So, my girlfriend and I took a lovely drive up to Point Reyes to be by the ocean and explore the…read moreiconic lighthouse. It was cold, but worth all the views! Afterwards, we've been pretty good about sticking to salads and healthy foods during the week, so we both looked at each other and said, "Pizza?" At first, she made the mistake of not packing post beach clothes, so she was like, don't choose somewhere fancy because I look homeless, lol.... I pulled up Yelp, of course, and started to search the surrounding areas as we drove home. Approaching Petaluma and finally having phone reception!!! I started to read reviews and .... honestly, it's hard to choose sometimes. Everyone has a different idea of crust, options, toppings, decor.... HOW TO CHOOSE..... I kept thinking about how their vibe is pizza and TAP.... so I thought, it can't be that fancy inside. We should be able to dine in, nom on some deliciousness and not be terribly noticed. I was right. Nice full parking lot. Situated right next to a Whole Foods (for parking reference!).... It's tiny inside, but they've made good use of a few low seated tables, high chair style, and so forth. There's multiple brews on tap, but we opted not to drink this time. The menu was the crowning glory. I want to start by mentioning a little factoid about myself... I feel like I am the 1 percent that doesn't like traditional style whole milk mozzarella. I can't stand it. Feels like gum in my mouth. Of course, any time I go out for pizza.... I seem like the weirdo that goes against the grain requesting ANY type of cheese other than trad. mozz.... ----- But here? They have 4 different mozzarella options. 4!!!!!!!!!! Fresh, Vegan, Traditional, and another. Are - You - Kidding - Me.... She ordered 12 wings over midtown; I ordered just the ponte de rialto with vegan pepperoni and chopped garlic. Delicious! 5 stars for excellent customer service 5 stars for food quality and taste 5 stars for the menu of options!! 5 stars for affordability (not too expensive to dine out) Oh, and make sure you try the half dome cookie dessert. 5 stars for that, as well!

About 2 dozen taps with local and craft brews. They serve some of the best Za in town. The crust…read moreis good and crispy on the outside yet soft and chewy on the inside. The red sauce is bright and tangy. The toppings are good quality and there is a wide selection of them. They only do 12" pizzas, but 1 pie is good enough to share for 2. The greek salad was delicious with fresh veggies and the shredded lettuce makes for a delicate dish. My kids devoured the garlic knots. Next time will need to order 2 baskets. Their wine selection has room for improvement, but they are known as a tap house so it's understandable. The service was attentive and the facilities were clean and modern. Shout out to Symphony our excellent server who made our first visit so excellent!

Had such a great happy hour here with friends! Our server Eddie was fantastic, super friendly, and…read moregave us great recommendations on what to order. Everything we tried was delicious. Service and food were both on point. We'll definitely be back!

My friend said "This was the best food I've EVER had in my life". Yes... the sea bass was pretty…read moreincredible. The wood fire pizza was fresh and made me happy. The caprese appetizer made me want to can cherry tomatoes. The tiramisu had the perfect density. And our server, Christina, was wonderfully friendly and attentive. There is no reason for not eating here! And the Santa Rosa location is also amazing!

Delicious pizza with quality ingredients. Conveniently they provide half and half if you can't…read moredecide which one to order. The crispy sourdough crust is excellent!

12" Pepperoni & sausage pizza and a salad for $45. The food…read morewas mediocre at best for the price. I love pizza but left half of that pie in the box uneaten.

Best pizza in Sonoma county imo, on par if not better than Acre (they both do things differently…read morethat make them great but Old Chicago is my go to every time). Never had a problem when ordering, the service is always top notch. The old look and feel of this place is especially great.

Our recent visit to Old Chicago Pizza in Petaluma. Its been on my list of must trys…read more Last Saturday was the day, its upstairs in a building, nice little restaurant. We were greeted and seated pretty quickly. The server got us drinks as soon as we sat down. It was quaint, and clean. Friendly atmosphere. We ordered a large Italian salad to share, and a large combination pizza. The salad was fresh and it was good. I love salad. Our pizza came pretty quickly and was delicious. The crust is thick. I knew it would be. I think I prefer a thin crust. Other than my preference the pizza was delicious from the stuffed crust to the delicious toppings and the sauce was perfect, not too much not too little. Thankyou so much for the awesome lunch and great service.

Owner is absolutely unhinged. Came in with family from out of state and the entire time we waited…read morehe complained about everything under the sun. Every hand written note in the shop or on windows is something negative and uninviting. You're right, Ralph. I must be remembering a different Fregene's where the owner didn't go on a 15 minute diatribe about his former business partner to the extent that half our party decided to wait in the car instead.

Great place to go to if you want quality food! We've gotten the daily special before ($3 slice +…read moredrink), but today we wanted to try a whole pizza. We got the Silsiccia and added bell peppers. Thin crust, flavorful sauce, right amount of cheese - overall quality ingredients. It was $30 for the large and it was definitely worth it! The owner even threw in some free brownies. The interior has a fun vibe to it and was very clean. We also noticed some freshly grown basil plants at the window! 10/10 experience - yummy quality food, kind owner, fun interior & so close to downtown. Will definitely be coming back! Note: payment options are only cash or Zelle.

We came here for our friends rehearsal dinner and everything was good! The service was on it, the…read moreparty sat down and not ten minutes later the food started coming in. We had everything from veggie pizzas to sweet and spicy wings and cookies. The crust on the pizza was a star on its own and the salad was nice and refreshing. They have a laid back vibe with plenty of seating and games. The staff is nice and didn't make faces when 72 extra wings were ordered, our apologies. Definitely would recommend.

Truly my favorite pizza in the north bay of CA. I will drive 40 min just to have that crust and…read moretoppings. Excellent service and fantastic flavor and consistent. Go!

This place seems to always be poppin with a line out the door. There are only a few seats inside…read morenear the windows where you can people watch or be watched by the incoming line while you enjoy a delicious assortment of pastries. I got the prosciutto, fig and jam puff pastry. So yummy and the crunch on the layers were definitely on point. I also grabbed me a chocolate chip cookie which is huge and probably the same size as my face. And of course my sweet tooth wouldn't let me walk away from the register without grabbing a brownie. Took my girlfriends here for some pregame breakfast bites before one of our tournaments and they loved everything they got. So many things to choose from, you'll probably leave with a box. But trust me when I say, I don't think you can wrong here. Clearly it's a popular go to spot you gotta come check them out early!

Cute little bakery and cafe in downtown Petaluma. This is a busy little shop so if you don't mind…read morethe wait, you'll be glad you stopped. They seem to be organized and keep the line moving quickly. Everyone who works there have been so friendly and kind but seemed a bit overwhelmed. Wide variety of options from pizza to breakfast pastries. I've never tried a sandwich but word is they are delicious, too. Limited seating but a great spot to try if you want a little treat to take on the go.

This place is sneakily one of the most best, most thoughtful food/wine programs in Petaluma. Their…read moreethos of "family owned" is present in everything they sell, from their well curated wine list, to their locally sourced ingredients. Insanely delicious pasta and pizza (highly suggest the Gnocchi) Service was great as well.

We popped into Hank's in Petaluma for a quick dinner on our…read moreway home from a trip to Pt. Reyes. Also to break up the lengthy car ride, which I don't do well with. We had their mushroom pizza which was quite good, I would order it again in a heartbeat. I also had their spicy margarita, which was tasty, and just the right amount of spice. Service was friendly and unrushed, which I appreciate, even though we were there at the tail end of dinner service. Nice spot, good for a casual dinner, yet nice enough for a date spot. Wasn't difficult to find parking nearby. Would return and recommend.

I've been to a few mountain mikes, but my personal favorite is on Lakeville in Petaluma . The staff…read moreat the front counter is super friendly. The place is super clean too. It's definitely a guilty pleasure for me when I get pizza from this place, as one who loves eating all kinds of great pizza. If I need something quick especially for a larger crowd, that hits that spot, then I aim for mountain mikes mountain size . My personal favorite is doing have white sauce and half red sauce on the pizza. Game changer for your favorite toppings.

This was a terrible experience. I would not recommend this place…read more They couldn't get my order right. I specifically ordered my sandwich with no meat, and it was made incorrectly. I also ordered sliced tomatoes, but they came chopped instead. The food was not what I ordered, and the mistakes were significant enough that I couldn't even eat it. Very disappointing.

Classic Pizza Parlor. Like a Shakey's of old…read more A lot of kids running around and video games too. My Uncle Lou Barber built the neon sign. Classic Petaluma.

I can't believe it took me so long to go to Pinky's. Their pizza is delicious. Seriously, I wasn't…read morevery hungry and I still managed to devour half a large pizza. The restaurant has a really casual, laid-back vibe. There were some arcade games in the back, and tons of families were there hanging out. I'll definitely go back!