Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Rare Steakhouse

    3.9 (88 reviews)
    Open 6:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Order Rare Steakhouse Takeout or Delivery

    Rare Steakhouse Photos

    Business Info

    RARE STEAKHOUSE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Happy hour specials
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Rare Steakhouse

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Chicken strip basket with fries, ranch, fry sauce, and honey mustard

    Amazing steaks, elegant decor since they changed names/owners, friendly and helpful staff, and delicious dipping sauces! I will definitely be back whenever I'm in Star!

    Fries
    Amber G.

    A little far from us but a really good meal! We live about 45 minutes from Star so getting to Rare Steakhouse was a bit of a drive but it was so yummy! The funny thing is, we were actually on the other end of the street for dessert and decided we needed something savory for dinner (not just ice cream). So, we wandered on over to Rare Steakhouse. The atmosphere is somehow both very laid back and Idaho-upscale. If you know, you know. The staff was incredibly friendly and we were tucked into a corner where we could watch the Boise State game on TV. No major appetizers on this trip but I did ask for my clam chowder to come out first. And ya'll...this is the best clam chowder I've had in the area. I honestly was not expecting to like it as much as I did. Highly recommend! My husband and I shared the prime rib and it was also very tasty--and a good cut, too! Easily enough for both of us with a few yummy potato sides. The only reason for knocking it down a star... The water was kind of weird. Our waitress assured us it was triple-filtered but it had an off-putting taste to me. If we're ever in the area again, I'd honestly probably bring a water bottle. Nonetheless, the food was the star and that's the most important thing.

    Michele R.

    If I was rating this on our lunch experience alone then it might be 3 stars for the puts and takes among ambiance, service and food (both quality and price point). But in considering how important are these longtime "mom-n-pop" type, local owner restaurants to the communities they serve, in particular one like Star that has had a big gentrification influx of people from California into this tiny, conservative territory, modest living for long timers Idaho town, I'll lean to 4 stars because these owners have had a tough row to hoe and have managed to adapt as needed. It used to be a restaurant called Rustic Table and reviews were not in great shape. The owners changed the name to Rare Steakhouse and the menu to that format but also expanded hours to be open for B as well as L and D. They did this in about Summer 2024 and now a year in, it seems they have found their audience and footing. The add of breakfast in a town like this where those options are very limited was a brilliant idea. We live only about ten minutes away from Star and we'll head back to Rare for breakfast some Tday. But this is not the kind of place for lunch or dinner that would have us return for those meals. Different strokes for different diners. VIBE: In the way of tell me your politics without telling me your politics, you'll note the plethora of American flags outside and in general the Star community is one where red hat wearing voters are the great majority. Also when we mentioned that the French fries, while super crispy had an unusual yet somehow vaguely familiar flavor for us, our hardworking and sweet server proudly said they used only beef tallow for frying and "non of those bad seed oils". OK then. (I was a nutrition major for a while and the topic is still a passion, so in that context I notice the seed oil v tallow thing is a political hot topic right now with the information on it largely wrong in some circles that also think Tylenol contributes to autism. I'll leave it at that.) The place was packed when we arrived on a weekday at the tail end of lunch hour and it seemed an all locals crowd of all stripes and in ages ranging from babies to octogenarians. I loved that about eateries like this. I posted photos of the interior, not certain I could describe it accurately, but it is what a small town might find upscale. EATS: On this sort of traditional, and comforting in the way of familiar in a rapidly changing world, menu we chose a sandwich we had not had in a long time, Club, and said we would share it. We chose fries from the "...or" option and also ordered a side of the blue cheese slaw that we had heard good things about. We are glad we ordered all of them but none of them would be do again choices, in particular the slaw and the fries. We were happy they split the meal between two plates for us in the kitchen and there was a split charge added to the bill. That fee is fine with us, it causes kitchens more to split, but it was a surprise. MENU & PRICE POINTS: BREAKFAST runs $22 for things like steak (or ham or pork chop) and eggs, to $16 - $17'ish for things like omelets or stuffed French toast to $12 for avocado toast. There was a tent card on the table that listed specials for about $9 daily. LUNCH menu features things like sandwiches (club, French dip, hot turkey, Reuben, turkey with pesto and so on) for $15-$17'ish. Also several kinds of burgers $17+ and salads from $18 - $22'ish. In general this would be a difficult place for vegetarians but there are a couple of those options. DINNER is steakhouse focus with appetizers ranging from $12 - $18'ish, mains of steak and seafood from $25 - $51'ish but with one over $100 and pastas in the $25'ish +/- range. LIBATIONS: Full bar. VIBE & SERVICE: There were two servers on duty and they were both running full speed to try to take orders, serve food and bus tables. This is the kind of place where the busing tub was brought out to the table to load dishes into it. When we arrived some tables had dirty dishes remaining on them because there was not enough help to clean them off. When things slowed down, remember this was end lunch time, the servers were diligent in getting dishes into the bus tubs and back to the kitchen. I seem to remember there was music on the sound system but at a low enough level to be able to hear the conversation of the adjacent table as well as each other. Standard height tables and chairs throughout, so hooray for accessible for everyone, as well as high top seating in the bar area. ACCESSIBILITY: ADA parking in lot. Some tables throughout seem to be useable for diners in wheelchairs. I didn't check the loo. PARKING: They have a parking lot which is a good thing! A (DELICIOUSLY) GOOD NEIGHBOR: Sea Salt Creamery is just a few doors down in this strip mall. Small batch ice cream and in house baked treats in sparkling old time ice cream parlor setting.

    Orange creamsicle
    Judi B.

    I haven't been back to Rare Steakhouse since the name change and when they introduced breakfast, so I excitedly grabbed the opportunity to go when it became an option. I feel like I'm the only person not overly impressed with this place, so my review may be the exception, not the rule. Overall, the experience was wonderful...great ambience, service was attentive and the happy hour drink options are fantastic (the orange creamsicle is outstanding!). My issue was the food. I ordered the grilled chicken sandwich with fries. As you can see by my photo below, the chicken breast was split or two separate breasts were used in one sandwich, which made it difficult to eat. The chicken breasts were large and unfortunately overcooked. Since there were two large chunks of meat, one bite would send each one to one side or the other, making the sandwich a mess to eat. I almost felt like a cave woman trying to gnaw through the chunks whilst getting any other thing, like the cheese, lettuce, bread or avocado in the same bite. I ended up to using a knife and fork, making myself small bites with all the parts to the sandwich so I could appreciate more flavor than just overcooked chicken. The fries are fried in beef tallow (it's all the rage) and quite crispy. I really liked them.

    Ana S.

    I absolutely recommend dinning here the food was amazing. My waitress Katie and the staff were very welcoming and kind. The ambiance was very relaxing. 10/10. I will definitely be back.

    Giant pretzel!
    Katie G.

    If I could leave this place 10 stars I would!! My husband Drew and I just celebrated our wedding anniversary here and our night was perfect. It was nice and cool inside and I love the calm vibe inside. The food was amazing and so fresh! We started with the giant pretzel & beets. Drew had the ribeye (I had a bite, YUM) and I had the salmon. Everything was SO good. Now... the star of the show, TRAVIS!!! This young man is a reason in itself to go back. He's so kind, his service is top notch and he works really hard. A++++++++ for him! He made our night! At the end, we even got a card signed by the staff wishing us a Happy Anniversary. What a special evening. Thank you so much Rare Steakhouse. We can't wait to come back.

    Classic burger
    Sara G.

    Very very cute place! Still looks the same as when the previous owners had it for the most part but with subtle changes. Burgers were very good! French fries and sweet potato fries are gluten free and they do offer gluten free buns! They also have 1 gluten free pasta option. The open faced turkey sandwich was amazing! The ravioli was ok, a little under seasoned for our taste, but not bad at all! We were offered drinks really quickly. Food took a bit longer to come out than we would have preferred for a slow Sunday early evening. Waiter was awesome, great at keeping drinks full! Will definitely be back! Want to try the hot rock!

    Grilled turkey pesto sandwich
    Sunny A.

    After hearing great things about this place from others, we Just visited Rare for our first time & were not disappointed! We were greeted & seated promptly by a friendly employee and soon met our server, Katie. She was fabulous overall, very positive & attentive to our needs. Hubby ordered the "Local Salad" and Calamari and I got the Turkey Pesto grilled sandwich with fries. Everything was delicious! Their fries are thinly sliced with skins on, served with fry sauce & are the best! Definitely recommend Rare!!

    Ahi Nachos

    See all

    2 years ago

    Stopped here for brunch with my son and had the BEST avocado toast and bloody mary I have ever had! Highly recommend!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Fantastic food, great wine pours, good prices, great service always, nice atmosphere.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Sundays Football Menu is great! Open 6:00-9:00... all you can eat wings . Lots of new TV's for football

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0
    Photo of J J.
    0
    6
    0

    2 years ago

    Food wasn't good, lacked taste and it was overpriced. I could make better sandwiches at home.

    Helpful 5
    Thanks 2
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Food was great, service was amazing. We got the Prime rib and shared it and it was more than enough food.

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 3

    Ask the Community - Rare Steakhouse

    You might also consider

    Star Country Cafe

    Star Country Cafe

    4.1(130 reviews)
    0.7 mi
    $$

    My husband and I made our way to Star today to run a couple errands. We were both starving so I…read moresuggested going to Star Country Cafe for Brunch. This joint has been on my to go list so today was the perfect day too try it out! It was about 1 when we made our way there and we were hoping that the breakfast/brunch rush had kind of slowed down. There was a table ahead of us. My husband and I decided to sit at the bar since therewere a couple spots open. We wanted to save the table for a family that needed more room. And we actually like sitting at the bar. We sat ourselves and kinda of waited for sone service. It was very busy still so it took a minute for someone to help us. No problem, my husband and I just chilled till someone got to us. We finally got coffee and juice started while we were looking over the menu. The gal that got my coffee was sweet. She got me fresh creamer and sweetner packets so I didn't have to use the communal packets. I appreciate how understanding she was about my requests and my want to protect my new kidney. The menu has a lot of options which was great! Everything sounded tasty since we were so hungry! My husband grabbed the 2 biscuits and gravy meal with 2 eggs. I got the Tomlet with some spinach added without the hashbrowns and toast. Our food came out fast and hot! It all looked so good. My omelet had hamburger, olives, onions, cheese, jalapenos and fresh spinach. It was just what I wanted! I added sour cream and salsa to that baby, it was so good! My husband's biscuits and gravy were massive! The best homemade biscuits and gravy we ever had came from a gas station in Athens, Ga. These biscuits and gravy were busy as good! They are the best we have had in town! The biscuits were fluffy and airy, not too dense. The gravy was savory and rich. I don't know what kind of sausage they used but it was really good! Sausage gravy is a 50/50 for us but this gravy was killer! Everything was so fantastic! We ate every bite of our food and didn't regret it one bit! I appreciate the small, hometown feel of this restaurant. Servers knowing their guests by their first names. The prices were reasonable. The coffee was hot and my cup was always filled. The food was killer good! Our service was great. This joint is a little further than our normal brunch joints but they are so worth the drive! I look foward to coming back and having another great meal! And having one of them massive cinnamon rolls will be a must as well!

    Classic funky little Cafe with a great breakfast menu, awesome service, and good prices. Have eaten…read morehere a number of times and the food has always been consistently good. We like the fact that they drop off the bill early, so when you're done there's no waiting around for your server to return like in a lot of places. The parking lot is almost always filled which shows how popular the place is.

    Photos
    Star Country Cafe - Inside is adorable

    Inside is adorable

    Star Country Cafe
    Star Country Cafe - Scrambled eggs with bacon, sausage, side of potatoes and pancakes

    See all

    Scrambled eggs with bacon, sausage, side of potatoes and pancakes

    Cattlemen's Cafe - Good food and great friendly service ... Makes you feel at home ...

    Cattlemen's Cafe

    4.6(56 reviews)
    10.0 mi
    $

    We dropped off my hubby's car to get his windows tinted in Caldwell and decided to grab breakfast…read morenearby. After a quick Yelp search, we found Cattlemen's Café--and what a fun find! The café was busy, but the service was friendly and the food arrived in generous portions. I ordered the half Belgian waffle with one egg, sausage, and bacon. Hubby went all in with an omelet, short stack, biscuits and gravy, plus a cinnamon roll to go! Everything was delicious, and we had plenty of leftovers. I even saved a few bites of breakfast meat for the fur babies to enjoy as a little treat when we got home. To our surprise, the café shares a building with a livestock auction, which is pretty freaking cool! We were secretly hoping to catch a live auction--or maybe spot Rip or Beth from Yellowstone--but apparently we came at the wrong time. We definitely plan to return when an auction is happening so we can get the full experience. Great food, friendly service (thanks to our server Nicole) , fun country atmosphere, and lots of quirky signs and cow-themed details to look at. We will definitely be back!

    Very cute little diner in the most unexpected location…read more Enjoyed the decor and souvenirs for sale. The service was great very fast! Food was delicious too. Very large portions Rated a 4 because the coffee was terrible. Didn't ask for a different drink or request a refund. For a breakfast place the coffee should be delightful.

    Photos
    Cattlemen's Cafe - Retail

    Retail

    Cattlemen's Cafe - Denver omelet (substituted sausage for ham), home fries

    Denver omelet (substituted sausage for ham), home fries

    Cattlemen's Cafe - Cute / funny decor every where:-)

    See all

    Cute / funny decor every where:-)

    Mr V's Family Restaurant - Chicken fried steak and eggs

    Mr V's Family Restaurant

    4.1(240 reviews)
    10.4 mi
    $$

    My husband and I , have driven past this hand fulls of times over the last 3 years! We finally this…read morepast Saturday afternoon went here because we were in the area for alittle bit....I tell ya 10/10!! The staff was so friendly, place is super unique and cute when you walk in you can go to the left in that door and it's tables and chairs only and then go to your right ...in the door and it's tables , chairs and booths! Same restaurant!! The service was so awesome the food and hot delicious!!! Great size portions. A favorite dish of my husband's is a corn beef hash....IT WAS A 10!! The meat was super tender...he just loved it! I had Idaho omelette with pancakes YUM!!! We now know we can share something! However, if you don't wanna share then bring your appetite lol. We are happy customers we will be back to try all kinds of other meals and there's amazing looking desserts. So if you're in the Caldwell area and looking for a great restaurant to go and try Mr V's Family Restaurant is where it's at! Mon-Fri.7-9pm / Sat-Sun 7-9pm Happy customers can't wait to go back and try other meals and there tasty looking desserts.....Oh did I mention they have whole made milkshake!!!!! Thank you again Mr. V for making our first visit awesome!!!

    I was excited to finally try Mr. V's Family Restaurant, especially after hearing about their famous…read morecinnamon rolls. When we arrived around 1:30 p.m., a young gentleman greeted us and let us know they close at 2:00 p.m. before seating us. Unfortunately, they had already sold out of the cinnamon rolls. There appear to be two dining rooms, so I'm not sure if only our side was closing or if the entire restaurant closes then. The food was good overall, but it wasn't seasoned much at all. I found their house seasoning blend on the table just as I was finishing my meal. I wish I'd noticed it sooner because I think it would have made a big difference. Our server was friendly and attentive, and our food came out quickly. The restaurant has a cozy, family-owned feel with lots of charming decorations, heartwarming quotes, and family photos throughout the dining room. One of my favorites was the sign that read, "I Love You Like Biscuits and Gravy." It was such a cute touch that perfectly fit the warm, cozy atmosphere. If I'm in the area again, I'll call ahead to see if they have cinnamon rolls before making the trip.

    Photos
    Mr V's Family Restaurant - Dining room

    Dining room

    Mr V's Family Restaurant - Pancakes

    Pancakes

    Mr V's Family Restaurant

    See all

    Moe Joe's Breakfast Eatery - Chilaquiles W/ orange mimosa  (Turkey sausage subbed the carnitas)

    Moe Joe's Breakfast Eatery

    4.5(1.1k reviews)
    9.2 mi
    $$

    Moe Joe is always a great little spot for brunch! My best friend and I have been here before, and…read morewe're definitely creatures of habit because we usually order the same thing every time I get the French toast, eggs, bacon, toast, and coffee, and she pretty much gets the same. The food is always good, fresh, and satisfying, and it's a nice casual place to grab breakfast or brunch. The service is great ! My only complaint is the flies! There always seem to be quite a few flying around, and sometimes you feel like you have to fight them for your food. LOL! I really wish they could find a way to get that under control because it definitely takes away from the dining experience. Other than that, we enjoy coming here. Good food, good brunch spot, and clearly we like it because we keep coming back!

    Have you ever returned to a restaurant and think to yourself, "Why in the world have I not come…read moreback here sooner." That is the thought I had when we sat down at Moe Joe's. This place is phenomenal and seriously one of the best breakfast places in all of Idaho. I hesitate to say that because there can definitely be a wait because of its popularity, but facts are facts. My wife and I went to Moe Joe's for breakfast recently and man was it good. I ordered the chicken fried steak and was stunned at the amount of food. Where to start. The steak was incredibly tender and enormous. The homemade biscuit was flaky and perfectly baked. The sausage gravy was meaty and flavorful. And the crispy hashbrowns seemed to cover half the plate. Then there are the house-made jellies. Who does that and how can I get more! The service was prompt and friendly with a great wait staff that made everything easy. The vibe of the restaurant is "friendly neighborhood spot" and feels like home. I cannot recommend this restaurant enough. These folks know how to do breakfast right and I cannot wait to go back.

    Photos
    Moe Joe's Breakfast Eatery
    Moe Joe's Breakfast Eatery - Let's eat!

    Let's eat!

    Moe Joe's Breakfast Eatery - "The California Burrito Hash Bowl" - housemade fries (opted instead of Moe Joe taters)

    See all

    "The California Burrito Hash Bowl" - housemade fries (opted instead of Moe Joe taters)

    Tavern at Eagle Island - Bbq bacon cheeseburger

    Tavern at Eagle Island

    3.9(237 reviews)
    3.7 mi
    $$

    After my last visit (previously reviewed), I haven't been back. My husband wanted to take me…read moresomewhere "nicer" and took me to Tavern. I was a little apprehensive, which unfortunately, my apprehension was warranted. We arrived around 5:45pm on a Thursday night and were asked if we could wait for 20 minutes. We sat and waited...and waited...and 2 other couples came in and were offered bar or outside seating instead of waiting (seriously?!?! We weren't given those options). One took the outside seating, the other opted to wait as well. We watched at least 6+ parties leaving, but we continued to wait. After 35 minutes, we were finally seated....and there were several empty booths around us. It took almost 10 minutes before our server arrived, so we had our orders ready. Drinks came about 10 minutes after ordering. Dinner came out at 7:15 pm. We had no idea this experience would be this long. Food looked great, but after one bite into my Cajun chicken club, I was really disappointed. The chicken was stringy-dry (at least my jaw got a workout) and the buns were borderline burnt instead of toasted. All the other ingredients (bacon, lettuce, tomato, cheese) were fresh and thankfully, enabled me to eat most of the sandwich. We rarely saw our server and both me and my husband ran out of drinks (we even finished off both waters) before she showed up for a refill. We didn't leave there until almost 8pm. Server was very nice, but the pace was a tad too slow...to the point of being absent. Hubby enjoyed his Tavern burger.

    Update: Even before we actually moved to the Treasure Valley, we have been coming to The Tavern. We…read morehave been here now for nearly two years, and we came here today, Friday, for an early dinner. It was not crowded, and we were seated right away. For some reason, we were seated in a corner booth near the bathrooms, while other customers were seated elsewhere in the restaurant. We didn't mind, however, because it was nice and quiet. And, for me, convenient. My wife had the Sirloin Salad, and I had the Ahi Poke Salad. My wife said that her meat was cooked the way she likes it, and the rest of the ingredients were delicious. For me, the ahi, sesame vinaigrette dressing, wonton strips, onions, and greens were very good. The food is always good at The Tavern. And, the prices are reasonable. Unlike our past experiences, the service this time around was not up to our usual. Our server, Hannah C., seemed in a rush and impatient. Though she told us to ask her if we had questions, I didn't find her responses to be pleasant. The first dish my wife was interested in had Boursin cheese. My wife had not heard of it, and she cannot eat a lot of cheese. She preferred something milder, like mozarella. When she inquired of Hannah, the reply was terse. "We don't have mozarella." "Do you have another milder cheese?" "Like what?" Not in a nice way, and not professional, in my opinion. And, she was loud. We waited longer than usual for our food, and when Hannah brought it, she just dropped the plates and split. To her credit, she did check in on us once during our meal. Now I don't know what kind of day Hannah was having. Maybe not so good. I don't know what kind of person she is, and I'll give her the benefit of the doubt that she is a nice woman. Hopefully she is not like how she was with us to all of her customers. I'm a 20% tipper. For her, it was 18%. I wasn't given a choice, but I would have gone down to 15%.

    Photos
    Tavern at Eagle Island - Inside

    Inside

    Tavern at Eagle Island
    Tavern at Eagle Island

    See all

    Rare Steakhouse - diners - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...