Cancel

Open app

Search

Shake Shack Middletown

3.0 (9 reviews)
Open • 10:00 am - 10:00 pm
Updated a few days ago

Order Shake Shack Middletown Takeout or Delivery

Shake Shack Middletown Photos

You might also consider

More like Shake Shack Middletown

Recommended Reviews - Shake Shack Middletown

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 14
Thanks 3
Love this 14
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Chris A.
179
1498
1178

9 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ellie K.

Ellie K.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ellie K.

Ellie K.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ellie K.

Ellie K.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Ellie K.

Ellie K.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Food is just fair. They don't leave room for custom orders. Pricing is mid-range. The ambiance is a bit cold. Easy and convenient parking.

Business owner information

Photo of Ellie K.

Ellie K.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Shake Shack Middletown

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for New American 16,772 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Sissy's Place - Chocolate Chip Pancakes, OJ, and blueberry pancakes.

Sissy's Place

4.2(25 reviews)
1.8 mi

A truly beloved local eatery for some seriously delicious food. We came on a Thursday, and there…read morewas one waitress and a cook, and they handled all the orders with efficiency and grace. We ordered a stack of blueberry pancakes and another stack of chocolate chip pancakes. They are served with butter on the side and pure maple syrup. Also ordered was a side of sausage links. Is your mouth watering yet, because mine is watering as I'm writing my review. You can also order beverages such as coffee (free refills), and they even have fresh juice (regular or large). They serve more than just breakfast items. They also have sandwiches, wraps, and other wonderful lunch options The only caveat is that they only take cash. I didn't realize that, but I was thankful we happened to have cash on us. Great service and the sayings on the wall, as well as the photos, give it a warm and fun feeling as I perused at them. Parking is a breeze as they are in a strip where parking is ample.

We love Sissy's! We moved to the area last year and have been here a few times for breakfast…read more The eggs benedict are awesome. Seriously one of the best I've had. The french toast is good as well. Home fries have been a bit undercooked and fruit side dish was a bit skimpy but it's a no frills, fairly cheap type of place. The ladies that work there are very sweet and make you feel welcomed. We will keep stopping by on the weekends!

Photos
Sissy's Place - Interior

Interior

Sissy's Place - Blueberries are abundant in these pancakes.

Blueberries are abundant in these pancakes.

Sissy's Place - The storefront.

See all

The storefront.

Belford Bistro - Thanksgiving special takeout mushroom appetizer before the oven (delicious)

Belford Bistro

4.0(151 reviews)
1.8 mi
•$$$

It wasn't good. Service was so poor. The other tables got their water and bread. I didn't get any…read morewater for a really long time until I had to ask my waitress again. She didn't bother giving me bread when she gave the other table bread. I wasn't exactly dressed up because I spent the day shopping. Worst part of not only being ignored, was that my salmon entree was so fishy. Completely fishy. So disorganised and chaotic on a Friday night. The one time I went was a fluke. I'm not gonna return.

I have come here between half a dozen and a dozen times. I swear this is some of the best food I…read morehave had in Jersey. Tonight I am writing this because I just had a rigatoni dish the world needs to know about. Homemade pasta, San marzano tomatoes, vodka, Parmesan reggiano topped with crispy eggplant. I cannot remember a time in my life when I have had dish this good. Service is amazing. Unbelievably sweet every time we have gone. Very local feel. I just love it here for so many different dishes. But mother of God ... that rigatoni. So good. I took a picture but the lighting is bad and I am a human horror show when it comes to taking pictures. Not sure it does it justice.

Photos
Belford Bistro - From ceiling to halls..let the gray drip down them wallsss.  Was this a former BDSM dungeon?  Who decorated this pace??

From ceiling to halls..let the gray drip down them wallsss. Was this a former BDSM dungeon? Who decorated this pace??

Belford Bistro - Thanksgiving special takeout turkey 2 lbs (perfectly sliced and prepared...avoids all the trouble)

Thanksgiving special takeout turkey 2 lbs (perfectly sliced and prepared...avoids all the trouble)

Belford Bistro - TOP SOUP BUTTERNUT SQUASH & CARROT OUTSTANDING!

See all

TOP SOUP BUTTERNUT SQUASH & CARROT OUTSTANDING!

Charlie’s of Lincroft - Meatballs

Charlie’s of Lincroft

3.4(177 reviews)
4.9 mi

First time here and overall really enjoyed it. The restaurant itself looks very nice and has a…read moregreat atmosphere. We went around 2:00 PM the day before Mother's Day, and it was pretty quiet inside besides a few larger groups. Service was kind and welcoming. The food took a little while to come out, which surprised me since it didn't seem too busy, but maybe there was a party or something going on elsewhere. For appetizers, we got the Brussels sprouts and the warm feta dip -- both were absolutely fabulous and so delicious. Definitely recommend them. Next time I want to try the fried calamari too. For our entrées, I was deciding between getting a pizza, but ended up ordering the Lincroft Burger while my friend got the Charlie's Burger. We cut them in half and switched so we could each try both. Great idea because both burgers were really good. I personally prefer my fries extra crispy and these weren't quite there, but they still tasted good. The cookie skillet dessert LOOKED amazing. We were way too stuffed to order it this time, but next visit I'm definitely saving room for it. Overall, I would come again. Enjoy!

We gave it another chance and it came through. The burgers…read morewere 10/10 Server was wonderful and the Christmas decor was charming! Glad we tried again

Photos
Charlie’s of Lincroft - Party space upstairs 70 people capacity

Party space upstairs 70 people capacity

Charlie’s of Lincroft - FRIED CALAMARI     $18 Sweet & Spicy Soy Glaze, Blistered Shishito Peppers, Korean Chili Aioli & Scallions. Delicious.

FRIED CALAMARI $18 Sweet & Spicy Soy Glaze, Blistered Shishito Peppers, Korean Chili Aioli & Scallions. Delicious.

Charlie’s of Lincroft - Bar area

See all

Bar area

Triumph Brewing Company - Flat Iron Steak- Roasted fingerling potato, ancho chili steak sauce.

Triumph Brewing Company

3.8(158 reviews)
4.4 mi
•$$
Free parking
Outdoor seating

After a four hour drive down from Rhode Island, my partner and I pulled into Red Bank and made a…read morebeeline for Triumph Brewing Company on Bridge Avenue. Sometimes you just need a cold beer and a bite, and Triumph delivered on both fronts. The space itself sets the tone nicely. Raw wood beams, big glass garage door-style windows flooding the room with light, and a mix of modern and rustic that somehow manages to feel like both at once. Green plants are positioned throughout, around the bar and seating areas, adding just the right amount of warmth throughout. The space is generous too; a large bar anchors the room with plenty of big tables spread throughout. It could clearly handle a crowd. It's the kind of place that makes you want to settle in. The service matched the vibe. Our bartender was attentive from the start, and at one point a second bartender passing by stopped to check if we needed to place an order. When we told him we were already taken care of, he smiled and moved on. Small moment, but it says something about the culture of a place. I started with the Baltic Porter, a solid pint, dark and roasty with that smoothness the style calls for. Good, but it was the second beer that really got my attention. I noticed the bartender working a hand pump and knew right then I'd be having their Pub Ale next. That's the real deal right there; a true cask pour is a rarity, and this one showed why it's worth seeking out. The ale was alive in a way you just don't get from a CO2 tap, soft carbonation with layers of flavor that opened up as it warmed slightly in the glass. It was genuinely awesome. For food we kept it light, a couple of snacks to set ourselves up for the rest of the evening. My partner had the falafel; fresh, nicely seasoned, with real crunch and plenty of accoutrements to keep things interesting. It was exactly the kind of bite that tides you over without weighing you down. I went with a special: Weisswurst. It was juicy and flavorful; served on a nice bun with mustard and the expected trimmings. My only gripe was the portion size, could've used just a bit more sausage. The real surprise was the side of housemade chips, which were exceptional. The kind of thing you find yourself reaching for long after you've finished everything else. Unfortunately, we arrived just as a band was packing up, but according to the schedule posted on the wall, they have live music quite a few days a week. All in all Triumph was the perfect setup for our little mid-winter getaway.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

Second time that I visit Triumph Brewery. The first time was mostly drinks and last night was for…read moredinner and drinks and to listen to live music. The place is really pretty and has two floors and a really nice vibe. The music was really great. It was this kind of sexy lounging jazzy type of music. The trumpet player was really good. The band's name was Red123 and I am a fan. We sat and ordered food at the bar and our bartender was great. The other two guys were equally as nice and personable. Now the negative. Although it's considered a brewery, they do not have flights. So keep this in mind when you do visit. I ended up have the Czech dark beer, which was good. It was a large amount as well. My friend had one of the Pilsners and it was pretty good as well. The food for me wasn't that great. I ordered baked oysters with breadcrumbs and bacon on top and it was to be shared with my friend. Unfortunately, the oysters were not cooked thoroughly because they were still kind of slimy and soft and not hot and they did not taste baked. I was OK with it because I do eat raw oysters, but she does not eat raw fish so she didn't have any. I also ordered a Cubano sandwich listed as containing braised pulled pork, Swiss cheese and ham with Bavarian mustard with thinly sliced pickles on the side. I ate half sandwich and it tasted ok. However, for the second half of the sandwich, I decided that I just wanted to eat the insides and not eat the bread. Unfortunately, the pulled pork that was in the sandwich was tasteless and very dry. I do cook roast pork as well as pulled so I know what it's supposed to taste like. I did not notice it at first because the dressing on the bread masked the bland taste of the pork. I did not continue to eat the pork and only ate a piece of the ham and the cheese. I do plan to go back for the vibe and music and if hungry, will try a different dish.

Photos
Triumph Brewing Company
Triumph Brewing Company - Red Wine Braised Short Rib- Roasted carrots, parsnip puree.

Red Wine Braised Short Rib- Roasted carrots, parsnip puree.

Triumph Brewing Company

See all

Shake Shack Middletown - newamerican - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...