Sugarmill Restaurant is located at 5446 S Suncoast Blvd. It's been there for years in a strip store plaza on the end near the street. It's a family operated restaurant known for their homestyle food offerings especially breakfast(which is offered all day) at affordable prices. We went around noon so everyone in our party of eight could order from breakfast and lunch menus. The inside has both table and booth options - with our large group we called ahead and asked for a table seating eight which accommodated our needs nicely. Staff was super friendly and efficient. We were seated promptly, given menus and asked about our drink choices. Our group had a variety of dishes from both the breakfast menu and lunch menu. Food portions were good - even the kid's plates. Everyone thoroughly enjoyed their food and ate well. Both of my grandsons ordered off the kid's menu. One had a cheeseburger with fries, the other had scrambled eggs with pancakes. They loved their meals. My husband had country fried steak with gravy, two eggs over easy, a grilled biscuit and extra crispy home fries which he devoured. My son had two biscuits with gravy and two eggs over medium - he wiped his plate clean. My granddaughter and soon to be son in law had steak (one ordered well done and the other one ordered medium rare) both were perfectly cooked to their liking and served with mashed potatoes and gravy - they ate it all. Her Mom had a club sandwich with fries that filled up her whole plate. She was very happy with her choice - said the sandwich was excellent. I chose a cup of their homemade chicken noodle soup which was very tasty. Large chunks of chicken and veggies in a homemade broth with noodles that were cooked properly. And then for my entree - I decided on crabcakes and my choice of one side was their potato salad. The only slightly disappointing meal out of the bunch. I thought that a Mom and Pop Greek restaurant would offer homemade crabcakes but these were store bought. Flavor was okay but not what I had in mind. Always ask if it's homemade first - lessoned learned! Their homemade potato salad was okay - a little bland so I added salt. They serve a large number of elderly customers so they're probably salt conscience for everyone's well being. Next time I will choose a different meal but seven out of eight people very happy is very good indeed! I cannot wait to go back again and maybe try their breakfast selections this time. All in all a very good experience! read more

See all

This was a friendly diner located in a small plaza with great service! Very friendly staff who shared some info about the area with us. We shared an omelette and home fries - plenty big enough to share between 2 people. Flavor-wise, the omelette was a classic average tasting omelette - great for those looking for a simple but good breakfast. read more

Our "regular" local breakfast spot was too crowded, so we tried this place instead. We're a little mad at ourselves for not trying it sooner! Luann gave us great service, the food was really good, and the coffee was better than our regular spot! We'll definitely be back to this laid back feel at home place! read more

Sugarmill Restaurant - Diners Near Me - Homosassa, Florida

See all

Awesome spot! Burgers are incredible--tastes like home in the best way. I almost didn't post because I want to keep it a secret, but that'd be selfish. Definitely try this place read more

Sugarmill Restaurant - Restaurant, burgers, American fair - Diners Near Me - Homosassa, Florida

Good food, good service, good prices but very busy and a regular stop for many locals. Our waitress was very busy but on top of everything. Our food was cooked to order and tasty. Nothing fancy and no frills but decent food at an affordable price. We left full and happy. read more

See all

This the best value for your money. Great breakfast, lunch and home cooked dinner specials you will enjoy.

Went here this morning for the first time. Ordered an egg scrambled soft and OMG it came that way. I think this is probably the 3rd time in many many years that it came out right. That alone deserves 5 s. The staff are very attentive and the owner is a real sweetheart. She was actually there with her family having breakfast but was also helping out as it was prime time for breakfast. She is also a fellow Greek and her husband was doing the cooking. Can't wait to go back and support a local restaurant with great food and to also say hello. read more

Service from Lou Ann, our waitress, was excellent. She was friendly, professional and very accommodating. Unfortunately, the chicken in the chicken/bacon/ranch ciabatta sandwich was so overcooked that I couldn't eat it. And, my husband's burger was odd tasting, like maybe not just beef. The restaurant itself was clean and cute inside. read more

Well I rate it this restaurant a few years ago, used to go there all the time, and the last time I went up two weeks ago, they were closed. Then I went up a week ago and they were still closed. So they either need to change their website, so people don't drive and find out that they're not open anymore. They're definitely not open from 6:00 to 8:00,, and they're not open from 2:00 to 4:00.. unless they're doing a midnight buffet I think they're closed. God bless Florida. read more

Excellent restaurant, good food, older people eat here, they know what's good and what isn't

New to area. Came upon this Jem.. Good home cooking. The Food and service are top notch.

Small hometown feel. Us city folks are used to dining at major chains and barely venture in to whole in the walls so to speak. This place is a gem , serving comfort style food at affordable prices. Good was good and this will be our go to place when staying at a RV park close by. read more

Sugarmill Restaurant - The restaurant - Diners Near Me - Homosassa, Florida

See all

Great food great service very fair prices I highly recommend this place!! Stop in if you're in the area read more

This place is amazing!! So cozy, comfortable, incredibly nice staff. The owner/ manager came around to check on everything, we love that! The food was yummy & affordable, we can't wait to come back to see what else they have to offer. read more

This place is a time machine of many sorts. The clientele are the older set, complete with walker frames - they all know each other and are not afraid to shout the details of their latest surgical procedure across the restaurant. There is a quite appalling, but most amusing, mural along one entire wall of the restaurant - comprised of Zeus, an angry-looking cloud, and a columned Greek building (probably the Parthenon), in three clearly-separately crafted panels, not quite matching in color, scale, or style. (I am guessing this was a Greek restaurant at some time, though not now! Check my picture!) But the food and the decor are clearly timeless favorites.... from the 50's. Floral plastic tablecloths are the perfect setting for grits, biscuits and gravy, eggs, omlettes, hashbrowns, homefries, and all the regular fixin's. The food hit the spot and was devoured quickly - being exactly what you would expect in a restaurant that was packed with pensioners by the time early-bird hour was underway. Nothing special - just good eggs and good biscuits served friendly and fast. So why the coveted five-star rating? There's not many places two can eat without complaint for less than eight bucks! (Cash only!) read more

See all

Great selection on breakfast menu lunch menu and full supper menu topped with great desserts and wonderful serving and very good prices and lots of room and take outs also good parking read more

Food was good, service was good, and we were able to get in and out in a timely manner. The only thing that I didn't like was that it was a little loud inside. read more

We just moved to Homosassa the day before and this was our first experience eating out in this area. We found a nice, clean friendly staff at Sugarmill, and the food was wonderful. Our waitress told us that they make their own biscuits every morning, and they were so light and fluffy, they were like clouds! The gravy that came with my "biscuits and gravy" was great! The sausage was not hot but rather on the mild side which allowed me to appreciate the taste of the gravy which was fantastic. My partner opted for bacon, eggs and home fries, all of which were just perfect. The portions were generous, the food delicious and the prices were reasonable. The wait time from order to delivery of food was minimal and everything came to our table piping hot. I would highly recommend trying this spot if your in the area, we look forward to our next visit. read more

Huge and delicious Greek Salad. Hubby ordered Cheese Omelet, Hash Browns with Silver Dollar Pancakes. Always good to have a place in a pinch. The food is always good and the service is always fast and friendly. Only complaint....could be a bit cleaner. Some things are a little old and worn and could be replaced or updated. read more

Sugarmill Restaurant - Greek Salad - Diners Near Me - Homosassa, Florida

See all

Stopped by this little gem on my way back to Tampa from Crystal River. I had not been to a basic diner style restaurant in years. I'm giving this place 4 stars for its authentic environment, plain old good breakfast food, unheard of prices (in the last two decades anyway), pleasant service and clean restaurant. Sometimes it's nice to go back to the basics. read more

Sugarmill Restaurant - Diners Near Me - Homosassa, Florida

Good breakfast and lunch, dinner you can eat cheap here! Biscuits and gravy is to die for. read more

Sugarmill Restaurant - Nice bright clean restaurant good food with a steak nite 10 oz. with all the fixin $8.95! - Diners Near Me - Homosassa, Florida

Went back there today (we go there often) at around 1:30pm for lunch. Light crowd, fast seating and superfast service. Chach served us, and it couldn't have been better. I had the the lentil soup and a turkey club sandwich. My wife had the chicken noodle soup and a reuben. Both dishes were very good. The only complaint is that my wife eats too fast. read more

Sugarmill Restaurant - Reuben sandwich - Diners Near Me - Homosassa, Florida

See all

Cute, clean diner with better food than I expected. The chicken noodle soup broth was tasty, the Greek salad had a great homemade dressing and yummy feta, and the triple-decker turkey club wasn't half bad. I'd skip over the open-faced steak sandwich though, as it was pretty bland. Will definitely come back for breakfast, which was recommended to us by a few locals. Good and cheap too! It's cash only but if you run short, there's an ATM across the highway. read more

See all

I don't care how cheap their food is, it's disgusting. Comparable to hospital food. If it wasn't for broke senior citizens with no taste buds, this place wouldn't be open. read more

Great little place for breakfast, food is excellent and the portions are ridiculously large. Very reasonably priced, clean, fast service and a really nice menu with good variety. Pancakes, omelettes, burgers, salads and sandwiches. We had a server named Joy who was over the top friendly and responsive. We had a great experience, highly recommend. read more

We are from upstate New York visiting for a family emergency this was the BEST comfort food!! Service was A+ Prices were very reasonable!! Best of all the food tasted AMAZING!! Definitely recommend read more

Accidentally finding this diner was a treat! Before heading getting on the toll road towards Tampa we wanted to get a bite to eat. This was place was the last restaurant we saw, and we really enjoyed it. Good creative diner with Greek and Italian influences. The service was quick and friendly too. read more

See all

Gotta say. This restaurant is really good. The best eggs Benedict from coast to coast. I have traveled many many business miles and remember the "bad ones v. the good ones" and this place sets the "bad ones" apparat from the rest. Sorry to those who experienced a bad meal in the past at this restaurant (and it does happen-unfortunately) but not the case now. Chris and his family truly live up to their mission statement in treating patrons like family. We eat at The Sugarmill at least five days a week. The blueberry pancakes are unreal. The New England clam chowder yummy. The Turkey club equally as good. But the eggs Benedict unsurpassed! read more

Stopped by for a lunch to go and very disappointed . Had not been there in over1?year or so . Turkey club was cheap water added lunch meat and the fish sandwich was on a dry stale bun . Not like it used to be . Won't go back . read more

Just like Kingpin said 2 years ago.....this place is great. Nice cozy waitresses and home cooked food. Our server was Greek and said this place is Greek owned. My friend and I had the 2 for $12.50 dinners. I chose the half chicken and he had roast turkey. Soup or salad...soup was delish!! Choice of a tater and veggie. Iced tea or coffee and dessert included. You just can't beat that. If you look in the mirror at the cloud my friend noticed you could see the word help. The cashier had never noticed. The waitress said there were more letters and was a greek word!! Lots of old folks...fun to watch :) read more

Small place adequate parking. friendly service. This place has the best breakfast around. Great prices, portions and service. The owner checked in with each table to ask how the food was! read more

Average food at an average price. Usually not to busy which is good. I don't like how they add a charge of 3.5% to the total bill if you use a Credit Card. That's not cool and it's not advertised on the door when you walk in so I wanted to put that warning out there in case you don't have cash. The 3.5% is not added until you're at the register. Sneaky lol read more

We went to this place after reading the previous reviews. We figured out that "Teddy" was busy cooking for the breakfast rush. Some omelets feature spinach or feta, a big clue to being greek owned. We also went there for dinner, Teddy and his family greeted customer after customer by name. This is another small town restaurant with a strong local following. read more

Sugarmill Restaurant - a sign for the restaurant - Diners Near Me - Homosassa, Florida

See all

Great deals on meals. 2 can eat cheap and never compromise on taste

Parents live down her and they have breakfast here often. So when we visit we eat here often. It's a small diner that is very popular. Sometimes it gets crowded. What you get here is a decent breakfast (Have never had lunch or dinner here) at a very reasonable price. All the customers seem happy. Tables are close together. I'm visiting this week and it's the same as usual. Decent breakfast at a great price. Just my opinion. Try it out and form your own opinion read more

If they only charged a nickel for a "meal" it would still be overpriced. The food is bland, never cooked properly and after seeing the bathrooms I am getting a little scared that the lack of cleanliness has led to some bacteria that is actually some mutant E. Coli cousin ready to ravage my digest system. Save yourself the anxiety and avoid this dump at ALL costs. read more

I had a work break and a co-worker drug me back there, I couldn't argue with the fact lunch was on him. I think someone listened to my last review, service was definitely improved, and the food was very decent. Service was quick, and the place definitely looked cleaner, and some of their crickety chairs had been replaced. Steady improvement, they are definitely doing A OK now. read more

Avoid at all cost. Staff is unkind and are more interested in gossiping with each-other than giving even sub-par service. They bicker with the owner, who has no respect for staff nor customers. They are unwilling and unable to keep even a teenage level of cleanliness. Dirt is caked into the floors, bits of food are between every tile, and the tablecloths (which are older than I) are half-assedly wiped with a dirty rag before each serving. The silverware is often dirty, and the mugs typically have lipstick stains. God knows what the kitchen looks like. But don't worry, every 60 seconds a waitress whom isn't even yours will come and fill your coffee over the brim, forcing you to sip it from the table like a toddler with no arms. Much like they disrespect their customers and staff, they disrespect the community, and have been caught on multiple occasions dumping their septic tank into the waters of Homosassa. The food is about what you could expect from a TV or frozen dinner. A cheaper experience could be achieved by buying some Tyson chicken nuggets, microwaving them, throwing them on a bun, and sitting down at a retirement home. Most dishes will be incorrect, such as the omelets, which are just eggs and frozen veggies fried until brown. Even the simplest of food is butchered, such as the "blueberry waffles" which are just watered-down Bisquick waffles with blueberries thrown on top, which cost extra by the way. Any complaints will lead to the owner angrily storming out of his nap and arguing with you. Which will happen often, by the way, because they don't know how to keep hair from getting cooked into every meal. You won't even be greeted with replacement food, but instead will have your plate returned to you with any complaints fixed, or completely ignored. The only reason I have ever gone here is to spend time with my elderly family who have been exploited by this disgusting establishment for years. Anyone who enjoys this "restaurant" is either lying or have lost all of their senses. The sooner this plague on our community goes out of business, the better. read more

I have no idea why this place is rated do high it was horrible the food was poor service was horrible and not to mention I could here them cussing and bickering if my kids were with there would have been a scene just too much to say, cash only I cant stop but i will never go there again and did i mention the waitress had on soo much perfume and make up that she looked like a clown! read more

My waitress was awesome and the food was great. The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars is because, just like I said with the Breakfast Station, it was discomforting that when the restaurant wasn't busy, the hostess sat me clear in the back corner by the emergency exit door. It didn't even feel like was inside the restaurant. It was like a table that was just there for overage for busy times---or sitting by the back door to be thrown out with the garbage. But it wasn't busy. I'm just hoping it didn't have anything to do with my non-white status. read more