through the fork. The owner needs to train their employees better. These kids need direction that's why I don't blame them but I do blame the owner. Start having training days!! I took a picture of the sauce but this app didn't allow me to upload it. read more

I gave always enjoyed the pizza from here - tasted like home- New York. But tonight I was extremely disappointed. It appears they have changed from using whole milk mozzarella to some cheap crap. I know the difference in mozzarella - the taste, the texture, the "stringiness", the melted texture and the grease dripping from the cheese This was the worse pizza I have gotten. If I wanted cheap pizza I could have gotten cheap somewhere else. This was not cheap and definitely not worth the price. Mary Race- you need to fix this! read more

Used to be our go to pizza place, but unfortunately this last time, pizza was undercooked, and salads were gross. When placing our order, it took forever to get someone to answer the phone to even place an order, girl taking order was very rude. I lowered my review to 3 stars, I would've lowered it more but the delivery driver was super nice, saving them a Star. Not sure I will be ever going back. So sad. read more

Always a fave! Delivery can take an abnormally long time so I'd recommend dine in or pick up. Food is consistently good. Staff is college kids so don't expect some kind of 4 star service but you will get your food. They have the best ranch. read more

We had takeout from Pulcinella's last night. Thin crust pizza with plenty of cheese and toppings. Fresh Caesar salad: Delicious! Staff was friendly and efficient. A Great Place! Rog read more

Pucinella Pizzeria on Shields in Fort Collins has a professional, generous, and flexible staff. I am an intern at a nonprofit in Fort Collins. Our organization was hosting an event and we reached out to Pucinella to see if we could get pizzas donated. The person I talked to was friendly and helpful. At the last minute we needed to make a change to our request and without hesitation they were able to accommodate us. The food is also very good and our clients and staff enjoyed it. Thank you Pucinella for your great hospitality and delicious food! read more

So goooood. Every time! I love their pizza by the slice and the location. Friendly people and nice environment. Love to stop there and get a movie next door! read more