If you've ever made the chef boyardee pizza in a box from the grocery store...then you've made better pizza.

Wish I could give a zero. Cardboard tasteless crust. Tastes like sauce from a dollar tree. We almost threw up! Don't eat here!!!!

Well my experience was not good, dough tasted like card board, about the worst pizza I've had in South Florida. In addition it was also expensive.. Maybe pizza is different in Chicago., than in New England , Philadelphia, Jersey, just saying! read more

I've only ordered pizza from here and it's very good; Chicago style pizza. The ingredients for the pizza I've ordered seem fresh. Convenient location; right near downtown Stuart. Outdoor seating in the back is a plus if it's a nice day. People are nice and service is good. I would recommend if you like thin crust pizza! read more

Finally had a chance to try Pusateri's. Had a craving for meatball subs and my husband tried the Hot Roast Beef sandwich . It's not to often my husband says "this is delicious " the whole time he was eating , then on the way home .. We will definitely will be returning to try the pizza . Not only was the food amazing , the staff was so kind . The outside dinning was available closed inside due to covid . Appreciate the effort. read more

Best pizza in downtown Stuart by far!! Has a sweet red sauce and amazing knots. We visit quite a bit but am never disappointed 10/10 would recommend. read more

We were on a lazy, aimless, Sunday Drive and wanted a small mom and pop pizza place and looked for places near us. Pusateri's came up, so we wound through downtown and found this tiny hole in the wall, squeezed in between a few other shops. We went in and looked over the menu and decided upon their super cheese thin Chicago pizza. Wow. I mean, WOW! W-O-W! The perfect crust; the perfect cheese; the perfect sauce. I took one look at my daughter and said, "shoot; now look how far we have to drive for pizza!" It was that good - and, despite the 50 mile drive - 100 mi RT, we'll be back! read more

Things have changed at Pusateri's Pizza. The hot dogs are the same but the pizza is not as good as it once was. It's still better than most but not up to the usual standard. read more

It is so true. This pizza is fabulous! The joint is family owned and run. You will not be dissatisfied. However, be aware that this is Chicago thin pizza from the burroughs, not deep dish or stuffed. If you are planning a trip to Stuart, Fl eating here is a must! read more

The best place to get your Chicago fix in south Florida. Staff is as friendly as a local Midwest town. A nice getaway from the New Yorkers invading se fl. Wish they were open 24/7! read more

Went for the Italian Needs, not as big as you get downtown Chicago, but just as tasty. While there realized they half half baked Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza to go. Crust nice and buttery, sauce very tasty, so nice to find this in south Florida. Highly recommended for those craving the windy city, I for one will be back. read more

Pizza was awesome.if you are from Chicago it is extremely similar to Aurelios. The other Chicago fare will be reviewed in the next couple of days. .very small place fun to be at.very good service. read more

This place is simply THE BEST pizza in Stuart. It is cozy friendly and delicious. Nothing fancy just great thin crust Chicago style pie. Excellent!! read more

Friends wanted to go, I didn't...it was terrible! The pizza toppings were good so I ate that. The crust is awful. It could have been cooked a bit more but even still it was terrible. I have been there a handful of times didn't like then, don't like it now....going back to Carmela's where the pizza tastes like...pizza! read more

I've been in SoFla for 11 years and I've stayed away from pizza because, let's face it, if you're from Chicago the pizza down here is terrible UNTIL 2 weeks ago when I was CRAVING pizza, so I Googled 'chicago style pizza and south florida", Pusateri's popped up, we drove an hour to get there and it was THE BEST!! Great sausage, great sauce, perfect crust, also ordered the Italian Beef on Gonella bread and YUM!! If I lived closer I would be there at least once a week!! Again, if you're from Chicago like me this is the ONLY place in South Florida for pizza! read more

We had a taste for pizza today so we schlepped all the way up to Stuart just for Pusateri's. As always the pizza was awesome (sausage and extra cheese)! It's as close to the real thing as you're going to get down here. Pam was very nice and we'll be seeing her in two weeks for our party order. Yum! read more

Wow! That pizza is amazing. Can't wait to come back to Stuart next year and have it twice again. Sauce, cheese and crust are perfect. Give it a try you won't be disappointed. read more

If you are looking for the best pizza in Florida, then you need to get yourself to Stuart. This hidden gem, hidden the fact that I live in Palm Beach Gardens and am not a Stuart local, is the best pizza I've had since I moved to Florida. This isn't your typical Domino's or Pizza Hut pizza. It is also not or try to be a NY Style pizza. This is Chicago style thin pizza. I only knew Chicago to be Deep dish and have enjoyed that style in Chicago, but this is my new favorite pizza. This pizza has a pastry like crust, that make this pizza so delicious. This pizza reminds me of a pizza from Ledo's Pizza in Maryland. The Ingredients are fresh and the amount of sauce is perfectly balanced so that the crust isn't too soggy and you can still make out the taste of the ingredients and crust. The staff is great and are always very attentive, even when they are slammed. The place is not very big so if you want to grab a seat at lunch, try and beat the rush plus they also offer outdoor patio seating. I come up this way for work and am always happy with my meal and the price. If you are in the mood for pizza, you won't be disappointed here. I've tried so many places, small and large, franchise and locally owned and this one is the best in my opinion. West Palm through Vero, this is the place to grab yourself a pizza. read more

Pusateri's Chicago Pizza - Here's what's left of my Small Pepperoni Sausage. Wasn't going to write a review but felt others should know of this place. - Pizza Near Me - Stuart, Florida

I had concluded that there were no good pizza places around until I found Pusateri's several years ago. The crust is thin and and not at all greasy. The sauce and cheese are very tasty and the toppings are fresh. The owner and servers are always pleasant as well. If you like thin crust Pusateri's is hands down the best around! read more

What else can I say other than True Chicago style thin crust pizza, well that's what brought us in and boy do they do it right! They have Italian beef that was good too, not slap your mom good but good enough to keep five stars lol! What really made this place great was the service tied in with the great food. Very friendly and making us feel as if we were sitting in their kitchen not their restaurant. Talked about the cubs, bears and other things Chicago!! Will definitely be coming back when in town! read more

The pizza is great, that's all we get when we go there. Not the friendliest place I've ever been, but it's the pizza we're after in the long run. Maybe we're just going when they're too busy to be smiley. It's a small place inside with a nice patio on the back (overlooks a parking lot). It's all about the pizza here. I do wish they allowed dogs on the patio though....we'd probably stop more often. OH, and if you're looking for deep dish, they don't make it here...you can buy certain ones and bring them home to cook. They're CLOSED on Monday and Tuesdays! Weird. read more

Best pizza I've found in Stuart. The sausage pizza is delicious as well as the JP- just mushroom and spinach. Even the regular cheese is to die for. I've had the Chicken Alfredo dinner which is also delicious. They get busy but well worth the wait and never disappoint. read more

The best pizza on the Treasure Coast! Coming from someone who enjoys NY style pizza, this place got us in love with Chicago style pies! You will not be disappointed in the pizza (their sauce is amazing), and the fresh garlic bread with cheese is a must. The staff is excellent and friendly, they go out of their way to welcome and accommodate customers. Kendra, Jaime & Luke are wonderful! Go eat at Pusateri's, period! read more

My favorite pizza place. Authentic Chicago pizza. They have a great outside seating area. We enjoy the environment. It's nice to find a pizza place that has a nice craft beer selection. read more

If you aren't from Chicago, you are going to love this place.....more like Pusateri's thin Detroit pizza or something other then, Chicago. First off thin crust?????? You mean New York with some sugar.#CORNMEAL missing. I was looking all over the place for a good Chicago place, the looking goes on. I also got and itailan Roast beef, or just Roast Beef because I barely tasted fennel in it, just boiled blood. I think the dude is either been to far removed or is really from Naperville Ill and says he's from Chicago.....either way just do us a fave and call it Pizza place. read more

What a nice little place, excellent food, service majestic, love it. Convenient parking in the back.

Was there twice this week. My wife loves their super thin crust. Sausage is the BEST I've had on any pizza. We do take out but small seating inside is cozy. Patio seating out back. read more

Pusateri's is an absolutely amazing pizza. We are visiting from Canada and had yet to find an American pizza that was worth eating. This pizza is slightly expensive but I personally guarantee it will be one of the best pizzas you have ever tried if not the best. I just couldn't stop saying WOW the whole time while I was enjoying my 16" pizza: ) So so happy we discovered this place just : ( we live so far away. The pizza we enjoyed was called the John Hancock. It had sausage pepperoni and roasted vegetables that were so delicious. read more

Husband and I stumbled into this place drawn in by the gluten free crust option seen advertised while walking by. Those with gluten sensitivities know locating pizza, GOOD pizza, can be challenging. This place rocked it! Very yummy! We were completely satisfied and the staff were welcoming and pleasant. If we ever return to Stuart, def coming here again!! read more

Amazing thin crust Chicago style . My daughter and I started with the fried mushrooms . Reminded me of when I worked at a hot dog stand in Chicago as a kid . We then had a sausage and green olive pizza . You can't find the crumbled sausage like they have . Also , green olives are great on pizza , but no other non Chicago places have it . Will try the dogs and beef next time ! read more

The best pizza in town! The service is always great and the pizza is always wonderful. Everything here is consistent so you know when you're hungry for the perfect Chicago thin crust pizza -- it's going to be right! I'm looking forward to the extended hours now that season is here. read more

Best pizza ever! I loved the thin crust and the sauce was so yummy. A little more on the "sweet" side, which is how I like it. Definitely get the sausage. Yum!! Will be back here to eat the next time we drive through Stuart. read more

Our son and fiancé have wanted us to try this place, coming from New Jersey it's hard to live up to what we're used to and living in Stuart we have been disappointed many times but not Friday night. We ordered two pies one medium with pepperoni and one large with vegetables substituted black olives instead green peppers both pies were excellent and cooked to perfection. Waitress was very accommodating and polite. Certainly understand why our family has chosen this as their favorite pizza restaurant. I know my husband and I will be returning. read more

The best pizza in the Treasure Coast! Dany was my server and was fantastic. Coming here is a treat.

Awesome pizza!! Best Around. Tried it today for the first time, I had delivery and the pie was a little cool but that is really my fault, I am way on the edge of their delivery range. Put slices in micro for 10 seconds... Delicious!!! read more

Honestly this is the best pizza I think I've had. And I lived in Chicago for several years. I'm not sure if it's the crust or the sauce or a combo but it's amazing. This place is a little hole in the wall...but the food is great. I even eat gluten free pizza and it's still amazing which is saying a lot if you eat gluten free!! Definitely stop in and get a pizza. read more

Real pizza not dough and ketchup like all the other places.love the hot dogs and beef too. Chi town is as good as it gets ! Glad we have this pizza place here. read more

Amazing food, staff, and atmosphere! My girlfriend and I went here a few days ago and we loved it the moment we stepped through the door! There are Chicago pictures everywhere and the smell of the food fills up the whole place. We got the gim'me garlic bread with cheese and the signature sausage pizza. Both were very very very delicious. We will definitely be going back soon! read more

This is hands down the best pizza in Stuart. However, it's also the most expensive. I would say it is definitely worth the price if you want quality pizza. read more

Had a great pizza and true Chicago Style Hot Dog! Nice area at the rear of the restaurant to sit out side. Would recommend it to anyone looking for good food and great service. Will return when we are in the area. read more