Bagels good service is extremely bad, everyone there is hispanic, and so i am i walked in one day to order placed my order with a shirt black haired woman. After i placed the order she started talking about me in Spanish saying I look weird and suspicious giving me nasty looks. Not realizing im hispanic too, and that i heard everything she acted like she didnt say anything in shock when i asked her why she said that. Im not sure who runs this place or how but discriminating is something to expect if your a young guy walking into this establishment so be ready to get weird looks if you are by their staff. AGAIN THE FOOD IS GREAT BUT THE STAFF IS VERY VERY NASTY, makes you really second guess giving your money to people like that. read more

This was my favorite place to eat back in high school. They have decent bagels but nothing to die for. I recommend a Taylor Ham and Cheese on a plain bagel. Giving 3 stars because I think they're a bit pricey! read more

Great bagels and their sandwiches are tremendous. The don't have stale lunch meat laying around...always fresh and always a great value but make sure you pay attention in the parking lot read more

This place sucks. First time ordering and won't ever order again. After waiting over an hour an half to receive a COLD breakfast, I then called and asked to speak to management. Roberto, the manager/owner, (we don't know because he barely knows how to answer and speak to a human being intelligently on the telephone) then proceeded to tell me that his driver was "supposed to come to our establishment first but I guess she didn't" -- please keep in mind, we then waited an ADDITIONAL 30 minutes after that phone call took place. Called again. He then offers me a 50 percent credit, which was acceptable. Fast forward to today, no credit on my account and I was charged the full amount. I proceed to call and speak to him when he proceeds to tell me that "his credit card machine won't let him offer a refund". Good one! Steer clear. read more

Good food but expect your order to be wrong. The food tastes good but they either don't listen to the orders properly or the employees aren't proficient in English. Just this morning I ordered a bagel with butter and the dude asked to clarify "with cream cheese?" I specifically said "no, butter." Lo and behold my bagel had cream cheese. I've also been there other times and people often come in complaining their order is wrong. So unless you're ok with getting a surprise meal, maybe avoid. It really sucks because I do like the food read more

The Bagel's are fresh, the service is strong, and the best part is the coffee is equally as pleasant. There is usually a line here and if there is one criticism it is that there is nowhere to sit. Nevertheless it is still a 5. read more

This was the first and last time I'll be getting a bagel from here. I usually don't like to write bad reviews, but when it takes 30 minutes for a bagel, I think it's warranted. I came in on a Sunday morning and everyone in line had already been helped. It took 10 minutes for anyone who worked there to acknowledge me and my husband. We ordered simple sandwiches (bacon, egg and cheese), but somehow that took 20 minutes for them to cook and assemble. I saw my order sitting on the counter for a good 5 minutes until someone working there decided to call it out and finally ring us up. The bagel sandwiches were actually really good, but for me, it's not worth the wait and frustration. read more

I love this place! The bagels are always fresh and the prices are reasonable. I enjoy getting my breakfast sandwich there on Sunday mornings. read more

My bagel sandwich tasted great. It was pretty packed in there so I think they're pretty consistent with serving fresh bagels and good sandwiches. They also had a variety of cream cheeses i never heard of so next time I will try one. The coffee was okay tasting but at least it was hot and paired well with my sandwich. The place is inconveniently small, even the parking lot. That's probably the most annoying part and why I knocked off one star. read more

This is my favorite place in the area. The food is really tasty, the portions are generous and it's affordable. There are a lot of choices, burgers, panini (these are really delicious) salads. And the staff is friendly, accommodating. Highly recommend. read more

Bagel box is the bomb, never have I had a problem with them before. The owner is a really nice hardworking guy. That being said mistakes happen time to time. On the rare occasion my food gets messed up, they'd be more than happy to replace whatever i got. Fiesta wrap is the way to go...... read more

The last time I went there there was a sizable line waiting to take orders. I had ordered a breakfast sandwich and small coffee. The counter people were too focused on taking new orders and not getting completed orders out the door. I felt bad about not leaving s tip but they left my sandwich sitting on the counter getting cold for 15 minutes while they just kept taking new orders. Get finished stuff out first. read more

Used to be amazing. It's awful. They screw up the same order daily. They are rude and don't care about the customers. Bagels are still good but I'll drive a little further to not have to deal with them Update. Went back to change the messed up order. They messed it up AGAIN read more

Gotta update my review since bagel box has been under new management. I gave it the old three strikes and now I'm officially done. First, I've been noticing a significant difference in the product here in general. Yes the bagels are okay still but the breakfast sandwiches used to be filled to the brim with extra eggs, cheese, huge pieces of sausage or a bunch of pieces of Taylor ham but now the sandwiches are a 1/4 filled. Dinky egg, a half a slice of cheese and a small breakfast sausage. The last one I got was just UGHHHH yuck. Even my fiancé who is easy to please actually said, "yea I think this the last time we go there." And I'm pretty sure their prices went up too and that is just ridiculous. More money for less, yea no thanks. And to make matters worse, the last time I went in they gave me the wrong order after I even questioned if I was getting the right one. It is unfortunate that this is the case because I want to come here, it is so close to me and the people who work there are super nice (hence the extra star) but I just can't justify it anymore. RIP Bagel Box. I will miss what you once were. :( read more

Terrible bagels and spotty service. More importantly, the bagels are terrible. 3/4 times I've been... they got my order wrong. I only tried more than once because it is so close to my house. But I now drive passed it to get real bagels because I just can't take it anymore lol read more

Only been here twice because it's not near me, but I have a few friends that live in the WO. Maybe it was because I was starving and probably hung-over, but I'm pretty sure it was one of if not the best bagels I've ever eaten. To me a fresh bagel doesn't need to be toasted. It is warm and doughy on the inside, has a crusty shell, and is delicious. These guys are pretty big. I remember what I had: an everything bagel, with smoked salmon spread, and a tomato. It was so good that I made my friend drive back so I could get a 1/2 dozen to bring back to the city with me. The next time I had a sausage, egg and cheese that was piping hot and the cheese oozed all over the eggy-weggy and crust and was just what the hangover doctor ordered. This place also serves "Sloppy Joe's", which in NJ doesn't equal what a sloppy joe is anywhere else in the world. It is basically a triple decker sandwich with coleslaw galore. Certainly not Adam Sandler's sloppy joe, but pretty awesome. Moral of the story: If you find yourself in West Orange, make a pit stop at The Bagel Box. read more

After living in Manhattan and eating H&H bagels, no bagel in Jersey had come close to them. But Bagel Box is the closest to that big perfect H&H - big and crispy outside, soft inside. Good flavor selection here, blueberry, choc. chip, Black Russian (Pumpernickel) some whole grains and even cheddar or jalapeno. They even have flavored cream cheeses and fish salads by the pound prepacked to go. They'll make you a sandwich of tuna, light tuna, coldcuts or chicken on a bagel of your choice. They have cold drinks or coffee as well. It's a small shop, so beware sometimes you may have a wait as other customers order a bunch of sandwiches or salads to take out. I'm not sure if you can call in an order in advance, but that would be helpful. read more

I used to love this place in high school but ever since they changed management the service is terrible. The staff barely speaks English and they always mess up orders. I've worked in the food industry so i know it's not easy to get everything correct, especially during high volume hours. This morning , i asked for a wrap that comes with bacon but i don't eat pork so i always replace it with turkey bacon. I watched her write "turkey bacon" on the paper and even after that when i started biting into the wrap i noticed that it was not turkey bacon. They've messed up my orders before and I've let it slide but this is my last time going there. I refuse to put money into a business that does not value their customers. read more

Great bagels! Good crust, fluffy inside. Exactly what you want out of a bagel. Pricing is good. It seems to be constantly packed, which is a good sign, though it might take a bit to get your order. No seating, just takeaway. read more

The Bagel Box is probably the best value for your money in the area for bagels. Their prices are about the same but they are the biggest bagels. They used to be pretty small but then about 5-6 years ago not sure why but they changed, not sure if its the same owners or not. Their new bagels are very good and a very nice size. If you want a good bagel in the area this is where I recommend. read more

They Bagel Box is good but if you call there are sometime when they say hold on and forget you are on the phone. There hash browns are great but very oily and if you get a Taylor ham egg and cheese it taste really great on a croissant read more

The food is good but I placed an order online ahead of time so that I could get to work on time. I set the puck up time for 7:30am and got there and waited another 30min before I got my order! That's just ridiculous! read more

The bagels here are really good. There needs to be a better system with online orders versus in-person orders. This morning I ordered in advance and 40 minutes later I arrived to be told that I had to get in line with everyone else to pick up. What's the point of online ordering, then? There should be two separate lines. Please get it together! read more

I used to go there all the time but the service has really gone down hill. There are a lot of bad reviews for this place here on yelp but most of them didn't make it into the "recommended reviews" section, but most of them are true. My biggest complaint is they can't get my order right, and I only order one thing: fried egg bacon and cheese on a roll, pepper ketchup. A couple months ago when they screwed up my order I told the guy who seemed to be the manager that they get my order wrong all the time. He said "ok". Last time I went in there, they screwed it up, making me late for work while I waited for them to fix it, then screwed it up again. Even though I had paid, I put the sandwich on the counter and told them forget it, I was already late for work. I'll never be back there again. I gave two starts because the food is good. read more

I was between 2 and 3 stars. This place is pretty overrated in my opinion. I have a high standard for bagels and Bagel Box did not meet it. First of all, they didn't label their bagels and they were set back far from the counter so I couldn't tell which was which. The service was okay. We only waited about 5 minutes but the bagels were definitely a disappointment. I like my bagel to be big and fluffy. These were small and thin, and they did not seem very fresh. We ordered Taylor ham, egg and cheese on an everything and pumpernickel with veggie cream cheese. Both were just ok. I wouldn't go back. read more

See all

When we moved from the city many moons a go this place was legit. They have new owners and make new bagels. They have a nice selection but the bagels are flavorless now. I paid $3.00 for a bagel with cream cheese. It use to be $1.75. I will just get my fix when he brings them home from NYC. read more

Every time I buy a bagel here I'm charged a different price. I think I counted 5 raisins in my raisin bagel today. The new owners have ruined this place. I've had a better bagel on a United flight. read more

Just learned that the Bagel Box is under new ownership, after having purchased a dozen. Not the same bagels anymore,Not the same bagels anymore, the texture is very mealy rather than chewy, and lack flavor.we can make a order with scream the radio always lower .. it is shame . maybe this why they have a mistake with the order .. read more

Incredibly rude. Hung up on. Ordered food for delivery which took a significantly long time considering I'm a few yards away. I could not pick it up because I am at work. I called and asked to cancel and for a refund because by now it's lunch time. He told me he would not refund my money and hung up on me. I will not be ordering from here anymore. read more

I normally love bagel box and they have been my regular bagel store for years. Unfortunately, I don't see myself going back there in the foreseeable future as they are not taking covid seriously. I had to ask a woman behind the counter multiple times to please put her mask on while handling my food. I NEVER right bad reviews but this is unacceptable. read more

Bagels are decent for the Jersey area however delivery is horrible. Not only did they give me the wrong order but they cancelled one of the bagels because they did not have the spread requested. A simple phone call letting the customer know would have been ideal. If you decide to try them out, def go in person. read more

Terrible parking lot on top of incompetent employees.. got an egg and cheese on a roll the other day and I couldnt find the cheese. When showed to the kid behind the counter he said "thats how we make it". Explained that I didn't want it and he said they would add a piece of cheese. So instead of making a new one he offered a cold piece of cheese on an already cold sandwich.. egg cheese and a roll isnt very expensive, although they charge almost as much as others do for taylor ham egg and cheese and they couldnt offer to remake?. Finally after having to demand our money back he obliged. They also have 5 people helping you with the same job and its a cluster f*** behind the counter.. the girl that ended up ringing us and the guy before us up charged him way less than what he ordered. He had to ask twice if $12 for 3 sandwiches 5 muffins and a 5 drinks was enough.. she was so confused and forgot to add all the sandwiches.. she also gave us a choco chip muffin when we asked for a raisin bran one.. We used to stop here all the time since there isnt any other bagel place close by and their food is pretty good.. we will now be driving to Montclair for breakfast on the go... read more

Ordered from out of state to be delivered to my moms workplace for her birthday. She was very happy with the delivery and food. Thank you

Bagels are great, but the last couple times when I ordered a bacon egg & cheese the bacon was barely cooked.

My business is located across the street from this place. Myself and my staff come here all the time for breakfast. I absolutely love their French toast bagels w/ egg and cheese!!! They are always prompt with the orders as well. read more

I heard stories about this place but needed to judge for myself. Unfortunately the stories were true. Cockroaches. Enough said.

Oh Bagel Box, I love you. Fresh bagels, amazing Service and the food is great! I remember this restaurant from high school. We'd be late to school because The Bagel Box was our priority at 8 am, not Math class. =-/ I love that they have a great variety of bagels verses just the average plain, blueberry, and grain. They also have a window of prepared foods like eggplant, cold pasta, chicken cutlets, and much, much, more. Grab a breakfast sandwich, a coffee, and a bench at the park. You'll love it! read more

Went in to grab a quick lunch and they had nothing left after tossing everything for the day. They weren't supposed to close for another two hours. They reluctantly scrounged up a grilled cheese for me. read more

Personally these are my favorite bagels in the area and I've tried them all. The bagels are larger than a lot of other places and they have a huge variety. They don't skimp on the portions either - any sandwich is a handful in addition to being a mouthful. What really seals the deal for me is that this place really does have great service. I don't know what the other guy was talking about. They've never messed up an order but more importantly, I'm confident that if they did they'd make it right. When I have large orders they've thrown in free bagels for no reason at all. The staff is always friendly and they have regulars that come in every morning. If you've never been there, it's a hole in the wall without any areas to sit down and eat so you'll be bringing your order somewhere else. It'll be worth it though read more

One morning I went in around 7 to get a few bagels and there was a mouse running around on the counter. Needless to say I cancelled my order. Wish all places adopted the letter grading system NYC has for restaurants read more