This is quite possibly the best pizza on the East Coast. It is a mandatory stop any time I am passing through Westchester, and I have been known to have friends driving back from NYC stop by and deliver some pizza to me in Boston. Beware of the gross bathrooms. read more

The best Sicilian around! If there is a Sicilian pie on the table and it's not from Sal's I'm not eating it! Fantastic

I have yet to find the PERFECT 5 STAR pizza but I would give this a 4.5. Everyone raves about the Sicilian slice but to me sicilian just has too much bread. I thought the regular slice was heaven very thin and very cheesy! Definitely one of the top pizzas I have ever had read more

One of the best Pizza places in Westchester, I've been going here for many years.

I've been to Sal's many times and it is always delicious. My favorite pizza to get is the Sicilian slice, but everything is great. The atmosphere is casual and the service there is very good. If your in the mood for a quick bite and great pizza Sal's is perfect place to try. read more

Been going to Sal's for years to both dine in and take away. Sal's is arguably some of the best pizza in the NYC area. The young guys who work there are really friendly to the point one time we got a whole pie and one small area of the crust was thin. The guy behind the counter insisted we take a 'replacement' slice. We went today for lunch and as we arrived well before noon, the typical line had yet to form. I stood face to face with a person I'd never seen. He just looked at me. No greeting. Did not ask what I'd like to order. I finally said hi, I'd like to order a whole pepperoni to go. He just looked at me. Finally he walked closer and said 19 bucks. Gave him a 20 and held my hand out for the change when he returned, only to have him throw the dollar on to the counter. After about 10 minutes I walked over to where they package up the pizzas to go. Same short douche of a little man just stands there looks at me and walks away. Minutes later the older guy (Sal?) takes pizza from oven and puts the pie in the box. Short guy walks over, tapes box closed and pushes the box at me almost off the counter and turns away. You know what? No need to apologize to me. Apologize to your colleagues for making a great pizza place an awful experience. You're an embarrassment and true waste of space! read more

I refuse to eat pizza anywhere else. The Sal's regular slice is absolute heaven. Thin crust. Fresh sauce. The best cheese there is. Always right of the oven but magically manages not to burn your tongue. I have a hunch that aside from freshness and thin crust, the cheese is the ultimate secret. My family and I decided one night to try and make our own pizza at home, so we headed to Sal's for ingredients. They were happy to sell us dough and we had our own sauce at home, but when it came to the cheese they had to call Sal himself to make sure it was okay! We ended up getting the cheese but it was still in no way close to Sal's quality. In the mood for something a little lighter? The salad slice is arguably just as good as the regular. When I go, I get one of each. I'd be missing out if I didn't. No cheese on this pizza, just crust, sauce and a lettuce and tomato salad. Not surprisingly, kids even like it! Finally: The Eggplant Dish This scrumptious breaded eggplant with tomato sauce, commonly referred to in my house as "eggplant parmesan without the parmesan," is for me, a Sal's favorite. Usually if I am actually eating at the restaurant and not ordering take-out I will feel too guilty not getting pizza to order it. BUT, it is the perfect alternative if you don't like getting home and your pizza is already cold. It's also delicious cold a day or two later. read more

I've been going to Sals for 35 years, since I was 5 years old! I grew up in Mamaroneck so of course it was a weekly staple but now I live in Houston, TX and I always make a stop to have Sals every time I come back to see my parents. Worlds best pizza and nothing else read more

The BEST pizza in Westchster by far! (And in the top five EVER in the US) I dream of it from San Diego. I can't come home without at least one slice of Sicilian and one regular....and a salad slice too most of the time. I ask for my regular slices well done so it is extra crispy. They know how to put the perfect amount of sauce and cheese on every pie - not too saucy and not too cheesy. The crust is perfect every time...Hard to find a seat, but it travels well. I even bring a few slices back to San Diego to keep in my freezer for when I need a quick fix of the good stuff! I have been coming here since I was a kid and plan to bring my kids here as well. RIP JP. read more

I gotta say, this place has the very best pizza in Westchester. both the thin crust and Sicilian pies a delicious. Their house salad are nice and fresh. Go there, it's worth the trip!! read more

Well, over the years people either love Sal's or they don't. They have great Sicilan pizza. It is like no other! Their salad slices are pretty good too. But, for regular slices and Italian food you can skip this place. read more

One of the best pizzas in Westchester, if not New York area. Just the right amount of sauce and a sturdy crust. Worth making an extra trip for; just don't expect to make any friends at the front counter. Service is rushed and rude at times ... Pick up and go! read more

We first tried Sal's for takeout, and found the pizza kind of average. That was surprising given the hype, so we decided to come in and eat fresh slices. It made all the difference -- Sal's Sicilian slice might just be the best Sicilian slice I've ever had. Now we stop by on the regular for our Sicilian pizza fix. The rest of the menu (we've had garlic knots, spaghetti & meatballs, salad) is perfectly fine if not award-winning. Friendly service that keeps the line moving. read more

Sal's Pizzeria has been around for ages and is still the crowned king. They are by far the best pizzeria in Westchester. I like how they have renovated giving the place a nice clean look. You can always count on exceptional taste at a reasonable price at Sal's. Their restaurant menu is really great and I highly recommend Sal's. read more

One of the best Sicilian pizza pie anywhere. Under $18 for a 10 slice pie is also one of the best deals! Their other food is good too, but don't miss the Sicilian if you come here! I grew up in White Plains and have been coming here for almost 50 years and it remains consistent. I live about 30 minutes away now but still come through Mamaroneck whenever I can to snag a pie or two! Only one caveat: ca$h only :) read more

This is the best Sicilian pizza anywhere! Even if you don't usually eat Sicilian pizza, try it here. I have been a customer for over 50 years, from the time that they were a tiny, little place, to now. I don't live near there anymore, but any time that I am close by, a visit to Sal's is a must! read more

Fantastic slices of Sicilian. My favorite in the world? no, but pretty darn good. I used to like the salad pizza, but for some reason its lost its appeal, maybe I just liked it when I was younger growing up. read more

This pizza place was hopping! There was a line out the door because I guess everyone in Westchester knows that Sals is great. I came for the salad pizza because it's one of my friends great loves and apparently no pizza store in NYC provides salad pizza! Everything was delicious at a reasonable price. If you're in the mood for a pizza, definitely check out Sals! And try the salad pizza! read more

If you love Sicilian pizza you've got to give Sal's a try if you are in Westchester. We picked up a Sicilian pie to take home and it was absolutely delicious. The crust is nice and thick with a crispy bottom and a warm, breast center. Topped with tasty sauce and a generous layer of cheese I could have eaten the whole thing! read more

The best pizza I have ever had...period! The salad pizza is a favorite as are the Sicilian pies and the sandwiches, but Sal's will blow you away with just a plain slice. If you are in NYC and have a car (or want to ride Metro-North to Mamaroneck) this pizza is worth the trip. read more

The Sicilian pizza is the best you'll find anywhere; heavenly. The other pizza is very good, but not extraordinary like the Sicilian. I like Pepe's better for thin crust. The wedges and dishes are good to very good and the value is 5 stars. I've been eating here for almost 50 years, since I was age 4. You can't find many places in business for this long, let alone ones with frequent lines out the door during peak hours. read more

Don't go alone unless you're on foot because finding a parking spot during the rush is futile. While I no longer live in Mamaroneck I did for several years and still have family there. I have been visiting Sal's going on 25 years and to this day I have yet to eat a slice of sicilian anywhere that rivals Sal's. I am only speaking to their sicilian slices for the purposes of this review as it is the only thing I have ever ordered. Ever. There is a good chance that several of my less popular family members ultimately stayed in Mamaroneck simply because they knew that without Sal's in their "backyard" we would never visit. They are correct in this assumption. Very kid friendly and on the cheap. Whoever gives this place anything less than 3 stars should have their Yelp account closed as they are doing no good for the Yelp community. read more

Hands down the best pizza in Westchester county. The guys behind the counter are pretty rude unless they know you, but the attitude is worth it. read more

Best pizza in Westchester!!! Even though the service it isn't that friendly. Totally worth stopping by and checking it out this Mamaroneck spot. read more

Delicious!! Some of the best pizza I've ever had. If you have a big appetite, get the trifecta - a plain slice, a salad slice, and a middle sicilian. Fave toppings are spinach and garlic together (especially amazing on their white pizza). The crust here is perfect. I almost always get pizza but the food from the kitchen is also great - chicken parm is fantastic, as are other pastas. Love their penne vodka. The service can be gruff and seem like a bit of an "insider's club" but it doesn't really bother me. Cash only. read more

Best Sicilian in Westchester. Try it. Now!

We ordered a Sicilian pie pizza with chicken, basil and olives on sunday night by phone. Somebody should have warned us about how big that pie is!!! It's HUGE and enough to feed 6-7 people. It's a square deep dish pizza with about 10 LARGE slices that fit the size of the pizza box. NEWCOMERS BEWARE! After the shock wore off, my husband and I tried and loved it! It's a lot of food and hearty, and definitely worth trying. I will definitely be back to order slices the next time. read more

Best pizza around. You know when you go to a pizzeria, and they re-heat cold slices? How it normally doesn't taste the same as a pie fresh out of the oven? Yep, not here! I don't know what they put in the pizza, or what is up with the oven, but a re-heated slice tastes the same as one right out of the oven. Again, best pizza around! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Sicilian and a plain slice! - Pizza Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

One of a kind. No one comes close to their Sicilian slice. Pure perfection! Cash only.

Sal's really does have excellent pizza. Their hot food is so-so but they get 5 stars for their creative pizzas (like buffalo chicken, and salad -- both delicious!) read more

Have been coming here since I was a kid and it's just as amazing as it's always been. Best pizza in the Tri-state.

If you grew up anywhere near Sal's, you know it's reputation as the best around. Is it slipping? Maybe, maybe not. (Just when I think 'maybe' I get hit with a sicilian slice that wins me over.) This is a straight up ny-style pizza joint and doesn't pretend to be anything else which is part of the appeal. You don't go to Sal's to have someone greet you with a smile. Decide what you want quickly, order, move on and enjoy. Their lines are out the door for a reason. At this point if they're polite behind the counter, I actually get a little worried that something's off. The sicilian is great most of the time (though my last slice was mysteriously thin - I hope that's not a trend). It's light years beyond what other places call sicilian. The white pizza, which you don't hear much about, is out of this world especially if you get a fresh pie to take home. I think they use some kind of white cheese combo no one else uses, maybe with gorgonzola. This is the only white pizza I'll eat. Like others have said the salad slice is also very good, better than most. The regular/plain is usually great too, occasionally just 'good' and I wish there were a little more sauce. Still worth the gamble. I've eaten in dozens of NY-style pizza joints in Westchester, Rockland & Fairfield counties (though I haven't made it to the Mt. Vernon one people rave about), and this is without a doubt #1 out of the places I've been. I'm not counting places with coal or wood ovens that use fresh mozzarella and fancy toppings - love those places when they do it right, but it's a whole other food category. Re what one reviewer said - yes, it's chewy which I take to be a good thing (no sore jaws here), and sometimes I blot the oil with a napkin too - is that such a big deal? For me it's just part of the NY pizza ritual. The cheese itself, once you're done blotting, tastes really good. If you're someone who eats pizza with a knife and fork, Sal's probably isn't for you, otherwise, try it. Just wish there were more parking. read more

Try the Sicilian pizza and the Lasanga. I have not, and do not think I will ever find a better examples of these dishes. Makes me want to move back into my folks place. read more

Whenever I dont know what I want to eat for lunch or dinner, the answer is automatically Sal's. I am from Mamaroneck and aside from a couple of unsatisfactory slices (I can literally count them on one hand after two plus decades) this place is awesome. I personally love the regular slice over anything but the 'Tri-fecta' of a regular, salad and sicilian slice is always my go-to order. The guys can be pushy behind the counter but they serve hundreds of people a day and as a customer I get pushy as well if the line doesnt flow smoothly in the narrow service area in the front. Enjoy Mamaroneck's best slice and dont let the hard working guys behind the counter get you down. read more

To the "idiot" who said people from Mamaroneck are afraid to go outside of mamaroneck for fear someone will steal there mercedes.. get a grip. Ive been to new park as well as many pizza places in manhattan and the bronx and i still think Sals sicillian is the best pizza in new york. AND to the guy who said "sals new and improved sicillian" isnt good & OVERPRICED?. What are you talking about "new and improved" the sicillian has been the same for the last 20 years. It was never DOUGHY. It was always thinner and crunchy. That is what is great about it. and overpriced? Did you have a fight with an owner or something - is that the reason for your post? GET A GRIP! in my opinion - Sals is awesome! read more

Been going to Sal's since high school - simply the best - worth the trip and the wait!

Myself and three girlfriends went to a small Bistro called La Provencal and walked out because the appetizers were atrocious. Dried out Mussels and disgusting sauce. As we walked back to our cars we laugh and say "wanna just get some pizza?". We pop into Sals and were so glad we made the decision. The guys at Sals should teach the French restaurant how to make a sauce. 5 stars all the way. read more

Came in with a sling on and they were more than pleased to assist me in every way possible. The pizza here is also the best around

A pizzeria worth driving out of your way for ... But only for the Sicilian. Crispy and fluffy at the same time with delicious sauce. Cooked to perfection and served quick. Stop by for Sicilian when you get a chance. read more

Being a Chicago native, every pizza I eat is compared to the pies I get at home. However, Sal's is great. Whether you want a quick bite to eat or craving a late night snack, Sal's is the place to go. Cash only. read more