We usually get a sheet pizza with a couple of toppings. Always cooked perfect. Great crust and and toppings go from edge to edge. The breaded wings are plump and meaty and by far the best we've had. No skimping on the sauces either. read more

We order here at least 3 times a week because of how close our job is never again called to order 2 pizzas man on the phone was absolutely ignorant I won't be giving them my business ever again read more

I've had pizzas all over the place and keep coming back to Salvatore's and we love the folks at this location. If you've never tried the Thin Thin Pizza, you should give it a try. If you love pizza, but find the crust just to filling, PLEASE try Thin Thin! My husband and I went vegan (to a degree... we draw the line at cauliflower crust even though that's pretty good too) and regularly order the Thin Thin doubles with pizza sauce, artichokes, red peppers, and banana peppers. Good Lord! This combo is so good! read more

the best drivers in the world. such professionalism, and great service. The food is great and when I stop in very friendly

Pizza is so darn good!! A slice is like a small pizza where I come from so all I can say is $11 a slice YES please!!!

Ordered a sub and when we called a 1/2 hrs before scheduled pick we were told our steak sub was already made. Completely unsatisfactory!! Then we opened it and it was not what we ordered. The manager, Jason, he... No wonder the 30 something has only achieved a manager position at a damn pizza shop. His parents gave to be so damn proud. read more

I've only ever had their pizza and it's constantly delicious, great sauce and filling tops. I've never had an issue with delivery so that's a plus. read more

Where to begin. First tho.. I will start out by saying the (female) manager this evening DID call back and took care to do what was supposed to have been done 6 weeks and 5 phone calls ago. In July I ordered take-out at the counter, opening it a short time later to eat it, only to find food was missing. Plus what I was given was cold and did not look at ALL like the photo. They wanted me to come back for the missing fries (!); but finally said they would deliver it as we were only 1/2 mile down the road waiting for an outdoor concert to start. They never came. I called them within the next day or two and after lots of back and forth (we had the concert people announce your name - huh?) was told I would get $10 credit to my card. It never came. More calls and was finally told the best they would do is put the credit on my account. (I don't have one.) "We'll open one for you." I don't want to do this, but am forced to. Now when I go to use it this evening I first get a "You don't have any credit" and then after a lot of pushing on my part am told I have to pay full price for an item in order to use my credit, because the "system won't let me, and you can use a credit or a coupon but not both". A manager will call me back because she's too busy taking care of other orders to come to the phone right now (!!??). We ordered somewhere else in the meantime. She eventually did call and was very apologetic and saying the agent was wrong (credit is not like a 2nd coupon where you can only use one), and also apologetic about the refund, etc, not being handled property any of the time we called. She will set up for me to pick up the money owed me in cash. She was willing to drop it off, but that is okay. i upped my review from a 1 to a 2 as a result of her actions. SHE gets a 4. read more

Very very great tasting sub (steak ) , but the meat was kinda skimpy , seemed better in the past ! read more

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria - Steak sub - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

Always friendly staff when I go in here. Family owned old fashioned customer service and the food is always fresh, delicious. Love the calamari, pizza and wings. Next time I want to try their subs ! read more

Today I called in an order for a Tuesday special, spaghetti and meatballs. Usually just over $11. I asked that my bread be plain as it is when it comes out of the oven. When my husband went in to pick it up he was told it was close to $18. They told him I asked for pasta and meatballs and to get the special I would have had to say spaghetti and meatballs . Which is what I did. And guess what, when we opened it.... It was spaghetti and meatballs. Good thing we took it home because stopping at north ponds for a picnic we would have had another surprise. It was cold. Had to be microwaved. I would have thought they would have made it good. Nope. Now I understand the poor ratings. The bread was perfect. read more

Stopped on 4-14-23, pizza was ok. Thicker doughy pizza not my thing, service was extremely friendly. Sat at the bar.

I just ordered from their Arthur Treacher's menu, the Famous Seafood Platter. Now, Salvatore's has never in all these years brought me bad food until tonight. This was the worst. The hushpuppies were burnt black. How could you guys put that in the container? That guy should be fired. The piece of fish was one texture from outside coating straight through to the supposed to be fish. The fries were mushy. The clams tasted good but were very soft, not like a fried clams should be. I asked for malt vinegar and received....NONE. I mean what is going on down there tonight? My niece got a pizza slice and wing combo and couldn't have been happier. Obviously the guy on the fryer needs an additional training session and I mean at his new job. For over $30.00 plus tip I certainly expect to enjoy the meal myself instead of enjoying watching my pit bull enjoying it. read more

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria - Burned up hush puppies and everything is fried and not crispy. It is soft and nasty. The fish tastes like paper. - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

Terrible service. We ordered a large pizza from them, and they said it would be ready in 20-25 minutes. When I got there they said they had no record of my order, despite one of the four employees at the front counter remembering my wife's name when she called in the order. They said the order was not in their system, and treated me like I was the one who screwed up. I then called my wife, and asked her to text me a screenshot of Salvatore's phone number that she called. I showed this to the employees, and they said nothing to me and just smirked. No apologies, no nothing. Obviously, they lost a customer, as I will never go there again. Salvatore-please train your employees better, and please teach them about proper customer service! read more

So I haven't had their pizza but their chicken parm sub is the best in town, delicious. I ordered one from the Bay road location a few times and it tastes completely different (not very good at all). This location nailed it though! read more

We don't eat pizza too often but when we do, Salvatore's is my favorite in Webster. The odd thing is, they seem to be a bit inconsistent from this location to the one on Bay Rd (which I think has better food more often). I've had days were the pizza is incredible and the last time, it was just "ho-hum". Sometimes the cheese is so gooey and perfect and other times, it looks like the pizza had been sitting around for hours already. Their regular prices seem very high to me. I personally don't want to spend close to $20 for a large pizza but if keep an eye out for coupons in the local papers, occasionally you will find a large for $10! Last time I had that $10 coupon and told them on the phone when ordering, I felt like the pizza was "skimpier" than usual. (Not sure if they cut back on toppings because they were making less money on it??) So next time I plan on ordering normally and showing up with the coupon and having the price adjusted then. And be warned, half toppings get charged at full toppings price (kind of weird). Seems better to just get full toppings. We haven't tried many other items other than pizza. The boneless wings were ok. The pizza fries were ok too. The deep fried mushrooms were decent- but kind of pricey. I was really in the mood for jalapeño poppers once and was surprised they didn't have them. All in all, we'll definitely return!!! read more

I've ordered from Salvatore's many times and every time I use delivery it always takes over an hour to get the food. Also I always have issues using their website when I need to update my payment method. I tried ordering again tonight but I again could not get my credit card to update so I ended up calling the store to place my order. I ended up having to call the order in. The girl that took the order was not very easy to deal with as she interrupted me several times and placed me on hold in the middle of my call. Not great customer service. I will be going to another pizza place from now on. read more

Salvatore's went from average to below average in less than a year. I am only thinking they are cost cutting or whatever they are doing because it used to be a decent pie. Bad customer service with 14 and 15 year olds who mumble when talking and have zero customer service skills. Too expensive to return. read more

I love Salvatore's food, just not from this location. Bay road and Monroe ave have much better food. I have ordered a shaved steak sub on two occasions from this location and both times the subs were so soggy I couldn't even eat it. I figured maybe they just can't make subs (even tho shaved steak is supposed to be a Salvatore's signature). I figured I'd try my luck with boneless buffalo wings but they were equally as disgusting and just as inedible. The boneless wings came burnt without enough sauce on them. I will never order from this location again. It's just a waste of your money. read more

I have lived in Webster for 62 years. This is one of those go to places. We have stopping here occasionally since they opened this location. We have enjoyed the varied menu and obviously, the pizza. One slice is really two. And delicious. Customer service is very good and the sitting area is comfortable. They will continue to see us every week or so. read more

We have have ordered from this Salvatore's and we never have had an issue. The last 4 times we have ordered from this location and I would pick up the order and get home and we would be missing items. We would call the store and they would apologize and fix the problem but this has happened 3 more times. I think the management needs to train there employees better to double check the order to make sure the full order is there for pick up. I am not looking for anything free but if this keeps up i am going to have to look at another place to get my pizza. I am very disappointed with this location and hope they can get their act together. Thank you! read more

The pizza is really good and the staff is friendly. The old fashioned pepperoni was okay and the buffalo chicken was pretty good. Also one slice is really two slices read more

Great pizza! It's a staple in Rochester for a good reason. Has an exceptional menu and the staff is always really agreeable. read more

Absolutly my favorite pizza shop in town. With their full menu you will definitely find something delicious to eat. They by far have the best subs in town. Their staff is amazing and it's always such a fun positive atmosphere. I love coming there for dinner or even just stopping in for a few drinks at their full bar. read more

I order from Salvatore's on North Ave at least once a week and every order is to my exact liking and cooked excellently. Wings, pizza, subs, and the many other items are fantastic and in many varieties. The customer service is excellent and they are welcoming as soon you walk in the door. Definitely a good place when you want to have a lazy night of no cooking and just get pizza. read more

Restaurant is very clean and the food is fresh. I feel I get what I pay for. The employees are nice and friendly. Great place to eat.

This Salvatores is horrible. You give them your order and you're specific with it. I swore I would never order from this particular establishment again. But my daughter ordered from here and I asked for extra Mayo on my sub, well when I got the sub I got tons of lettuce, oil and honey mustard but no mayo. So I called and express that there was no mayo on my sub. Well I was informed that he would send a driver to bring me some Mayo. REALLY???? And if this gets deleted I will screen shot this and repost it again. Never again will I order from this particular Salvatores again. read more

Dear lord, went here for a buffalo chicken wrap. Got a ton of sauce. The wrap was loaded with it. Outside and inside. Not a ton of chicken. Really sloppy. I want to say that this only reflects on the food. The staff and over all look of the place would make you think the food was good. Need some standards and some training. Really feel ripped off. If anyone one needs buffalo sauce stop on by and I will pour you out some. read more

Their chicken finger sub was Fantastic! Super saucy, great blue cheese and fresh veggies on a fresh and flavorful roll, which tasted homemade. It was huge and was easily two meals. Their pepperoni and mushroom pizza was also great - loaded with toppings and delicious. But their homemade chocolate chip cookies were amazing! They also had a decent tap list and friendly staff! We will be back! read more

The pizza and calzone are pretty average. I would prefer another small pizza place nearby. I tried pizzas, which had nothing special in them. Customer service is pretty awful too, if you ask me. read more

Salvatore's in Webster is some pretty good Sicilian style pizza. I stop in for a slice a few times a year and at work, we order their sheet pizzas. They make the only good sheet pizza I've ever had. They sauce it up nice with plenty of toppings. I'm not sure why other places skimp on sauce for their sheet pizzas. The wings are mediocre and I haven't tried anything else but pizza and wings. read more

We have ordered pizza from this salvatores multiple times asking for our medium pizza to be cut into squares and it never is. Today we ordered 2 medium 1 topping pizzas that cost over $40 and asked for them to be cut into squares and yet again delivered wrong. When we called my wife heard the girl on the phone call her a bitch for calling to tell them it's wrong. We will NEVER order from this salvatores or any other again! Marks will treat us like family! read more

Last night was the 3rd time we have ordered delivery from Salvatore's in Webster. We ordered a pizza which was delivered. When we opened the pizza box, it looked as though it was carried sideways. It was all slid together on one side of the box, slices on top of each other and stuck to the lid. Well, we paid $20 for this pizza and tipped the driver $5, so we called them. The girl who answered seemed just plain annoyed with us, never apologizing, and talking with attitude. We were to get another pizza delivered. When we got off the phone we started thinking... and just by the way the phone call was handled, we didn't feel comfortable getting another pizza from them. Who knows what they would do to it if they were so annoyed us. So I called back again, I asked for a manager this time. I told him that I thought if they'd made a mistake with an order that they'd be apologetic about it and instead we were treated poorly on the phone. To my surprise, the "manager" began to defend the girl we spoke with!! Horrible management, he should've just made it right. All in all, we drove the pizza there and returned it to them ourselves, got our money back, lost $5 on the delivery boy and we were still hungry! This was the worst customer service I have had in a long time and we will never order there again, which is sad because their food is SO GOOD. read more

Ordered a sheet pizza and thin crust. Order came not a thin crust, hardly any sauce on it. Didn't taste to bad. Was disappointed since we are from an area in Chicagoland that makes pretty good pizza. read more

AOK. I tried Salvatore's for the first time last night while visiting family in the area. We got four pizzas (for pickup)... A pepperoni, a sausage and pepperoni, a cheese, and one with mushrooms, olives, peppers and onions. The dough was fresh and tasty, yummy crust... The sauce was unremarkable, not bad, but not tasty either... Plenty of fresh cheese, but the toppings for me, were the shining star... Lots of pepperoni all over, no skimping her whatsoever. The sausage pieces were big 'ol chunks of sausage, lots of cheese, the veggies were diced small (which I like) and were fresh and tasty. At just over $80, it was a tad expensive for four pizzas, but overall Salvatore's was a delicious treat. read more

The pizza was good! Try the sweet and sour chicken! Strangely delicious!! Service was good, felt welcome and appreciTed!

I like the Sweet Country Breaded Wings and I get mac salad with it. One time they left out the mac salad. I called and the person I spoke to was nice and said they could deliver one or they could put a note in and it would be free the next time. I was satisfied with that. Next time I ordered the Mac Snack with breaded sweet country and got regular wings, not breaded. This time, last Friday, I ordered the ten piece breaded sweet country and got regular wings again. I agree with another reviewer that said the person on the phone talks way too fast and is in a hurry in general. This isn't that important, just annoying and frankly, I think there are other places that give better service and food is as good or better. I'd rather go someplace else, get decent, un-rushed service and get what I ordered than to put up with these little annoyances. read more

I will never go back again. Ordered chicken fingers and fries. It took 25 minutes just for that when they were not busy at all. The fries were rock hard, cold and I would guess to be old. Chicken fingers were also very small and seemed to be over cooked as well. Def not worth the $$ read more

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria - Biggest chicken finger was the size of a ketchup packet. . - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

Check your order before you leave. I ordered a tuna wrap today and got turkey, another order we asked for sausage on our pizza and it wasn't there (and got charged for additional topping) and yet another order for a tuna wrap they forgot to put the tuna in the wrap. Very disappointed with this location. To their credit they did offer a store credit. read more

Go here all the time for lunch the slice display is huge and the pizza is amazing. They have so many TV's and Sunday ticket my new hang out. The staff there is amazing so friendly and quick. read more