Lack of a better word...GARBAGE! Their Instagram pictures are smoke and mirrors. They don't even have what they show on their page, In the actual diner. Wings were dry. Disco fries can be made way better at quick check. Oh and the one that takes the prize...spinach artichoke dip. The chips were stale as hell. And to top it off,they gave me an extra piece of PANCAKE!...I DIDNT EVEN ORDER PANCAKES! SEE THE PIC FOR YOURSELF!. I don't know who eats here and decides to vote this new jerseys #1 diner. Maybe people fresh from a 39 day stint on survivor? I wouldn't even send my worst enemy here. Never again. read more

Sparta Classic Diner - a piece of leftover pancake from a previous person's meal? - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

So sad to have to post this... We used to love the Sparta diner, but over the last few years, it seems that the food quality has gone down and the prices have gone up!!! We ordered from them about a month ago, and received MOLDY buns on my son's sliders-- thankfully I spotted it before he ate them!!! I didn't write anything at that point because I felt that with Covid etc, maybe it was just a fluke... I called and told them and they were apologetic and remade the order. Last night, we decided to give them another try... MOLDY bread AGAIN!!!!!!!! Sorry, if they are sending out food like this, what aren't you seeing behind the scenes.... Really sad, we used to go there alot, but not anymore read more

Our family has loved this diner for many years. My mother is disabled (and elderly) and she and my MIL love having breakfast here. Enjoyable atmosphere, friendly staff and good food. read more

overwhelming portion size; glasses are never clean; waitress had cool earrings tho; we were the only ppl in here felt like we were at war with the other side of the room read more

See all

Food was alright but our table used the mobile pay that is on the receipt to pay for our bill and our waitress Emily V, stormed to the front and caused a scene asking why we didn't tip her when we did on the card. Wish I could take the tip back after we already waited 30 minutes to be sat and another hour to get food. read more

EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED . Went there in February . ordered 2 meals .. my meal was wrong. my son's hamburger was hardly cooked. had to send back both.I ordered a rubin and got a egg sandwich. . Now come august ordered delivery. . same rubin..was ok nothing with it but dried up small container of horrible potato salad . . Tonight ordered from Jefferson Diner. wow was great..Sparta diner prices are way to high for what they give you. OVERPRICED! will never go or order from them. Quality is overrated. read more

This restaurant is great for delivery. They're very good at packaging food up similar to catering for large groups if need be. I would recommend them for any catering or large gatherings that you might want to have at home instead of going to the restaurant. They do typically only deliver within a 5 mile radius but if you tip high enough to cover the drivers time and gas they will go a little farther. Unfortunately I cannot comment specifically on the quality of food because I had it delivered to a friend. But I can say is that friend recommended I order from here so I'm assuming the food is wonderful too. read more

Great milkshakes and breakfast. 5/5 for that. 3 stars because every time I order out they usually forget something or mess it up. This has caused me to not order out from them as much. I kind of got annoyed after the 2nd/3rd time. The food good here but sometimes it's hit or miss. Certain days for lunch/dinner I'll be very happy with the out come but other times it's just ehhhh. Staff is nice, also great for groups. Summer time they have outdoor seating which is nice! Overall 3 stars. I'll still go here but it's ok read more

Price point much higher than other diners in area and food not that great. They pass off Italian dinner sausage as breakfast sausage. When we complained they got snotty, stating, that's what we serve. They do have good hamburgers for dinner and staff is usually not that snotty but they are off my list. Prefer the Rockaway Diner and the Franklin Diner. read more

Disappointed with the food and Covid safety. We ordered meatloaf dinner and chicken pot pie. The meatloaf meals were perfect. Although one was served 10 minutes after the other three meals were served, it did not disappoint. The chicken pot pie however, the vegetables were hard and crunchy. When the bill came, we were over charged three dollars on each of the meatloaf dinners and two dollars on the chicken pot pie. We brought it to the attention of our server and he came back with a revised bill. While reviewing the revised bill, I brought him back to tell him that he did not correct the price for the chicken pot pie. Also, we brought to our servers attention that we were concerned about the cleanliness of the lemons they were serving because it still had the sticker on the slice of lemon that was in the glass. Server did not say much and then I caught the attention of the manager to review our dining experience and he wasn't interested. No apology for wrong meal brought incorrect , every meal charged a different price from price on their plastic menu (not paper), and no apology for gross lemon. I have been here many times before and had no problems. They were not busy, there were two tables in the dining room that had customers and they were two people sitting outside on a Sunday night read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

Food has always been good at SCD. This diner has been an asset for the area. Sadly their attention to the covid protection of customers is selective. Safer alternatives are the ultimate Jefferson Diner 10 minutes down the road or cross town to the Andover Diner. The SCD is fairly priced for the market that it is in. Food is good. The vast majority of servers are excellent. read more

This place is great! Their shakes are insane!! Food is always great and the owners are onsite and always attentive. We love sitting outside on their patio in nice warm days. Their brunch menu has a lot of different, delicious options! read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

Delicious !!!!!!!! Will be back !!!!! Milk shakes awesome !!!!!!!! Highly recommend!!!!!!! Ty !!!!!!

NEVER ever get an order right. Delivery takes over an hour and is never as I ordered it. Now they want to upcharge me for extra syrup on my pancakes. Last time I called to complain my order was not I asked for they gave me a partial credit against a future order. Really? Find somewhere else. The food is not good enough to make up for the high prices and incompetence. read more

I've been here many times Food is usually very good. A little pricey Went the other day and had there Special Turkey sandwich with stuffing. Very little turkey on sandwich and had to ask for gravy. Very little gravy on sandwich and none on side. Overall was ok but very dry! Usually satisfied but this time I wasn't. Take my advice don't order this! read more

Ordered a large order tonight, 2 apps and 5 meals to go. I got the chicken Madeira. Literally all that was in my platter was just chicken, sauce and the bottom halves of asparagus. No mashed potatoes and the asparagus was horrible. Extremely disappointed. Always raved about this place and now my opinion has changed. read more

This is the 3rd time we have had issues/bad service/incorrectly prepared food. We have sat waiting while our server talked on her cell phone ignoring that we had an issue with our meal that needed attention and only came back to give us the check. We have ordered breakfast take out that was missing home fries and toast (yes it was on the online menu that there were included-even asked what kind of toast). This time, the hostess was wearing gloves but not cleaning the menus after taking them from the tables (we are peek Coronavirus) I was asked if I was getting take out, said yes, was asked what I wanted, said I didn't know. Was not offered a menu, had to get a dirty menu myself. I should have walked out, but hunger had the best of me. I didn't see what I was looking for so I was told I had the wrong menu. I ordered. On the menu the Taylor Ham egg and cheese was listed as $6.50 & the steak and eggs listed as $16.00. I was told my bill was $27.08. I questioned why. She took out the menu and checked the prices, saw the difference in the prices (7.00 &18.40) and said there is a take out fee. That is fine, but you didn't know that when I asked you? And you were not sure about it. I think you just ripped me off for the last time. The sandwich wasn't even fully wrapped to keep it warm. Now if there is a take out charge, shouldn't it be a separate charge on the bottom of the receipt? You would think that would be the proper way to keep track and to explain to customers. This place is just terrible and that is the last time I will ever go there. read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Receipt showing overcharged from prices on menu - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

Awesome diner! This place saved me and my friend after a long hike through nearby High Point Park. We arrived starving and cold and shaken by nature (jk the hike was great, highly recommend) and left hardly able to waddle back to the car. Everything was super yummy, fresh, and came in huge portions. The sweet potato fries were perfectly thick, hot, and crispy, and I've got to give a special shoutout to the lentil soup. This may be a "classic diner" but it's not your usual greasy spoon. This is real quality food! read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Super extra milkshake and fries (that's brownie smattered around the glass) - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

See all

Pricey for a diner and okay food . The menu has been cut down since covid, so has the hours. They close at 9 and won't take orders at 8:40. The portion size in salads is greatly reduced. This may be covid related and I'll totally understand, if that's the case. Paying $12 for a salad that is a fistful wasn't worth it for us. The disco fries used old fries reheated and slipped w gravy. Definitely not good. Chicken tenders kids loved. Good cuts of chicken. Burgers a little to messy, but so good!!! All in all - it's a local run to, but nothing that makes me crave going. read more

So, to go along with a lot of other reviews, i'm a Sparta resident that enjoyed the diner before the fire, and was anticipating the return and having a nice local diner to go to. I also am disappointed with the food and the overpricing. Many items that were about $10-12 have jumped by over $5 and it just no longer is affordable with my wife and 3 kids. The kids sliders are basically 1/2 a burger cut in to 1/4s. The grilled cheese is an astounding $10 (it's two slices of the cheapest white bread and crappy american cheese) (should be $5 at the most). I had the tacos, and the salsa and guac and they are bad. I don't know who approved the recipe, but it's bad. So, just for the price, it isn't worth it any more. They still have the same problem they had before with leaving items out for any to go orders. I always had to drive back, even before the fire. Things like leaving out Tsatsiki sauce for the Gyros, or leaving out part of the order all together. Check your bag fully before you leave. Service is good, but when the waitress asks if everything is ok, and you say no, it wasn't good. They shrug their shoulders and say "sorry about that" and don't do anything to make up for it. read more

I have never been a fan of diners but this one is amazing! The food is great. It is fresh and the quality is very good. The service is also great! You can't go wrong with what ever you order. This diner is worth the drive for us. We live about a half hour away but it's worth the trip. You won't be disappointed! read more

No, just no. Yet again, the Sparta "Classic" Diner never fails to fail. As we like to say in our house "It's not an order from the Sparta Diner if it isn't missing something!" They actually cook a decent burger but if you go INTO the diner, you wait forever for your food (and they screw it up) and if you order to go - they'll forget something with your order. There is no winning here. read more

This establishment has horrible serviced. Only was served a water, was never asked for any other drink, SPECIALLY asked for no peppers, i am highly allergic and she never came back to check one me, had to switch food with some one WHO ALSO was served the wrong food. Was served regular french toast when asked for cinnamon. this place has gone down hill. the service is cold and pushy and don't care any more, didn't even look any of my family in the eye when talking. Highly recommend not eating here. read more

An old style diner just like I remember but with some modern menu twists! I moved from New Jersey, the land of late night disco fries and Taylor Ham and cheese sandwiches on a super amazing hard roll 22 years ago! I landed in California where nobody had any idea what Taylor Ham or Disco Fries were and god forbid any of the healthy sprout eating late 90's health nuts knew what these staples were....they would rather die than eat this! My brothers family moved to Sparta recently and we spent the night and decided to visit for brunch on Veterans Day. It was everything perfect and the hot chocolate loaded with whipped cream, choc syrup and a pirouette was a kids dream come true! Yes, I had my NJ staple and it was amazing. Loaded with Taylor Ham and cooked to perfection! I powered it down. My son had the pigs in a blanket. This was a large plate great for a growing kid with a big appetite. My little guy had the turkey lunch and my brother had the breakfast sliders. The service was great and overall a fabulous morning! read more

Stay away from the delivery service. Received the food an hour and twenty minutes after the promised time. Delivery person, nice guy, indicated they were slammed, poor communication from Sparta Diner. They should have called to communicate Communication- I called 30 minutes pass due and was told the food was out for delivery and should be arriving in a few minutes. 15 minutes later I called GrubHub. Once delivered the food was stone cold. Another 20 minutes of trying to get this resolved they offered to process another order. No thanks, not waiting for cold food again. Food is sitting on the driveway for Sparta Diner to pick up. After seeing the other reviews it appears there has been a management change who does not care about quality. What a shame! read more

Does classic diner food with fresh ingredients for a great price. Nuff said The owners and staff are great and I marvel at how they're able to be so consistent with how busy they are. read more

Stopped in for breakfast today and was greeted and seated quickly. Plenty of staff on hand and Elisa was my waitress - very friendly and got my much needed coffee in a heartbeat. I just needed a simple bacon and eggs, which appeared without delay, great job Elisa! The food and service is always very good and I look forward to my next visit. read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

See all

Revived my feelings about diners after having a complete shit experience at the Jefferson diner the last few diner outings. Clean! Friendly and professional service thank you Elisa and the food was delicious. Just an all around good experience. I'm new to the area and will definetly be returning. read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

The five of us dined here around 6p on a Sunday evening. Place looked retro from outside as well as inside. Came in and was seated right away. Light crowd. Friendly greeter. Not over huge diner but clean and had 'warmth' to it. A young waitress (I forget her name) greeted us promptly and got our drinks. Very pleasant waitress. She was very patient as our youngest took a bit to decide on her dinner choice. Before she left our table to give us a few more mins, I asked her if there was any possible way to turn up the heat in our corner. Although our table was far from the door, the extreme draft of the cold winter night just kept coming our way each time the front door was opened. I had little hope that they could even control the temp in a certain area but decided to ask anyway instead of being miserable through dinner. Would you believe the heat increased?! Double thumbs up for accommodating one family! Awesome!! FOOD Stuff: Menu was not as extensive as other 'typical' diners but had a fair amount of choices. Philly cheese steak, Reuben, grilled turkey breast sandwich, Mac n cheese bites were ordered and a beef gyro for me. All in all delicious food and not overly salty. Very flavorful. There's a difference. Arrived within 15-20mins. Dishes were neatly presented as well. I'd say that's awesome service. SERVICE: our waitress was very attentive to our needs and was always pleasant and did not rush us. OVERALL: would recommend. Solid choice for good flavorful diner foods that 'hit the spot'. Great prices. Win-win! read more

See all

Absolutely best diner for miles around. Very clean, really good diner food. We always order the staples & here we were not disappointed. Have been looking for a good diner in Byram township for 4 years & we finally scored! Boss man supervises & keeps the register. Standard fair + some higher end surprises on menu (gluten free choices & angus beef). Also Huevos Rancheros (a fav) awa standard Greek dishes. Really good! Highly recommend!!!will definitely go back! read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Spinach pie w/ Greek Salad DELISH! - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

We love diners so we traveled here for dinner. The soups are outstanding! Acorn squash puree and matzo ball were so delicious The food was quite good. Turkey dinner was the best turkey around and the curry stuffing was good. Fettuccine carbonara was good. Nice size portions and the service was excellent. All the wait staff seemed to be happy and efficient. Sierra was our server. She has a great smile and very attentive The one negative is the price. $18-$22 for dinner specials - $2.75 for a cup of tea read more

The food is pretty decent. Nice and clean place. I gave it 3 stars because the service is kinda slow but the servers are friendly. If you are in a hurry skip this place. read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Kids meal pancake - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

See all

Love this diner! The hamburgers are delicious. Breakfast omelets, pancakes, grits everything I've had was delicious! Wait staff is very friendly. I've never had a bad experience. read more

Great diner, fast service, large portions. Friendly staff and very clean, ample parking

Usually have a overall good experience at this diner, however this past Saturday morning I have never felt so unappreciated as a customer as I did this visit, that I had to share this review. I ordered a arugula balsamic mozzarella pizza and it came out with tomato sauce as if the cooks just added arugula and balsamic on top of a regular pizza......the menu did not say that it had tomato sauce and no one except a tomato sauce when they order a pizza with lettuce and balsamic as well. Anyway the server came and offered to have it made again ,mean while my family is eating there meals while I am waiting. By the way manager /owner never came by to apologize or anything. Ok , brought the new pizza out barely had any arugula in it maybe 2 or 3 pieces on each slice, so I asked for some extra arugula .Was enough for about half the pizza , so I asked for a little more arugula and the manager then came by to tell me he would have t ou charge me for that arugula!? Are you kidding me ? He never came by to apologize but he came over to argue about paying for the arugula and to tell me it's not a salad!? So at this point I dont even want to finish the food, I ask for the check and of course I was being charged ,which most places would comp the food for the aggravation. So before I left I had to just clarify with the manager / owner that I felt he handled the situation very rudely by not even apologizing after They messed up my order and I had to wait while my table finished eating before I got my food and he never came to the table except to tell me I had to pay for the extra arugula.......So then he said"what do you want? you want me to take off the pizza ?" So that is the least he could of done!! I will not be visiting the Sparta Diner ever again.... Very aggravating and insulting experience. read more

Food is okay and was served quickly. My son didn't like his chicken fingers. A little expensive. Almost $50 for three of us.

Probabaly the worst diner I have been to, so not worth it. First off everything is way overpriced that it's ridiculous, the place used to be a dump and now they are taking advantage of people. Their employees sit there and make fun of customers right IN FRONT of customers. Only good thing about it was the server because she was quick with our order. Better off going to the BLD, so don't waste your time or money here. read more

I came here with my family and it was horrible. The service was slow and my hashbrowns were cold when we got them. It took 30 minutes for breakfast to be cooked and there weren't a lot of people. I will not be back and I definitely will not be recommending this place to anyone. read more

Love the food here. The shakes are good, sometimes hard to finish. The Oreo waffles are my favorite. Sometimes little things disappoint but overall good place to eat. read more

Sparta Classic Diner - Oreo waffles - Comfort Food Near Me - Sparta Township, New Jersey

Everything is excellent. Lose the paper straws. Please. Don't fall for that PC crap. NO ONE likes paper straws. 5 stars once that's resolved. read more