Prices were a bit higher than other sushi in the area for same-sized portions. The inside of the…read morerestaurant was tired and didn't have a very fresh smell- more like mop water that has sat in a bucket for too long. I ordered some vegetable sushi which was ok, nothing to write home about. My BF ordered some tuna & salmon and said it tasted a bit fishy. The vegetable gyoza were barely warm when they came out and extremely greasy. Not a place we would really stop in again unless we had nowhere else to eat.

It's my first review of the year. I was craving sushi and found out that many of the nearby sushi…read moreplaces open late after 2 or 3ish. Sumo was the only one closeby open for lunch. I came in at 12 and the empty restaurant surprised me (remember this for later). I was seated and then went to the restroom. When I went into the restroom someone was in the stall so I used the urinal. ** The person in the stall leaves and I kid you not, dipped his hands in the water for less than 5 secs and left... *Remember I told you the restaurant was empty? It was an employee... Gross Anyway, large menu: but I'm basic and was craving something fresh and spider roll. I ordered a rainbow roll. When it came out, I was so shocked at how small it was. The spider roll was mostly filled with cucumbers and the rainbow roll fish slices must have been flattened to about a millimeter. I didn't even taste any soft shell crab other than fried tempura bits. The only positive was that because the roll was small there was less rice. My lunch came to $30. To be fair, I don't think it's bad chefs or bad server but more of a management issue bc I have worked in a sushi restaurant before where portion control was a thing. Long story short I left hungrier than when I came. I went to Wegmans and their sushi was sooo good. Like night and day. It hit the spot and was cheaper. Ambiance was quiet and dark and while waiting for a server to get my order I noticed an odd interaction at another table that came in. She [the server] was at the table about to take their order but delayed and told them to wait while she turn on the music bc it had turned off. It was just odd... I wasn't in a rush but was already turned off by the restroom event... Server was nice. But probably won't come back..

An outstanding little hole-in-the-wall sushi spot. The food was incredibly fresh, authentic, and…read moredelicious--it brought me right back to Japan. The atmosphere is cozy and intimate, and every dish was prepared with great attention to detail. Reservations are definitely recommended, as this hidden gem fills up quickly. Can't wait to come back!

I don't want to write this review because Shiki is the BEST place for authentic sushi but it's…read moresmall and already tough to get a table. If you don't have reservations, the wait is often over an hour. The food is ready when it's ready, don't rush the greatness! Make a reservation.

My new obsession. Never ordered from here before but when my daughter comes home she always orders…read morefrom here. My husband doesn't eat this type of food so after a medical appointment I decided to get some Thai iced tea as I have had that before at other places. I decided to try the salad bowl. The young lady told me how to order using the little cards which was great so you can take your time. Omg. I ordered the rice with all types of salad fixings. It's so delicious. The tea. I could easily down 3 of these. It's expensive so it's a once in a while type thing. Just one little caveat. The Irondequoit sign inside is spelled wrong. Gave me a chuckle.

Fast service lots of drinks and very cute vibes! Good size and good prices. I'd def come here again…read more:)

My husband does not eat sushi but when I saw this place had a kobe burger, I convinced him to give…read moreit a try. To be honest, we didn't have high hopes for a burger at a sushi place, but I would have been jealous had my sushi not been incredible. The burger had the perfect char and was medium rare to order. The special sauce was great. This sushi place has a lot of creative options I haven't seen elsewhere. I had the O-ren and the tuna una - both fantastic. I wish some of the other choices didn't have cucumber but I would have had a hard time narrowing my choices down otherwise. The bartender was new but he made my husband the best old fashioneds he's had in awhile. Very smooth. I had a refreshing lavender lemon bubbly gin based cocktail and a glass of plum wine with my sushi. Service is great. The restaurant is cozy. It rivals some of our best sushi places in Buffalo. I wish we had it here.

I ordered a big takeout order for 6 people for pickup from Poke Sushi. Their online ordering has a…read moregood option where you can specify the names of the person to whom each dish belongs. Everything was plated up excellently according to instructions and everyone was pleased with what they had. I got the Sweet Potato Roll, a chef's Veggie Roll, and the Pickled Rick which came with mango and pickled ginger and which was a real treat. Poke Sushi has risen to the top of my list of sushi restaurants in the Rochester area. Check them out, they do a great job!

My bf and I tried Sushi585 for the first time this week. We're new to the AYCE game, so keep that…read morein mind. We went on a Wednesday evening and were the only people in the restaurant for a little bit, so I would definitely recommend coming out on a week night if you can! Our server was absolutely lovely. Super attentive, even with the fact he didn't have to take our orders. Topped off our waters multiple times, made sure we were enjoying, etc. Speaking of ordering, their system is awesome!! It was super easy to browse the menu and make our selections, and we didn't have to worry about any awkwardness. Might just be a me thing, but I sometimes feel self conscious putting in a big order when I have to actually say it out loud to a person, so their phone ordering system was super helpful in making me feel more comfortable. The food was really good! On par with many other sushi places I've been in Rochester. I don't eat meat, and there were still so many veggie options for me. I especially loved the veggie dumplings and tofu skin/avocado roll. My bf loved the spicy crab onigiri and the beef skewers. The restaurant and restrooms were clean. The price seems to be slightly cheaper than other AYCE places in the area, even for dinner. We will definitely be back! As much as I miss Tap & Mallet, I was very happy with this spot!

This is my experience. Take it or leave it ;)…read more Decided to try Sushi 585 after a few cocktails at Daily Refresher (great bar, highly recommended). They are known as an all you can eat place, but we got two rolls for take away instead. From what I saw when picking up, the place looks nice enough inside, but nothing special. We ordered a Dream Roll and a 2 in 1 roll. Neither were that great and the dream roll was missing the tuna and salmon it was supposed to have and they used a crab stick instead of real crab which was disappointing as well. The 2 in 1 roll was ok but nothing special. I will say that the order was ready early and they were gracious enough to included eel sauce and spicy mayo on the side as I requested, because it was not available as an add on, so I am going to assume the service is solid. Unfortunately there are too many good sushi places in town to try this place again.

Visited on my birthday for a lunch with my friend. Shared some sushi. It was amazing. I'll…read moredefinitely be back. Easy to order and great service. Parking is super easy as well.

The sushi that I got here was very good! They were very helpful and accommodating with my…read moreallergies. I do enjoy the I-Square area, but was sad that the rooftop was closed on the particular day that I went. Otherwise, I recommend bringing the food to the rooftop!

BEST SUSHI I EVER HAVE, not even understating the amazingness of this sushi, they also have cool…read moresnacks.

Unique food items and friendly employees. We pass this place all the time and finally tried it.read more

Shema never disappoints, thanks for another great meal! We got the sea scollop, sake belly, and…read moretobiko nigiri, as well as the sake, takka, and miami maki rolls. For special rolls we got the toro power, and shema special.

I ordered salmon sushi rolls for takeout, and once I got home i realized it was all nigiri. I…read morecalled and offered to come back and exchange, but they told me they wouldn't fix it because I already left the store. I had miso soup, so I wasn't going to tear open the bag so it spills in my car. and who checks their takeout order when it's tightly wrapped up? The girl was so rude to me on the phone. Absolutely terrible customer service. Never coming back again. PS. Replying to Young C: You could choose between nigiri and sushi when I checked out online. I clearly picked sushi. See picture below. Most places would try to help make the customer happy, but not you guys. You just tell the customer they are wrong so you don't have to remake it.