We stopped here last night and got a few slices for dinner. It's great that you can just order by the slice. I loved it! Staff were friendly! We were able to walk to the water with our slices to enjoy them and had a perfect first evening in Nantucket! read more

Steamboat Wharf Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

The service was weird. We asked for a whole pizza ($28), which was just made and sitting on display, and she said we had to wait another 15 minutes for a new pizza or pay the per-slice price, which would make it much more expensive at $6.50 per slice (around $39). So we waited. The pizza tasted all right. It's meant to sooth any late-night post-drinks muchies but given the lack of ambiance and frills, it's just an okay spot to get food. If I did a little more research, I would consider Pi Pizza or Oath Pizza, so read those reviews and make your decision! Make sure you get a receipt like the other reviewers said! Cashier was a bit shady about that. There's no seating inside, no AC, and it's hot as you know what! They do have shakers with cheese and red pepper flakes and garlic. read more

Steamboat Wharf Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

The pizza itself was great, but not worth the price. As a visitor, I check things out where I'm going to see where I may want to go and this was one of the places I checked out beforehand. And while, I realize websties can sometimes be outdated, there's is sersiously outdated. On their website their '2 slice special' is only supposed to be $8.75, but in reality its $12. That's a pretty substantial difference to the point where its not like it missed 1 price increase but multiple. And again, while the pizza itself was great, its not worth the price even if it was for the price on the website. read more

Steamboat Wharf Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

If a slice of pizza is your thing, or you just need a quick little something to knosh on to take the hairy edge off then the Steamboat Wharf Pizza is the answer. Great location, great summer hours, and off-season hours too. Wide selection. Excellent prices. Clean. Friendly staff. read more

Good spot to grab a quick slice, staff were nice, and the pizza was good! It's a stop in grab a slice and go vibe, no tables and chairs, but it's perfect for where it's located - cause you can simply run in quick, grab a slice, and walk around the town. read more

Steamboat Wharf Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

Pizza was decent. We ordered some for take out during vacation recently for a large group. The pizzas are huge so that worked out well. It's nice you can customize though there are limited options for toppings but we did get one with roasted garlic and pepperoni and that was done well. The roasted garlic were small pieces and added a good depth of flavor to an otherwise basic pizza. read more

It was sooo good and the service was super fast too. I got two slices of cheese and may go back today for more!

$6 for a cheese slice, $6.95 for pepperoni. Service was not good. This is Nantucket, but still. Oath is the way to go for pizza on this island. read more

Steamboat Wharf Pizza - a slice of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Local on Nantucket's opinion... conveniently located right on the strip... steamboat has the best pizza on island along with the friendliest staff. The crust is great crispy on the thinner side, toppings are fresh. My favorite is the pepperoni or sausage. Hawaiian is excellent also. The pepperoni will send your taste buds on a ride. The sausage, notes of fennel tangy sauce great ratio of cheese to toppings. This place will not disappoint! The staff is funny always a smile on there face! A dollar or 2 or $5 will go a long way. Best pizza on island must get! read more

We were getting bikes from the rental shop next door and were starving. We popped in to grab a couple of quick slices. Unfortunately this place is ridiculously expensive for what it is, and the pizza really is not great. There is not any seating, just a small spot to grab and go. That being said, it was quick and convenient. read more

My one diminutive slice of tepid cheese pizza was $4.70. The sauce was fine, cheese had potential but was burnt, but the crust was the most disappointing thing about it. Communion-wafery [at least to the best of my memory, oops...] and with a flat and uniform texture, it had that consistency of decent airline pizza [the one you eat in economy class] but no better than that, and seemed to be baked on a wire grill. We were in a rush to get on the ferry and this was our last and only hope, it seemed. I would recommend eating elsewhere, even if it's in the cafeteria on the ferry. read more

I was visiting Nantucket, and as a pizza fanatic, I always aim to grab a slice of pizza wherever I travel. The full pepperoni pie caught my eye, so I swapped out my caloric allowance of an ice cream cone at Juice Bar for a slice instead. I'm no stranger to overpriced food based on location, but Jesus effing Christ, Steamboat. $6 for a small pepperoni slice. With a bottle of water, I was in over $9. In similarly spendy Manhattan, this same combo would run $5 max. Steamboat is cash only too. I didn't encounter this kind of blatant cash grab at any other restaurant or shop during the remainder of my long weekend in Nantucket, so I must assume this is the result of one owner's unabashed greed. The pizza itself wasn't that bad. They have a decent amount of turnover, so you get fresh slices. However, the slice is small in scale, and ingredients are supremely average. My advice is to stick to the shellfish and ice cream cones while on the island, and to get your pizza fix somewhere, anywhere else. read more

I had no complaints with this pizza. I ordered a slice of cheese, it was good. The sauce had a nice flavor to it. I was pleased. Nice for a day time snack. read more

Ordered two slices of pepperoni, $16!!!! Slices were small and flavorless. Tasted like wonder bread with tomato soup on it. #neveragain read more

I found the staff incredibly rude, the pizza passable and the pricing ridiculous. Then to top it all odd, it's only a cash establishment, but they charge almost $30 for a full pie with a single topping. Just silly. Eat something else if you're on the island. read more

Shitty pizza. And they have the nerve to charge $6 per slice. Yes everything in Nantucket is expensive but this is worse than 99 cents pizza in nyc. Tastes like crap. read more

Nasty pricing but it's Nantucket. Kid gave pizza 5 stars. A little more Greek style from the appearance but that's typical up in MA. There are others in the area worth trying to find the kind you like. read more

Get it while it lasts! Only open for the summer! Really nice crust and perfect toppings (by that I mean nice actual product and a good amount). Okay sauce (probably should be nicer for the price) and great cheese. Very pricey, but you are on island...slices are large as well. read more

The people that say this place is awesome, they must live on totinos... This place is brutal.. Yes it is edible and only reason it got 2 stars.. First, the size of the slice has gone done.. They used to give huge silices, not you get a tiny slice... The crust, is terrible.. It was like biting into a piece of cardboard Price... Wow.. Be prepared to take out a 2nd mortgage for a slice of pizza... If you have a hanking for a slice... Go get a burger before eating here.. read more

I can understand why this place gets some hate, but I thought the pizza here was pretty good. Yes, it's like $5 a slice, but that's not a bad deal compared to the rest of nantucket. And yes it's not gourmet or Neapolitan style pizza, but I thought it was top of its kind. I think the trick is to ask to get your slice or slices (depending how high roller you are) heated up in the oven, that really brings it back to life. If you're pressed for time and trying to grab a quick bite check this place out read more

Steamboat Wharf Pizza - Pepperoni and mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Steamboat Wharf Pizza makes an above average slice but no offer to heat it...your better than that SWP...or maybe not??? I'd go back, but I guess I would ask them to reheat. Oh yeah, $4 for any slice is too much. Mediocre value-well maybe not on Nantucket. read more

This place has the worst service I have ever experienced. I will never again come here to be treated so poorly. Just avoid it and go somewhere else. read more

The location is fab - right on the Steamship Authority wharf, adding to a good selection of street food options in the area. The 'za was also good enough to eat cold, but..... $45 for two delivered pies!? I know it's Nantucket, and... well, it's expensive but UGH. Even the wealthy prep school sitter was horrified, and refused to leave the delivery guy an additional tip. Maybe they charge extra if they have to drive on a dirt road, even if it's nearby? read more

Steamboat Pizza is fantastic and the only place to get a slice when you're 30 miles out to sea. The gals there are terrific -- always letting me know when the newest pie is coming out -- right out of the oven is best!! read more

I can really see this place serving one purpose....feeding mediocre pizza at inflated prices to drunk vacationers. Don't get me wrong, it's not the worst pizza in the world but it far from great and barely gets to good. For four bucks you might just be better off going down the street for a taco....better yet, go buy yourself another beer and eat when you get home. (I did say that the staff was quite nice and not rude as others may have experienced.) read more

Lady working behind the register tries to scam customers. Charged me $12 for two slices of pizza without ringing it up on the register. Asked her for change and she told me there was no change. I then asked her for a receipt and she printed me a receipt showing that my total was $11.24. She then proceeded to give me my change -- looks like the employees here are pocketing money from the owner and screwing customers. read more

Best pizza on Nantucket and you can but just a slice if you like. Only wish they had gluten free.

Really average pizza. No reason to pop in here unless you're starving or drunk. Great service though

First and foremost you have to take in the variables here. Your on Nantucket so everything is overpriced and tailored to tourists. With that said, I thought the pizza here was very good. The slices were normal size but the price, about $5 a slice, is way overboard. Sadly it's still one of the more economic places to grab a meal on the island. The pizza was good. I thought the dough was crisp but not burnt, the cheese was fresh and good quality mozzarella and the sauce was flavorful. It's not Frank Pepe or NYC quality pizza but I'd recommend it if your stuck on an island lol read more

Overpriced, cash only and no seating. I had to pay $4.00 atm fee inside of the restaurant just to buy two slices of pizza. $16 later and the pizza was just ok. Do not dine here. Get a credit card machine - join this century! read more

Did you say that'll be $30? For ONE pizza? You do realize it's just dough, cheese, and sauce, right? Extortionary price for a captive audience is one thing but then to also only accept cash? Come on buddy... if you're going to cheat the IRS at least do it at more reasonable prices. read more

Located on "the Strip", here's a great place to grab a slice or two when the bars close and you're jones-in for a snack. Pizza is passable, and I say this because there are places in this world with better pizza and almost none of them native to Nantucket. read more

Went there not to long ago pizza and as a kid used to go all the time there..it is good pizza@$5.00 a slice of cheese & $24.00 for a whole Pepperoni (large) is little much but perfect location downtown close to the boat and about 5 min from the local bars....but all in all it good pizza just think it a little much for what you get. delivery is available there's a charge for that to drive to different parts of the island w/a smart car... read more

Pizza, near a ferry warf, on an island renowned for fresh seafood; 'nuff said. Seemingly a favorite for high school and pre-teens.

Absolutely terrible. We ordered delivery and two hours later they called and said it would be another 30-45 min. When we got it there were a couple long hairs on the pie and the cheese was cold and chunky. Do not go here. Entitled island restaurant. Waste of time and money. read more

One Bite Pizza Review: Supposedly, this is the best pizza on the island. Looked good. Asked for it well done. It's good pizza. Score: 8 out of 10 read more

I'm giving this place a 1 star...wished there was an option for zero because the customer service was one of the worst I've experienced in a while and I was most surprised and disappointed that of all places it occurred on nantasket. People don't peanuts to vacation there, but the Jamaican cashier girl was absolutely horrible. Its a no card place if business...strictly cash, but there was not one sign displayed informing customers of this, instead u r directed to ATM machine snuggly and conveniently located inside with 4 ATM signs with one boldly displayed at eye level on the hot display letting customers know it was readi l y available to charge u $4 per transaction. When I asked the horrible cashier where was the sign informing customers of this she Said "its behind the no mask" sign , so I asked, csn I see it, she said she its bolted down and it wld have to be unscrewed to be shown. I paid for the pizza , and left...i wkd never ever purchase rhere again read more

Owner can care less about service and quality Avoid, go to Oath Do not order take out 2 hours later still not here read more

Great late night pizza joint! This is one of the only places open late in Nantucket for food!

The add is wrong they do not accept credit cards!!! They are also very rude you have to wait in line forever and it is very expensive. You are better off taking a cab to Sophie T's or Fooods for here and There it will b cheaper you can sit and eat and they will be nice to you! Ps this is coming from an Islander. read more