This is definitely a local hangout. The mozzarella sticks have a great cheese pull, the burgers are juicy, the wings are their highlight and the Philly cheese steak was a little salty, but OK. If you want a cold beer and a non-pretentious bar food/set up this is the place. read more

See all

Right off Lake Eustis it's a good stop for some food and cold beer. You can sit inside or outside but take note that outside people are allowed to smoke. We came on a Sunday and if you know anything about restaurants Sunday is tough to forecast and thought for call offs. With that being said we were seated right away. Our server was kind, knowledgeable, and listened to us. My kids Nana needs her food HOT! and the server made sure her food came out piping hot. We waited a bit for our food and could tell they were understaffed for the small rush that came in. But, the food came out hot and our drinks were refilled as needed .Burgers were good, fish basket was good, and gator bites were good. All in all great stop. read more

See all

A great historical landmark you must see right on the lake. The food is reasonably priced. They had a great special on wings and they cook them to perfection. The dry rub isn't as good as the sauces but still good. read more

Awesome food great service fresh fish staff is amazing good for a date outside seating

waiter was not attentive what so ever. when he did come by he seemed like we were a bother to him although we asked for nothin, except a refill on my husbands drink (Mr. Pibb) that only needed refilled once! Food was okay but definitely won't be back read more

My boyfriend and I came back to here to eat yet again so he could try the gator on the menu that we're busy this time, a bingo game was being hosted in the back, understandably kitchen was kinda backed up, despite that that still handled everything professionally and as fast as they could. Amazing friendly staff! love the vibes here so much. We are definitely going to miss it when we head home. read more

The Crazy Gator - Fried Cajun Gator - American Near Me - Eustis, Florida

See all

Just a down home restaurant/bar with a lot of locals. It's an enjoyable atmosphere playing good country music! I enjoyed the patio since I had my dog. The server was quick on her feet and very friendly. we will definitely be checking them out again. We enjoyed our cheese curds!! I give 4 stars since they ran out of bone-in wings and that what I was craving lol!! read more

The Crazy Gator - Menu - American Near Me - Eustis, Florida

See all

This is on the lake with docks for the boaters. There is covered outdoor seating as well as indoor separate bar and dining room. There is an extensive menu with typical American options. I had the mushroom Swiss burger with tots. The burger was a half pound and they gave plenty of tots. The burger was overcooked but still good and the tots were great. The server was attentive and friendly. The other servers were cleaning when they weren't busy which was good to see. They serve Coke products. Lost one star due to it having a strong urine smell between the bar and the dining room (outside of the restrooms). That was disgusting. read more

See all

Dropped a star for the heavy odor of urine emitting from the bathrooms - luckily, we could not smell it from the far wall in the dining room. Burger was tasty, although not cooked to mid rare (closer to a mid well) Fries were ho-hum Service was great Choices were Great Dining room was very clean read more

See all

My first visit to the Crazy Gator wasn't great. We went there because my friend wanted to get Gator tail. She didn't say much except being surprised it was served with honey mustard dip with one other choice. I didn't think you could screw up a grilled chicken sandwich but was wrong. The chicken was tough and I could only eat about half. I was also surprised to get the same honey mustard dipping sauce. I should have sent the sandwich back but didn't. With tip my bill was $50- disappointed! The server was attentive at least. read more

I love the location. The staff is friendly and the food is good. A bit more expensive than other restaurants in the area but you are paying for the gorgeous views. read more

So I don't know, maybe it was the menagerie of bad juju on the way in. A clowder of black cats dancing about the parking lot. Two crows cawing at me. Who knows, but truth be told, the wings were pretty good and service was very friendly ...but they were slower than molasses! Supper was dreadfully long; took almost two hours with only two beers in between. Yep, that second BOGO beer took forty minutes to come out. And don't even ask about the check. I'm just so glad we had the cash to get the @?#! out of there just as soon as she brought it. And whatever was special with the view and the sunset was covered up by drawn blinds, so no view. And supper took so long, was too dark to enjoy a sunset walk afterwards. Was a real bummer. read more

The Crazy Gator - Umn yum - American Near Me - Eustis, Florida

We have been eyeballing this place for about 6 months and finally stopped in. I'm sad to say we were very disappointed. I got the Thai chili wings and a side of fries. The sauce was great but a few of the wings were pink inside. My fries were warm but soggy. My husband's chicken taco salad had like 3 pieces of chicken (cut in a square) and was cold. He asked for a side of beef since there was hardly any meat and I'm sorry but it was horrible. I feel like it was a frozen hamburger that was just sliced up. There was absolutely no flavor to it at all. He ended up using my wing sauce to give his taco salad flavor. He felt bad and told the waitress it was really good. It sucks to have a cheat meal and it's not good. The service was pretty good, she was very nice. read more

The Crazy Gator - American Near Me - Eustis, Florida

Food was good (waitress forgot to put in our appetizer order). Live music was very good. Service was good. Table was sticky (outdoors). Disappointed with smoke on outdoor patio. read more

We have come here since '99, it has gradually became a dive . This is what we got given to us ordering take out fish basket. He said they were out of take out boxes.. We planned to eat at the park. He gave me two restaurant bread plates. I had to ask for utensils, lemons, and a copy of my receipt which he didn't give me at first. Both the fish and the tater tots were sorry. We didn't notice until we opened it that it did not have the coleslaw or tartar sauce either. Simply pitiful. You can get better food from a roach coach on the side of a country road or Carnival. We decided to take it back and get our money back. I don't know what happened to this place because it used to be awesome. The last several times we've come there's been one issue or another but nothing like this! read more

The Crazy Gator - Takeout fish basket lacking everything including the takeout box. Think twice before you go there I don't know what happened to it - American Near Me - Eustis, Florida

See all

Actually some really nice views and sunsets here with the lake just off to the West from the restaurant. Always super friendly service and the food is solid. Some dishes a bit better than others, but, overall it's a solid place that never serves anything just flat-out bad. It's worth the stop, and if you have the time, get there early and take a walk along the "lake-walk" after dinner. read more

The Crazy Gator - American Near Me - Eustis, Florida

See all

They were out of a lot of stuff gator bites overcooked bun on steak and cheese old and stale.Wont be going back there.

The location by the lake is nice. I wish adjacent railroad was active for tourists in addition to freight. The flatbread was meh. The fries with the wrap were cold, but the wrap itself was hot and pretty good. Most everybody here knew each other. Service was meh, she seemed to have more of a focus problem than being overwhelmed. So ok if you are in the area but not a destination drive. read more

The Crazy Gator - Patio - American Near Me - Eustis, Florida

See all

Food average. Atmosphere ok as well, but the damp smell goes throughout the place especially in the dining room. Fantastic location on the water but this place needs a good overhaul. I want to like the place but we can't get past the mildew, wet smell going throughout the place. Front bar and TVs are the best part of the restaurant. We attended a Xmas party there in back room and most people said the same thing. Food was ok but a little TLC needed in the restaurant. Nice staff though for sure. read more

We are a snowbirds so we wanted something different. We both had fish. It was very quiet. The waitress was very nice. She came to the table adequately. Food was served in tin pans. Food was good. The fish sandwich was huge. Fries were a little dry. read more

Terrible! We have eaten here for years, and we went for pickup tonight and were so disappointed. When we go the kids like to split a large pepperoni pizza - the 16". We ordered it it as the "large 16" pizza". They gave us a small child's size pizza yet charged us the bigger pizza price. My husband immediately noticed and brought it to their attention but they said "we don't have a 16" pizza." Then why is it on your menu and why did you let us order it? The flippancy of the staff was laughable too even after reaching out after to complain again. Will never again eat there. Highly recommend you go the other better restaurants in Eustis and Mt Dora. read more

See all

After spending the day walking some nearby trails, we were quite hungry and happened along this place on the way home. It's on a lake and has a gorgeous view from the outdoor seating area. Since it was nice outside, we took advantage of this patio and set up there. Our server was very nice and was happy to answer any questions. They have a menu with a wide variety of options. I chose to try Eustis Cobb Salad and a cup of chili. My boyfriend ordered the Cajun gator tail and a side of fries. I chose ranch dressing for my salad since the server mentioned it was made in house. Everything was very delicious. The salad was huge and the ranch dressing was very good. The cup of chili was also pretty tasty and I sampled the gator tail and thought it was quite good as well. The only downfall here is that service was pretty slow. It seemed to be a staffing issue since I saw our server working very hard and it was pretty busy. She was always nice and seemed to try her best to get things out in a timely manner. The inside was pretty big and the bathrooms were clean so that was another plus. Overall, I think it's a nice place to try for good food and a great view as long as you aren't in a hurry and just want to enjoy the ambience while waiting for your order. read more

See all

Was looking for a good burger and found it here. The staff was great, a bit overwhelmed probably due to staffing but they were on top of things. I believe the chef brought my burger to me and yes she was a chef because she cared about what she was serving. The fries are a little short for my taste but I still finished most them. Overall, nothing special about the Crazy Gator but that is what makes it great. read more

In the area for the day and stopped by this place for some much needed lunch. Not too crowded and seated right away. Waiter was knowledgeable about menu and prompt. Portion sizes were good. We had fried fish, a club sandwich ,Cobb salad and a hamburger. All good was good. Nothing fantastic or special about it but overall a decent lunch. Not a bad stop if in the area. read more

See all

It had been a couple of years since we have eaten at the Crazy Gator, and it has gone through a bit of a reverb and regime change, so I have been meaning to go back. We went as part of a group and were in the function room. Our server was excellent, friendly and efficient, especially considering we were a group with separate checks. They have a daily buy one get one free draft beer special, a deal somewhat diminished by the fact that the mugs are so small it really is close to a normal draft glass in other places. But it is still a good price, I think. I ordered a bowl of chili and a baked potato. The chili was, well, fine, but it was more of a cup than a bowl and was not memorable. It turns out it isn't a menu item anymore, except to be added to meals, like you add for a chili dog. It is fine for that, but I wouldn't order it separately again. The baked potato came with toppings you add yourself and was nice and hot. Like I said, we were in a function room, but I noticed the regular dining area has been updated. There used to be tall bench seat backs so that you couldn't see the staff and they couldn't see you. They have fixed that and put in regular tables and chairs and it gives the area a more congenial, open look. So all in all I am fine with the idea of going back and trying other menu items. read more

We were out boating from Mount Dora and docked our boat at the dock behind The Crazy Gator in Eustis to have lunch. The restaurant isn't much to look at from the outside, but the inside has a fun, casual atmosphere. And our server, Connor, was phenomenal. He was extremely friendly, attentive, and helpful. He has such a welcoming personality and inviting smile. He was truly a fantastic server. The menu options were extensive and reasonably priced. I had a tough time deciding which entree to order because several were appealing to me. Of course, the gator po' boy was one item that caught my eye, but I went with the fish basket instead. I expected it to be fried, but Connor offered it as grilled or blackened as well. I went with blackened because I love that flavor (and it was probably a healthier option than fried). It was absolutely delicious. The piece of fish was big and perfectly cooked and seasoned. It came with French fries as well (or a side of my choosing), and the fries were tasty, too. For about $10 at lunch, it was a great value. Connor let us know that on Fridays there's an all-you-can-eat fish platter special (but that one you do have to get fried). It would definitely be a great deal, but it was already so much food, I don't know if I'd be able to eat more than one! (OK, I know I *could*, but I'd feel a bit full afterwards.) I look forward to our next visit...and hopefully Connor will be working that day! read more

The Crazy Gator - Wall mural in dining room - American Near Me - Eustis, Florida

See all

Great location nice little spot, but the food was horrible. I just ordered nachos and it seemed like they pulled it out of bag and throw it on there and thing was warmed. Even the chicken taste like it was pre done. Which is weird because I've been to this place before it wasn't that bad but that's probably the last time I'll go there. read more

We went with a large party of 8, four adults and four kids. Overall the experience was good. Service was alittle slow on this particular Tue during lunch hour. They looked short handed. Kids portions were large and were brought out early which we always appreciate as they tent to be slow eaters and it entertains them. I had the mussels it was a large portion and the broth was very hot. Had to wait to eat it for a few minutes. Waitress was happy and helpful with the menu. The bathrooms on the premises were large and very clean. We had to eat Inside the restaurant due to the size of our party but the outside seating would be a great place for a date night as it over looks lake Eustis. We definitely eat here again. Also has docks if your on the water and are looking for a place to stop and eat. read more

The Crazy Gator - Kids fried fish - American Near Me - Eustis, Florida

See all

Wow, this place was great! Went for all you can eat fish fry. The food was great and service amazing. Our server was so wonderful, I wish I remembered her name (sorry)! I'm from California, so this was a special treat to go to with the family. The owner stopped by our table and talked with us for a while, such a nice man. He wanted to make sure everything was to our liking. There was a thunderstorm, so we stayed longer than we prepared for, and we were served coffee on them while we enjoyed our stay. My parents go there regularly and are known by name and treated with the royal treatment. Thank you so much! Oh, and they absolutely adore Andrew! He wasn't there since he is now on days, but I couldn't hear enough about how well he has always taken care of them and their group from Mid-Florida lakes. read more

I'll start my review my saying that I've been here now about 6 times over the past 7 mths. Today, however, was THE best visit. Hubs and I decided to take the boat over and dock on Lake Eustis. Upon approach, we were greeted by a friendly guy on the dock who was offering his assistance to help us dock and tie off our pontoon. He introduced himself as Randy and was easy going and unpretentious. After our boat was secured, he revealed that he was the owner of Crazy Gator and Kalua Beach Bar. We have loved them both and frequented them before. We had a fun and friendly exchange and told him we loved the fish basket at both places and now it made sense. So to wrap up this review... If you love fried fish, come here! It's a deal for sure. For $8.99 you get a large piece of white fish which is battered in Yuengling beer batter. It's not soaked in grease and the fish is amazing! Choice of sides and good tarter sauce as well. We will return obviously. They have a dog friendly patio/deck to boot! My only criticism is sometimes the service lacks, but that's a wide spread problem across Florida. The owner is aware and works hard to correct. read more

The Crazy Gator - Fish basket with slaw - American Near Me - Eustis, Florida

Roach came out of the wall next to my friend and crawled in him so we had to move tables. Gator was mid , sauce tasted like shit, don't come here read more

The Crazy Gator - Gator Blt - American Near Me - Eustis, Florida

Service is slow. Order 2 drinks because you will need to wait before you ever will get another. Food took forever plus our toddler didn't get his food while everyone else did. Our beef tips taste like the meat turn, chicken was tough like could of been microwaved. This use to be the spot but not anymore. Whatever has changed in the last year we all can see it. read more

Very good food , right on lake shore , fast friendly staff recommend indoor outdoor seating read more

See all

We went for the gator bites and were not disappointed! The fried pickles are also solid but I really recommend the pretzel! It's huge!! The chicken quesadilla was also really good (and humongous). The Caesar salad had a bit too much dressing for my liking so I'd probably order that on the side but the chicken on top was delish! Generally bar food - but it's good quality and we'll def be back when we're in town. But more than al of that, that they had friendly staff and really quick service - that alone is worth the review :) read more

The Crazy Gator - Hand for scar. The pretzel is huge! - American Near Me - Eustis, Florida

Stay away from the "pizza, Philly cheese steak sandwich" and tell them,"don't overcook the gator meat"! The Philly cheese steak is a yellow cheese, pizza is tasteless and the gator meat was tough! read more

Fried scallops basket was one of the best I've had. Very friendly and attentive staff. Great views on the edge of Lake Eustis. read more

This used to be my favorite place to grab a drink and meal. It has gone downhill fast!!!! Food isn't fresh, chips are stale and service sucks lately. Very disappointing!!!! read more

We were traveling near your restaurant recently and decided to stop and have dinner. Very good food and very good service and wonderful atmosphere. We would gladly stop here again. read more

My bff told me how good this place was so we made it a double date night with our husbands. We ordered the burgers which my bff swore by and they didn't disappoint. I'm craving their cheeseburger as we speak. Next time I'm in town, I'll need to come here again. read more

Waited over an hour for meal. Beef was cold on salad and some pieces so rare they were inedible. Hamburg was good but bun very soggy. Asked for cost of drink to be discounted due to unreasonable wait and manager refused. Server did the best she could but obviously kitchen staff was inadequate, many tables not bused and obviously management doesn't care. Would not recommend. read more