Classic nyc slice joint. don't go expecting di fara. I prefer a Sicilian slice but the traditional also hits the spot. I think that says it all. read more

What a NYC pizza joint should be. Orange plastic benches with attached tables and posters of Sicily, which have not been changed since the early '80s. Pizza is fast, fresh, and hot. Crisp crust with perfect ratios of bread, sauce, and cheese. No need to venture beyond the classics here. read more

This place has been around FOREVER. And by forever I mean at least since I was born. Because that's pretty much when things started to matter. Right? This is where I had my first slice, so Smiling Pizzeria can be credited with starting a lifelong love affair between cheese, sauce, crust and me. It isn't the best pizza I've ever had, but it's always fresh, and it tastes just like childhood. And I mean that in a nostalgic, non-creepy way. They say you never forget your first time, so Smiling Pizzeria and [name redacted], I'll remember you always. read more

Smiling Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've been coming to "Smiley's" pizzeria (as he we used to call it) on & off for a couple decades now. Sometimes it's really good, sometimes it's okay and a few times it wasn't good at all. Recently they've been on the better side, but today was an okay day. Smiling pizzeria is a typical old-fashioned NYC pizzeria. They have a small variety of pizzas, beef patties (which a lot of pizzerias aren't doing now-a-days), calzones, garlic knots, zeppoles (another hard to find item!), mozzarella sticks, chicken rolls, i think they have knishes, etc. I asked for my son's pizza "not to hot" but when he got it, it wasn't heated at all. I wasn't that hungry but knew I should eat something and opted for an order of garlic knots knowing the kids would eat at least 1 each. The knots where fresh, and tasted good because of that pp fact alone. There wasn't much flavor to them though. And my daughter said her beef patty was spicy so she didn't eat most of the meat. (Yes, I know they don't actually make the beef patties- they just heat them up. Perhaps they ordered the wrong one?). Masks are no longer mandatory here & social distancing is not enforced. Also, a family was allowed to enter and sit with their dog. I love dogs, but they don't belong inside restaurants/diners/pizzerias. I gave 4 stars because most of the time the food is good, and the staff are nice to the customers. They might beef at each other, but they're nice to the customers! lol. Also, they have 2 tiny restrooms for customers only. read more

When I moved to the neighborhood I stopped in a few times hoping for a great slice - always mediocre to disappointing. However, the other night a bunch of us came in after a night of karaoke at the Old Carriage Inn nearby and I was pleasantly surprised! I ordered my late night slice, it came back toasty warm, very edible and actually pretty decent. Would I special order a pie from this place? Never. But emergency slices are starting to sway me. read more

Smiling Pizza Restaurant - Emergency late night slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I've somewhat grown up with this pizza shop. I'm from neighboring Sunset Park, but my cousins grew up four blocks from here, and since I visited them almost every weekend-- we came here a lot. Also, my JHS was about ten blocks away; so, I can say I've had my fair share of Smiling Pizza. The shop is located right above the F train (7th Avenue station) what will always stick out is the prices right above each food item. Certain items are a bit high in price, but the pizza, knots, and beef patties are typically on point. They usually have four or five guys behind the counter which allows for only a short wait to place your order. Quality slices, short wait times, prices clearly labeled, and conveniently located near the train; if all of this sounds appealing to you, then give Smiley's a shot. read more

Smiling Pizza Restaurant - Prices clearly labeled - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Got a plain pizza and garlic knots. I'd been here a lot in my childhood and always thought it ranked second or third in the neighborhood. The top spot is gone now. Pizza is still more than decent and the garlic knots are big and you get a good amount of them. The delivery took FOREVER, almost two hours. But you'll never lose if you're just going in for a couple of slices read more

Smiling Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

One of the Best Pizzerias in NY. Been enjoying Smiling since the late 1980's. Awesome guys have kept this place running while dozens of others have come and gone. They inspired me to Open, Own and operate my own NY style Pizzerias out West for 25 years. I hope they continue to Serve Park Slope for years to come. read more

It's a decent slice. Very busy, small place. Only a few tables and chairs. Corner location just grab and go.

I didn't leave smiling Well, it was a half smile b/c it's pizza It was regular. Nothing to shine my bright whites at but also not frown It was lite on the sauce. Why!? The cheese didn't move ... I know that sounds crazy but do you get it? Like... mozzarella cheese (most hot cheese) stretches when breaking it apart. It started moving towards the middle where the oil was. Oh. It also wasn't oily enough. I like my NYC pizza to be oily. The level of oil that snobs blot with a napkin. .... I blot with my crust! Then I remembered the price for such a regular pepperoni pizza: $3.50 Nah homes, this slice is worth a buck. One dollar. Plus fifty cent for pepperoni. But when in park slope a $1.50 slice will cost two more dollars read more

See all

I ordered a pie and it was ice cold, all the cheese slid off the pie and was just left in front of my door. my neighbor rang my bell to let me know the pizza was there. this was ordered with grub hub. I've been ordering from Smiling and eating there since the late 70's. when I called i was told they are not responsible for the delivery drivers. I've never had a problem with Smiling until now. They have lost a loyal customer. how do you not stand by your service. they didn't want to hear it. I got satisfaction from grub hub who issued a refund. I guess business is so good they can afford losing customers. read more

Let me start by telling you that my family orders from Smiling at least twice a week @ about $75 per order. There was never really a problem because it's NYC fast and furious, I don't expect over-the-top courtesy.. BUT, this past time pushed me over to write a review - here's what happened: I called (917) 905-3403 - their number from Seamless. Someone picked up the phone, I told them I'd like to place an order for delivery: * he said, "can you hold for a minute?" * I said "no problem" * 8 minutes on hold (because I can see the duration on my phone) * the hold system rang their line again, and no one was picking up * after the 10th ring, I hung up * I called the same number 4 more times, but kept getting hanged up on * after my fifth call, someone picked up * I told him that I'm a loyal customer who orders about $150 per week from them, and that I had been on hold for 10 minutes * nonchalantly, he said, "the phone's are messed up" * AND THEN he said, "hold please" * so I said, "wait, you're going to put me on hold after 10 minutes of hold? what kind of service is that? can I speak to the manager?" * he said, "I am the manager" * I said, "what's your name?" * he said, "Alex" * I said, "you're going to put me on hold again?" * (silence) * I said, "never again, Alex" * he said, "no problem" * and then he hung up. No acknowledgement, no apology, but instead trying to put me back on hold. I understand they're busy, but I'm one of the people that have gotten their business to be busy. But to hell with that... I've known this store for 30+ years. The older owners/managers were real people. They don't sugar coat relationships, but they were at least responsible and had some semblance of customer service. My family, and the 3 other families that always order from Smiling are gone. Never again, Alex. read more

This place has been around forever. They make a solid slice, and have a ton of seating. The decor is also super traditional Brooklyn. Bright orange plastic booths. Brick walls. The works. I mean, probably not that good if you're not drunk, but how often are you not drunk? I don't have a drinking problem, you do. read more

See all

Favorite pizza place in the area. Directly out of the subway entrance/exit. Open late, cheap, and fast! I've had regular slices & specialty slices & they've never disappointed. The veggies slice is THICC & won't leave you wanting more. The guys who work there are all super nice & polite! read more

Smiling Pizza Restaurant - That thicc slice! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

best pizza in the neighborhood! even my family from out of town confirmed. delicious!

I ate two slices of pepperoni pizza it was so delicious because one of my nurses from my unit bought it and it was his last day he asked me which pizza is the best around Park slope I told him smiling Pizza so I do recommend this pizza shop to anyone !!!!!! read more

That Grandma pizza!!!!!!!!!! Love this place and especially their Grandma pizza: sinple and just sooo good read more

Like ordering a pizza at Chuck e Cheese but the nasty pizza isn't accompanied by any games. This isn't real New York pizza, it's oily goop on a too thin crust. Pretty sure any other park slope pizzeria is a better spot. read more

The grandma pizza is the best delivery pizza in Park Slope. If they ever go out of business, my marriage is in trouble!

This is the best NY pizza I have had! And I'm from Chicago so I am picky about what pizza I eat! The sauce and cheese were so good. I will definitely keep coming back for more! read more

Smiling Pizza Restaurant - Cheese slice and Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Awesome pizza super quick delivery. Always a go to. Pasta dishes are great too. Definitely worth a try.

Finally. A place in Park Slope where I can buy pizza by the slice! But sadly, bland, generic pizza at best. And the stuff they had sitting around at the counter.... yipes. I think I'm going to wind up eating at every restaurant in Park Slope before I find something I half-way like. I had better luck in Brownsville. Sheesh. read more

Solid slice, with a simple straightforward sauce. I wouldn't come out of my way for it, but it will satisfy your craving. More than the pizza I dig the atmosphere. I grew up in places like this. Plastic wood patterned booths, neon in the windows, the guys behind the counter busting each others balls. It's nice. read more

Smiling Pizza Restaurant - Couldn't wait - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This place is fine, an average pizza spot that's down the block from me. I usually just get a cheese slice, but it's really not the best. In my opinion it's too cheesy and undercooked. That being said, I do usually like a crispy slice which might be why. All in all it's good pizza, but it's overpriced. If you need a slice and you're in the area, its a good option. Personally prefer Joe's Pizzeria in South Slope. read more

Pizza was good and quick, really wish they had a vegan cheese though! Ended up getting the salad one which was fine Most other places in P.S. do have vegan cheese so not sure if I'll be back, maybe with a larger group sometime :) read more

Everything about smiling pizza is amazing ! Staff is super kind, delivery is VERY fast and the sauce is just insane. Favorite pizza spot in Park Slope read more

This place knows pizza. They've got it down to a fine art. Small wonder, then, that it's the kind of place that's been around for years, despite an adversarial real estate market and especially uptight neighborhood. No pretensions here, just come in for a slice or two, or a pie if you've got mouths to feed. The grandma pizza is a personal favorite, perfection served on a paper-thin crust that crunches at each bite. read more

Smiling has always been my go-to for Italian take out Since we moved into the neighborhood nearly 30 yrs ago. But I have got to say, last night's spaghetti & meatballs was amazing! I have always been a fan of their sauce, but whatever magic happened in the kitchen last night took it to another level. Bravo Guys ! My husband & I ate almost the entire dish, SO GOOD! Keep up the great food service ! read more

This is such a mom and pop pizza place. It's Smiling! I think it's been around for at least over a decade and you always see families milling around here in the heart of the Slope. I was tipsy stumbling in this weekend and decided to try a slice for the first time. Just plain pepperoni and cheese, please. A little greasy but it hits the spot. A little over-priced for what it is. A one topping slice was $4.25. Boo. But I would equate it with a Brooklyn neighborhood version of Rays. The cheese and sauce ratio is spot on and it tastes delicious. It's just nothing special or to write home about. Clean restaurant and people were sitting there eating in at around 12am. So they must have a good groove going. Great also that it's open late. read more

Why 2 stars? Here's why I took one start off because they weren't friendly. I don't speak for other customers but I am sure they'll agree. When we walk in we want to feel welcomed. I am not saying I want fireworks going off and then dancing but a "Hey welcome to Smiling pizzeria, what would you like?" Or any type of welcome would be great. Instead they are just doing their own thing until you have to wave or speak up to get their attention. Took off my second star because they charge you a card fee of $1. Now I know what you're thinking "it's just a dollar" but my point is customers shouldn't have to pay a fee at all. Some stores lie about being charged when they accept payment off a credit/debt card. Just to make the customer buy more food to make more money off it. Ok maybe the first two reasons you guys might not agree with but my last star I took off you will agree with me. It was because the pizza wasn't that great. Don't get me wrong it's good if you want something at the moment that will feed your hunger. It taste good but it wasn't great like some other pizzerias I've tried. They got one star for a ok looking place and the second for have napkins, powders etc available for you on each table and because like I said the pizza was ok. read more

Smiling Pizza Restaurant - This is what I got and honestly it was ok not the best I had. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I have been coming here since I could walk. My parents grew up coming here as well. Conveniently located near the park, and train station. The chicken Parmesan hero has been a staple of mine (especially on a snow day!) The pizza is not brick oven, thin crust but because of my memories here as a child, I will always be a fan. Those swinging doors to the bathroom have made this pizzeria spot a park slope landmark! read more

Smiling Pizza has been around since I've been born and I have to give them credit for lasting so long. They're really not bad by any means, with a crust slightly thicker than the New York norm they're actually a nice change of pace and really one of the better corner pizzerias. This place is always packed with children however, so try to avoid going there after school hours... unless you can only enjoy pizza to the soundtrack of loud chatter and the backdrop of mothers glaring at you for taking up precious space sans offspring. read more

They have the best eggplant parmesan hero. Their pizza is out of this world. The people who take the orders over the phone are very respectful. The delivery men always get a big tip from me because they're on time and professional. read more

The chicken roll wasn't so good! Pizza is all right! Not the best quality! Prices are good for a park slope location read more

I've been to this pizzeria twice, with the same intentions both times. I was hungry, it was late, I wanted pizza...and they were open. Do I think they have good pizza? It's your standard New York pizza slice. Nothing extra ordinary, neither is it next level, it's just a NY pizza slice. The staff is really friendly and they accept cash or credit. Yes, they have restrooms just in case.... There mozzarella sticks were not that great so I don't suggest getting the mozzarella sticks, I do suggest there white slice and there regular slice with pepperoni or without, but who doesn't love pepperoni?? If you're hungry for late night pizza, and don't want to spend the money to go to a coal/brick oven pizza place this is the pizzeria for you. Metered parking, located on the corner. Quick service. read more

Food is ok. Cash only. Food was ok. I might come back. Food was ok. Heck I'll come back. Since the food was ok. read more

Not a great attitude in store or for delivery from employees. For mediocre food, I'm not willing to deal with this place's staff, not even if it means supporting a local business. Shop anywhere else for quality and positivity. read more

It was the first time a roommate of mine has ever offered dinner to me. He said to me, yo I'm ording pizza you want? I was like no thanks. Pizza delivery guy came and went and he then said to me, I bought a pie man, help yourself. Hesitant about getting chummy with my roommie/ summer room renter, I thought what the heck - I was too busy to cook my dinner anyhow. Hmm ok... good amount of pepperoni, I'm impressed... Crust is a little thick but it maintained good sauce/ cheese ratio. I have to be honest because I can't comment on how much it costed since I basically ninja'd two slices. This place is perfect for nostalgic Brooklyn pizza because of the thick and chewy crust, however these days I prefer it to be a little thinner. Call me carb-conscous... or a pig cuz I ninja'd another two slices an hour later! Good call roomie, next pie is on me! read more

Pretty good as far as delivery goes. I've ordered from them about half a dozen times and the quality is consistent and it is delivered hot. It's not going to make me forget about the best pizza I've ever head, but remember, this is delivery read more

Smiling Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Picked up some pizza & spinach roll. Good stuff. Been coming here for decades. The problem was the pizza guy tried to bully me into tipping him and put someone ahead of me as punishment for not tipping him. It was a pick up order. Then he perposely didn't give me what I asked for. Wow read more