Fraudulent Overcharging and Tax Manipulation at The Bread Factory Cafe
Date & Time of Incident: March 16, 2025 (Sunday) at 5:30 AM
Location: The Bread Factory Cafe, 470 7th Ave, New York, NY 10018
Incident Summary:
On March 16, 2025, at approximately 5:30 AM, I visited The Bread Factory Cafe to purchase breakfast. The menu listed an omelet at $10.95, but when I proceeded to pay, the total came to $16.55.
I inquired about the discrepancy, and the cashier provided the following explanations:
1. Weekend/Holiday Surcharge: The menu posted that there would be a $1 extra charge for omelet orders on Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays. The cashier explained this, which I understood.
2. Egg Price Increase: There was a sign stating that an additional $0.50 would be charged for egg orders, but instead, they charged me $1, effectively keeping an extra $0.50 beyond what was posted.
3. Tax Overcharge: The actual correct price should have been $12.45, but the cashier was attempting to charge me $16.55, which suggested an incorrect tax calculation. When I pointed out that the tax was too high, the cashier explained that she had applied 8.875% New York City sales tax to $12.95, which resulted in a final price of $14.10.
Calculation Breakdown:
Original Price: $10.95
Weekend surcharge: $1
Egg surcharge: $0.50
Correct Price: $12.45
Overcharge Details:
Initially, I was overcharged to $12.95 instead of the correct $12.45.
An unauthorized overcharge of $2.50 was applied to the total, which was being kept for the cashier's personal benefit.
This $2.50 overcharge was added on top of the correct price, making it $14.95. This should not have been the case, as the actual correct total should have been $12.45 + $1.10 tax = $13.55 (after tax).
However, the cashier was trying to charge me $16.55, which included the unauthorized overcharge:
$12.45 + $1.10 tax + $3 "overcharge" = $16.55 (the price she was trying to charge me, lying to me about the "tax").
Once I questioned the overcharge, she immediately changed the total to $14.10, which means she still kept $0.50 extra on the base price, charging $12.95 + $1.15 tax = $14.10 instead of the correct $13.55.
Once I questioned the price, she immediately became defensive and aggressively tried to justify her fraudulent actions, saying,
"I am just a cashier, I got no time for this, move aside!"
That was the moment I could tell she had been caught cheating on the tax rate and was trying to shut down any further questions.
After catching this issue, I realized that this was not a simple mistake--this cashier has been cheating every customer who comes into the store,
adding extra unauthorized charges, and keeping the difference for herself.
Cashier Description:
Hispanic woman in her late 30s to early 40s
Wearing black leggings, a black hat, and black running shoes
Hair tied back
Gold earrings
A mole on her right cheek
Thick eyebrows
Slim body type
Action Taken:
After realizing the overcharge, I called 911 immediately to report the issue for fraud and theft.
However, no officers arrived at the scene. Four hours later, I received a call stating that police would not respond as it is a civil matter and recommended filing a complaint with consumer protection agencies or seeking legal action.
Supporting Evidence:
1. Receipt available for submission (attached).
2. The receipt shows no itemized breakdown of the food ordered, only a vague reference to "tax" and an inflated total amount.
3. I have been visiting this store for the past month and suspect I have been overcharged multiple times.
Request for Investigation:
I am formally requesting an investigation into The Bread Factory Cafe
for:
Potential fraudulent pricing practices
Improper tax application and possible tax fraud
Unauthorized overcharging and possible employee theft
Failure to provide an itemized receipt upon request read more