Rosati's pizza? Yes! Rosati's salad? Respectfully, no. Recently hosted a party and ordered in a handful of 18" pizzas and salads in for everyone. Got the classic combo, windy city (love the hot giardiniera on that one), Hawaiian (yes pineapple belongs on pizza), the meat mania (dang that one is loaded), and the white pizza which has fresh garlic, tomato, and spinach. Honestly they were all tasty! Definitely a fan of the thin-crust options here. Oh and they're all square-cut which I feel like it worth mentioning because square v triangle is always a debate. Overall great for a big group! Chopped salads x3 were also in the order and just didn't go down well with anyone really. Very subpar, tons (and tons) of iceberg lettuce and not much topping. The sweet Italian was more oily than anything. As for ordering- it was seamless. Went online a few hours ahead to put it in / pre-pay for it, and it was great that we could select a pickup time. read more

We ordered Rosati's for delivery on Saturday night. The Fox Point location always has friendly customer service and the wait time for two pizzas was only 45 minutes. We ordered a sausage and mushroom pizza and a white pizza. Both were good, we like their thin crust. Only complaint is we asked for the pizzas to be well-done and they weren't. read more

Rosati's Pizza - 16" Pizza - Build Your Own Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fox Point, Wisconsin

See all

I'm trying to explore the pizza options closer to where I live, so we recently tried Rosati's. I ordered by phone for pickup. The person on the phone was friendly and confirmed my order: 16" thin crust with sausage, onion, and spinach. I also requested that they make it a little crispier - but not burned (obviously). The pizza tasted pretty good, but my partner and I were disappointed with the small amount of sauce, cheese, sausage, and spinach. I'm wondering if this is a trend with all pizza places when you order multiple toppings. I noticed this at other places too. Should I just be ordering one topping and then put on additional toppings at home? I was also expecting the pizza to be crispier as per our request. To me, it didn't look like they left it in the oven longer than a normal pizza. We had to heat it at home to get our desired crispiness. I'm trying to support small business as much as I can, but when I don't get what you want, it's really hard to justify not cooking at home. read more

I was in with a nasty cold and a friend came by with one of your pizza's and it was delicious!! I told many friends about how delicious it was!! read more

We ordered a make your own Chicago style pizza with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and black olives the other day, and went to pick it up. This location is just carry out, and you can pick up or get food delivered (there really isn't a place to sit. Good service. We brought the pizza home and it was good-good quality and taste. But, the sausage and mushrooms were sparse on the pizza! The pie is cut into large slices-we got the 14 inch-and you'd expect more than 1 or 2 pieces of sausage on each slice, but it was barely that. We were wondering-did they just forget to add the toppings? When you get a pizza and you're all standing around questioning what you ordered and what you got, well, then you know something's off. So despite the fact it tasted good, we felt that the ingredients we ordered were barely on the pizza. It's disappointing to order toppings on a pizza and have those toppings barely present! So, while that was a disappointment (we've ordered from Rosati's many times before), and will probably will do so again, next time we will have to ask about the quantity of ingredients. I'm torn on what rating to give. On taste I'd say 4. But given the topping issue, I'd have to say a 2-3, because it wasn't just one topping that was scarce, but both the mushrooms and sausage. So overall, I have to rate this lower putting all those factors together. I'd like to bump this up next time! read more

Rosati's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fox Point, Wisconsin

See all

It took well over an hour to have a pizza delivered from Rosatis's Fox Point. It was COLD. BAD

We've been ordering from Rosati's for 10+ years...through management changes, ownership changes, etc. Our pizza ordered Monday, a few days ago, was THE best pizza my husband & I have ever had! Delivery was prompt, courteous, friendly driver & --bonus-- our pizza arrived hot! Our veggie pizza w a few add-ons had extra sauce and the flavors were so fresh, so tasty on a thin crust! Rosati's you completely outdid yourselves! I hope each of our next many pizza orders are as fabulous tasting as Monday's pizza was!! Thanks! read more

Rosati's used to be my favorite but not anymore. Skimped on the toppings and i think the sauce has changed I'll keep looking for mu new favorite... read more

Date of visit: June 24, 2023 We have a standing pizza night with another family where we take turns trying a pizza from the hosting family's side of town. June was our turn and we decided to try Rosati's since we hadn't had it in quite some time. Online ordering was a breeze and thankfully the construction in the area didn't add too much time to my commute over there. Unfortunately the estimate for the order was not accurate as I had to wait for a good 15 minutes beyond the time I was advised to arrive for my order to be ready. Complicating matters was that the counter person did not speak much English and struggled to assist with order retrieval. I sat on the bench in the restaurant while observing two of the most annoying people on the face of the planet trying to pick up their order. Neither of them had called the order in, nor did they know whose name it was under or the phone number for the order in question. They tried "Colleen." Or "Dave." Or "Adi." None of these resulted in any matches and they then called whomever they believed placed the order to find out what name it was under and what the order consisted of. While none of this was the restaurant's fault, I mention it because had staff been better versed in the local language, they could have asked the cast from "Dumb and Dumber" to step aside while they figured out how placed the order so they could assist other customers in the line that was now out the door of the small waiting area. I did finally get my pizza and it was a mixed bag. The pizza itself was good, though it had a hint of some sort of spice in the sauce or cheese that I couldn't quite put my finger on. Some of us didn't mind it while others were not a fan. The cheesy bread was quite good and disappeared fast while the mozzarella sticks were awful, cold and lacking any flavor. Definitely could have made better ones at home in the air fryer for less. read more

I've ordered a thin crust pizza 3 times from the fox point location. I will not order again. Only thing good was the crust. They put one piece of Italian sausage per slice and some slices didn't have any at all. Same with the pepperoni. Pizza was dry if I had wanted a cheese pizza would have ordered that. Buyer beware read more

Rosati's Pizza is some of the best tasting pizza I've tried. I have eaten from this brand in 3 different states, 5 locations and the experience is consistent. Crispy crust on the thin pizza which I love, delicious sauce and flavorful pepperoni/sausage. I recommend everyone that loves pizza to Rosati's. read more

Used to be a great local place to order a quick yummy meal. It's going on an hour and a half since I ordered and paid online. I can't get through to a person when I call. I live close enough that I drove over. The woman working there was rude and unhelpful and just said "it's out for delivery." Never ordering from here again. read more

I have been saving my 50% off coupons from the side of the pizza boxes since I moved to Whitefish Bay. I have never gone to any other Rosati's. Last night I went in to use them and the cashier said they had to have red writing on them. She then called her boss and put him on speaker phone and he said he has owned the store for 2.5 years and they have only had red on them. I don't see how this matters..,. As the old coupons from the same exact location should be honored. I am very disappointed in this rule, and I will not be going back. Also there pizza is very try average anyways. read more

Ordered from the Fox Point location for the last time. Deliveries are always slow but this week it was almost 2 hours after we ordered, despite being told to expect it in an hour. When I tried to contact the business for status no one was answering the phone. Too bad, we liked the pizza but service is terrible and unreliable at best. read more

Ordered a 16 inch fab 4 pizza and a 14 inch double sausage pizza with a 10 % off coupon on my complete order. Received a 16 inch sausage pizza -no double sausage, and a 14 inch fab 4 pizza which were the reversed sizes. The cashier could not figure out how the coupon worked so I paid $47.21 which was the original cost for my original order without the coupon. I did not open the boxes to see that my order was correct. Was also told they only have thin or double dough crust. Rosati's has really gone down. read more

We pick up and/or get delivery. Always hot and fresh. We usually get thin crust and The salads are good too!

great food good service I don't know what you guys do now pizza is test so great keep up good work read more

Best in the city !!!...i order almost all the time I'm at work they should know me by now I'm the house in the dark they can't never find we some of them lol try them out tell a friend read more

Ordered online. The thin crust was light and cracker-like, the pepperoni and sausage flavorful and the balance of toppings on point. Will order from them again. read more

End of a long relationship with this local restaurant after a wait of 90 minutes, and a promise that the manager would call which never happened. Pizza not good enough to put up terrible delivery service.... read more

Still haven't received money back or a phone call for a delivery order I placed last week.

Pizza was good! Spicy sauce. Easy to grab as we were visiting nearby. Quiet area if it's nice outside would be good to eat outside after walking there read more

Besides the food being good, theirs not a lot to love. First, we were given someone else's food without food, sorry Tim. Their is no dining space, although their are some uncomfortable seats with tables outside. The food, as I said before, is good. The topings, however, fall off the crust, making it a mess. It's also more pricey, $8 for 6 small mozzarella sticks. read more

Had a few issues a few years ago, but have been getting beef sandwiches and pizza every week lately. Service has been great, food is excellent. The young woman delivery driver always smiles and is awesome, so tip her well. She deserves it. read more

Recently the Fox Point location has seen a change in ownership and they are struggling to deliver good food consistently. Meat portions have been skimpy and disappointing. They have forgotten to add the meat on 2 of my orders. Will they ever get it right?? read more

We ordered pasta and a salad tonight to be delivered by Grubhub. The pasta was good; however, we didn't get our salad.

We have been looking for "our" pizza place since moving to Wisconsin in June. We have found plenty that we like, but nothing that we loved until our babysitter recommended Rosati's. We have definitely found our spot! read more

This is my first and last food review. I have never had a wet deep dish pizza with the consistancy of a diaper until now, please for the love of all is good don't waste your money on this place. That is all. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fox Point, Wisconsin

See all

9 bucks for a BBQ sandwich that just had cold cuts in it with sauce. Too much sauce the roll just breaks apart to be eaten with a fork. Long wait time while I was the only customer there. Doesn't serve pizza by the slice. Handled my bills then went to work with food without washing hands. That's all. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Big portion, thick bun broke eitherway due to waaaayyy too much sauce. Proceed with a fork. - Pizza Near Me - Fox Point, Wisconsin

Solid thin crust pizza with the perfect balance of cheese and sauce. One thing to make it 5 stars would be to crisp up the crust in the middle read more

The last 2 pizzas I have purchased here just smelled so off when I put it in my car. The taste just isn't the same under the new owners who are trying so very hard to have a good business. We analyzed that it wasn't the sausage but maybe they changed the brand of cheese. It is now off of our list of pizzas to get. Darn! It was a favorite for years. read more

If give this place negative stars if I could. I called for a pizza pickup at 3:15. They said it would be ready in a half an hour. I showed up at 3:45 to pick it up. Ten people were waiting for their food and we were told the ovens hadn't even been turned on yet! Every time I order from there there's always rude kids running the place, I can barely understand them. The food always takes much longer than they estimate. I am done with this Rosati's. Lou Malnati's will now be our place to go for pizza. Ridiculous. read more

I'm committed to trying as many pizza's around Milwaukee as possible. I was skeptical of this place because it's a chain, though some of my friends living in the north shore like it. Rosati's is SOLID. We had the godfather, which comes with fresh garlic, sausage and giardineira. It was excellent. I do not recall which style crust we ordered, so I assume it was the standard one. This is my favorite type: thin, but not the super thin, cracker type crust. Try it. read more

This is our favorite pizza place since Pizzaman closed. We almost always order the Monster, and have it delivered. Delivery can take a while, so plan on a1 hour - 1 hour, 15 minutes before you have your food. They are only 6 miles away, so I sometimes wonder why it takes so long for delivery. They are usually delivering at the outside of the delivery window - you know, when you're looking at the phone to check the timestamp and wondering if you should call to check on your order. When I'm eating pizza, I'm not worried about being health conscious - so we usually splurge and get the garlic bread. It's good and greasy, but it doesn't heat up particularly well - so order just enough to eat with your pizza. The crust of choice in our house is their signature crust - the thin crust just doesn't hold up to all of the toppings. The pizzas do come loaded with toppings. If you haven't tried Rosati's, you should. It's expensive, but good. Also, there is a delivery charge. read more

The pizza was great, although it arrived quite burnt. This isn't usual for them though so I will order from them again. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fox Point, Wisconsin

Stopped in and met a friend for lunch today. It's a beautiful day so we took advantage of the outdoor seating. I ordered a small Caesar salad and one of their daily specials, the Penne & Grilled Chicken A LA Vodka. The food was delicious (and lots of it!) and the service was great. Will return! read more

The food itself is tasty, however this is the second time in a row that they have missed an ingredient on our pizza. The person taking the order even repeated it back to us, and upon pickup they weren't busy at all. read more

Came in with the family for a nice, filling dinner and we got exactly what we came for. Food was hearty and delicious, got family sized deep dish pizza and tasted right out of Chicago. Great service as well. We'll be back! read more

Most amazing food I've eaten in the last year. I spent 15 years in New York, trying all the pizza the city had to offer, and I can honestly say that none compare to what Rosatis has to offer. Not only is their pizza delicious, but they have amazing sandwich options. Compliments go to Willie, who crafted the most incredible Italian Beef Sandwich I've ever had in my life. read more

Hands down amazing pizza! The workers were so polite and engaging when I walked in! My mouth was watering as soon as the delicious smells from Rosati's crossed my path. Once I brought my pizza home I was thrilled at the beauty of it but even more impressed by all the flavors that tasted incredibly fresh! read more