It's no secret - West Seattle has a lot of pizza places. But the you should know the nuance for each one of these places. Each location has a distinctive style of pizza and hands down Supreme has the best East Coast style pies. This is where I go when I feel nostalgia for NY pizza - the types of slices you can walk and eat on your way to the Subway, or back home from the bar. Although I wouldn't recommend just taking a slice here and eating it while you walk down California and check out the rest of the junction (you do you, though) - the experience inside is part of the charm as well. It's like a neighborhood dive bar that's very welcoming, and while the service I've had here has been pretty limited just with the person the bar - they've always been friendly. This is a great spot to drink and get a casual dinner while you focus on catching with up friends. I'd recommend the Double Pep, there's just something so satisfying about the classics in a place like this. read more

Their website showed the business was open and it accepted our order for pickup. We paid online and showed up and the doors were locked, lights off. We are unable to find a number to speak with anyone about a refund. read more

Finally got to try Supreme a couple times. With some caution, I say it is the best Pizza in SW Seattle. The caution to be detailed below. Firstly, however, the basic pepperoni is excellent. Very airy, light crust with sizable cornichone. Super thin in the middle. Suspect they are using a high protein 00 flour and a long ferment. Cheese and sauce are flavorful, although carries an aroma similar to Dominos. The pepperoni - outstanding. Authentic cup & char. Topping proportions well done. Now the problem. And that is both times we ordered, the pizzas were cold and centers very soggy. This may be a consequence of them learning the ropes during COVID - I'll explain. We order these pizzas through the (horrid) Caviar app and requested store pick up in an hour. I suspect in both cases they made the pies as soon as the orders were received. Thus the finished pizza sat for an hour before we picked up. Pizza so bad the second time I almost took it back for a refund. But didn't want to be a Karen. One last point on the CAVIAR app - Supreme only allows orders through this. Supreme will not pick up the phone to take an order. The CAVIAR app crashes and will not permit to pay cash on pickup. Supreme lost our business for Weeks due to having to use this app. Can't you guys use the phone or is using such against millennial principals? Lord knows Caviar is taking a fee from Supreme. We will hold off on ordering any more from Superem. Will wait until post COVID when we can get a guaranteed fresh from the oven Pizza. Maybe then I'll change the rating to 5 stars. read more

Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

For starters, I'm giving them at three because this is the first time I've tried the pizza. I ordered the Detroit Square with added ricotta cheese. My honest opinion is it is very very heavy the dough with everything else on it per piece is very heavy. it is very salty as well. I paid $50 for Detroit Square with a soda to have a delivered. Very high for the price I was only able to get one and a half slices in. I will try the regular pizza next time and if it's better I will change my review but for now it takes a select person that enjoys this type of pizza to enjoy it. read more

My visit to Supreme Pizza in West Seattle left me with a heartwarming experience I'll not soon forget. Arriving near closing time, I was disappointed to learn they had just sold their last slices. Feeling a bit bummed, (knowing this was completely on me and no fault of the staff), I asked the bartender for nearby food options. To my surprise and delight, a kind man named Dave, who works there part-time, overheard my conversation and generously offered me his slices he was planning to take home. His act of kindness truly blew me away. He wouldn't let me pay him for it, after insisting twice (He also gave me a lesson about how many times you're allowed to insist/refuse before it ends up being rude :) and if you're curious, it's two times. :D) so, we decided I'd leave a nice tip for the bartender and be on my way. As I enjoyed the delicious pizza, I thought about Dave's gesture. It's moments like this that remind me that there is good in the world and being a kind person costs us nothing (except maybe a slice of pizza). Thank you, Dave! You made my night. 10/10. read more

Heard good things about this place so I decided to check it out! They were right, great pizza and great vibes!

The pizza was so very good, I've been trying to find this place on yelp to let them know. The service was a-ok, they were definitely busy when me and my friend came in to grab some slices, so I won't fault them on not getting to us super quickly. They did mess up my order, but they fixed it right away. The vibe of the place was very nice for a late night, low lighting, a game on in the background, strong drinks, and decent music. All in all a good experience, I would gladly go again just for the pizza! read more

A slice of a "Detroit Pizza" is the only thing I would recommend...have it thrown in the ("re")heater for an extra minute more than normal.

Waited 40 minutes for my slices, and was forgotten about. It was a Friday, but they weren't slammed hard enough to make such a silly mistake. I left without my pizza once I talked to the guy running the bar and realized they just didn't give a shit. read more

Supreme is what's up. Joe in particular always takes care of everyone and is a rockstar. He and the staff are an American treasure.

I was impressed with the quality of the ingredients at Supreme. I'm not a fan of thick pizza sauces, and the sauce here was flavorful and just right. The crust was pretty good, although nothing special. The flavor and texture of the cheese wasn't 100% spot on, and the half of the pizza that I ordered with sauce definitely could have used more cheese. There was a little bit too much flour underneath. It didn't blow me away, but it's a solid option for New York-style pizza. read more

Supreme - Mushroom & onion, half no sauce - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Very good crispy thin crust pizza, huge slice, great beers, friendly place - great service.

Damn good Pizza and fun atmosphere. I stopped in last night and was pleasantly surprised. I'm usually a pizza snob but this hit all they right marks. read more

Extremely rude staff, okay pizza. It was over 20 minutes past when they said my would be finished and when I asked if I could have any information on when it would be done, I was just told "we don't know, try some patience." No one could tell me where to pick up my pizza and when I waited by the kitchen to give the bar staff some space because they were clearly overwhelmed, the kitchen staff yelled at me. I was shocked. Picking up a simple pizza has never been so stressful. read more

Crawling along California Ave. between grabbing drinks, we stopped in for a quick couple slices (Double Pepperoni Square, and a slice). Your standard NY pizza joint, as others have said.. look elsewhere for the warm and fuzzies. Excellent pizza, quick drinks, and a comfortable low-key atmosphere. I'll be back, Cheers! read more

It's good slices and good drinks with a fun atmosphere. Casual bar service with friendly staff, this is a great stop for a low-key bite!

First time ordering tonight... She just handed me my order. Didn't smile and didn't say thank you. Maybe she was tired or had a bad evening. Definitely not a good vibe after the small interaction with the business. The food is ok. If you pickup your order they give you a pickup time of about 50 minutes. My food was barely room temperature. Seems like this place is a bar that serves pizza instead of a pizza joint. Why did it take 50 minutes to give me two slices of old pizza and wings that were obviously cooked as soon as the order was placed? Is it that hard to say thank you to a new and friendly customer? You didn't have to clean up after me or deal with me drinking too much alcohol. $20 for the order plus a 10% pre-tip (for nothing). I really wanted to like this place read more

SLLLLOOOOOOOOOWWWWWWWWWWWWWW 2x drivers claimed restaurant was 45-1 hour behind. Hire more cooks, give better estimates or use your own drivers! Either way. So late had to rearrange plans. Will be requesting full refund, and I literally NEVER do it! Pizza is decent but not 3 hour wait worthy. read more

If you're looking for a basic late night option I for sure would recommend this place. It's got a laid back vibe and the decor is lends itself to that "I need to get something on my stomach because I've had way too much fun" individual. We ordered a few slices and some of their cheese bread sticks. It was about room temp for both which at the moment was totally fine. I'd only frequent this spot for a quick in and out or a I need a late night stop option. When places close at 9 or 10 it's nice to at least have a decent pizza option. The cheese bread with the dipping sauce was on point though. read more

Supreme - Love the red lights and ambiance in general. Nice little in and out spot. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

The 3rd rude bartender in a row. There's no excuse for people who don't know how to treat people.

Our favorite place for a slice and a beer. So grateful to have this in the neighborhood!

First time trying this place after living here for 3 years. If you like salt, more salt and even more salt...this place is perfect. I ordered 2 slices of pepperoni with extra cheese. I paid for extra cheese but got nothing extra. A total rip off. Pizza is nowhere near NU standards having lived there for 2 years. Old...aged out and tired pizza...not even fresh. So many other options in the area with better food. read more

First time to his place in the West Seattle junction. This place has a real "dive" feel. I love it!!!! The pizza slices are crispy and hot. No kids and a very dark lighting situation. Middle of the day for day drinking? This is your place for a dive bar. After work? Slide or two with some friends, this is a good place. Looking for a place to bring business associates - this is NOT your place. You don't want your boss to know you like this place. I'm the boss at my place and I don't want to know u go to this place. However, it has a pac man video game and pin ball so an old guy like me will say OK. Prices very reasonable, I will be ordering pizzas to go for this place and picking up and taking my time before heading home. In summary good New York style pizza slices that in and of itself is good. The atmosphere is very appealing for those who get it. Not appropriate for a business setting. But very appropriate for cheap first date or an hour or two with the boys. read more

With SO many pizza options in West Seattle, Supreme stands out. The pizza is absolutely delicious, with creative varieties so there is truly something for everyone. The salad is also excellent, especially the Caesar which is one of the tastier ones I've had. And, whenever we can (finally) go to bars again, this place has such a fun vibe. Great drinks, including frozen cocktails if that's your thing. You can also buy by the slice when it's open. My friends and I spent a great deal of time playing multiplayer Pac-Man here while enjoying cocktails. Whether it's a late night or a weeknight evening, this is definitely most of the most fun places to hang in West Seattle. So I guess if you're one of those ranch-dipping pizza people, you might be disappointed? But if you just love pizza and supporting awesome small businesses... you'll love it. read more

If you could only order one thing at this joint, make it the Supremesicle! Pizza is meh, wings are bomb, but Supremesicle is life!

I'm all for supporting businesses in this time. But upon arriving for pick up and being told it was being boxed as we speak then 15 minutes later that it would be coming out and then 20 minutes later told it hadn't yet gone in the oven, well I'm going across the street from now on. Honesty would be appreciated. We can all live with more of that. And Caviar app is not accurate. Don't believe it. read more

I really enjoyed this pizza! I went to NYC and had some great pizza and some really bad pizza in NYC lol. I would say this is definitely NY style pizza and good! I'm happy to have another different style of pizza in West Seattle! Pizza is something so simple that everyone loves. There are times where I feel like dominos, or zeeks, or credo or tutta bella, talearicos ..it's nice to have another option that fits into a different TYPE of pizza category. I had the cheese and pepperoni slice! Chose it from the counter they heated it up for me and I really enjoyed it! Great thin crust, somewhat soft and chewy but crispy, very nice texture. I'd definitely recommend giving them a try! Everyone likes different things and you won't know unless you try them! read more

I used to love this place, wow, now they are another overpriced lousy pizza. Times are tough and you want to support local, well, this is a local place that maybe should fade away. $30 pizza, if you add toppings to a whole pie it's still a reheat with toppings added. Even Wendy's cooks your order fresh. I paid extra for these jalapeños. I should have been given a discount. read more

Supreme - Supposed to be pepperoni with half jalapeños. It was an old pepperoni that they dropped some jalapeños on it. - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

If you want a good slice of pizza, I would recommend stopping in. The slices are at the end of the bar and Supreme has at least 6 different pizzas to try with some none meat options. Last time I had sliced eggplant and the first time I had mushroom and olive oil. You'll be happy you stopped by. read more

Supreme - Eggplant and basil - why not - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

The detroit style pizza at the west seattle supreme has been my favorite pizza in seattle for years and you don't have to wait 3 months like Moto ? Its not on the menu that is the secret but you can order a whole pie at the bar or over the phone. I have taken dozens of freinds there over the years and they all agree. Plus great a beer selection and cocktails. This place is just solid. read more

Already in love with this new addition to West Seattle! We recently moved from Cap Hill and were missing the vibrant night life and food options, so hearing about the opening of Supreme put a HUGE smile on my face. We went on a Thursday night around 730p with a group of 6. All of the tables were full, so we opted to order pizza to go (took it to Beer Junction next door) and have a drink while we waited. Seating: The seating has a strange layout that doesn't flow well, in my opinion. I think it's best to get here early with a group of 4 or less, if you want a better chance of grabbing a table. Because of the weird layout, it's awkward to find a place to stand around and wait for a table or a drink and not be in the way of servers walking by. Food: Pizzas come in one size, but they also have slices (cheese, pepperoni and rotating special) if you want a smaller portion. We ordered the "Oh, You're so Hawaiian" pizza and I believe it was about 8 larger slices. Depending on how hungry you are, a pizza can serve between 2-4 people. Drinks: Do yourself a favor and order one of their frozen slushie drinks! The drinks were easily the highlight of my experience and tasted amazing. I was able to sample 2 -- Passion Fruit Habanero and the Supreme-sicle -- both were amazing! Arcade: They have a few arcade games and a juke box type of situation where you can pay $$ to request songs. The highlight of this room for me was the chalkboard walls and neon chalk! The black lights make for some fun art. All in all, this is a solid spot that just opened. The pizza is good, but the slushie drinks will keep me coming back! Definitely worth a visit. read more

See all

Yum yum god Jell-O shots and drinks and vibes and outs pizza yum yum. Need to open a location in Portland!

Not impressed by the pizza here. Full disclosure I came in around 9pm on a Thursday so maybe the kitchen was winding down? But they're open and serving til 1am so... Nonetheless, pizza was kind of lukewarm and soggy. Sauce was zesty, so one star for that. Bartender was friendly so that's my second star. It was just abundantly clear that this pizza sits under a heat lamp or something for hours before maybe being popped in the oven for a minute before serving. Ordered a pepperoni slice and supreme slice. The veg on the supreme was not cooked. Pepperoni was overall fine but again, texture and temp was a bummer on both. Also staff tends to get drunk at the bar once off shift and feels it cute to be rude to customers.. read more

I have to admit, I I'm not a YELP king. In fact, I mainly yelp when I'm angry. This pizza is awesome! I'm gluten intolerant, but , and for some reason this pizza leaves me feeling clean. I eat the crust. I want to eat the crust. Thanks supreme! read more

a couple of days into their new place and it seems like mark fuller and his crew have found their groove. the slushie drinks have great flavor and don't seem to skimp on their alcohol content (woe is me once the warm weather comes back around next spring.) the pizza offerings may seem standard but the flavor and size of the slices are more than adequate. there were no complaints at our table with the cheese and pepperoni slices that got put in front of us. the service was much better than what previous reviewers had reported. our server was attentive and accommodating. at one point, mark fuller himself brought one of the slices we'd ordered to our table--you can't ask for more personalized attention than that. prices are reasonable and the place was hopping by the time we left at 8pm on a tuesday weeknight. i can only imagine that come this coming weekend and into the future when people stumble upon supreme as a late night junction option or head specifically there with 100% intent, this place is going to develop a solid reputation (especially with us locals) as being somewhere you can rely on for food and drink. period. no pretensions. this place is what it is and will do well to stick with the casual atmosphere and plain and simple delivery of tried and true pizza with unique drink and slushie flavors to tempt the curious. i'd say go and check it out. i fully support how mark fuller has helped to shape our community by contributing to the culinary offerings that prevent us from having to brave growing traffic nightmares across the city if we want interesting food and fun libations. read more

See all

I'm here prettty often, whether its to hang out or stop by to grab a few slice to go. Here weekly at this point. I love their pizzas, all so simple yet so delicious. If your stomach and taste buds can handle the ghost pepper one. I'd recommend trying it as well since I love the heat, but don't take my word for it. I've been told my definition of spicy was screwed up. The cheese pizza here just happens to be my favorite thing to order when I've been drinking. I dunno what it is but it has so much flavor and no matter where I've been earlier in the day if I can, I will almost always make my way to Supreme for a few slices of cheese pizza to go haha. read more

They are slices. I get it. But how you gonna have that big a piece missing. THEY ARE SLICES, the "prep time" was an hour. This shit just sits under the heater. At least they sure look like it... the Supreme is missing half the toppings on the portion that actually has toppings. I'm under isolation, so I can go in. But now I know that's all this place is good for mediocre slices in person after read more

Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

This is by far one of the finest pizza places in Seattle, my personal favorite(along with Big Marios as a close 2nd). If you are looking for a classic NYC style pizza, this is the place to go. This is the best sicilian(or deep dish/Detroit) in the city and their regular cheese pizza has a perfect crust with an entirely authentic approach. Having this joint in my neighborhood was a dream come true. Highly recommend. read more

Came here for lunch on a Saturday, just had a few slices and a cider, over all the experience was okay, nothing special about the pizza, but will give it another shot if invited by a friend. The locations is on the main street in west seattle, and seems to be a pretty cool place to hang out a night, with a large bar and a few booths to sit in. There are a few arcade games in the back. Came at 1 on a Saturday, and it was pretty empty, and just went up to the counter to order two slices, a pepperoni and there meat special along with a cider, then sat down at a booth while waiting for the slices. They have tons of options for whole pies, with some unique options, while for single slices, its pepperoni, cheese, a meat special, and a veggie special. For the meat special when I went, it was a Mexican breakfast pizza, with eggs, chorizo, and arugula pizza. Its the standard new york style, the pepperoni was okay, while special didn't really work out with the arugula being to bitter for it. read more

See all

Had this when work ran late and the boss fed us dinner. I had two slices (one was not enough) of the BBQ Chicken pizza and it was the best bbq chicken pizza I've ever had. Such a variety of flavors within each bite. And the crush was very French bready; firm and chewy. Little out of my regular price range, but if you're in the mood for a higher end pie, check them out... read more