Behind and underneath one of the buildings in the center of the village, The Cottage is small,…read moreunassuming breakfast and lunch restaurant. The food is invariably served hot, fast and more importantly, reliably. I order the same thing every time and it tastes the same every time. More importantly still, it's served by a friendly, attentive staff. When time comes to cash out, you'll be surprised by the bill; breakfast for the two of us is less than 20 bucks! Including tip! It has become our go-to, and I'm planning to go eat right now.

I was in the area last Friday and my sister suggested trying this place. It actually was difficult…read moreto find because I was looking for a entrance on the Main Street at the 4 corners in Baldwinsville and I couldn't see it. We then called and they said it was next to the appliance store Sheeans so I went in at the bville diner and went in the back and saw the back entrance. Upon entering it was like going back in time ( like the 60's). We sat at a booth and waitress came right over. The special was a fish sandwich with one side for 7.25!!! We both got that and I couldn't believe the size of the sandwich for that price. Actually all the food items are very reasonable. Many regulars were eating lunch because the waitress knew them by first name. The fish was excellent and the side coleslaw was also. This is not a fancy place but the food is good and service also.

4.5 rounding up to 5…read more My husband has family around these parts and we recently were taken to dinner here on our last visit. It tends to be a popular spot, as evidenced by the parking lots on each side of the gravel road. Fortunately, it wasn't too crowded on the Wednesday night that we arrived. It looked deceptively smaller on the outside to me. As we came in, we went up a few stairs and there was an extension we decided to sit at so that we would be able to have a little more space and less volume for privacy so we could catch up. It was pretty dark compared to the other area, which I prefer. Once we were seated, we were provided with menus and glasses of ice water. Our server was better than excellent. She gave an overview of the menu choices, which included burgers, wings, entrees, and a fantastic choice of appetizers. Our relatives went with a warm pretzel, which came out hung on a stand with 2 kinds of dip, beer cheese and I think a plain cheese, and mustard. We had a mixed appetizer dish which included chicken tenders and onion rings (I forget the other items, so much food.) These were typical pub fare, with 3 different dips you choose from idk how many total. Speaking of sauces to choose from, there must have been 30 or more on the list for wings and anything else you want it with. You'll notice that the prices are very odd, like $17.12 or $13.16. I regret not asking what the story is with that. Most of us went with burgers, which were 1/2 pound patties on beautiful, soft, shiny buns. I had the bourbon burger, which had a delicious sauce, crispy onions, bacon, cheese, tomato, lettuce and onion. I could not finish this thing. I love that NY state lets you have your burger cooked to your choice of doneness, so I was extra happy to enjoy mine medium rare. I got my usual fries for my side, which were par the course if too salty for me. My daughter built her own burger as an option, which she also loved but couldn't finish. My husband's wings were enormous, as was the order of mac and cheese our cousin had. Our server was practically telepathic as she anticipated when we needed refills or other incidental. I love that this place lets you buy the staff a pitcher of beer to show appreciation. Idk when they drink it or how they share, but it's a great gesture. My guess is it's when they close and before they go home. It's the kind of place you can sit around and enjoy for hours while watching sports on the television screens all around, or have a game and your drinks. Solid spot for a casual pub style meal. Would definitely be going regularly if I lived there.

Excellent food and service. It's not close to home but I definitely want to return. Great vibe.read more

Food and drinks were decent, but definitely NOT worth $80 for 2 beers and 2 burgers. We wanted to…read moresub fries as the side for our burgers and got charged the actual "side" price of fries ($6 each). So they charged us $12.48 to sub for a side of fries for two burgers. That seems like a bit much! Safe to say we will not be returning which is unfortunate because it had potential. Their prices are outrageous for average food and drinks.

Terrible, stale tap beer, watched the "cook" dig thru a garbage can with his bare hands, all the…read morecondiments are on a public table crusted over and disgusting. Walked out, but still tipped the bartender backseat not thier fault. If you're looking for bad food and bad atmosphere this is your shithole. So disappointing.

Loved the atmosphere and friendly staff , stopped in on a road trip and saw the reviews for the…read moreIrish Breakfast , it was amazing , I am happy I stopped in !!

My wife and I had an early Valentine's Day dinner, or late lunch depending on how you look at it…read more The place was already full on a Saturday afternoon in the bar area, but we had our table waiting for us in the dining room. The host was friendly, our server was upbeat and attentive, and the owner came by to chat late in the meal. A truly welcoming experience. We started off with two Black & Tans (Guinness and Harp) and an order of the Irish Fritters and mini potato pancakes. Generous enough portions of both, that we set aside half to take home for the next day. Our entrees were the Irish Meatloaf dinner and the baked haddock dinner. Both arrived perfectly timed and perfectly cooked. Again, we couldn't quite finish them, so we boxed up the remainder for Sunday. For dessert, we opted to drink ours. We ordered a strawberry Martini and a whiskey cocktail named after the title of Ireland's Prime Minister. All in all, it was 2 hours from start to finish, the bill was $110, to which I added a 25% tip. If you're looking for a real taste of Ireland, look no further than Kitty Hoynes.

Some reviewers referred to it as a dive, but it's definitely a step above it. I only had cheese…read morecurds but it does have a full menu. They also have a wide selection of drafts, but it's 95% local/big names, not really my game. For drinks, I had a draft ($5) and a nice/strong jack/coke ($8). They do charge a bit extra if you pay with a card. Don't be afraid of the $10 parking charge sign for parking outside, no need to pay for parking if you are coming to the bar.

I met my friend on a late Sunday afternoon. The bar area was busy with families from events, and…read moresome young children. I was able to scoot into a corner of bar seats waiting on my friend. A short wait for menus and to scour drink menu. I went with pomegranate cosmo, unfortunately it lacked presentation due to shortage of appropriate glassware. Server was apologetic, taste was pleasant but strong and lacking garnish. My friend just ordered a light draft and we ordered Reuben egg rolls to share. Best Reuben egg rolls I have had in the Cuse! Tons of tender corned beef, and just a hint of sauerkraut and Swiss served with thousands island dressing! I ordered an extra for take out for my Irish man at home and short rib tacos. Those did not keep well for take out, more meat and toppings would improve the continuity compared to tortillas. Service excellent, frequently checked upon for refills and food order. Prompt delivery and friendly service! Great place for meetups with a pub sports bar atmosphere. I'm not sure I noticed remanence of the prior press room. Many televisions great for sport events. Menu is simple and pub oriented.

We attended a wedding here. The outside portion of the venue is stunning and a great place for…read moreguests to hangout. The food was amazing and the portions were huge. The servers were great and very tentative. One of the bar tenders was great, super friendly... one not so much...but that's okay because we still had an amazing time!

If you and your partner work full-time, and you are hoping to have a small wedding, this venue…read moremight not be for you. Each appointment we had with Rochelle was conflicted, except our first meeting. We only met with her three times. When I say conflicted, second meeting, a pair waiting for a funeral meeting was left waiting in the corner when we were there (conflict of appointments on their end). (Sad and awkward). Another time, another couple was left waiting. It felt rushed, and it definitely felt like we were customers being funneled through. The rehearsal was incredibly difficult for us to schedule. Traditions is ALWAYS booked. And, if you are hoping to have a rehearsal that proceeds your wedding day and is celebrated that night with a dinner, this place is not for you...unless you have a big wedding and are paying more.... On the night of our rehearsal, Rochelle scheduled a big wedding that was to take place the next day on top of our rehearsal. She first tried to say it was our error. I asked her and my husband to pause and really think how this mistake took place. Rochelle finally took ownership for overbooking...but the rehearsal began 40 minutes after scheduled, while the bigger wedding with some young folks were celebrating and taking pictures to the side (Good luck to the happy couple!--no shade, much love, it wasn't their fault). It did make me feel like, though, because our wedding was small and perhaps not bringing in as much as theirs, that they were more of a priority. And the dishonesty to blame my husband for her scheduling error, another scheduling error, was disgusting. Last, my husband and I both work very demanding full-time jobs. Rochelle was honest in saying that she is not a wedding decorator. Two days prior to the wedding though, we were displeased by her lack of organization and asking for us things like, the literal numbers that go on the tables and a sign that says where each person is seated. We thought this has to do with pragmatics, not decor, and the last minute request, we would have happily done it sooner, but we just laughed about it at this point. The food was lovely and on time. Do not ask to bring home left over cake or cupcakes that you brought in, unless you want to have a conversation about it. My husband and I work in the service industry. We recommend this place as a kind of airbnb, they provide food and drink, and an AMAZING SETTING. As for the rest, you need to be 100% on top of your game with planning, you will not get any help at all in this area. We were promised a timeline, for instance, to help us be aware, but it never was given. The prices were great, so if you approach it that way, you'll be good.

Nice warm evening to head up to Tipperary Hill enjoying some of the fun and festivities and grab a…read morebite to eat at the authentic Coleman's pub. After a evening of shopping, it was time to wind down so considering the options we chose Coleman's. Place was packed as always. The band was setting up to start to play in an hour. We got a table out back. Hankering for a shepherds pie that is one of the premier meals here. But before that we got ourselves, some spinach and artichoke dip. I haven't had this in what feels like decades. It was pretty darn good. Plenty of chips and plenty of dip. So much so, that I brought the leftovers home. So both of us did go with the shepherds pie. Both of us really enjoyed it. It came out, piping hot, with the mashed potatoes on top, covering up the beef, sauce, peas, onions, and whatever else they put in this thing! A drink to top off the evening.

Update: Just had a…read morebad experience so Im updating my review to reflect that. I think I left my credit card there yesterday during dinner. Called today at 4:30 and the girl that picked up said she needs to check with the bar but they are too busy. She wouldn't check and I was on hold for over 20 minutes. Thats how you treat customers? Im out of town and its at least a 30 min drive and she said "if you think you left it here then Im sure is here". What kind of answer is that? Dropping from 5 to 3 stars for the horrible customer service. I was in the area visiting friends and they took us to Coleman's for dinner and a concert. What a fun local spot! The food was great, everyone enjoyed their meal. I got the guinness beef stew which came out steaming hot in a bread bowl. I loved the gravy, if anything wish there was a little more meat but the flavor was delicious. The service great, our waitress was a nice young lady who was attentive and helpful. Afterwards we went outside for a concert and drinks. The band was playing older and newer covers until 10pm. Was a really fun end to our night, highly recommend.

Fancy this place is not but I have found some of the best food I have had has come from a dive…read morerestaurant/bar. This place is perfect for the Sport's enthusiast as there are TV's on every wall pretty much, for fans to catch their favorite teams playing. There is also, a separate room off the bar area for large gatherings. Our waiter was warm and friendly. He took our order promptly.... we waited and waited for our food to come out. Mind you we ordered two sandwiches and a bowl of soup. The soup came out and again we waited. Unfortunately, all we got to try was the soup as we had an event we had to get to as our sandwiches when asked were not prepared. Sometimes things happen when you run a business and it is how you handle them that is the difference between just a restaurant and a great restaurant. This restaurant would earn five stars on just how things were handled. Kudos go to the staff there.... The French Onion soup we had for me was not my cup of tea as it was over seasoned and had way too many croutons which between the seasoning and bread overpowered the soup. My partner in crime thought it tasted OK and proceeded to devour the soup so will leave that up to you to decide LOL !!!!

RECENTLY, the F-M Class of 1985 held their 40th H.S. reunion 9/5. All 88+ of US descended upon this…read moremost Iconic Fayetteville Staple of Our Community @ J.P. Mulligans. To say It was Great is an Understatement, to say They Accommodated this large group with Grace and Attention is an Understatement. Growing up, most of us, Multi generational in the Village, and HAVING THIS GATHERING PLACE we All Call Home- was beyond Accommodating, Inviting, and Welcoming. The Bartenders were OUTSTANDING, and all the attentiveness was Bar None! I can, without hesitation... SAY, from the F-M Class of '85. Thank You!