Great place for a meal and you'll go back Vinny ozvoldo are great.they all have good attitude

Poor customer service. Rude phone contact. Just okay food. Making and selling great pizza is not difficult but when you get it from super pizza, it seems to be the case. read more

I stopped in for a quick slice yesterday. Solid New York slice. Thin crust that was on the doughy side. The service was quick and the slice was reasonably priced at $2.60. read more

Super pizza goes back to my childhood. original decor and all! I played video games with my friends Back in the 70's. this is a Bellmore landmark for those who dont know. The pizza is the best around. Always consistent and has the taste that brings me back to the days I miss. steve C read more

You gotta love Super Pizza!! This place has not changed in 20 years and the decor shows it, but that's the charm of this no frills classic pizza shop. Pizza and pinwheels are excellent. The staff is very friendly. Plenty of booths if you want to eat in. I love an old pizza shop that still has video games to play. Feels like going back to your childhood. Classic is the one word to best describe Super Pizza. read more

Super Pizza is the best pizza in Bellmore....and beyond. I have been going to this pizza place my whole life and have never been disappointed. The pizza is top quality!! I reccomend a regular slice for any occasion. The hero's are top notch, as well as the pepperoni rolls, garlic knots, everything. You can top off your meal like I have done since I was about 8 years old with an italian ice. I highly reccomend super pizza to anyone who apperciates good ny pizza. read more

Super Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

Been going there for 25 years. I've always like their pies. Their sandwiches are pretty decent too. I've gone to many pizza places and always go back there. http://www.bellmoresuperpizza.com read more

See all

We ordered 2 chicken Parm Heros and a chicken Caesar salad. The food was so bad it made me sick. The chicken Caesar had a weird teriyaki breaded chicken that did not match the flavors of the Caesar dressing , it was so bad I got sick. For real how do you not make note that it is a breaded teriyaki sauce on the salad? As for the chicken parm hero's-- the chicken was not breaded and was chewy which did not help me after my sour stomach from the weird salad we tasted. The sauce had no flavor and my husband had to doctor it up with seasoning and our stomachs got worse. I called to ask for clarification about my food- the teriyaki weirdness and they said that this is how it is- you have to ask for the chicken on the Caesar salad to Be "un sauced" I said nowhere on the menu does it say that and it's making me sick... and then I continued to say it should be stated somewhere because that Probably happens a lot they couldn't be bothered. And they said goodbye. My next move was i went onto Slice_ where I ordered from and chatted with the customer service and they were able to get a partial credit for the chicken despite the food making me sick. $5 - the salad was 12.50 I give this review as a warning; don't order from super pizza. We had their pizza which was pretty good, we had their wings which were not great but we are picky about wings (and they don't have any sauce on them) but after this monstrosity we will never give them our business especially since they didn't even take the salad off the check. Here I am I'll and they don't even care read more

I haven't been here in over 13 years, always enjoyed it back then, and enjoyed it again when I went today(I moved away). I've only ever had the pizza, so I can't comment on anything else. Staff was nice, just like I remember. RC fountain soda, or Coke bottles in the fridge. read more

Super Pizzeria - tasty pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

Really wish they had half-stars. It would be a 3.5. It's no frills, old looking and reasonably priced. Pizza was ok but too much sauce made the slice soggy even thought the bottom looked to be crispy. It's super convenient but not exactly my go-to read more

Ya know... I dont get the higher reviews. I've been to this place a few times purely for convenience. They suck every time. Come on... We're Lawg Islanders if we know nothing... We know pizza & bagels. For the life of me... I don't get it. Perhaps the people that are giving higher reviews are ordering something other than pizza. That's all I've ever gotten here & I think it's the pits. The crust on a regular slice isn't crispy & the sauce is so-so . When I got home with my pizza... It was a mess... Pic included . Ugh read more

Super Pizzeria - Not a very appetizing take home slice - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

You'd be hard pressed to find a better deal than the Wednesday $11.00 large pie. It's no frills pizza and I love it. Place is a throwback in design as well. read more

We ordered food to be picked up later and the counter guy gave us the price. We went to pick it up and the jacked up the price from $79 to $89. When we opened the bags , we were missing 2 sandwiches. My wife called to let them know and the guy starts cursing her our telling her that she was full of shit. Then he called back 20 minutes later to tell her that she was right. This pos had no right to speak to my wife like that and the food sucked anyway never again. Many food places are looking to regain business. This a**hole is chasing it away. read more

I found this place accidentally when. I was on the run and drove by. The pizza was surprising very good. So good that I decided to come again and it was equally as good. Both times I had the grandmas slice which I recommend. read more

Super Pizza is one of the better local pizza places in Bellmore. All of the food is really good and you won't be disappointed in anything you get here. Great place for take out but they also have tables if you want to eat there. There is a large parking lot so it is easy to get in and out. read more

Super Pizzeria - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

The pizza was very salty and burned at the bottom. Rude guy on the phone hung up on me 2 times when i try to order.

We just had a large cheese pie - well done per our request and it was PERFECT!!! I used to go to Super Pizza when I was in high school but haven't been there in quite a while for no particular reason. I've been disappointed with the new fancier pizza places popping up ~ not so great and way too $$ Super Pizza nailed that pizza last night - and for $10.50 on Wednesdays - HAPPY! I'm gettin two next week ~ read more

One bite, everybody knows the rules! This is just a really good cheese pizza there's something about the crust the sauce and the cheese and the old school pizzeria place that all come together and make it a great slice. Reminds me of the old Cherrywood Pizza in Wantagh before Umbertos came read more

Good old school neighborhood slice joint. Sicilian was really thick. Nice airy dough. Crisp on bottom. Regular slice was ok nothing great. They had rc cola on tap. Haven't seen that lately read more

Super Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

I enjoy walking there with my daughter the Pizza is really good and fresh Old style pizzeria

They require a $12 minimum for credit cards which is illegal and their pizza tastes like garbage- I just stopped in because it was convenient. They were completely unapologetic and impersonal. Do your self a favor and pick somewhere else. read more

I've been frequenting super pizza for years now and they've always had my favorite regular pies. Call ahead and ask for a fresh pie and you'll never be disappointed! read more

This place is a bellmore staple. It's a classic Long Island pizza place. No fancy bullshit. Far better than anything they serve at umbertos on bedford ave. Keep supporting super pizza. read more

Excellent pizza!! There has never been a problem ordering. This place has excellent food, heroes, lasagna, meatballs , you name it.

Best Sicilian pizza in Nassau County. Consistently good for 30 years. They use the best ingredients to get the best flavored pizza.

Since i've lived in Bellmore for over 8 years now i guess its about time i finally checked them out. I was very happy with my 2 plain slices and will def be back. The counter man was very nice and smiled and that is very rare these days unfortunately. This beats the hell outta Umberto's with the nasty counter help,,,, read more

Good pizza. Family owned business. Have been coming here for years. Sauce is great. I come from upstate to have this pizza.

Been going here for years. The pizza is by far my favorite on Long Island. The service is great, the owner will almost always chat with you in a friendly matter. It's like going to a family member's restaurant. The atmosphere is relaxed, you aren't rushed, and the food gets made quickly. Great place. read more

I love this pizza I was going there since I was little. Best pizza in town 10 stars read more

Nice local shop that's be around forever. Weekly pie specials are available. The food and service is good.

Super Pizza is a wonderful local spot. A perfect old school pizzeria. Prices are competitive, staff is friendly, and food is unbeatable! Give it a try! read more

I never had pizza in LI, and my aunt recommended Super Pizza, as that is where she normally gets pizza from. We ordered a large pie and had it delivered to the house. It arrived pretty quickly, and was still warm. The pizza itself tasted pretty good. It had a good amount of sauce and cheese. The bread itself was a bit too thick for me, but that's really a matter of preference; I like my slices super thin. Overall, this is tasty pizza and I will definitely grab a slice when I'm in town again. read more

Super Pizzeria - Large cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

Old school. Used to be good. Now it's hit or miss. Call ahead for a fresh pie. That's it.

It is by far the best pizza I have ever had on long island it blows domains way out of the pizza sauce.

User Rating: 2 out of 5 stars by Dee 06/12/2010 I recently moved down the block from Super Pizza, so naturally I gave the place a shot. The pizza was good. Well, last night I ventured out and ordered the Chicken Parm dinner. It had to be the worst chicken parm that I have ever eaten in my life! The chicken was soft, like it was undercooked 3 days ago and reheated in the microwave tonight. The sauce was horrible, so the pasta was not edible. It seemed like the sauce was different that what was used on the pizza. If you are going to order a pie, then please go ahead, you won't be sorry, but be skeptical about their dinners. read more

Horrible customer service! We have ordered from here for years, the past few times there have been mistakes. Frustrating, but understandable a few times we just dealt with it and other times we have called and they have fixed the problems. Well tonight they made a mistake and when I called they were rude, and said we'll get it rite next time. I said that that was not ok, I needed the problem fixed this has happened before and I'm not getting what I'm paying for. The worker then simply hung up the phone on me. We will never order from them again! read more

The pizza is only good if you order a pie fresh other wise the pizza lays around for a long time.

Very good pizza and healthy potions for their dinner orders. Stop in for sure........ read more

I have been here a few times and each time seems to get worse. Have had undercooked pizza and chicken rolls that are mostly raw dough. Will never be returning!!!!!!!!! read more

One of the better Pizzeria's in the area. Service is alway pleasant, food is always very good. A very good stop for a takeout dinner on friday nite. read more