The pizza was so good I ordered more. I felt safe eating there.they were busy due to the Super Bowl ... but I was patient and cashier was efficient. Affordable kosher and delicious pizza read more

Stopped here for a slice of pizza. It was tasty, service was fast. It's walking distance from the American Museum of Natural History. read more

See all

Tried the regular slice. I taste more of the breading/crust than cheese and it was burnt in the bottom. Didn't really like it...

For a dinky little pizza shop that has kind of an odd selection of pizza slices, it was affordable and quite good. Interesting thing about the crust, the slice looked like it was thin and possibly hard and the square cut looked doughy, but both of them were surprisingly flaky. Really strange because they don't look that way. The mushrooms are fresh and don't appear to be from a can, sautéed quite wonderfully. And most importantly it sat well in my stomach :). I had two mushroom slices and a bottle of water all for 13 bucks, very filling, not a bad quick lunch. I will return. Very good pizza. read more

Saba's Pizza - A mushroom slice and a ricotta square with mushrooms (half eaten :-) - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Solid slice of plain! Grandma might even be the most delicious here of all locations. Guys who work behind the counter are a lovely bunch of professionals. Excellent location to take the kids to eat ! read more

There gotta be a better way to regulate the temperature in this place. During the winter, they 'crack' one of the doors open cause the kitchen is warm else the place would steam up. Sounds good in theory other than that makes the entire restaurant seating useless as it's freezing even with jackets. 30 degrees and the cold is coming in read more

Saba's Pizza - Freezing cold in the winter with doors cracked open - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

horrible experience. they are so mean and unhelpful. I am disguested. they don't care and they're busy and on Uber eats they don't provide the right time. read more

Hmmm, where do I start? Messy restaurant with too many chairs & tables; disorganized. Now for the juicy part. I had lunch there a week ago, and while eating a veggie pizza a female manager came over to interrupt me from eating my meal to ask if my ice- coffee I walked in with was Kosher? WTH! I've never been approached in that manner b4 about something so trivial. She kept asking what was in the ice coffee, so I said almond milk & that she could one next door. She was redundant asking over & over what was in the coffee This is crazy NYC so I was trying 2b patient with her. She was acting weird, but never said she was the manager, until like 5 minutes into the conversation, & kept saying good thing the boss wasn't there bc he wouldn't like that I had a non kosher ice coffee. She's like it's a kosher pizza shop. Well if it was that serious they should have it in bold letters on the wall. Plus the pizza guy saw me drinking my coffee as I entered & again when placing my order & paying. Pizza guy was happy to take my money . As if he didn't know the rules where he worked. I thought it was disgusting her Hovering over someone as they're having lunch. If it was that much of a problem they should've given me back my money. I actually, had to say Miss I'm eating can u excuse me. A business, like this should not be open for business if ur gonna harass ur customers about what they're drinking? So, suspect! No wonder, it was kinda empty. Next time I'll walk another block to the other pizza shop. The pizza at this Sabra wasn't even that good, but it was a very hot day, so I took a chance. I bet it's so kosher, that if Department of Health may not find it so kosher in the kitchen. Never again! I do not recommend! read more

See all

I came in for a quick slice and ordered the square spinach/garlic pizza. Amazing flavor and crunch.

the pizza is beyond great but never mind that!! Magali i don't know her last name just gave the most incredible customer service i have ever EVER experienced. I live in Virginia and when i come to ny i only go to Sabas UES only to get my 'Za from her. This time i ordered 6 pizzas to go to Sloane kettering to my doctors for 9 years cancer free. AND IM STILL IN VIRGINIA NOT IN NYC. Magali dedicated and decorated all 6 boxes with printed signs and colored markers as if I were her husband coming back from WAR!! Who gives this level of unbelievable customer care in 2025. This pretty young SINGLE girl must love her job and her bosses!! I've met the owners they are extremely good and clearly this level of great service comes from the top, at least they recognized a superior person to represent them. Great great pizza, Shout out to Magali tell her you saw this review. Great Pizza awesome magali and staff!!!!! My doctors love it too!! They order now from Sabas too! read more

One of the best pizzas in the upper Westside. Highly recommended. If you're a pizza connoisseur, this is a must try.

Tasty, humongous cheese slices, with a perfectly resilient thin crust. Friendly, efficient service. A couple tables out front if you want to eat asap. read more

Saba's Pizza - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Good pizza and fries. Arrived on time and they remembered to cut the slices in halves for the kids. So

You wanna know? Let's do this. Service 5 stars for ordering -2 for paying, but they were getting slammed with orders. Food 4 stars Solid cheap pizza slice. Haters shut it. Todays walk on was worth it. Mushroom slices Space/sitting 3 stars = it's possible but why. Nah don't. Parking It's on Amsterdam. Are you really trying to park for a slice? What's wrong with you. This is slice-on-the-way. Or take out. Keep driving. Don't bother stopping. Keep going. And it's not cuz I've been in LA and Coming back to get some real pizza might be skewed. Cheap neighborhood pizza should be FAST HOT COOKED WELL (before reheated) ENOUGH CHEESE SAUCE THAT HOLDS UP 4 Stars cmon. Think about it. You're rating this against other cheap fast pizza delivery/reheat slice. read more

Good late night snake. Nice size slices and fast delivery. Think they were running out of slices as it was the end of the night but overall very delicious. Small hole in the wall with a couple tables. Just Did a grab and run overall recommend read more

Saba's Pizza - a slice of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Ordered delivery on a weeknight, which arrived on time and piping hot! We got a half mushroom and half black olive pizza, size large. The crust was nice and thin, the cheese had good coverage and the vegetables were well distributed and not too skimpy. The extra toppings added $6 to the cost of the base cheese pizza. We also got a Caesar salad which was very enjoyable. Overall a solid pizza and salad experience! read more

Saba's Pizza - Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I ordered in-store on Monday, June 5th. Very disappointed. Pizza came out after 25 mins even though there wasn't any demand. It came out soggy, and cold, and half of the pie had no cheese. Pizza was expensive guessing cause it's kosher... Still. I asked their employees to do anything with it, such as re-making, refunding, etc... But they denied everything I said. In conclusion, Service + Taste + Price all together were terrible. VERY DISAPPOINTED! I recommend going to other pizzerias in NYC. read more

Unreliable, ruined my kid's birthday party by never delivering the pizza. I heard other nightmare stories about their non-deliveries. Pizza is standard, not good but not awful either. read more

Nasty attitude on the phone. All I wanted to know is if they were open and how late Saturday after shabat. As I'm NOT FORM THE AREA. a**hole

I love this place. It's easy and delicious. I have never had a thin crust veggie pizza this good. I mean, would you just look at the photo I posted? Look at all the toppings! I am not a pizza authority by any means, I just like my pizza to be thin crust (I will NEVER understand New Yorkers' love for bagels and thick chewy pizza!) and I honestly prefer this place over the over-hyped Mama's Too. And for you folks complaining about the unpredictable hours...it's a Kosher restaurant! They observe Shabbat, silly! The guys who work here are super nice, too. read more

Saba's Pizza - two slices of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The pizza is a solid NY slice. The bottom is nice and crispy,l and they left the bubbles which is a big plus for me. Flavor is lacking on the vodka sauce slightly. The two slices cost me just under 10 dollars, which I would believe is a little bit of a higher price point. Overall, good slices. read more

Saba's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Not good for word. dont Trust their ordering system. Not even apologetic. If you can't fulfill an order turn off your delivery system.

Lead guy behind counter (Order-taker/Cashier) is rude and unprofessional. Be prepared to be spoken nasty to. Otherwise food is good. read more

Do not support this business!!! I came in for one slice late night but the guy said we only doing pies so I get one, A couple come in and order single slices I called the manager and I told him what's going on why did I have to pay for a whole pie when the other couple is getting the slice he told me it's because it's late and sabbath we are trying to only support the Jewish community only by the way I'm Hispanic that broke my heart to hear this, because I thought we were all equal. read more

Saba's Pizza - a hand holding a receipt - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Pretty decent experience until we got home and opened our takeout box. We were shocked to find a dead fly on one of the pizzas. This, as you might assume, was a horrifying, gross encounter that made us not want to eat anymore from this place. Very unfortunate and even though they do have a "B" cleanliness rating, no one should expect any type of insect in their food. Definitely want my money back. read more

Saba's Pizza - Insect in box - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Best pizza on NYC. Thin crust. Sauce is spot on. Service was great too. Small space. Sat outside - very comfortable people watching while eating my slice. read more

It's good pizza, and unique in its own way, but not the best you can find in the city. I tried the Sicilian, mushroom ricotta, and caramelized onion ricotta pizzas. My favorite was the Sicilian, very rich in good quality tomatoes. Even though I love caramelized onions, I personally found it to be a bit too heavy for me. read more

Came here at 9:30 on a Sunday night. They close at 10 p.m. and were scrubbing down the counters which frankly makes me concerned that the employees just want to get out of there. We ordered two different pastas to go: a spaghetti luciano and a penne arrabiata. We only had to wait 10 minutes and during that time a number of other people came in to pick up their orders. The spaghetti was good. It had good garlic and wine flavor and the noodles were not overcooked (which I hate) but the penne was one of the worst I've ever had. The sauce had almost no flavor except the spice (i.e., there was no nail and the tomatoes were bland). I ended up throwing out more than half of it. read more

See all

I've been pretty much out of commission for nearly a week, after having pizza with a friend of mine at Saba's Pizza two Fridays ago, 4/15/2022. My friend had diarrhea the following day, and it ran for about two days. I got the worse end of it: the whole plethora of food poisoning symptoms that ran over a week! There were times where I even felt like I had broken glass in my stomach. Everything I drank just went right through me. Good luck trying their pizza at 2AM... Never again... read more

I came in to grab a quick slice of pizza since i was in the area. The place is super small I was shocked so I'd recommend you grab a slice and leave but there is seating and I managed to grab one while I'm here. The pizza is pretty price, paid about $5 (including tax) for a square slice of pizza. Sad to say it wasn't great. Wish i could have tried the Grandma slice that they're famous for but I doubt I'd come back to try it. If you're in the area save your money and try another pizza place. read more

Amazing pizza. Off the charts. This place is better than any pizza I have had in los angeles, which isn't saying much.

I was starving, they were the only place still serving Pizza at this time of day. They are so warm and friendly. Would recommend 10/10.

The best kosher pizza in nyc! ! It even tastes a lot like regular pizza and you can never tell that it's really kosher pizza!

Came here with a friend after a day at The Met and we split three slices. This was exactly what we needed. The square slice had some pesto on it which was probably my favorite. I'm looking forward to the day when we can return to our museum and pizza routine, just so I can get that pesto slice again. read more

Saba's Pizza - two slices of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Waited forever for the delivery. Never got an update on timing. Very disappointed. Will not order from there again.

Saba's has one of the best plain pies in NYC. It is a very thin crust and I really like their sauce, it is kind of sweet and you can actually taste it. I am not a fan of pizza where you cannot taste the sauce. I would also recommend the artichoke Alfredo pizza. I am from NYC so I know what I am talking about when it comes to pizza. The salads are very good here as well, I like the pesto salad. Everything from this place is always extremely fresh, and I have never had a problem with an order. It is also kosher if that is needed. read more

The manager at this location is so rude! I went an hour after the website said they opened and nothing was ready. I was told it was only open for ordering, so I suggested they change the information on the website if they aren't ready to serve customers for 90min after "opening ". The manager was horrendous and basically told me to get out. I will never go back there. I've had their pizza in the last and it's mediocre at best. Sadly Roma and Viva closed so there aren't Other kosher options on the UWS. Ended up going to Marinara up the street and they were lovely and pizza was better! Stay away from Saba's! read more

Oy Saba, how much we wanted to give you a better score because we love your pizza but twice you disappointed us. We ordered the extra thin margarita deluxe ($24 for a 6 slice pizza -expensive did we say??) and when arrived it was one big mash that doesn't even look like pizza. Then when we called you offered to send a new one (thanks but. Ow it's an hour wait) and to our surprise it came the same way. Seriously big disappointment! I hope you'll improve it because we love your pizza read more

Saba's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Pretty good thin crust pizza. Very fast service. They are only selling by the pie due to COVID. Only standing room in store. There are a few seats outside. The pizza was good however the best part about it was the SAUCE. Incredible. We got a regular pie and it was great. Not much else to write! read more

Kosher Pizza, tremendous cheese slice and Grandma's (thick square). Very friendly staff, clean atmosphere and great service. Very happy this is in the neighbourhood. Went back for take out, another great pizza, also place is very clean and procedural about social distancing and precautions at this time. Thank you. read more