I was driving down Forest Avenue at dinnertime, and I saw a big sign that said "Colombian food!" I love Colombian food, so I stopped. Parking can be tricky, I parked halfway down the side street in front of the city park. The place was clean and everybody was friendly. I liked the atmosphere of the restaurant. It kind of reminded me of a Cantina. Definitely a Latin vibe. The menu was on an iPad, and it was in Spanish, but just by knowing a few words and by the pictures, I knew what I wanted to order. I could've also used the Google translator on my phone, if I wanted to. I ordered the bandeja mixta. Grilled steak, grilled chicken, sausage, blood sausage, rice, beans and sofrito covered potatoes. The food came quickly, and it was delicious. Both the steak and the chicken were tender and had so much flavor. I loved the taste of the Sofrito covered potatoes. The potatoes were just the right texture, and the Sofrito was creamy and delicious. A little bit of the rice, I mixed in with the beans, And it made for a wonderful rice and beans dish. It was definitely a lot of food. I made it through the chicken, steak, the potatoes, and a little bit of rice and beans, and I was stuffed. I took the rest home for later, and it all reheated very well. The sausage was delicious, especially the blood sausage. Yes, it's an acquired taste but I absolutely love blood sausage. The flavor is deep and rich. For all that I got, especially since it was two meals, the price was very reasonable. I would stop back by the next time. I'm on the island. Thank you! read more

Rinconcito Paisa - That was an amazing meal! - Colombian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

It has been way too long since I've been here. Dinner was a combo of plantains, rice, and side salad, featuring a grilled pork loin. Everything was seasoned well and I can't rave enough about the plantains. Secretly, I wish I had ordered another side of plantains with guacamole l, but that's for another time. I came here with two other friends, we were in and out in about an hour. The service was quick and we found the staff members to be very nice! read more

Rinconcito Paisa - Grilled Pork - Colombian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Went in on a monday night with 9 people and they were able to accommodate us with a high chair as well. Service was prompt and the menus are literal ipad with option to translate to Spanish as well which is very cool. The table salsas were 10/10 and i got a bandeja, they are very generous with the portions and me and my group enjoyed everything! read more

Rinconcito Paisa - Colombian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I haven't seen the restaurant. I have noticed they were doing some renovations. I hope it matches the food because I have ordered from this restaurant several times and the food was delicious, fresh and cooked exactly as I requested. But that's just one person's opinion. read more

Friendly staff and the food is good. The ambience is ok. Tried it a few times and it's good.

Would give zero stars! The person who answers the phone was extremely rude and was constantly flirting and giggling with someone, while taking my order. Made me feel uncomfortable. Needs to be fired! 9/3/25 @ 9:30 p.m. read more

the food and service is amazing!this is a hidden gem! definitely deserves 5stars!!!!!!!!

The first two times I went I had the chicken and shrimp in garlic sauce and it was amazing with lots of delicious sauce. Yesterday I ordered the same thing and there was no garlic sauce read more

Good neighborhood Columbian food. Service is attentive. Not a fancy place. However. Clean. Good food. Good sangria. Been there twice already. My kids live close by. Would definitely come back again read more

Food was on point. Well seasoned and the sangria was good. We were a group of 7 and didn't have to wait long to get our food.

desde.nino. en mi pais guatemala. uno de los platillos.tipicos. lostamales.diferentes.carnes y sabores. pero los tamales.colombianos. son super buenos.y satisfactory. completo. los recomiendo. good job.parceritos. read more

Rinconcito Paisa - Colombian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Very delicious Colombian food. My first time trying them out and I sat in the restaurant. When trying a new Spanish Restaurant I usually opt for Rice and beans with grilled chicken. It was so good, I almost finished the plate and it was very good serving size. They are on Uber eats thankfully so I'll probably just order that way from now on but I def recommend giving them a try. read more

See all

I haven't had Colombian food in a while and thought to try out this local restaurant. Ordered online, yet it was a bit delayed when I arrived. The dish was good. The yuca and potatoes had a lot of flavor and stood out from the rest of the dish. Other parts of the dish were good, but it would be great with some seasoning. Overall, it was an interesting experience. I'll come back here to try out their baked goods. read more

Rinconcito Paisa - Grilled Steak with Creole Sauce Dish - Colombian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Feels like you're eating a home style meal. Authentic dishes, fresh ingredients, good portion, lots of flavor and affordable. Only reason I didn't give it a 5, was because the wait was longer than I expected. -Bake clams were juicy, garlicky, with a sprinkle of red onions and cilantro. -tostones loaded with fresh limey guacamole and a grill shrimp on top was my favorite. -cazuela de marisco a mix of shrimp, mussels, clams, calamari in a white carnation sauce, served with white rice, 2 tostones and green salad with Italian dressing. Delicious! -grilled chicken with grilled shrimp was very savory, served with a full yellow plantain (wasn't ripe enough) white rice and beans. A cultural gem on the island read more

See all

Great place . I don't eat there anymore. Busy . And a bit too much testosterone there . Looking at me , etc . But I had a coffee there a little while ago and was excellent . read more

I picked up and order for DoorDash from here and let me tell you the smell of the food inside made my stomach so hungry I was like ohhhhhh nooo I have to try this . Yes in deed did I drop the order off and sure as best I placed my order for pick up , my boyfriend got the "Bendeja mixta " nits under typical dishes . He enjoyed his meal ! Really filled him up . & I got chicharron I enjoyed this sooooo sooo much it's rare to find a goood assssss chicharron spot and honestly this my be my spot ! read more

See all

Horrible place, the chicharones are always oily and the meat in the bandeja has no flavor. Shame that it's the only Colombian place on Staten Island . The staff is unattentive and the owner doesn't speak English. Used to love coming here but it's gotten worse over the years read more

Depending on if you go there on a busy day you will get hot food. But if your catering g a party no good. Food came out not fully cooked. Very disappointed and this was for my birthday and for church event. read more

Meh I lived in the neighborhood for over 15 yrs I remember when this place opened I said I'll go in but never did. My husband was raving about how good this place is (3 yrs ago) so we ordered food for pick up (delivery was almost 2 hours to a location that was less than 4 blocks) .. anyways I ordered pork chops with rice and beans He ordered something called county fried And the sampler appetizer. The rice was very mushy The beans lacked flavor The pork chops looked like half of a pork chop (they give 2 but it equals 1) The sampler was suppose to come with a blood sausage instead they just gave us 2 sausages honestly that was the best part of the sampler. The salad that came with another meal that was ordered was the best part of the meal for me.. Honestly I wasn't a fan and probably willl continue to drive by this place . Authentic Spanish food is hard to do and this place misses the mark for me ... read more

See all

Unprofessional as fuck. They do not care about their to go orders or answering the phone. The way they leave the food out I could just take my order without paying. If yall are busy, at least ADRESS the person waiting and let them know that you will be with them soon. I'm writing this review as I'm standing here waiting for 10 MINUTES and workers are giving me eye contact but are not saying anything or asking me what I'm here for. They do not care and wonder why they hardly get tips. I've worked in restaurant industries and the workers they have in front of the house are unprofessional and need to be retrained because if this is the service I get for a quick pick up order is crazy and I would never want to sit down. read more

The good: very very clean and the morning pastry selection looks very good. Nice decor and very friendly staff at counter My opinion: disappointed that they don't make oatmeal. I had a pineapple pastry and it was more like bread (would have been good if I liked that kind of thing). The coffee was alright - but not as strong and Columbian as I expected. I would try again for lunch but may skip breakfast time... read more

See all

Lets bring out the obvious..Service as excellent this day. The server was always on top of things. I think he is part of the family owned and run restaurant. I had the bistec a caballo and it was super delicious. It came on a hard skillet with rice, yellow plantain and some sauce that was super good. it also included a side green salad with avocados Prices are super cheap and will def go again. The only reason it did not get a 5 star is because i ordered my steak medium and it came well done. its typical of spanish restaurants to overcook the meat. read more

Rinconcito Paisa - Bistec a caballo - Colombian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

This Columbian restaurant is a cute location in Staten Island! It's rare to find Spanish food on Staten Island! Staten Island is limited in choices but this is a good place! The service was good and the good was tasty too!! I really enjoy my fish, major salad and Sangria!! The Sangria could use a little more alcohol but it's ok! It's only lunch time!! I suggest making reservation because it gets pack and it's not that big!! Also street parking struggles!! It's located right across from Walgreens! read more

See all

It's the best Spanish food I've had so far on the island. It's a very friendly and family oriented clientele. We came on a Saturday evening, but were sat down right away. there were large families with small children, the adults looked like they were enjoying their time. Staff was super accommodating, our server was super friendly and hospitable. She started us with drinks, we ordered a pitcher of sangria which for two people maybe was a bit much lol but the sangria was smooth but after the 3 glass you def start to feel the buzz. Def get the sangria! Then we ordered the plantain chips with the avocado dip As entrees I ordered the paisano platter which comes with steak , rice, beans, fried potato, half a plantain, pork skin. Def recommend it all! I don't even eat beans but those beans were delicious. My husband ordered Steak with Criollo Sauce. Which came with steak, rice beans plátano, something fried that resembles a potato but we're not sure but it was delicious. Our daughter shared our food and it was def enough. She's two and enjoyed everything as well. On our way home she was singing and dancing so that's how you know she had a full belly haha. As I write this the next morning and force to eat my breakfast because we're still stuffed from last night. Oh and we order a pan dulce with caramel for the way home but ended up being eaten with our coffee this morning yumm. Came looking for pan de Bono but they had sold out. Next time ! read more

Rinconcito Paisa - Bistec con salsa de criollo - Colombian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Super disappointed . Meat was tough/chewy . No flavor . Empanadas were ok . Not much meat inside. One and done for me.

Must try the Country Platter. Bring your appetite, large portions. Friendly, attentive staff.

I was there 12/30/23 with my wife, 2 yr old daughter, and cousin. We ordered two bandeja paisas and one paella. We all got extremely sick from it. Horrible food poisoning the next day which is still lingering in our systems. My daughter was vomiting at 1-2 in the morning while we were sleeping. Thank god she didn't choke on her own vomit. She continuously vomited from 2-6 in the morning. We still haven't been able to eat normally since that day. Everything makes us sick. Bread is constantly stale and empanadas taste old. I went the next day to talk to the owner, she wasn't there, so I left a message with the manager. He said she will give me a call to talk to me. Never received a call back. Never eating there again. read more

I was impressed with the portions, but that ended there. The rice had no flavor or seasoning the beans tasted like they came out of a can, the chicken lacked any seasoning at all. The empanadas were under seasoned and looked like they may have been frozen. I gave them 2 stars for speedy delivery and portion size. read more

The service was 5 stars, nicest waitress and staff. I had no idea what to order but the waitress helped guide me. I started with the -Vegetable soup, it was tasty but once I added extra Cilantro and the house made hot sauce to kick it up, it was just awesome. Spicy, fresh and the vegetables still had texture which I prefer. It was the Tuesday special and I'll be back for this. -a Beef Empanada- not like most the corn was much more flavorful than traditional Mexican empanadas. I really liked this. Then we split the -Farmers Plate which was a piece of beef, fried pork, 2 kinds of fried plantains, rice and fried egg. We added a piece of Chorizo. This was ok I expected more flavor. I wouldn't reorder this. We got -Rice pudding to go. It was very thick and needed to be doctored up. All in all I will be back for -appetizers and soups. -the service -pretty inexpensive for the amount of food. read more

See all

This food has no flavor. The beans looks like it's just poured out of a can. The best thing on the menu is their guacamole. They used to be decent but unfortunately their food quality has gone down. read more

My SO has recently moved to SI. I need breakfast...not just any breakfast but a rice & beans/eggs/maduros breakfast. This will be our go to breakfast place. I ordered the huevos revueltos and the SO ordered the desayuno montañero. As soon as our plates came out..I exclaimed, "the eggs are perfect! No brown at all!!!" I can't eat eggs with any hint of brown in them. I asked for hot sauce for my scrambled eggs... didn't even need it. The eggs were perfectly scrambled. My arepa was crunchy on the edges and soft in the middle...delicious! SO shared his chorizo and chicharrón because I'm a carnivore...both were delummy. We will be back again and again. I literally want to hug the cook...that's how good my food was. read more

Rinconcito Paisa - Menu - Colombian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

If you're looking for good Spanish food in Staten Island, this is the place to be. Food: I like to order the Bandeja Paisa. I love their Bandeja Paisa. It's the right amount of food and it tastes delicious. Drinks: Full bar and great selection of natural juices. Last time I tried their Guanabana juice in water and it was one of the best I've had. Ambience: I was here on a weekend once and they had karaoke night which was very entertaining. I've also being here for lunch with the family and it definitely feels like a place to come with family and friends. Overall: Best Colombian restaurant in Staten Island, period. read more

Rinconcito Paisa - Colombian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

The staff is so rude here. The service is awful. Either you're ignored or it's just like slapped down like "here." No one checked in to ask how our food was or if we needed anything. The food was ok. But the sangria has no taste and the fruit in the sangria tastes old. I ordered a cappuccino and it was all milk. I told them and they brought me more coffee which was bitter. I tried to mix them together myself and it made a huge mess. They should have remade it. I should have asked for it to be taken off the bill. read more

I was very excited to see that finally there was a Colombian restaurant in Staten Island, I wouldn't have to travel to Queens for some authentic Colombian food. I've been there for breakfast and it did not disappoint, the recalentados are very delicious. However I went for dinner and from the very beginning I was not happy with the service the lady who sat us down had an attitude, I said whatever her problem not mine. We ordered the food, and honestly I don't understand how they are still open, they brought food out and shocking to see that the carne molida was still frozen LA CARNE ESTABA FRIZADA! Chunks of ice all over the meat, we sent it back and it seemed like they popped it in the microwave and brought it back out, because it was watery and still cold. The beans weren't even cooked flavorless, liked poured out of the can added, water and served it. I feel bad for the people eating at this place because they're not providing the service and food that actual Colombians would do and the authenticity is not there. I've never gone back and probably never will. It's very sad read more

The place is ok to go grab a fast bite but they always change their waitress all the time and the service some times is not so great. I usually order the picada but seems like it's an order full of yuca and potatoes because I can only count five pieces of chicken and meat that's it and the pieces are very small. I think they should improve on service and quality of food freshness especially with the empanadas de carne three times I received with horrible potatoes smell like if it was saved over night and reheated very bad. read more

Older gentleman running deliveries, cried when I asked for change when I handed a 20 for delivery so i can give him a tip, he thought i wasn't going to give him a tip. Delivery was also wrong and complete opposite of what I asked. Rude, will tell others and family members to avoid the place. read more

Rinconcito Paisa - Colombian Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

I struggled with this rating because the food itself was incredible!!!! Packed with so much flavor. I had empanadas de carne (beef) and they werent too bad. My friend had cheese ones and they were super greasy. Their tostones were amazing. She had fish, rice, and salad. I had beef stew and rice with beans. The food was honestly incredible. If you ask for water, they give you a bottle of water which costs 1.60. Cost overall- this place is really affordable, very cheap. Also, it is a very nice setting they decorated well. Why three stars than!? MY FRIEND FOR THE FIRST TIME IN HER LIFE GOT FOOD POISONING. She was throwing up among other things within an hour after we ate for the next 24 hours. She never gets sick off of food, so this was a shock. Even though they were empty the servers were pretty bad, slow is not the word. Although they were good I am weary of returning, she definitely would never return. read more

Walking into this restaurant, there are flags in the ceiling and some ethnic artwork on the walls. The bakery section of the restaurant displayed some nice traditional Columbian bread and buns. We came here last minute with 25 of my friends on Sunday afternoon and the staff was quite accommodating. They had another party of 20 as well but didn't seem frazzled with another large group. Many of my friends ordered the Bandeja Paisa which is a very popular traditional Columbian dish that everyone orders. A few of us also got the Carne a la Plancha con Camerones which was also quite good. Empanadas were massive and filling. All in all pretty good food and the service was even better. Considering the large group we had, everything came out fairly quickly. Mayra did a great job! read more

See all

Delicious Colombian food! This restaurant is the only one in the island & they have been very consistent with their food & delicious Breakfast and yummy authentic bread. read more

I used to work in Staten Island but I am now in NJ. I MISS THIS PLACE! The food is amazing and so is the service. Everyone is friendly and smilig all the time. Whether you eat in or take out you will not be disappointed. AND THEY DELIVER! So if you work ot live in the area and you want some yummy Columbian food at great prices this is the place to go. read more