Small takeout portions for $25 meals. I let the staff know that I was disappointed and they were fine with it. The food was ok otherwise. read more

The Feast Restaurant - Chilean Seabass - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

Absolutely perfect. Incredible food, menu, service and soothing friendly atmosphere. The crab legs, chowder and pasta were DELICIOUS.

Great pizza on Anna Maria island. Quick service; however, you may need to pick up pizza if you wish to dine at home. Delivery is only certain days of week. read more

Appetizers we thought were amazing, got the pot stickers and the calamari. Entrees were disappointing. Crab stuffed shrimp , the crab was more filler than crab and what crab was in them was a bit strong. Chicken Parm was ok, basic pasta dish but overpriced. Hogfish was ok, nothing outstanding. read more

Pizza here is beyond delicious and fresh I can't say enough about how great it was from crust to perfect amount of toppings and cheese! Pizza perfection read more

We only spent 5 nights on AMI, but we ate here twice! The first night we had stuffed shrimp and the surf & turf. Both dishes were perfectly executed and delicious! The next night we came back for the pizza because we heard it was good, and it did not disappoint! We also tried the orange sunshine cake and the keylime coconut cake, which were moist and delicious. Both nights we left in a food coma. Our waitress the first night was Alex, and we had Olivia the second night. Both of these women were knowledgeable and great at their jobs. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Visiting from out of town - we were looking for an easy pickup order night. Ordered a large pizza and grouper bites. Pizza was well prepared and fresh. Grouper bites were excellent as they were very lightly battered and a LOT of fish. Well balanced with seasoning too. Didn't experience the dining in, but staff was extremely pleasant and very upfront on wait times as the island is definitely hopping for the 4th of July weekend. No issues whatsoever and would definitely dine again! read more

Best food (coconut shrimp to die for). Staff so gracious and kind when coping with a situation beyond our control. They really understand the concept of customer service! As a result, husband's birthday dinner was a success. read more

We have visited Feast several times during our trips to AMI and they never disappoint. We usually order the grouper blackened or the fish and chips. Yummo! We've also eaten the shrimp and lobster scampi pasta. All of those meals have been amazing. This trip we decided to try their pizza since we've heard so many good things about it and I am so glad we did! The crust is on the thinner side, perfect amount of sauce, and cooked perfectly! We ordered the 14" The Works. It was just the two of us and we had plenty of leftovers. It was another great meal at The Feast! read more

My extended family always tracks to Anna Maria for our big family vacation. This was our first time trying this restaurant and we were blown away at the food and service we received. I had a special seafood pasta with shrimp and lobster and it was incredible. Others in my family had the crab legs and raved. Fresh and flavorful. Reasonable prices on wine as well. Highly recommend this spot while visiting the island! read more

Dinner at The Feast restaurant on Anna Maria Island was one of the best dinners we had there in the entire week! It's unassuming location in a small strip retail area brings more surprise to its excellent food and vast craft beer and spirits selection! It was also a great value for the price. read more

We were in town for several days and ordered from the feast 2 times. Several meals at a time. Food was outstanding and reasonably priced. The only downfall was the online menu needed to be updated. Other than that staff and food was great! read more

Solid for AMI and probably the best pizza on the island. The salads are great too. I'm a fan of the tropicale salad with salmon.

Food was wonderful. Atmosphere was relaxing. Lighting was wonderful. Our waitress was very kind and patient. If I'm ever in this part of Florida again I'll come back here for dinner. read more

A locally owned restaurant and it shows! We enjoyed prime filet and Red Snapper with crab, gulf shrimp cream sauce. Delicious! The Coconut Shrimp is always great! Chef has seasonal offerings. Salads are large and fresh. Restaurant has a varied menu including pizza, pasta, seafood, and prime steak. Casual ambiance for an evening dinner or lunch after a walk on the beach. Reasonable prices. read more

Excellent food and service. This was our 2nd time eating here. Our waiter was super friendly and knowledgeable. Not tons of seating though so reservations may be nice but in our case weren't necessary. read more

See all

This was the second time here and forgot to post a review last time so I couldnt remember what i ordered last time. This time shrimp lobster alfredo ... Yum. Gotta call ahead and make a reservation ! read more

The Feast Restaurant - Alfredo shrim and lobster. YUM!!!! - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

Pizza was actually great. Ordered online and they nailed it. Quick pick up. No wait. Friday night 6:30ish. Zero complaints.

Food was ok but staff horrible. Staff: Made reservations and they messed up the time, a whole hour late. Our server seemed as if she didn't want to be there with snarky attitude and couldn't even bother to say happy birthday after carding for a drink (it was my birthday). Server also over promised sides with meal and then went on to say "she didn't say that". Food: Love the individual ingredients in my dish but so bland! Absolutely no flavor and two people I was dining with were also disappointed in my dish and theirs. Overall: Tried someplace new on my beloved AMI and I was very disappointed. I will not be returning or recommending especially with the treatment, bland food and high prices. read more

The Feast Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

OMG~ We were so impressed by the lobster bisque and shrimp and crab pasta!! Highly recommend; especially when Shauna is your server.. what a delight!! Will be back read more

This is our first place for dinner when we arrived. We had a party of 9. Let start with the service they are so NICE. Everyone that works here smiles and welcomes you. Food was excellent as kids enjoyed the cheese pizza. Which was freshly bake not cardboard pizza. read more

Our dinners were delicious and served quickly. Our waitress Isabella provided excellent service and was super pleasant. We would definitely recommend The Feast! read more

We always come to the Feast when we are in town! Great beer selection and even better pizza! Our server, Trey gave us a wonderful recommendation to try his personal favorite, goat cheese, prosciutto and red onion pizza which did not disappoint! We will definitely come back and have "Trey's pizza" again! read more

The Feast Restaurant is located in the strip mall that looks like it's still in the 1970s but don't let that stop you from stopping by and having a bite to eat. We start off with appetizers and we order the escargot definitely hit or miss when you order and escargot outside of Paris but I will tell you the escargot which was under $10 was better than the ones we had in France! Simply amazing. We also sampled their white pizza which was the Lish and their additional special which was buffalo chicken tenders with firecracker sauce. Simply delicious our waitress Chasity from Toledo Ohio was not only friendly. accommodating but a joy to have as a waitress!!! Don't pass this place by!! read more

Read a review in a Facebook group saying this is the best place on the island to eat... SO not true. The calamari was just ok. Where I had a big problem was my entree. I had the chicken carbonara which was honestly the worst I ever had. The chicken was poor quality filled with tendons and honestly gross to even eat. The "bacon" in the chicken carbonara was 100% bacon bits... all this for a $20+ dish? Super disappointing. Service was slow, and I feel like I'm a pretty patient customer. read more

the staff was very friendly and attentive. the crab legs were good and fresh! the broccoli cheddar soup was very good and hot! the restaurant was clean, and cute! would definitely go back! read more

Do not judge this place by the outside... So in and have a great lunch or dinner. Service and food were off the charts. Great seafood and amazing desserts. Note - Beer and Wine only.. read more

We ate here for the first time tonight and we're from the east coast of Florida and I have to say this place was truly awful. We both ordered hog snapper and grouper and the fish was extremely dry and devoid of flavor. It was probably the worst piece of fish I've eaten in years. The sides, squash and rutabaga, were bad as well. I can't believe any self respecting chef would allow these dishes to leave his kitchen. I sure hope they can turn this place around because it has potential but I'm going to have to read some raving reviews in the future before I ever come back. read more

Went here for the first time with family the other night. We had to sit outside because there weren't any a available tables inside. Food was delicious. Service was good. Will definitely be back! read more

I was having a hard time finding a good restaurant in Anna Maria. However, this place was recommended by a local and i'm so glad we decided to try it out. I ordered the Shrimp Scampi pasta and the flavors were really good and my fiance ordered a pizza and he loved it. Next time we are in AMI we will definitely have to go back. read more

By the time you're my age (I remember when Gilligan's Island was not a re-run!), you've eaten a lot of pizza. But I have to tell you - I've never had a love affair with a pizza crust like I had with this one. It was a traditional NY-style crust, and I'm usually kinda "meh" about most of them. But this one was feather-light, just a little golden-brown, and yet it carried the full-bodied flavor of the heaviest deep dish pie Chicago can offer! I'll be back! read more

Caution dessert only review!! We had dinner elsewhere that did not offer dessert, so we placed a carry out order. We ordered a dreamsicle cake slice, peanut butter pie, and two key lime pies. The cake was dry. The key lime pies were ORANGE ... unsure if it was truly their key lime or a mistake. Lacked flavor either way. The saving grace was the peanut butter pie. Would not recommend getting dessert here. read more

have been here many times. It is a little old school but the service is good and atmosphere is nice. I at lunch I had some lobster bisque which was great and some calamari. I had been kind of seafood crazy but I noticed the they had some non-seafood options. A nice change of pace one special was a New York strip steak which was served to perfection. My friend had a lobster steak dish which was really good. The other time she had a shrimp and lobster scampi which she said was incredible. Families could probably afford this place because they have pizza but you have to watch the time of day that you go because it does get crowded. Parking is easy and it is a little hard to find but a nice place I would recommend this. read more

Hidden Jewel located in a small strip mall. We started with grouper bites. Hubby & I shared a mix of food. Lobster bisque soup was creamy, Grouper bites were flaky, Hogfish entree was a nice flaky white fish, we received 3 good size pieces and we chose sweet potato mashed & veg medley as our sides. Every tasted great. read more

The Feast Restaurant - Lobster Bisque soup. Delicious!! - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

Ordered take out from Feast through Island Eats...this was a 2nd chance since last time the 1st dine in experience was awful. Right away we noticed crab cakes missing lobster sauce, sides of Cole slaw, tomatoes and ketchup missing. Dry crab cakes with no sauce sound awful so a phone call to restaurant was made and after speaking to two people they didn't care AT ALL, just blamed Island Eats and said to call Island Eats. Since this is the 2nd terrible run in with Feast we will not return. The fries were frozen meh gross, the cocktail sauce which was inside the fried shrimp box was warm and paste like, the crab cakes inedible, too dry. They also didn't include napkins. We order from delivery services quite often and those are basics, the delivery services don't forget bags, and even if it was a mistake by delivery service the restaurant chose to handle it poorly. Not sure how the Feast is stays in business. read more

See all

Hidden gem. Great specials every day. The standard menu items are excellent too! Service with a smile and business is greatly appreciated. read more

This is one of our favorite places on AMI. We have come here 3 times in the last 2 weeks. The food is always delicious and service is great. Fire cracker shrimp is a must as an appetizer, it does have a kick. You can't go wrong with the pasta dishes either. Tonight I had the surf n turf. The steak was melt in your mouth amazing!The shrimp n crab pesto was delicious as week. Highly recommend. read more

See all

We were very sad and disappointed with our experience. Waterfront restaurant was great and this was nothing like Waterfront. Walking into the restaurant it smells fishy. We ordered 5 entrees 2 of them were uneatable because they had such a bad rancid fishy flavor. We arrived at 5pm and the food came out at 7pm while we waited for 2 hours the server came out once. We needed to go into the restaurant twice to ask for water and how much longer for our food. It was a huge disappointment and extremely overpriced. read more

Nice local place, reasonably priced simple fresh dishes. Friendly staff. Clean restaurant, looks more like a diner inside. Outside appears more upscale. Nice selection of fish grilled, blackened, jerk and broiled. More than half the menu is Italian food. The pizza looks really good. Also have a good selection of salads. Place was booked on Sunday Mother's day but they got us a table without reservations. read more

See all

The pizza here is known all around the island. No delivery pick up only or eat at the restaurant but it's worth it by far the best margarita pizza I've ever had read more