I really don't get the hype. I think it's all a mass delusion based on marketing bullshit. I am pretty sure these guys have their crust trucked in frozen from Chicago. It's a near-twin to the crust in a "Home Run Inn" frozen pizza box. Mind you, "Home Run" makes a bitchin' frozen pizza. The best. And Pusateri's is tasty. But Pusateri's is not homemade. It's made on a plastic tray in a conventional conveyor oven, and I am pretty sure it's made from frozen ingredients. read more

Wow... It is the best Chicago thin crust pizza in the state of Florida. They are not kidding! Get a Chicago Italian Beef while you're here. Can't go wrong! read more

Pusateri's Chicago Pizza - The John Hancock - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

This is hands down the best pizza in the area. I have tried multiple in the Stuart/Jupiter area and this one takes the cake. Amazing quality in the ingredients which give each bite something to remember. Perfect amounts of sauce and a healthy helping of toppings every time! The staff is super friendly and very helpful with the menu. They make it a wonderful visit no matter what time of day you go. Definitely check this place out!!! read more

First thing I thought was "Chicago thin crust?" So glad my Girlfriends and I stopped here for lunch. The service was fast and friendly. I believe our server was Sherri. She was great. The pizza was piping hot and tasted amazing. I got the a sausage and pepper personal pizza. The crust was crisp, the cheese was melting and gooey. I'm a sauce person so the ratio of sauce to pizza was on point. Um can we talk about the sausage? Super yummy and flavorful. They even had gluten free pizza for my friend who has a sensitivity. Whenever I'm visiting the Stuart area again I'll be back!! read more

Very mediocre food and bad service. When I was done eating I waited 30minutes for my check. Italian Grandpa's homemade pizza crust doesn't cut it anymore. I paid eight dollars for a huge Caesar salad that came out of a bag. Don't waste your time on this place -- typical cheap, bad food advertising itself as "family Italian." Nobody in Italy would eat this crap. read more

Terribly disappointed in visit tonight. My dad, a 90 year old veteran led our party into the dining room and was told there wasn't an open table. Many ppl around the dining room said they were almost finished. When one table vacated their table, the hostess made a point about us "running them off" she made her point by showing me an unfinished beer. So disappointed in the service by her. read more

Well don't know where to start ! First who are those people who are putting 5 start review on this pizza place ! The service was okay but the food one of the worse ! I read the previous review and some of them were good and some of them were bad, so I decided to try! Well I can agree to bad ! Pizza was horrible, I think papa johns it's a actually better ! Dough was worse than a frozen pizza and the sauce was super sweet ! Cardboard pizza !!! Plus crazy price Mozzarella stick (frozen ) Large pizza House salad Total $45 Wow ! Never again read more

Best pizza east of Chicago in south florida "hands up"! Not a long wait at all,staff is very friendly and eager to make your visit very comfortable and pleasant. read more

This place can get busy and if it's not nice enough to sit outside, they do not have a lot of seating inside and you may have to wait, so please keep that in mind. I do think that this place could use more inside seating, but with the location they are currently at there is just no possible way. It was decided to get a large pizza with sausage on it, being split between everyone that we went with. The pizza was very large and they do cut it into square pieces. The sausage was a little spicy and very tasty. One thing to prepare yourself with though is the sauce. The sauce used on these pizza's is sweet. I personally am not used to sweet sauce nor would I want it if I had pizza often, however, it is more tasty when it is contrasted with something of a spicy flavor. read more

This is the pizza that God ate when he rested on the seventh day. Just sayin. The most painful part of moving from Florida to Texas was leaving this unparalleled pie behind. Oh... friends too... miss them also. (Just not as much as Pusateri's...) read more

So good! My kids (6 and 8) really liked it too. Next time I'm in town, I've got to get some more of this pizza.

All I can say is, if your from Chicago, this is the REAL deal!!! Everyone thinks that Chicago pizza is only deep dish. Not so! Deep dish pizza is nice from time to time, but, this is the pizza that most people from Chicago eat on a weekly basis. Most of their ingredients are flown in from Chicago......including bread from Gonella. If your from Chicago, you know who Gonella is! ;) Anyway, this place is a must! During a recent visit home (Chicago), my wife and I found ourselves craving the taste of a Pusateri's Pizza!!!! read more

This is the best pizza place in Florida omg! We had mushrooms and pepperoni pizza and it was delicious.. I will be back!! I was just visiting my parents.. They go there all the time.. read more

The Best pizza in Florida. I'm from Chicago and love the pizza, the hot dogs and especially the italian beef.

Best pizza and staff in Stuart. First timer and had a great experience with Philly (spelling?) as our waitress. Looking forward to coming back many times. read more

I have been eating their pizza for years now. Very thin crust pizza, cut in squares. We used to frequent a place up north that served a very similar pie. If you have not tried the pizza with the Italian sausage, you are surely missing out. I have had Italian shredded beef sandwiches from vendors in Chicago, and Pusateris' sandwich matches it to perfection. Get it "wet" ;) I have always had friendly & courteous service there, whether dining in or taking out. I have called ahead several times and ordered, and always had a great experience. Brought friends and family when they are in town visiting, and its always a hit. read more

You want real Chicago thin crust, this is probably as good as it gets in the state of Florida. I'm from Chicago, and while I'd prefer the pizza from back home, there's nothing wrong with what is happening right herein Stuart. I would eat here again and again. Hot dog was good too, poppy seed bun and all. Looking forward to trying an Italian beef. read more

This is a great place to eat pizza and Italian Beef sandwiches on the Treasure coast. The Italian Beef Chi-Town Combo is my favorite topped off with Hot Giardiniera Peppers dipped in au jus sauce. This has both Italian Beef and Sausage. Yummy! Get in there and get some because this place is GREAT!!! One downfall is that they are not open Sunday afternoons, Monday's, or Tuesdays. read more

Best pizza we've found in the area, even though "thin crust Chicago style" seem like an oxymoron. Signature sausage had plenty of cheese, sauce is excellent and sausage was plentiful and tasty. Food was ready sooner than they told me it would be, so if you're picking up you might want to show up early. read more

Good pizza. Yikes!!! It's served hot right out of the oven. Lunch service was prompt and polite.

Great pizza. I always thought that Chicago style was tick crust, Pusateri's taught me that that is not the case. Don't care for the dough on most pizza. This place does it correctly. Very thin, cracker like crust and delicious toppings. We will be going a lot! read more

Got the Chicago hotdog & small build your own pizza. Wonderful!! Amazing service :):):)

Although the label on Yelp shows this place as being a Chicago thin crust pizza place, the name is just Pustareli's and is advertised as a Chicago style pizza place. I was craving an authentic Chicago deep dish pizza and found when I arrived that they only serve the deep dish pizza 2 days a year. However, the thin crust Chicago style pizza they do serve is amazing. Well worth it. The place is very small and only has a few tables inside. They said that is the reason they don't serve the deep dish everyday as they don't have enough room. Overall, the pizza was amazing and the service was great. The servers are trying to move around a room the size of a large bathroom to serve everyone and do it with a smile. Great people, great food. read more

Likes Ledo's but better !!!! We r from Maryland Been so so said Missing our thin crust provolone mix cheese Pizza Pusateri's sausage cheese pizza Is not just similar But surpasses it !!! We drove 47 min from palm beach And will be back Thank you for a taste of home read more

Not the best in town. Good service but who wants to hear politics while getting a bite to eat ? Chicago pizza ?

The four stars are for the pizza alone. The pizza has always been fantastic, but the service could be much better. We went for halloween and we were abruptly stopped about our masks. We were received with a sigh about us wanting to eat inside. Our server didn't smile one time. She barely greeted us. We were told to wait multiple times when asked if we could get refills. It was and has been often unpleasant to dine here. read more

Came in Saturday to grab some pizza. The pizza was great! Philly was our waitress. She was kind, thoughtful, and cared about her customers. Great to still see service like this. We will be back! read more

Small cute place with great Chicago flavor. All Chicago sports represented and a hell of a Chicago thin crust! I will be back!!! read more

See all

I am originally from Chicago and this place is just like home! Whenever we have people in from out of town I think I'm here. The Italian beef, the real Chicago hotdog, and the Thin crust pizza is to die for! I highly highly highly highly recommend this place! Go Blackhawks! Go cubbies! Go Bulls! read more

Pusateri's Chicago Pizza - Celebrating Mother's Day with a taste of Chicago! - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

Some of the best pizza I've had!! We got the personal pizza for $5. Our waiter was also really nice. Super solid place that's nice & homey too. read more

The name of their web site says all you need to know, "best Florida pizza." True to its Chicago pizza roots, Pusateri's imports its ingredients from the windy city. The sauce is Chicago pizza sauce sweet and the sausage is real Chicago-style sausage. The only disconnect is given its Chicago connection, no deep dish pizza is served. The service is great and owner Pam is an absolute joy. She chats with the guests, serves tables and creates an atmosphere that makes you feel at home. This place is very casual and the seating is limited. If you go on a Friday or Saturday night, expect a well worth it wait. All in all, the best pizza in the state. If someone tries to tell you otherwise, they're probably from New York and don't know what great pizza is ; ) read more

Eating Pusateri's Pizza makes me want to move to Stuart, just so I can be close by. They have the best pizza I've ever eaten, few pizza places can even come close. I discovered this place while on a Dj gig, now every time I'm up here for work it's a new tradition of mine to stop in and eat a classic sausage pie all to myself. If you're a connoisseur of great pizza and you haven't tried Pusateri's, then you truly haven't lived. And if you are one of the few lucky people who have stumbled upon this pizza gold mine than make sure you share the wealth with everyone you know! read more

Pusateri's Chicago Pizza - Classic sausage pie - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE DO NOT leave without eating the Chicago pizza, you'll regret it. The sausage alone is too die for. Best pizza in town !!! read more

The BEST pizza ever! My favorite right now is the BBQ chicken. Amazing flavor! I recommend to everyone.

Great both times we visited. Once for dine-in on patio and once for carry-out. Amazing pizza. Crust makes it special. Fresh, generous toppings and wide variety on menu. Everyone found something they liked. Service fast, efficient & friendly. Great local restaurant! read more

Pizza was good, however I would not recommend their cannoli's, which were small and lacking flavor and substance. Dining room is very small so if you want to eat in it's very close quarters. Staff was very courteous and friendly. read more

Met a client here at his recommendation for a business lunch. Ordered the "thin Crust deep dish Chicago style" pizza, which sounds like a bunch of words that really don't go together, but they did, and the pie was great. Not as thick as your traditional Chicago pie, but pretty thick for what you normally get on a "thin crust" anywhere else, but the big deal is that the crust is still crispy. Great sausage on the toppings, too. Friendly service, local atmosphere -- we sat out back on their deck -- and totally reasonable for as much as we got. Looking forward to my next chance to try another flavor. read more

Excellent service and food! Pusateri's is our "go to" for thin crust sausage pizza, it is delicious! Staff is always very pleasant when we've gone. read more

The BEST Chicago dogs and hot beef sandwiches in the area! And the service is always fast and friendly.

When I hear Chicago Style I envision thick crust,stuffed with toppings and options of sauce on top or bottom this is how they serve it in Chi town! This pizza is more of a thin crust New York type pizza. For some reason this happens a lot here in Fl.! If you want a true Chicago pizza you will have to drive to Hollywood Fl. to Capone's Flicker Light on Ocean its worth the drive and you will not be disappointed!!! Now on to the Italian sausage. As an Italian I feel qualified to review this, (absolutely awful)!!! It was not a sausage but ground sausage flattened into a patty, really, I can't imagine that these owners are Italian! If my mother ever served this to my Italian farther it would have been in the trash, which is where my went!!! read more