Early in the week, I made online reservations for Friday at 7pm. I got text confirmation of that reservation. Something came up making Friday a bad choice, so I made another reservation for Saturday and cancelled the on for Friday. Once again I got a text message for both the Friday cancellation and Saturday booking. The automated replies made it convenient. We arrived a few minutes before or reservation and were seated right away. They were quick to respect my request for a nearby booth, as I have a disability walking. We ordered the steak appetizer roles that were outstanding! My wife ordered a Caesar salad that was huge, along with the filet with a baked potato. When I looked at the menu days prior, I was eyeing the shrimp and grits, but after seeing nearby tables entrees, I quickly ordered the ribeye. Our server, Jesstina was off the wall spectacular! Our appetizer came out quick, and our main course came out soon after we were done enjoying our appetizers. She made sure our every need was taken care of, and her attitude was as if we were her long time friends. We were there to celebrate our wedding anniversary of 23 years, and the dining experience was perfect! Spectacular service, an outstanding food selection and a 10 out of 10! This was our first time at this Stoney River, but it won't be the last! And you can rest assured, we'll make sure Jesstina will be our requested server! read more

Stoney River delivers solid flavor and quality, and the ambiance makes the experience even better. The atmosphere is classy, dimly lit, and upscale without feeling overly formal. It is a great spot for a date night or a special evening out. We started with the crab cake. It was definitely good, flavorful, and nicely prepared, but at 18 dollars for a single crab cake, it felt a little steep. The standout of the night was the Wild Mushroom Meatloaf. It was hearty, well seasoned, and something I would absolutely reorder. We paired it with asparagus and Parmesan fries. The asparagus was fresh and succulently seasoned, cooked just right. The Parmesan fries were crispy and flavorful and made a great complement to the meal. I ordered the London Dip, which had good flavor overall, especially paired with the roasted wild mushrooms. That combination worked well together. However, for the price point, I think next time I might try something else on the menu. It was good, just not quite as memorable as the meatloaf. We also tried the smoked gouda mac and cheese, which was rich and tasty and definitely a solid side option. Overall, Stoney River offers good quality dishes with strong flavors in a classy setting that makes it perfect for date night. A few items feel priced on the higher side, but I would return, especially for that meatloaf. read more

See all

We came here for our 10th Anniversary dinner. I made a reservation through the Resy app, so it was very easy to do. We were seated quickly. They have plenty of parking on site. The restaurant was very nice. I ordered a glass of wine. My husband got the Manhattan. Then the bread came out and the rolls are like a delicious cross between a donut and a roll with sweet butter. For dinner we both got side salads with our meals, which were big enough to be an entree so we could've shared one. We both got the lobster bisque, which was delicious and I highly recommend.i got the lamb chops for my entree. The staff was amazing. I was happy with my meal but the manager came out and said they were making an extra lamb chop because they felt the size of the ones that were made weren't big enough. I was shocked at the level of detail and customer service, in a good way. That has never happened to me. The portions were decent and we had leftovers to bring home. I would definitely recommend this place for a celebration. We had a great time. The food was good and our service staff were wonderful. Our server even brought us champagne to do a toast to our anniversary. read more

See all

While visiting Athens Alabama, I was treated to lunch at this restaurant by my sister and brother in law. This was such a wonderful experience! The ambiance was lovely, service was great, food was outstanding! I absolutely recommend this awesome restaurant. And anytime I'm in Athens, I will be definitely look forward to patronizing them again. read more

Stoney River - Pecan crusted trout, broccoli and mashed potatoes - Steakhouses Near Me - Madison, Alabama

I had a pretty good experience at stoney river ! The restaurant was clean and welcoming. My server was very kind and attentive. I had a spectacular espresso martini and the cedar plank salon. The salmon was very fishy and not my favorite, probably wouldnt worder again. My creamed spinach and mashed potatoes was delicious! Overall a decent experience. Would definitely to back for date night. read more

Stoney River - Cedar plank salmon - Steakhouses Near Me - Madison, Alabama

See all

Within the first few seconds of being seated, my arm stuck to the table. My side of the table had not been wiped of whatever the last patron spilled on it. My first impression did not bode well for the rest of my meal. We were greeted, our server introducing herself and completely ignoring the person who followed her around all evening (I'm assuming she was training). The named server went over what each menu contained and then recommended the egg rolls. We instead both ordered lobster bisque. The large bowl of bisque had a respectable amount of lobster but it had an odd aftertaste of "heat". Something that didn't have a specific flavor note nor anything melding it to the dish. It was just weird. I ordered the bistro chicken substituting a baked potato for the mashed. The chicken was served warm, not hot. This may be part of the reason for the panko breading being mushy. I scraped off what I could though I also lost the sauce. I gave my husband a large piece to try. He didn't eat but one bite. He said it was all mushy breading. My potato was hot but had been sitting too long as evidenced by the hard brown chunks of potato mixed with the rest. My husband had cedar plank salmon. The large piece of salmon was executed well - moist and flaky. It lacked in flavor - a lemon wedge probably would have gone a long way. He did have the mashed potatoes and was disappointed. Both of our meals were served with broccoli. We had to ask for bread - small, sweet rolls more dessert like than a bread accompaniment. While my husband had an old fashioned, I had a Sazerac. It was smooth though way too much absinthe in the last few sips - the bartender didn't take the time to properly swirl the absinthe. The serving sizes were large and we took plenty of food home, though I doubt neither the potatoes nor my chicken will be eaten. The unacknowledged server finally checked on us as we were finishing. I told her about the chicken. Our server with a name came by a few minutes later and offered to remake my meal, an offer I would have appreciated about 15 minutes earlier, not when I'm obviously finished (or obviously have given up). The restaurant was much less than half full yet was very loud - the music was so loud that the patrons had to speak up to be heard. Definitely took away from what could have been an intimate dinner. My husband and I always talk about my review after our meal. He said he was at 4.5 stars. Since I'm writing this review, I'm overriding his assessment and giving Stoney River a very generous 3 stars. I'm disappointed, I really expected a much better experience. read more

See all

Good Food. Good vibes. Good services. I would definitely go back. The Philly egg rolls were by far my favorite. Yes they have tvs at the bar. read more

See all

My wife and I were seated as soon as we arrived (on time with our reservation) on a Tuesday night. The booth we sat at was clean and comfortable with soft lighting. Our waitress, Ariel, was very attentive and made sure we had plenty of zero. We had drinks--wine and a Manhattan cocktail. The food was quite tasty and full of flavor. The bread that came to the table was very good. Almost sweet cornbread muffins but a different texture. I ordered the Cedar Plank Salmon with mashed potatoes and a substitute side of creamed spinach. She had grilled shrimp with creamed corn brûlée. Fabulous if you have a sweet tooth. Overall, we had a great time enjoying a special midweek dinner eating out on the town. We would highly recommend Stoney River if you want good food and a special treat. read more

See all

Went here for a birthday celebration (table for 4, not a party). We sat in the bar area and had a good time. The staff was personable and inviting. I had the French dip. Was it the best I've ever had, no, but it was good. My wife had the lobster roll, which she enjoyed. Would repeat if you're looking for a nice place for dinner. read more

Stoney River - French dip and fries - Steakhouses Near Me - Madison, Alabama

See all

Truly enjoyed our beautiful family dinner. Everything was spectacular. From the ambience to the service and of course the food was impeccable. One of the best crab cakes I've ever eaten. Will definitely be back. read more

Great service 3 out of 4 on food. The ribeye was slightly under seasoned but that may have been the blue cheese throwing me off. Clean and elegant ambiance. read more

See all

The hubs ordered take out from Stoney River for me. He selected the dishes. I think he based it off what I've previously ordered at places along with his best friend's suggestions. I'm sure the experience would have been four+ stars had I dined in. The takeout was packaged well and travelled well for the few miles home. I had their deviled eggs. These were over stuffed. There's nothing wrong with that, and they tasted just fine, it was just overkill on the yolk mixture to egg white ratio. I had the crab cake and steak combo. The combo came with two to go ramekin containers that I had no clue what was in them. After checking the menu, they were roasted pineapple salsa and Dijon mustard sauce for the crab cake. In my opinion, these are odd sauces for a crab cake. The crab cake, like the deviled eggs was overly thick. One bite, and all I could taste was a wet breading sensation. Yuck. I thought of throwing the crabcake out, but I just couldn't bear the thought of wasting it. The next day, I divided the one crab cake into two thinner crab cakes and seared it myself, because, despite the menu description of "pan-seared," this crab cake was not pan seared to my liking. After pan searing it the following day, it tasted good, had a good amount of crab and I topped it with some lemon juice and ignored the salsa/sauce they provided. I still prefer the crab cakes at Char over this crab cake. I had the filet rare, which was seared well and very flavorful! It needed absolutely no seasoning added. However, I almost got out my kitchen scale because the portion was minuscule! It was two little pieces, period. Their menu says these were filet medallions. They are right about that, they were small. It came with a side of mushrooms, which I think were roasted "wild" mushrooms. They were good, although slightly salty. Hub's slice of cake was absolutely giant! It looked delicious, too. Had I dined in, I would have sent the crab cakes back for more sear, and asked for fresh lemon wedges in lieu of the salsa and sauce. Although I am not a big steakhouse fan, I would be willing to visit Stoney River in person. read more

See all

Fantastic!! Excellent service, the food was fantastic, and the ambience was spectacular. Highly recommend!! Ian was our waiter and he was amazing!! read more

See all

Fantastic experience. Loved the bread with cinnamon butter. The service was first rate. Very polite, helpful, and attentive. The menu is pretty expansive, even at lunch. The food was amazing with fantastic flavor and texture. I highly recommend the steak egg rolls. The atmosphere is pleasant and upscale. You really should check them out. read more

See all

We were there for a busy Saturday evening before Mother's Day. The food was excellent. Atmosphere good, despite the full restaurant. Service was good. Rarely does Stoney River fall short, if ever. read more

Daddy/daughter week continued at Stoney River Steakhouse & Grill, and we were lucky enough to stumble in on Opening Night! We've been watching the build-out, eagerly anticipating their grand opening, and while I usually wait to leave reviews (to allow for growing pains), this place is the exception to the rule. From the moment we walked in, everything ran like a well-oiled machine. We were seated in under 5 minutes, and drinks were on the table within 30 seconds. While it's a little odd that water isn't automatically served, that's a minor detail. Our server was fantastic, and it's clear that the staff has been trained well--you'd never know it was opening night! Ambiance & Décor: Stoney River strikes an interesting balance between upscale sports bar, contemporary steakhouse, and a semi-formal dining experience. Whether you're dressed up for a special occasion or just grabbing a bite after work, you'll feel comfortable here. The bar seats around 40 and seems to be a focal point. In fact, I overheard the owner personally seating a few guests and introducing the bartender as "one of the best there is" and mentioning that he flew her in from Florida to get things started. That level of investment in service says a lot! Appetizer: Deviled Eggs - Phenomenal! A must-try. Bread Service: They serve a unique flat muffin-style bread that's both salty and sweet. Fresh, warm, and tasty. Caesar Salad: Perfectly balanced dressing--not too heavy, not too light, just enough to complement every bite. Lobster Bisque: Highly recommended! My daughter loved it. Entrées: Signature Steak & Biscuits: Delicious! The steak was cooked perfectly, and while the biscuits were tasty, they were plentiful--definitely a carb overload! Half of it went home for breakfast. Salmon: My daughter's dish was well-cooked and flavorful--she barely made it through half, so leftovers were a must. Bonus points: They box up your food for you at the table, a touch you typically see in higher-end restaurants. Drinks: Their drink glasses are on the smaller side (I'd estimate about 8 ounces after ice), but refills come quickly and consistently, so you never feel like you're waiting. Dessert: We ended the night with Crème Brûlée and French Press coffee--a perfect way to wrap up a fantastic meal. If you sit in a booth, bring a jacket. There's constant air blowing, and you might get chilly! Stoney River delivered an exceptional experience, especially for opening night. The service was A++, the food was well-executed and plentiful, and the ambiance strikes a great balance between casual and upscale. If you're debating between this spot and the steakhouse across the street, I'd say give Stoney River a shot--you won't be disappointed! 5 Stars! Can't wait to return. read more

See all

Perfect Valentine's Day dinner spot! Super romantic and higher-end atmosphere. The service was fast and friendly. The food was delicious, would definitely recommend the Steak Eggrolls as appetizer read more

See all

Excellent service and atmosphere. Upscale steakhouse. Tasty and cool signature cocktails.. wedge salad was huge - splittable if not your main course. Liked our mains and will explore others on future visits. Easy to make a reservation on Resy . I did so 45 minutes after deciding to go there on a Sunday pm. read more

See all

From start to finish our experience was great! We were greeted with a smile from the hostess, seated immediately, and then greeted again by a manager who thanked us for joining them for dinner. After he left our server came by with some wonderful poppy seed breads and butter. Our drinks arrived soon after and they were perfectly delicious. We started with the spinach and artichoke dip, piping hot and delicious. My wife had the tuna stack for dinner which was not only beautiful but delicious. I opted for the sea bass. It is served over a layer bok choy and sushi rice, unbelievably good. This is a wonderful addition to Clift Farms and one we will come back to regularly. read more

My husband and I really love this place. The atmosphere is very nice. Dim and quiet. The rolls they bring before the meal are addictive. They taste like a poppyseed muffin and cornbread had a baby. Yummy! We usually get their steaks--all cooked perfectly. The servers have always been wonderful. I would have given 5 stars, but the last time I came for lunch the hostess was very dismissive and never smiled and it wasn't busy. That was a little off putting, but the waitress we got that day was a delight. read more

The food was so good--you've never tasted food as good. Our server, Fallon, was excellent and anticipated our every need. Every employee here is gorgeous. The place is cute and decorated very nicely. The art decor is beautiful. The only complaint I asked to cook my salmon all the way through, and unfortunately, it was raw in the middle. I had to send it back to get it re-cooked. On a positive note our waitress Fallon should be a model, If she's not already and she was so professional. We enjoyed eating here. read more

Stoney River - Filet mignon and smoked Gouda macaroni and cheese - Steakhouses Near Me - Madison, Alabama

See all

The service is amazing , but the food is so so . I got the swordfish and it was a little too greasy but the taste was ok . The braised cabbage was not all that but the sweet potato casserole was good . The drink menu is decent . Could it be a few dollars cheaper sure but all in all it makes a good date night . read more

See all

I love the aesthetic of the restaurant. It reminds me of J Alexander, obviously. I went to celebrate my friend's birthday and unfortunately they overcooked my steak, and for the price you would expect perfect execution. The remade it and it was much better, but still kind of killed the vibe. The service was great our waitress was very knowledgeable and able to recommend a good appetizer (crab dip). All in all I don't think you would be disappointed. ALMOST FORGOT THE BREAD.... ORDER 100! It is like an elevated Texas Roadhouse roll with the cinnamon butter! *Chef's Kiss* read more

See all

We love the chill atmosphere, it's nice and quiet. The food is always delicious. We have visited twice and the kitchen has struggled in a few areas, but the food really is good. The service was just meh, but not a deal breaker. read more

They have a fantastic brunch. Their steak and eggs and the red velvet waffle are our favorites. Their steak French press coffee is very good. The ambiance is pleasant and the service great! read more

There are two components to my review - the food and the service. We made reservations at Stoney River to celebrate and were looking forward to a nice meal and experience. The ambiance was the perfect blend of nice steakhouse with a fine dining feel, even though most patrons were dressed pretty casually. We were early to our reservation, so we grabbed a drink at the bar. I had a Martini that was delicious and my boyfriend had The Draper, which was right up his alley. Our bartender was friendly and quick to take our order. Our table was ready right on schedule, and we were seated in a booth right by the kitchen. Service: Unfortunately, I was not pleased with the service. It wasn't what I excepted at a restaurant of this caliber. I didn't want our food to arrive on top of each other, so we waited until our salad arrived to place the order for our entrees and glasses of wine. That was a mistake. We finished our drinks and our salad and then waited. And waited. And waited. Eventually our waiter came by to tell us it would be "just a second" and we requested waters. And then we waited. And waited. Eventually the water came, but still no food. I thought "well maybe he'll bring our wines, at least" but that was a no. Eventually, the food did arrive and then after that so did our wine. I know they're new, but I guess I would've just done things differently from a service point of view. And while there were other tables, it wasn't like they were super busy. Food: I had the swordfish, which was incredible. I would change nothing about that dish. It came with rice and the seasonal vegetable I chose was cauliflower. That had some heat to it, but was still delicious too. My boyfriend had the filet medallions and had ordered it medium rare. Two out of the three were overcooked, so that was unfortunate, but the flavoring of the steak was on point. We had wanted dessert with a glass of bubbly, but by time our wine came out for our entrees, we had a decent portion of wine left by time we were done eating. We settled for just the white chocolate creme brûlée, which was still a good pairing with our red wine. Overall, four stars. We will return, but are going to wait a bit and hope they figure the timing of things out. read more

See all

Nice atmosphere and very clean. Service was good. Food is very good but portions are small. read more

Stoney River - filet medallions and crab cake $44 - Steakhouses Near Me - Madison, Alabama

Highway for a last-minute dinner and my service was great and the food was delicious. Things came out quickly and I had a nice time trying things I have never seen before. The environment is welcoming. read more

Stoney River has a beautiful exterior and a warm, upscale atmosphere -- definitely one of the better spots in town for a nice dinner date. I took my girlfriend here and she really enjoyed her wine, and the service was friendly and attentive throughout. The bread rolls were fantastic, but I'll be honest -- the steak and overall entree quality didn't quite meet the high bar I'm used to coming from L.A. Still, I'm a business owner myself, and I always support local spots doing things the right way, so I'm giving it five stars. It's a great place if you're looking for a solid date night experience and your expectations are reasonable. read more

Stoney River - Steakhouses Near Me - Madison, Alabama

Such a disappointment. Had 8pm reservation on weekend. Server was friendly. We each ordered a cocktail to start. The restaurant was not busy but it took 20 minutes to receive our drinks. Ordered food, both getting a version of filet. I ordered the Oscar, he had with crabcake. The food tasted good, but both of our meals came out cold. The crabmeat and sauce on my steak was refrigerator cold. Steak and potatoes were was room temp. His fries were cold and steak was room temp. Didn't expect to pay $50 a plate for two meals so unappetizing. Didn't complain, but definitely won't be back. Bright note, the poppy seed bread and cinnamon butter were delicious. Note for the ladies-it was sooo cold in the building. Was freezing with a short sleeve maxi dress on. read more

February 21-2025 @2:30pm. My Wife along with Son and a friend stop by to eat and view the new restaurant. We ate at the bar and it was an excellent experience. The service was highly informative and the food was amazing. They are doing great work in this establishment. read more

See all

Food was good. Atmosphere was to crowded. Not the servers fault. Server was just over stretched in tables she needed to cover.

We arrived Sunday just as they opened. I went to the hostess desk and told them 2 adults and 1 baby that would require a highchair. We were called within 2-3 minutes to be seated. We arrive at a high booth. I said do you have booster seats for these and she said no. I said do you have a high chair tall enough for the booth and she said she wasn't allowed to bring high chairs in that area. We asked if we could sit at another table that allowed them and she looked very confused. Once we did get sat we ordered our drinks and were told some biscuits would be out shortly. Every table around us including folks that had just sat down were receiving them. Never made it to our table. I ordered the fillet and eggs. Asked for medium steak and over medium eggs. The steak came well done and the eggs came just hardly done over easy. Wife liked the lobster bisque. The service was just off from the time we tried to sit down until when we left. I wait almost 30 minutes for a straw. I'm going to assume you have to ask for them because if you don't ask, you're not getting one. The place is layer out nice and looks very clean. The bar looked to have a really good selection of wine and bourbon. I'll try it again, I know they're new. read more

Stoney River - Fillet and eggs - Steakhouses Near Me - Madison, Alabama

Went on a date with my wife here as our 2nd visit, (our first visit was lunch). Overall the appetizers are great, we tried the egg rolls & deviled eggs on this visit. The staff was friendly and attentive so that's a huge plus!. However, the aged coffee ribeye left much to be desired. At $65 my expectations were much higher. All and all, it was a great experience, but as a steak lover, I was disappointed. read more

Stoney River - Aged coffee cured ribeye - Steakhouses Near Me - Madison, Alabama

I am beyond impressed with this place and I would give more than 5 stars if I could! To start, the lady who sat us explained what each menu had on it which I really appreciated. The menu for food wasn't too overwhelming and had a good variety of choices. Our waiter was very attentive and made sure we had plenty to drink. We got the steak egg rolls as an appetizer and I was super impressed with the amount of food they gave and the quality! I got the Cedar Plank Salmon with broccoli and mashed potatoes. Again, very impressed with how much food was provided. Representation of food: great. Prices weren't crazy. Most places charge a lot more/or same price for a lot less food. Also, service at other places is not near as good as here. The staff really cares and I believe the owner came by to ask us how everything was at the end. Lastly, the ambiance was great. Very high quality. I will definitely be back!!! read more

Stoney River - Cedar Plank Salmon - Steakhouses Near Me - Madison, Alabama

See all

My first and not my last visit to Stoney River!! What a beautifully decorated restaurant! In addition, the service, food, and drinks were great! We had their Steak Egg Rolls as an appetizer and they were so delicious! We didn't mean to eat them all because we certainly wanted to save some room for our entrees, but we couldn't help ourselves lol. For our entree, we had the Turf and Tide with garlic mash potatoes. Now even though the dish was very tasty and flavorful, it was served cold. We reported the issue to our waitress who then sent a manager to our table to correct the issue. Even though he gave us a new plate, the steak was still not as hot as we would've preferred, I believe the Dijon Blanc sauce made the steak medallions on the cold side. But a good ole oven would fix that issue. Lastly, we also ordered a cookie dessert which came with vanilla ice cream, which was very decadent and rich. All in all, despite the mishap, we will be back soon to try other items on their menu. read more

See all

I don't know it was our first time we were celebrating my daughter's 33rd birthday. The waiter was horrible,bad attitude the food was just okay they ruined my daughter's experience. Don't know if we will go back read more

Food was amazing ... the crab dip, crab cakes, and the steak frites were all very good. The filet medallions and crab cakes specialty entree was outstanding and paired extremely well the perfectly prepared one-pound baked potato (one of the best baked potatoes I've had). The steak salad was extremely good. Service was good. Ambiance is fantastic. Excellent food in a very comfortable and upscale environment. Definitely will return. read more

Came in with my mom and brother for the first time. Atmosphere is very nice and clean. The hostess was friendly and greeted us upon entering. Our server Hannah was amazing! Very kind and personable, she helped us navigate the menu and had great suggestions. There was a slight discrepancy with my mom's food but the manager Joe came right over and got everything squared away promptly. Great overall experience and the food and my mojito were great. I'd definitely come again. We had the steak eggrolls and crab dip for appetizer, lamb chops, ribeye, filet medallion and crab cake, mushrooms, loaded baked potato, asparagus, mashed potato's and the creamed spinach. read more

See all

Possibly the worst dip I've ever had. 16$ for a pile of wilted spinach with some Parmesan sprinkled on top. The one star is for taking of my check. Eaten here 7 times and been disappointed 6. Only thing I have had that was price worthy was the bistro chicken Probably never coming back. J Alexander blows this place out of the water. read more