For almost $30 (with tip), we got an underwhelming brownie ice cream sundae but the s'mores cocoa was fabulous The sundae's brownie was on the small size and served disappointingly lukewarm. It's SINGLE ice cream scoop was wonderful quality though Frosty Barrel seems to be transitioning to a Snoqualmie Ice Cream shop as the menu downsized quite a bit. I've been before and always loved it but this time it fell short For ice cream & fancy cocoa, it's top notch but other options fall short read more

The Frosty Barrel - Brownie sundae and s'mores hot cocoa - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

The warmest winter compells me to eat more ice cream. So glad I stopped by. The decor is so cozy for an ice cream based joint. Their fireplace kept me even warmer while I indulged in my double flavored cup of ice cream. Besides the hot fireplace they have hot food for sale. My server was beyond helpful. Ever flavor I tried was good enough for me, but I ended up going with the cherry ice cream since its been a while. I also gave in on the mango because I thought they would go well together. read more

See all

I really enjoyed my visit to the Frosty Barrel after a hike at Coal Creek park. The service was SO friendly and super helpful. I noticed on their website that they have hot cocoa flights but that wasn't indicated on the menu in-house. A staff member explained that they're moving away from that to streamline their cocoa recipe and just focus on the ice cream flights instead. They also acknowledged that the online menus need to be updated. That was fine with me because the s'mores hot chocolate I ordered instead was one of the best I've ever had. The toasted marshmallow fluff on top was perfect and lasted the whole time I enjoyed the drink. I really liked that because usually with whipped cream, that just dissolves after a while, but this way, you get a taste of toasty marshmallow with every sip. On the staff's recommendation, I also ordered the prosciutto sandwich, which comes with chips, and that was delicious, too! I had a taste of the cherry amaretto chocolate chip ice cream and salted caramel banana sundae and those were so good. The ice cream (Snoqualmie ice cream) is super smooth and excellent quality. I really don't think you can go wrong here. The inside is a fast casual vibe and they have a fireplace table, which is a neat touch. Hopefully, they update the online menus soon, but don't let that stop you from just going in and finding something good. read more

The Frosty Barrel - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

See all

I tried out the Frosty Barrel with my Dad and was very impressed! I had never heard of such a cool pairing before! It was super cool! I had the white wine and ice cream pairing flight, which was delicious!! It turned out to be more than enough ice cream for me! The inside was super clean and had plenty of seating available. The staff was great and helped us figure out exactly what we wanted. read more

The Frosty Barrel - White wine and ice cream flight - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

See all

Never say no to ice cream! Came by for a post dinner sweet treat and was greeted by some friendly workers who helped us sample a wide variety of flavors. My friend and I ended up sharing a flight, which was so yummy. I love that the place also serves specialty drinks. It elevates the whole "just an ice cream shop" vibe. The interior is very simple but I imagine in the winter when their little fire is on, it's super cozy. read more

The Frosty Barrel - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

My daughter and I stopped in here after a nearby event and this time we both tried a white wine and ice cream pairing flight. Who would've thought ice cream and wine went so well together? Delicious ice cream (and sorbet) and a great pairing with the wines. There were a lot of families and couples coming in while we were enjoying our pairings and everyone was in such a happy mood. The staff was great too. I wish I lived closer to the Newcastle area and I would come in more often! read more

I love coming by for the ice cream (snoqualmie ice cream) the selection is a decent amount for the local area. I really like the quality of the ice cream. I haven't really tried anything else but the ice cream. But I appreciate the fire place that they have there. It's a perfect spot to grab a sweet treat, or an alcoholic drink even to catch up with friends or something quick. The service is friendly as well. I'd highly recommend this spot! I know they rotate their flavors on the ice cream too :) read more

See all

Love walking here whenever I get the chance! Customer service is always beyond helpful and sweet. Music, ambience, ice cream and drinks have never disappointed. Love that it's locally owned too! read more

The Frosty Barrel - Left: cookies and cream in waffle cone Bottom right: cherry amaretto Upper: cookies and cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

See all

On a random detour while part of 405 was closed, The Frosty Barrel appeared. I had no idea it existed before then but a quick look at the website made us want to stop. I'm always susceptible to unique hot chocolate. The Dubai Hot Chocolate was tasty. I think I would try a different one next time but it was good. I expected more of a sit down or different ambiance inside from the website, and it's definitely more of a fast casual vibe, but that's fine. Just know what you're getting if you go. Service was fine and attentive. To be fair, there was no one else in there and there people working so it would have been awkward if not. Overall, unique concept and some tasty options. I might stop by if I were ever over there again, but I wouldn't make a trip for it. read more

I've been wanting to try this place for a while, but it did not serve like I wanted it to. When I think alcohol with ice cream, it's such a really great concept but I was wrong. I do want to start off saying that the ice cream is good, but we got the whiskey cocktail and some special drinks float at the time and it was not good. The service was good and the place is a decent size for indoor seating. I'm giving them a 4 because it might have just been what we ordered. read more

Back again...in love with this place Wanted to try out some new fall flavors and they did NOT disappoint. I tried the Pumpkin Cheesecake and Maple Scone and they taste exactly like the real thing! My boyfriend got the Apple Cider Donut ice cream and he found a chunk of actual donut inside. That's how you know they're using REAL ingredients. Love it here! read more

The Frosty Barrel - Pumpkin Cheesecake and Maple Scone ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

Delicious ice cream flavors here. They also serve a few beers, cider and wine. And, booze shakes. I opted for a seasonal flavor of apple pie a la mode. Just delicious. Creamy and not too sweet. Full of pie crust crumbles, apple pieces and vanilla ice cream. Of course. Super friendly service and good vibes. Clean store with water. Looking forward to coming back for a boozy shake. Plenty of parking in front. And outside tables if you want. Happy treats! SYOY! read more

See all

Cute little joint but with a vast menu! Had some yummy hot cocoas here: red velvet and Smores. The drinks weren't sweet and it was the toppings that made it sweet. The smores had whipped cream, graham cracker, and Choco syrup. Red velvet had crushed red velvet cake and whipped cream. Both were delicious but Smores was my favorite. Gonna have to come back to try their boozy concoctions and icecream flights with wine. read more

The Frosty Barrel - Red Velvet and Smores hot cocoas - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

This is the neighborhood go-to for desserts. The ice cream they serve is high quality and they have a wide selection of flavors. We split a double scoop, blackberry plus cookies and cream. The vibe is a step up from your average coffee shop, there's generally easy parking, and the employees have always been friendly. read more

Been a local favorite for a few years. It seems they were quietly acquired by Snoqualmie Ice Cream in the last month - the menu has changed subtly and the interior branding has changed much less subtly. I think the recipes have as well - the cookies and cream had a different texture than I was used to from the previous incarnation of Frosty Barrel. Thankfully Snoqualmie Ice Cream is pretty great, and the local ice cream scene hasn't been amazing in terms of competition, but I'll admit it's a little bittersweet to see the family owned business get absorbed into a larger one. Still intend to return regularly. read more

The Frosty Barrel - Rotating display now shows Snoqualmie branding - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

See all

We were looking for an ice cream spot for our anniversary - heard a lot of great things about the different kinds of flights you can do. We missed out on the hot cocoa flight but did the ice cream flight. So glad we did, I loved being able to have small tastings of the beers/ciders to pair with the ice cream. read more

The Frosty Barrel - Icecream + Brew Flight - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

My friends and I wanted to do something a little festive, so we headed on down to @frostybarrel to see their festive decorations while trying out their holiday drinks/icecream! There were so many delicious items to choose from, so we ended up doing a couple flights and individual drinks! Below are the items we got: * Tipsy campfire * Pepperment chocolate martini * Ube hot cocoa * Caramel chai hot cocoa * Smores hot cocoa * Peppermint hot cocoa * Ginger bread hot cocoa * Gingerbread icecream * Peppermint snaps icecream * Apple brandy pecan icecream * Spiked peppermint hot cocoa * Spike butterscotch hot cocoa * Tennessee whiskey icecream * English cream strawberries & shortbread icecream Everything we had was incredibly delicious and surprisingly not overly sweet despite the amount of items that we got! They also sell savory items on the menu, such as flatbreads! I definitely plan on coming back again, even after the season is over, as there were other icecream flavors and drinks I wanted to try, such as their wine flight pairing with icecream and their ube icecream! There are not many seats inside, so keep that in mind if you are interested in getting their flight options. It took about 10-15min to order, and took another 10-20min waiting for the order. They also have a cozy firepit to sit at, if available! read more

See all

Great food, ice cream and drink options. The East coast panini was amazing, red velvet hot chocolate was very good and we sampled ice cream including chocolate raspberry, strawberry and ube. The ube ice cream was our favorite! read more

See all

Very cute little shop with patient staffs. We asked a lot of questions and changed our mind several times but they were all very happy to accommodate. Their chocolate drinks and ice cream are on point and I love their flight options so that you can try multiple flavors read more

The Frosty Barrel - Hot chocolate flight - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

See all

Located in a strip mall in Newcastle with parking. Love the setup of the store that has one table with a fireplace top. Lots of ice cream options that you can sample first. There are a lot of food options as well. We tried the ube and strawberry sorbet. Staff was patient and friendly. read more

The Frosty Barrel - Ube - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

Went here after they decorated for Christmas and it is so cute inside! The details are immaculate with gingerbread walls and a hot cocoa bar inside. I had the hot cocoa flight with paired ice cream and it was so good. The staff are super friendly and help you decide what to get because they have so many good options. read more

The Frosty Barrel - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

Hot chocolate flight with pairing was delicious, and a cute fun atmosphere inside. There is also a table with a fireplace (gets taken quickly). Nice place to hang out with the girls. read more

See all

Ambience is cozy. The selection is just ok and very commercial. The staff is also meh. I wasn't thrilled with the wine flights, finding the wine highly overpriced for the brand. This is a great "first date" location but leave it off the list if you are really trying to impress someone. Also, it's always freezing in here so dress warm. read more

Love this neighborhood ice cream spot. It's got more than ice cream as they also serve alcohol and charcuterie boards. I had the ice cream sushi and it was adorable and tasty. We've also brought both kids to have their first taste of ice cream here. Such a special place for our family read more

The Frosty Barrel - Sushi ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

Obviously not the "season" for ice cream, but my kids will never say no haha. Anyways. We came from far away, but the thought of trying something new is always exciting. The girl at the counter was sweet, and offered samples. My kids got vanilla bean and I tried the peanut butter something rather. We also got a crossisant and two macarons. The ice cream tasted good, but honestly I was underwhelmed. read more

The Frosty Barrel - Vanilla bean, peanut butter ice cream. Chocolate crossisant and macarons - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

Expensive melty icecream Lavender is a nice smell for my home but not in my icecream...bleh Nice cozy clean dining space for hangout Helpful service read more

Can't say enough about this awesome place-fantastic food, Staff, service. Always lots of new flavors and items on the menu. We had a graduation party here and it was absolutely fantastic. Highly recommend the Sweeney family knows how to do it right to do it now! read more

See all

This place is a bit out of the way for me but glad a friend of mine recommended it. What a great concept and quite honestly, glad we don't have one closer. After looking at the photos, before we went, I just knew I needed a flight of beer and ice cream. Well, ok, not need... It was great, I didn't have to think about that to order and they really hit the spot with their pairings. The ice creams are really good, great flavors, textures, and my husband even got their dairy free, whatever free, and it was super creamy and had great flavor, even though it was chocolate, which I don't like. Highly recommend for a fun evening after dinner, or lunch (they do serve food). read more

Based on their website, the experience was completely different than we expected. We thought this was going to be more like a sit-down restaurant where we would be served by a server, not a quick-serve restaurant. So that was a big blow since it was our family bonding outing. We do quickly adjust though. We sat at the nice fireplace but it is obviously not used as such since it had tea light candles in it, which were not lit (they never last long if they were). They had 4 flavors of dairy-free ice cream, 2 of which were sorbet. Of the 2 ice cream, only one was gluten-free (peppermint brownie which was very good). They said they always have 4 DF options. Being gluten-free really limited us since we could not get any of the platters since they had too much gluten. So we decided to get sundaes. They did have a GF brownie so was able to have one, although the brownie was not very good - definitely tastes "GF." We had the hot chocolate flight DF (with oat milk) and felt like they were all just okay so they werent a normal experience would be...which we were told would have milk, whipped cream and additional toppings on the whipped cream. So, all in all, with dietary restrictions, I would say maybe go for the 4 ice cream / sorbet options but other than that skip it since it is underwhelming. For someone that can eat normally, I cant really comment on what the food experience is like. read more

See all

Ordered some hot chocolate flight particularly Dutch hot chocolate, orange flavored hot chocolate. Also the ice cream I tried was the salted caramel, this flavor was good balance of salt and sweet. The service is awesome and very hospitable. The place is very cozy and really love their fire pit. The parking isn't the best though even if they have lot parking it gets pretty full sometimes. read more

The Frosty Barrel - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

See all

I love the concept here of pairing booze with ice cream! It's so tasty. I got to try some fall hot chocolate too and I fell in love with the caramel chai. It paired well with the salted caramel ice cream. I also tried some of their flatbreads and was not super in love with the flatbread that had sausage with butternut squash and nuts. The sweet flatbread that had chocolate and strawberries on it was pretty good but did not wow my taste buds. I definitely want to come back and try some of their other drinks and flights. Their menu looked fun and I wanted to try a bunch of different things at once. I think frosty barrel is a great place for families and groups of people to come enjoy an ice cream + drink flight! The servers are all super friendly and fun. Its good and fun vibes here :) read more

See all

Hot Chocolate Heaven - 10/10 Literally! I ordered 10 Traditional Dutch Hot Chocolates from The Frosty Barrel (yes, TEN!) for a group, and every single one was absolutely on point. Rich, velvety, not too sweet, and perfectly topped with whipped cream and chocolate sprinkles--just the way hot chocolate should be. They nailed the consistency and flavor in all 10 cups, which honestly says a lot about their quality and attention to detail. Everyone in my group was blown away. The vibe here is warm and inviting, and the staff handled the big order like pros. If you're looking for next-level hot chocolate, this place delivers--literally and figuratively. Will definitely be coming back for other goods on the menu. read more

What a fun place! There is some outside seating, but it is just right in the parking lot, so that is a bit of a bummer. The inside had some cute tables but since it was pretty crowded we ended up in a so so one. We got the ice cream sushi and it was fun to eat and tasty. Such a creative idea. I look forward to coming back to try some of their other pairings read more

The Frosty Barrel - Ice cream sushi - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

I am not the biggest dessert or ice cream person but I love beer floats. This place offers beer and ice cream! I recommend the beer flight. Their ice cream is pretty good. Their tap list was pretty good when we visited. Nothing crazy but had different styles of beer and local options. But the magic happens when you mix the beer and ice cream together! Parking sucks here. The venue itself is nice. Staff is very friendly. Price is not cheap. That's about it! read more

The Frosty Barrel - Beer Flight Pairing! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

Getting ice cream & drink pairings here was so fun! When we walked in, there was quite a line. I noticed there weren't a lot of tables and it was kinda tight seating. Guess it's a popular place! After ordering, the server was able to maneuver the tables with ease to bring our orders to us. He did have to bring them separately, though, so by the time the beer flight arrived, my salted caramel ice cream in my white wine flight had melted quite a bit. Perhaps more staff to serve tables could prevent this. Once we had both flights at the table, I joyfully noticed the presentation of each drink with their ice cream right in front of them, and the card that labels what you are getting, with short descriptions of the drinks. We were excited to get to it! It was awesome to compare & contrast the pairings, then decide which we liked best. I didn't love all the flavors (ube definitely could've been better), but my focus was more on how well the drinks & ice creams went with each other. I personally loved the brightness of the Pinot gris with what I think was the raspberry sorbet (I'll explain later), and the buttery notes of the Chardonnay were awesome with the salted caramel ice cream. As far as beer pairings, the peanut butter stout went wonderfully with the Mukilteo Mudd ice cream. I'd say the bourbon barrel stout with the Tennessee whiskey ice cream was a close second. The reason I was confused about the wine flight's raspberry sorbet is because there was a sorbet in the beer flight that was also called "raspberry sorbet", but it looked and tasted different. I think there was a labeling mistake. Overall, I was really happy with our experience. When I'm ready for another alcohol/sugar rush, I'd love to come back to try the red wine flight & hot chocolate flight. read more

See all

This is our new go-to spot for ice cream. Our child has a dairy sensitivity, and this is one of the only places we have found that has multiple dairy-free options that are not just sorbets but actual creamy, delicious ice cream! We've had both the strawberry and chocolate dairy-free/gluten-free ice creams, and today, there was even an oat latte dairy-free/gluten-free option, which we will try next time. The staff has always been friendly, and today's service was especially great. One staff member checked in with us frequently (I'm not sure, but he might have been the owner). In addition to ice cream, they serve paninis, flatbreads, a charcuterie board, and a variety of drinks, including alcohol. Our family will continue coming in for sweet treats! read more

This is one of the best ice cream places I've ever been to in Washington. Every flavor I've tried has been delicious. I ordered a flight with four scoops: ube, strawberry shortbread, honey lavender, and espresso. Each one was perfectly sweet and flavorful. The flight of four flavors cost $15, which is quite reasonable. Everything was great, and I'll definitely be coming back to try some drinks. read more

See all

On a whim, I pulled into the Frosty Barrel to get out of the traffic when I was heading home. It's a very cute shop with sweet servers and some interesting ice cream options. I ordered a scoop of Goat cheese whisky cherry and a scoop of Smooth bourbon (hey, booze theme here) - it was my dairy happy hour!) The ice cream was quite good, and I really enjoyed the goat cheese bourbon. I will definitely visit again. read more

The Frosty Barrel - Goat cheese whisky cherry and smooth bourbon - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

I ordered the bubble pairing and it was so good, probably be back for other pairings! read more

The Frosty Barrel - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

We visited around lunchtime on a weekday. There were very few customers when we were there. Service was quite slow but we were not in a rush so did not impact our experience and allowed us an uninterrupted chance to chat and catch up. We had two of their creative hot chocolates which were delicious and would absolutely recommended for a treat. Also had the flatbread which was fine but not memorable. Would return for hot chocolates and to try the ice cream creations. read more