Was seated quickly, food came quickly and tasted excellent! I would eat here again! The ambiance was very nice inside! read more

Russo’s New York Pizzeria - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

Wildly contradictory place to eat. The presentation and atmosphere had my wife and I excited to try a new place. As a Sicilian -Greek. Food is very much part of my life and upbringing. My wife is a trained dietetic specialist and food specialist. Essentially we do food! The service was poor. Low attention to tables. No silverware without asking. Our server spent most of the time being loud enough to hear her conversations with a guy about dating and what happened last night. None of which was professional. She would reach over our food to grab and set things down. She handpicked the cheese out of my wife's food and admitted to thinking that she got it all out instead of remaking it. My wife is dangerously allergic to dairy. My food came out cold and overcooked. Was very soggy and the taste was bland and unfriendly in the mouth. My wife's was also soggy and absent of flavor. Noodles over cooked and the sauce was burnt. I get that each place has its style of cooking but bad cooking should be something you shouldn't charge extra for. There was a customer table next to us that had a billing concern and the GM came out berated them for asking for clarity to only give him his money back. Then the waiter and my waitress around all the customer decided that was the place to talk trash about the customer at. When it was time to leave. We stood up and waited for our waitress to see us and bring us our check for a while and decided to start walking out the door before the hostess welcomed us in like we weren't in there for 30 mins already and I told her we needed our check. In that same time my wife used the restroom and came out and said to the hostess how dirty it was and looked like no one has cleaned it all day as trash was everywhere and she found a credit card in the floor. The hostess said oh she was here for lunch I know her. Indicating they had not been in there all day. When mentioning its filth. The hostess said yah that's not her job. Looking back I think it has potential but it's not run well nor does it stand out from any other place that will soon fail for bad service. It's just not worth the time or effort. Goto Olive Garden. You will get better food and service and at least they clean the bathroom. Positives: Friday night. Kinda empty no parking concerns. read more

I wanted to like it and sometimes I do. However it is so inconsistent. From service to food presentation and preparation. The inconsistent nature of this establishment has me feeling negative esp to recommend to anyone else. I went w a 3 star review because it has the potential to be great but just usually is NOT. read more

poor slow service, order confusion and didn't make it right. Food average lost my business read more

Great food. Great service. We went at 830pm on 1/10/26. They close at 10:00pm. Food was fresh and hot. 10/10 we will be back. read more

See all

Our services was amazing! She was so kind and quick. The food was not worth the price at all. The bread knots was very hard and the marinara sauce that went with it was very runny so you could barely get it on your garlic knot . they were definitely not worth how much we paid for them. I had the chicken manicotti, which was very flavorful 8/10! When we first pulled up, I thought the place was closed because we were the only car there we were there for about an hour and only one other car showed up so it's not very busy. read more

See all

It has such great promise, but totally meh. Inconsistent service, food took way too long, and partially burned. I don't plan on returning.

several friends and I visited several weeks ago and three of us ordered the 'pizza luncheon special with two toppings' and each of ours were delicious. Non-greasy, tasty and more than enough to take home for second meal. And the luncheon specials did not break the bank and service was quite good. The interior is quite pretty and welcoming and I will be returning read more

Let me preface by telling you I have been here seven times and have done take out once. I write this review sadly after multiple experiences. I have tried and tried. Every time something has been massively wrong, especially the last two times. Which is hard to write because South Broken Arrow needs a good Italian restaurant. Expensive menu for cold, sub par and small portions of food. In fact, the menu has increased over time steadily. Last and final time I went, it took two hours to get our food and then our order was incorrect. So I had to wait an additional 45 minutes for my pizza to arrive. Our drinks were never refilled, and our bar drinks never arrived. Lastly, the kitchen was burning food contsantly which had smoke coming into the dining area. We had movie tickets at the Warren that we had to return due to our meal taking hours. read more

The food was hot and so tasty! The marinara was a little bit thin for my taste, but only slightly. Cocktail - Junglebird - was freaking delicious! Server was so kind and personable. The whole place was nice. read more

We recently had dinner at Russo's in south Broken Arrow, and it's such a welcome addition to this side of town. In fact, we ran into several friends who were also dining there, which says a lot about its local popularity. To drink, we both had the sweet tea, which was nicely sweetened and refreshing. We started with the Lemon Arugula Salad, which was a light and healthy way to kick off the meal. It came out quickly, and the presentation was great. The salad features fresh arugula and shaved Pecorino Romano cheese tossed in a Sicilian extra-virgin olive oil and lemon dressing. The lemon flavor is very forward, more of a bold citrus punch than a light accent. I personally enjoyed it, but if you're looking for just a hint of lemon, you might consider asking for it on the side. Salad: 7.5/10 Before our food arrived, we were served complimentary bread with seasoned olive oil, a delicious touch. The bread is flavorful and quite heavily seasoned, so have a drink handy. It's a standout starter that sets the tone for the meal. Bread: 8.5/10 For our entrée, we shared the Chicken Rustica pizza, topped with grilled chicken, spinach, basil, feta, Roma tomatoes, mozzarella, garlic, and olive oil. The pizza was baked perfectly, with a crust that balanced crispiness and chew. It had a great blend of flavors and fresh ingredients. We'd definitely order it again. Pizza: 9/10 Service was decent overall. We waited around 4 to 5 minutes before being greeted or having our drink order taken, and we did have to request straws, which should be a standard. That said, once things got going, our server was friendly and kept our drinks refilled throughout the meal. Service: 7/10 The ambience is clean and modern, but it can get pretty loud inside due to the tile floors. Also, the entrance area feels a bit cramped, especially when waiting to be seated or picking up to-go orders. Ambiance: 7/10 Overall: A great spot with fresh Italian fare read more

Russo’s New York Pizzeria - Dinner w/friends - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Was really excited to try this place after hearing it's yummy- long long wait for kids food (1 hour on a "slower" night). We just ordered pepperoni slices for the kids. My husband ordered a sandwich and I had soup and salad. Food was decent but not worth the long wait with hungry kids. Everything came out scorching hot and in odd intervals. Really wish it was a better kitchen to table restaurant. read more

Russo’s New York Pizzeria - Cup Tortellini Brodo Soup - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

My friends and I had a great experience at lunch a few months ago so my husband I have started going a lot more and have been pleased with all of our visits! Enough so, that when it was time to plan a Christmas dinner on 12/23, we made reservations for a party of 16. The manager and his team had everything prepared before our arrival and even shared specials with me to share with my family (making it extremely affordable!) $10 spaghetti and meatballs and fettuccine Alfredo was the deal of the day! We love the bread and oil they serve before meals as well! Rush was our server and he did an excellent job and we appreciated the managers care as well. We'll be back for more soon! read more

Russo’s New York Pizzeria - Party of 16! - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

We've been three times and all of the very bad experiences. My biggest gripe is the food. I haven't had the pizza, and maybe it's good, but the pasta dishes are poorly executed with cheap ingredients. The chicken has the taste and texture of frozen bagged chicken and the sauces aren't good. The bar is very sad for a full service Italian restaurant. They can't make an Italian margarita (what?) and they brought me a caberbet that was chilled to about 45 degrees. read more

Not from the area but this place was recommended. Nice setting for a pizza spot. Two pizzas were great, hot and kids loved them!! Cheese cake was really good. Staff took great care of us and were very nice and friendly. Will definitely comeback next time I'm in town. read more

Always good tasting pizza with fantastic crust. This is the only pizza that I've found that can be reheated at home and it tastes as good as at the restaurant. Generous salads that can be shared. Service usually is prompt and efficient. read more

went there Saturday for lunch with my husband and 3 other family members. Only 2 other tables occupied and already had their food. We ordered all at the same time. Mine, my son-in-laws and my granddaughters food came. My daughter-in-laws salad came out after about 5 minutes. My husband's didn't come out for 30 more minutes. Waitress kept saying a few minutes but yes, 30 minutes late! Everyone else was already done eating. Completely unacceptable and I told the waitress this. She never offered to take it off. We paid over $100 and my husband couldn't even eat with his family. We won't be going back. I've told many people about our experience. read more

Date night and wanted to try a new spot. So glad we stopped in here for dinner. They offer a relaxed atmosphere and tv's in the bar have lots of sports options if you're so inclined. I ordered the shrimp scampi and it was yummy! They offered a healthy drink menu and have happy hour also. They accommodated my husband's meal request and our waitress was so sweet. I gave it 4 starts because there was a lag in between ordering and when our food arrived. Overall really enjoyed it and will go back again! read more

See all

Saturdays are our "Something New Day" so today we tried Russo's in Broken Arrow. I want to start off that the Service was Great' Ivana was our waitress and was very helpful with questions about the menu and brought out samples to help out decision making. We started off by ordering the Tuscan Salad which came with a Delicious Balsamic vinaigrette. Ivana also brought a bowl of bread with olive oil and special seasonings. For an appetizer we ordered the Housemade Italian Meatballs. Very good meatballs! For our main course we ordered the chicken manicotti with Bolognese sauce. This was also very good. My wife asked for a sample of the Alfredo sauce And it was outstanding mixed with the bolognese with chicken manicotti. It was a great meal and we will Definitely Be Back! read more

See all

First time I ordered online..1 pepperoni pizza. They didn't start cooking it til I got there. Gave them a second chance yesterday. My order was totally wrong. Ordered a pepperoni pizza and side of bruchetta. Got home....had a pepperoni pizza covered w/black olives. Salad w/ black olives and a bowl of chicken fettuccine. Called to complain to Manager and he could have cared less. NEVER AGAIN!! read more

place was clean and fully staffed. but it took us 75 minutes to get one pizza, a kids slice, and kids bowl of Alfredo. Next to us a table with a kid got dough for them to play with while they wait. We had a few kids in our group, but they didn't get anything. At one point the entire staff was standing at the counter, noticed I was looking over to see if our food was out yet. My daughters Alfredo was brought out 15 minutes before anyone else's. Appetizer bread was old/stale and just pulled out of a tote they had sitting on the counter. No redeeming qualities. Manager went around to tables around us but somehow skipped ours. 1/10. read more

I recently dined at Russo's New York Pizzeria, where Italian flavors met New York style with some memorable results. Here's the play-by-play of my carb-loaded adventure: Fettuccine Alfredo with Meatballs The Fettuccine Alfredo was creamy enough to make my cardiologist raise an eyebrow. The pasta had that perfect al dente bite, and the Alfredo sauce was as rich as a tech CEO. Adding a meatball (an extra $5 well spent!) felt like upgrading to first class. This meatball was huge, tender, and seasoned to perfection. Plus, the whole dish was dusted with parsley and Parmesan, so at least I got a little greenery in my diet, right? Calzone This calzone was a beast! Crispy on the outside, melty on the inside, and stuffed to the brim with cheese, ham, and olives. It came with a marinara sauce for dipping, which felt like a little Italian flavor booster pack. It was gooey, filling, and probably the only calzone that's tried harder to hold itself together than I did during 2020. Eggplant Parmesan The Eggplant Parmesan was the kind of classic Italian comfort food your Nonna would approve of... if you had one. The eggplant was tender and topped with mozzarella so melted it practically sang to me. Served over spaghetti with marinara sauce, this dish was like a warm hug from an old Italian friend--assuming your friend is coated in cheese and sauce. 12" Build-Your-Own Cheese Pizza Sometimes, simple is best, and this cheese pizza nailed it. The crust was crispy around the edges and soft in the middle, just the way it should be. The cheese was perfectly melted, stretching in that satisfying way that makes you feel like a kid again. It's a reminder that sometimes all you need in life is a slice of cheesy goodness (and maybe some napkins). Service and Atmosphere Our server, Anthony M, was on point, making sure our plates were full and our cups were never empty. Russo's has a cozy, family-friendly vibe that says, "Come in, sit down, and forget about your worries--at least until you see the dessert menu." The prices were fair for the portions, and I left with both my stomach and my wallet pleasantly full. Overall Impression Russo's New York Pizzeria is a great spot when you want Italian-American classics with no fuss, just flavor. From the saucy to the cheesy, they delivered comfort food done right. If you're in the mood for a meal that'll make your taste buds high-five, I'd recommend Russo's. Just be warned: you may need a nap afterward. read more

See all

We were visiting relatives here in Oklahoma and decided to try this Italian restaurant/pizzeria. The restaurant is a very nice, updated facility and the staff is extremely friendly and attentive to your needs. The Focaccia bread is one of the highlights of the meal. It's soft and extremely addictive. They bring you plates of olive oil with seasonings in it to dip the bread, but you must ask for Balsamic vinegar (which is a must). My BIL got the Diablo Shrimp with spaghetti and he loved it. He said it wasn't too spicy, but just right. My SIL had the baked Ziti and said it was one of the best that she's had. My wife ordered the chicken parmigiana and said the red sauce was mild and very flavorful. She said the chicken was moist and thoroughly enjoyed the meal. I had a Caesar salad with grilled chicken which had a great amount of dressing and the chicken was moist and tasty. We will definitely come back to try a pizza one of these times. read more

-Booth seat was so far from the table I had to scoot the whole table in and then the next bench seat so we could reach the table. -No soap or paper towels in the bathroom. -The meat in both our dishes was overcooked. -My Caesar salad had no dressing on it. I had to ask for dressing. But the waitress disappeared and so we waited 5-10 minutes for her to come back to even ask. I'm not a picky person and I don't leave reviews...but this was terrible. read more

Was looking for a good happy hour after work on a Monday and Russo's has half price house wines, beers and appetizers! The wine was great and the appetizers were delicious. Everything came out quickly and we had good service. read more

Stopped by with my husband and in-laws after catching a movie at Warren Theatre last Saturday. I immediately liked the style of the restaurant; it was clean and all of the tables were set nicely. There are plenty of tables and the dining room was bigger than I expected from the size of the building. There is also outdoor seating available. We were one of 7 tables around 2pm (the hours on here, and the Russo's franchise website, are not correct. The sign on the door shows this location open at 11am). As another reviewer stated, the staff is not required to wear masks but I didn't feel weird walking in with mine on. Our waitress was efficient with refills and didn't hover, which are pluses in my book. She brought out a basket of bread that had puffy pieces and flatter pieces inside - the puffy ones were great, the flatter ones were hard. Oh well, just helped me to save room for my entrée lol. I ordered the Truffle Mushroom Pappardelle - this dish was FANTASTIC! I will order this every time we visit, hands down. I could really go for a bowl of it right now! My husband ordered the Eggplant Parm and he said this was one of the best he has ever had. Very nice size portions all around. My in-laws ordered the Lobster Ravioli and the Giant Cheese Ravioli (these are massive). Everything we had was great! My mother-in-law has already requested to go back for her birthday so I really hope our next visit is just as good. read more

Date of check in/review 1/14/23 Russo's opened in 2021 at the peak of the life sucking, business destroying, world changing pandemic. At the time life had become curb service, order on line, gallons of hand sanitizer and terrified humanity hiding behind blue masks. Our world has changed. Our society has been indelibly scarred; the prospect of normalcy still seems distant. I remember the appearance of Russo's new building that mistakenly impressed me as a stuffy high end Italian food joint. Not my kind of place. Aversion to people packed restaurants then (and now) and the fact that I really am not a fan of Italian food made it easy to ignore. Out of curiosity this week, I got online and checked Russo's menu. Right now, my wife and I are setting in a comfortable booth, waiting for a Chicken Rustica pizza! Yeah well, I will eat a Pizza now and then. In Broken Arrow there really are only three, maybe four legitimate dine in pizza restaurants. I think all but one claims to be "New York" style pizza. Who cares! A pizza is a pizza. One restaurant is a prominent well-known, Oklahoma based, college town original. I have tried them all. The attractive décor, the dining environment and the service, sets Russo's apart from the others. Russo's is a nice comfortable restaurant with superb service. Russo's is easy to get to. Unlike downtown Broken Arrow; Russo's has ample easy access parking and you don't have to navigate the traffic congestion at malfunction junction (Lynn Lane between the BA expressway and Kenosha.) The restaurant is just down the street from the Regal -Warren Theater. Convenient. Pizza and a movie! According to my receipt, our waiter today was Kara C. Great service, delivered with pride and ownership. She must be a manager or owner. Anyway, the service was great! The restaurant starts your meal with a complimentary Italian style appetizer; the equivalent, of chips and salsa. Toasted squares of seasoned pizza crust and a seasoned olive oil dipping sauce. This alone was enough for a meal. Our choice, the Chicken Rustica, is a delicious white pizza with grilled chicken, fresh spinach, basil, feta cheese, Roma tomatoes, Wisconsin mozzarella, Sicilian extra-virgin olive oil, and fresh garlic. A 16 inch. A great lunch today and enough left over, for a great lunch tomorrow. Good pizza, nice restaurant! read more

See all

We were the first customers through the door on opening day. The restaurant filled up quickly! South BA is excited for another restaurant. The calamari appetizer was quite tasty. We ordered the Buffalo chicken pizza, and it was slightly burnt on the bottom. The overall flavor was good and the ranch complimented it well. The waiter was very attentive. The staff seemed happy to be there. The restaurant was pretty and very clean. One thing I noticed was there was no waiting area for those waiting to be seated. No benches or anything. They may need to consider that. We will be back to try the calzones and pasta!! read more

See all

The food is just ok. The price is high for the small size portions. We ordered 2 spaghetti carbonaras and one baked ziti.

We just had a delightful lunch at Russo's! Starving at 11 am and as you can see in the photo we were the first customers of the day! The yummy fresh bread (made with pizza crust, yummy spices and a side of olive oil) they serve you immediately was outrageously delicious! Great selection of salads, with all dressings house made! Highly recommend the Caesar but our other Mediterranean was also very good! Service with Anthony was perfect! We can barely wait to go back! read more

Russo’s New York Pizzeria - Interior - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Great food here at Russo's. The Margarita Pizza is great with the olive oil base. The bread and oil has great flavor. read more

Russo’s New York Pizzeria - 16" Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

It's just hit or miss which is disappointing. They have some of the best cocktails in town and the pizza is fantastic. On the other hand, their lobster ravioli is the worst I've ever had. Last visit the service was a disaster. We came at lunch with a large group and we're told we couldn't get the lunch special because they were out of pizza by the slice?!! We were the first people in there for lunch. Our waiter brought feta salad without feta. When asked for feta, he brought blue cheese. I'm sure I will give it another shot but hoping they work some of the details out for a better experience. read more

See all

This is my second time stopping to eat here when visiting broken Arrow. The pizza is fantastic, the service is phenomenal, and that bread and dipping sauce can't be beat. The prices are reasonable and the environment is clean and inviting. They even have an outside sitting area you can eat if you so choose. Definitely stop in and check it out. read more

See all

We have been here a few times now, and the food has been consistently tasty while providing a nice ambience. The restaurant has a very elegant casual-esque feeling to it with an open kitchen and a nice bar seating area. I can vouch for the eggplant parm, mushroom pasta and truffle mushroom pizza. All were very tasty, served hot and in a good size portion. I usually end up taking home some of whatever we order. It's nice to have another Italian food option in Broken Arrow other than Olive Garden. We are fans and will keep coming back! read more

Russo’s New York Pizzeria - Eggplant Parmesan with a huge mound of spaghetti underneath. It was fantastic! 10/10 would order again! - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

What a pleasant surprise! My wife had seen this little gem and wanted to go there Saturday when we were running errands on that side of town. They were open for business at 1 pm even though their Yelp site said they were closed. The service was outstanding and fast. The location clean and well organized. We had a New York Specialty pizza and a tomato/mozzarella balsamic vinegar appetizer. The appetizer came out super quick and was fresh and oh so yummy. The pizza was out of this world! The crust was not too thick, yet crunchy and bready at the same time. Toppings were on point. The price point was right for a nice lunch! I think we're have a new local go to!!!! read more

Russo’s New York Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

We were the first customers of the day. There was crumbs on the floor, multiple tables, and chairs. I guess they don't clean at night. The waitress didn't seem to care. They were having trouble with the pizza oven which caused us to wait almost 45 minutes for our food. The pizza was undercooked. Waitress apologized but we would have liked to have seen a manager so we could show them all the mess that was not cleaned up the night before. We will not go back. read more

This is the 2nd time I have give. this place a shot in a year and I should have learned my lesson the first time. piss poor attitude from the cook and when it's a open kitchen you get to see it. I had food to go and waited by the register and let me tell ya he would be gone. the Alfredo was decent not for the 26 with shrimp but the garlic bread and tiramisu desert are huge jokes they would be worth it if they was free maybe. Moose get up here.needles to say I had shrimp Alfredo with garlic bread and desert and it was $60. maybe worth $23 read more

See all

This place will make a really nice dispensary once it inevitably fails. Ridiculous overpriced, for the mediocre food they serve. read more

We chose to check out this new spot in the middle of a restaurant desert which is south BA. Just like 99% of BA places they don't require masks, no staff are masked and we got strange looks from almost all the "BAknights" or when we walked in with our masks on...so yah, pretty typical for BA.. It's a very open concept, zero walls and tables and tables a pizza bar and a regular bar you can watch food made or drinks being made. We had the meatball app ( didn't get a photo) and some bourbon. The bartender was fantastic he was always on top of the drinks and for sure can suggest some bourbons. We tried a few of our favorite drinks while we hung out. We got the New Yorker which is all meat, we enjoyed the flavor of the crust, the toppings as another review on here pointed out were a little soggy and not crispy in the middle, we still enjoyed it but next time might as for it a little more we'll done if we get more than a cheese pie...outside of that it was good, we actually got a Togo cheese pizza a few nights later for the kids, which in case you order it they do sprinkle some sort of oregano on top of it which, kids won't eat for the most part....give it a try it's a great pizza place for south BA. read more

See all

Walked in to pickup an order. Very nice workers. The establishment was quite amazing. The pizza was fine. Crust was hard to chew, cheese and sauce was okay. Not my favorite, probably won't go back. read more