I stopped by for lunch recently because I had such a good experience last year. What a great choice. I had the scallop special. They were excellent! They were expertly prepared snd beautifully presented. The tomato slices and salad were fresh, tasty and beautiful. I am taking the whole family soon. While there I saw many natives stopping to get carryout which is a good thing in my book. Well done Feast! read more

This place is legit. Great food. Great value. Great service. Everything on the menu is good and satisfying. Im on vacation and have had snapper special, halibut special, surf and turf, grouper sandwich, firecracker shrimp and salads. Happy with all of them. Value- expect to not spend more than $25 for an entree that comes with solid fresh fish probably topped with shrimp a veggie and a starch. Service- I ordered surf n turf to go. Manager looked at the steak noticed it was over cooked and had cooks make another. Comped me a beer for the wait. Any other place would send the steak to go for the eater to find out when they got home. read more

I was there on a Saturday evening. The host juggled some tables and we were seated promptly. I ordered bourbon and coke. No liquor. Minus one star. Ordered a filet medium. It came out med/rare minus another star. I am not one to send food back or cause a scene so I attempted to eat it. The steak was so bad that I could not eat it. I even gave a bite to my date and she agreed. Terrible. Minus third star. When hostess came around I explained very quietly what the problem was. She was very helpful. She went to the manager and came back. The manager comped me two glasses of wine totaling $18.00 rather than comping me the steak which was $27.00. Minus another star. So I will properly never go back and will definitely not recommend read more

This the best pizza on the island. It is worth every penny. The crust is perfect and the cheese is always fresh.

To start I waited an hour and a half for my food even though we made a reservation. When I asked about the wait on the food, they said "to-go" orders were putting the kitchen behind, which is unreasonable as an excuse. On top of waiting our food came out with multiple mistakes. After all of this, we asked to speak to the manager and a rude man stopped by to tell us "the salad is on us". The $3 salad when our entree was $25. In the end, he took off his own servers "automatic gratuity" instead of doing something to help our total. Our server was the ONLY good part of our experience. She did everything she could. I find that despicable as a customer. Go anywhere else. read more

Crab cakes were full of broken pieces of shell, almost every bite had a piece of shell. Finally gave up, not edible. Sides and desert were ok, but definitely not up to par for the price charged. read more

Loved the all you can eat gulf shrimp lunch. We enjoyed the food and atmosphere so much we came back three times.

Ambience: poor Service: ok Food: Alfredo, lobster bisque, French fries and side salad were amazing. Fish and chips was a little tough, sweet mash potatoes were not good. Recommend for pasta! read more

Casual and good food. Families and couples enjoying good seafood and delicious steaks. I will go again just for the Key Lime Coconut cake.

Loved this restaurant! Great food, great service, kid friendly. We tried the firecracker shrimp, coconut shrimp, and Vermont salad and the kids had the mozzarella wedges and cheese pizza- all very good! Will for sure come back to this place! read more

We went here for dinner and lunch and could not have been more delighted. They have new and interesting specials everyday so it's worth it to come on different days. The pizza here is also good but it is a very thin thin crust. Service is slow but everyone is super friendly. It's very busy here so call ahead. read more

We visited The Feast recently during spring break on Anna Maria Island. We arrived about 40 minutes prior to closing but were welcomed in anyway. The atmosphere is quite nice, yet casual & comfortable with outdoor seating available. There is plenty of parking, & also was walking distance from our vacation rental. There is the added convenience of various shops in the complex, too. Our server was a real gem! She was prompt & so friendly, just as the other staff were, as well. The food was served quickly, portions generous & quality was very good. The bathroom was impressively clean, which we appreciated greatly. We look forward to returning next spring! read more

Checked out the feast for lunch, ordered the zucchini appetizer and the fish and chips with homemade chips. Tender fish very tasty and light. Chips were excellent. Great service too. Cute place. read more

Been vacationing on the Island 11 years. How'd we miss this place? Food was phenomenal! Our server, Amanda, could not have been better!! See you all next year. read more

This was the first time we ever got anything other than pizza here and we are not impressed. The pizza is very good but we decided to get seafood take out. Nothing was very flavored the grouper and lobster were both undercooked and the green beans seemed uncooked at all. For the price I though it was terrible and will probably never go back even for their pizza. read more

The Feast Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

This is my second time at Feast. The service, food and sangria were wonderful. My husband who is not a salad lover ordered the small beet salad and ate the whole thing. Pizza was delicious as well as the mushroom risotto. read more

One of the best on the island and perhaps the #1 value. It may not have a pretty view, but you trade that for excellent food and service. We will make sure to visit everytime we are on Anna Maria. read more

This place is a gem! Located in a rundown strip mall, the food was great, the staff was friendly and attentive and the cost was reasonable. I recommend the crab stuffed shrimp! read more

Absolutely delicious food. Had a small Greek salad with their homemade dressing, and the grouper nuggets. She had the shrimp and crab cake platter that was awesome. Sides of yellow and red tomatoes with a pasta salad. Great service. Found them on Groupon so the extra 15 bucks off was nice. Try this place. read more

$100 worth of terrible food. Service was sweet, but that's about it! Do not order the chicken parm.

Had a great dinner at this place and Keith gave us wonderful service. Calamari appetizer, black and blue tenderloin, Atlantis pasta, everything we had was very good. Not the most scenic location but the decor is very nice inside and the food is fabulous. read more

You'll never find this place unless you're looking--it's at the back of a strip mall with no sign facing the street. But the food is affordable and very good. We went for lunch, and I was impressed with the variety: You can get anything from a salad to a burger, seafood to pasta. Much more diverse than most restaurants on the island. The interior is charming, the staff is helpful, and everything we had tasted good. Unfortunately, we were the only people in the place, so I'm not sure it will last unless it gets some buzz. We had to wait a long time for our food, but we were an 8-top and it's a new place, so I'd give them the benefit of the doubt on that. read more

This place is awesome, I've been here twice and I've been very pleased with all the food my family ordered. The feast is now my favorite restaurant on AMI. read more

Great salads especially with the add on of grilled salmon. My favorite is the Vermont.

Food tasted microwaved from a plastic bag that was frozen solid 3.5 minutes before it was served. blistering hot in spots and cold in others. read more

Best veggie burger I've ever had! We were recommended to eat here by another restaurant that couldn't accommodate my fiancé's healthy eating habits. So happy they did! We will definitely come back! read more

Delicious dinner. Three people in my party had all you can eat crab. Raves all around. I had shrimp and lobster scampi with penne. Also delicious. Wait person attentive and tuned in to the needs of the one year old at our table. Small place but great service and really good food. Beer and wine only. I'd go back. read more

The Feast Restaurant - Shrimp and Maine lobster scampi. - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

Great spot- we were hesitant to go because reviews were so-so, but overall price and food was pretty good, especially in comparison to the other spots on Anna Maria. Pizza was delicious. read more

Pretty good, but didn't knock our socks off. Seafood seemed either not fresh or overcooked, it was a bit rubbery. Kids loved the pizza. Server was very pleasant. read more

I can honestly say this place surprised me. I was not expecting much from such a small place in an old shopping center. First, the one negative that caught my attention right away was the smell of smoke, drifting over from the bar next door. On to the food, I had the grouper sandwich, it was on special. It was great. The house made chips on the side were good as well. I would defiantly go back. read more

Not sure how this only has 4 stars....best meal on the island! We have eaten everywhere, but this was such an incredible meal. Party of 12 and we were very well taken care of. Every single one of us loved our meals. Buffalo grouper bites, coconut shrimp to start...all 5 stars. Meals were steaks, grouper, pizza, kids meals....all AMAZING. By far our favorite place on the island. And the service was fantastic too! read more

Food here is fantastic, ate the day before at "EAT HERE" and A moveable Feast is so much better.----enjoy

My family and I ate here last week while on vacation and unfortunately had a not-so-great meal. We started with the lobster bisque and pizza for the kids which were both great but it was downhill from there. The kitchen lost our ticket and had to put our meal order in again. The waiter was super nice and apologized profusely for the error. When we got our meal, the seafood we had was not fresh - fishy scallops and crab cakes. We had been at Legoland all day and just didn't have the energy to send the food back and wait again. They offered us a free dessert due to the lost ticket issue which was nice but even the Key Lime pie was not great. The service was excellent but we won't be back next year. And as a side note, as another reviewer mentioned, the old, dirty carpet needs to go! read more

Very pricey restaurant definitely don't recommend coming in big groups or with kids. Got the margherita pizza good but not worth the money.

First time we tried the Feast in the 8 years we've been here. Wish we had tried sooner! After watching another table gobble up their Grouper Bites appetizer, we couldn't resist! The fish was fresh, the coating was delicious and not over cooked or over seasoned. Some of the best we've ever had. I'm allergic to shellfish so I had to steer clear of all the specials, but the braised ribs were tender. The sides did lack imagination, but the main dishes were great. My husband had the lobster and shrimp pasta. It was wonderful with way more seafood than he expected. The creme brûlée was exceptional with made with real vanilla beans. We will be back! read more

A great meal! The food is more sophisticated than the decor. Generous portions and a great variety! They serve pasta, fish, pizza, burgers, and ribs! The waiter, Ken, was very friendly and made sure the meal was safe for one of our friends with severe food allergies! We had the seared ahi tuna appetizer that was tasty and large for an appetizer. The ribs were very good, too! read more

A nice dinner place on the island. I think I was hoping for more though based on the reviews. Our service was friendly and fast, but everything was just good. There wasn't anything we got that we thought was spectacular. There was no wow factor. They had a lot of land and sea options which was nice. The atmosphere was very casual, lots of families. I wouldn't go here for a romantic dinner/date night. read more

Weird that it's in a strip mall, but it was pretty good. I had the lobster and shrimp pasta. Very generous with the shrimp and lobster, good sized portion. Our waitress was very friendly. read more

We have always wanted to try FEAST. Well, tonight was the night. Early reservation, rather quiet atmosphere. It went downhill from there! Terrible table, gentleman behind me kept rocking into my chair. Wrong food was served. Grouper cheeks were more breading than grouper. Key lime pie was tasteless. Server kept rushing us. We stayed a total of 55 awful minutes! Of all of our AMI dining experiences in 25 years, this had to be the worst! We will never be back! read more

What a find! I've lived here for 8 years and been to AMI a million times and never knew about Feast! Went for lunch with my daughter and had a delicious meal at a very reasonable price! The blackened diver scallops were grilled perfectly and so yummy! The cole slaw was a nice side and their homemade chips with a side of their own ranch style dipping sauce was delish! My daughter raved about the coconut shrimp she ordered that came with a sweet sauce. Everything was really fresh! The atmosphere was unique and welcoming and our waitress ( the only one there at that time) was super nice, helpful and attentive! We bought a Groupon right away and will be returning for sure! Not your typical island restaurant ...and that's a good thing! read more