So good we went 2x during our trip. I tried the fruity pebbles and chocolate donut with mint chocolate chip ice cream. So delicious and fresh and service was great too. Loved the wall outside for pictures! read more

Sundae Donuts Montauk - Chocolate donut with mint chocolate chip ice cream - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Came here for the first time as our original dessert plans fell thru for the evening. At first by the colorful decorations and vibe I was worried the appearance was more than their flavors. This was not the case, it's a vibey dessert spot with fantastic options from ice cream, milkshakes, and donuts. The girl who served me was beyond patient and helpful as I was definitely overwhelmed from a Long Beach day and the bright colors inside, LOL. I opted for two scoops of their strawberry ice cream and it was delicious with real strawberry chunks! I will definitely be back as I've been told their donuts are outstanding. I also really enjoy that you pay by the scoop and not just for a generic size. Because sometimes a small or medium or large size is just too much ice cream. read more

Sundae Donuts Montauk - Two scoops of strawberry ice cream - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

Came here this past weekend craving their edible cookie dough I loved last year. Bummer: they don't carry it anymore :( I wonder why? I settled on chocolate ice cream and it was fine, nothing special. I kept thinking about how much I missed the cookie dough. Anyway, this shop will totally fill your sweet tooth. Decked out with ice cream and donuts galore, Sundae Donuts is extremely funky and will brighten anyone's day. The last row of ice cream features your traditional flavors with donuts mixed in. Pretty cool. read more

See all

Specialty donut shop with some fun varieties. Staff were friendly and the place was pretty empty so service was quick. The shop itself is super fun with all rainbow colors, lights, and tie dye merch for sale. We got the glazed, Nutella, jelly, and apple fritter donuts. The Nutella was outstanding and the glazed was good but to be honest the apple fritter was only okay. My husband was not particularly impressed with the jelly donut. They also have candy and other options which we didn't try. Overall glad we tried it and found it to be a fun experience overall! read more

Sundae Donuts Montauk - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Great spot for artisanal donuts. The shop is beautiful and clean. I stuck with old school jelly, and it did not disappoint. Stop in if you're in the area. read more

Sundae Donuts Montauk - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

This place is very colorful and cute place, but the food was just okay. This is a good spot to visit if you like donuts, milkshakes, and candy. We got the jelly donut and a chocolate milkshake, however, the chocolate milkshake had cookies in it so I'm not sure if that was made correctly. It also took a while to check out because the worker couldn't seem to figure out the cash register. It's a fun place, especially if you have a kid with you, but I'm not sure if I would come back again. read more

See all

Average ice cream, average donuts. I've been here a couple of times, and I'd rather go to John's or buy a pint of haagen dazs than get ice cream here. The jelly in the donuts is of low quality, which takes away from what could be a decent donut. The jelly croissant at montauk bake shoppe is much better. On the bright side, the service was good the last time I was there. read more

A fun and colorful combination of ice cream, donuts, and tie dye! My husband and I got a scoop of vanilla with donut and a scooping birthday cake with donut, which was delicious. There also were some interesting donut choices (like a really loaded s'mores donut), but unfortunately did not have enough space to get a donut haha. The store was also really colorful, which definitely set a fun vibe. Definitely a fun little stop in Montauk! read more

Sundae Donuts Montauk - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

Best donut shop in the south fork! Super high end and lovely. Cookie dough bites, milkshakes, ice cream coffee - whole 9 Super friendly and welcoming staff - Highly recommend read more

See all

I have to start off by saying the donuts here are DELICIOUS and definitely worth it! The service is also great. The only reason I'm not giving a full 5 star review is because they run out of donuts and desserts frequently, limiting your options. I have never made it to Sundae during the morning hours, when I assume they're fully stocked with a house full of patrons? My very first experience happened after I was very dissatisfied with my dinner that I had at a restaurant down the street. I barely ate and was moseying around Main Street and happened to see that Sundae was still open. My options were limited but I was lucky enough to try their Nutella donut, and it was amazing! After that experience, I have only been back a few times in the afternoon and later in the day. During these times my options were limited and they were very slow with little to no other customers. On a couple of occasions I walked in and right out just because I didn't see anything I wanted. Had there been more options I'm sure I would've bought something to satisfy my sweet tooth! read more

Sundae Donuts Montauk - Nutella donut - worth the calories and sugar overload - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

Great ice cream & donuts in Montouk! Very friendly staff! I can't recall if they have tables indoors but definitely one outdoors... but nice to get your food and walk! :) read more

Passed by this place and instantly had a craving for some donuts so we stopped in to check out the place. Ordered a jelly filled donut and a Boston crème donut which were both tasty! Staff is nice and friendly so it's a pretty inviting spot. Drop on in here if you're also having a random craving for some sweets! read more

Sundae Donuts Montauk - the entrance to the store - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

The donuts were mid, and I'm being nice. It was a fairly disappointing dessert closing out an otherwise gorgeous outing. The service itself was fine. The place was clean enough. I would rather go anywhere else, though. For a dessert shop in Montauk this was far below par. read more

This place is kind of hidden in what looks like the basement under MTK lobster house. It looks like your normal donut shop but due to covid we couldn't walk in. One thing that was kind of offputting was there were bees in the donut cases. I know in montauk there are a lot of bees everywhere but that was not appetizing. Nevertheless I tried the apple fritter, oreo donut, and glazed. The overall theme was that they didnt taste fresh. I hate to be mean but I like the apple fritter at Wawa rather than here. There wasn't really anything special about these other than the interesting combination of toppings. I didnt understand the hype on this place. Seemed very average to me. One thing that wasn't average was the prices though so not sure I would go back. The product wasn't worth it. read more

See all

Never ever again. I had three kids with me and two adults. I spent a significant amount of money. As i went to grab my edible cookie dough scoops, another customer was behind me and I accidentally dropped it. No big deal right? Wrong! The girl at the front says "sorry you'll have to pay for another one!!" I just paid for the one that accidentally fell and because of an accident I have to pay double?? Even the customer behind me was like "it's an accident". As I storm out, she says in this passive aggressive voice, so will you be paying for another one? Good food will not make up for bad customer service. Update-it gets better My HB goes in to speak with a manager. One of the girls tries to say that I dropped it outside. So he gets a manager who then has to look at the video to validate. I can't make this up. And clearly on the video you can see it was an accident. The manager says we can't possibly reimburse everyone who says they dropped something. My HB says you have a video and can see it's an accident. Mind you, i was never blaming anyone but myself. Nor did I ever say it was their fault. So after 10 minutes and multiple arguments, I got my 3$ scoop back and they lost a customer and hopefully many others. Was it worth it? read more

Awesome ice-cream and donut shop! Came here with the fam and was truly blown away at all the original flavor and combo ideas here!

Great local doughnut and icecream spot. (new to the area) Doughnuts are creative and a mix of classics + childhood cereals. The icecreams are great too. Loved the tie die cookie monster ice cream sandwich (so fun!) and love the cinnamon toast crunch doughnut! They have packages for DIY as well which could be fun for parties or events. Everything I've had hear has been a sugary delights, hit the spot, and tasted great. Social distancing currently observed due to covid, fun creative menu, and outdoor seating to enjoy in town! Definitely will be back! read more

Sundae Donuts Montauk - a variety of donuts - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

Delicious!! Must stop. They are expanding and one is coming right near me in NJ. We ate the chocolate sprinkle explosion. We forgot to take a picture of it. It was that good! read more

See all

These are some delicious gourmet donuts. The flavors, textures, soooo good! Coming back for more donuts daily! read more

Sundae Donuts Montauk - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

We were on a mission for a yummy pre-Montauk-hike breakfast. So this donut spot right in town was the place to go! The decor is so quirky and fun and eye catching. The graffiti and crystal chandeliers really give it a playful whimsical feel. And to top it off the donuts were so dense and sweet and delicious! They were giant! I got a Cinnamon Toast Crunch donut and it was amazing. Would definitely come back to try more. read more

Sundae Donuts Montauk - Vanilla frosted with sprinkles - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Great donuts for a late night snack in Montauk! Lots of interesting options and friendly service!

Stopped in for dessert and thought it was a prefect concept! We got donuts and added a scoop of ice cream on top! 10/10 recommend!

Adorable little donut shop in town. Had two of the most amazing donuts today. Wished we lived here so we could try them all! read more

Sundae Donuts Montauk - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

ventured out to montauk this weekend and had to try sundae donuts!! this spot is ADORABLE! if you're looking for the perfect photo op, this place has it!! when you first walk up, it is covered in multicolored hearts and it looks so cool! right now due to covid, the store front is just walk-up, but the inside from what i could see is set up very nice!! there were SO many awesome options for donuts! it was $23 for a half dozen - a little pricy but hey, when in montauk! the donuts are a good size! not too small and PLENTY on top so i feel that they are worth the price. donuts are fluffy and tasty, and so far all the ones i've tried are yummy! definitely a cute spot for a fun dessert!! read more

See all

The menu is a bit overwhelming and we're only allowed one sample per person. But once you decide what you want you can't really go wrong. We came at the end of the day so I thought the donut was a bit dry and the ice cream wasn't extremely creamy (probably because there's donut bits in the ice cream, but it was still delicious so I'd definitely recommend this place for dessert read more

Sundae Donuts Montauk - Donut sammie with frootloops and chocolate sauce - Bakeries Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

The small scoop $6!!!! Robbery! Their prices are completely overpriced and girls who work here are rude and passive aggressive. Ice cream is not even that good. I miss Ben & Jerry's and Frozen Anchor. This place does not even come close. Will never go back. read more

The ice cream is great. Getting the doughnuts here is also just as good. On the main strip on Montauk but slightly hidden away. Would recommend for people that have a sweet tooth like me. read more

Quite the interesting concept for a dessert place and well-executed at the same time. It's exactly what you expect from its name: delicious ice cream on delicious donuts. There's a vast variety of toppings and its a fairly big place. The staff are friendly and serving sizes are large. Only warning is that whatever you get will be VERY sweet, but that's probably what you're looking for if you go anyway, right? read more

Tasty donuts with creative toppings! They did taste fresh to me and the kids loved them. We got the s'mores, Oreos, M&Ms, rainbow sprinkles, and chocolate sprinkle donuts to share. And the s'mores ice cream was a hit also! read more

Absolutely amazing!!! The staff is fantastic and friendly! The ice cream flavors are awesome and delicious! I love the ice cream sandwiches they are my favorite! Totally recommend for all ages, it'll put a smile on your face! read more

Fillings were good, but certainly not enough. Donuts were average - a bit on the dry side. All 7 of us didn't finish out donuts and through them out after we ate the filling. A cheap simple Dunkin' Donut is far better than this donut shop's fancy looking donuts. Decor and Feel/Vibe of place was very alluring and made us want to eat there. Unfortunately, looks are deceiving. Wish the donut itself tasted better! read more

On our visit we ended up visiting 12 times (jk) as my daughter has a sweet tooth, ok 3 times. Had the smores donut (better), oreo donut and the campfire ice cream, and I had the mint chip ice cream with the donut pieces inside and it was really good. Need more help on the weekend night in September as its the ideal place to visit after dinner! read more

This place missed the mark for me. They have so much potential, but the quality and pricing structure isn't there. They have a lot of fun offerings (specialty donuts, cookie dough, fun ice cream flavors, etc.), but when I went to order I asked if they could do ice cream + cookie dough and they said no. Fine. I settled for just ice cream. My boyfriend wanted a specialty donut with ice cream. Again they couldn't accommodate. Only plain donuts with specialty ice cream or plain (chocolate or vanilla) ice cream, with specialty donuts. All the shop would need to do is program these options into their POS and they could provide a much better customer experience while making a higher profit by upselling us on their specialized products. Honestly a no brainer, but unfortunately a bad customer experience. Also the ice cream was some the worst quality I've had in years. I'm boggled buy the poor business decisions the owner of this establishment has made. read more