Fresh oysters awesome. Service just ok. To compare to other Hershey restaurants this place is just ok.

I have only ordered out here but not once have I been disappointed in the food. Top 5 burgers I have ever eaten along with the soups they offer always high quality and delicious. Farm 2 table for the win!!!! read more

Went for dinner to celebrate our wedding anniversary! The minute we walked in the door we felt welcomed. Service was amazing. Highly recommend the crab cakes. They are probably the best I've ever had. Highly recommend The Mill!! read more

The Mill in Hershey is solidly on my list of preferred brunch places. It is the kind of spot where a couple can go for brunch, sit at the bar, have a well made Bloody Mary, and get a unique food experience without dealing with the louder post church crowd and big groups that can take over some brunch places. The atmosphere works. It feels like a mill, but in the way an upscale, intentionally themed restaurant should. It is not cheap, but it is worth it. I have been here a number of times, both when it is quiet and when there are several groups in the room, and the experience has been consistently good. If I had one caution, it is accessibility and parking flow. The parking lot is long and runs parallel to the street, and the entrance has a staircase up to the door that could be challenging for some people. I assume they have an alternative entry option, but it is something to be aware of. Service is consistently professional and well paced, and it is personable without feeling overly casual. Overall, highly recommended. read more

Nice place! First I have to start with our server! Brice was our server and he was awesome! Knew his menu and cocktails and made great suggestions, everyone enjoyed ! Started off with apps, flat bread was good, crab dip was fantastic, calamari was average! I had the brisket! Real nice! Good flavor Mac a cheese side was tasty, veg was carrots could have been hotter! read more

The Mill - Hershey - Brisket - New American Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

Visiting town for work and came across this spot online and so glad we did! The atmosphere is rustic-chic with an amazing patio that really sets the tone. We started with the beef barley soup, which was fantastic and loaded with generous chunks of filet. For our mains, we ordered the crab cakes and they absolutely delivered; two hefty 4 oz cakes made with pure crab and no filler whatsoever. Truly outstanding. Our server was friendly and fast. I'll definitely be coming back the next time I'm in town! read more

The Mill - Hershey - Maryland Broiled Crab Cakes - New American Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

We chose The Mill for my daughter's graduation dinner, and it was absolutely the right choice. A huge shout-out to Madi, who handled my lengthy initial phone call with patience, kindness, and professionalism. She offered helpful options and perks for our group, stayed in touch with me by text leading up to the dinner, and made it incredibly easy to keep her updated without having to step away and disturb the graduation ceremony or the people around me. That level of customer service is rare and appreciated. When we arrived after the ceremony, they took our group right in with no stress, no confusion, and everything flowed smoothly -- even with separate checks and a larger party. The atmosphere was warm and welcoming, the food was excellent, and the portions were generous. But what stood out most was how seamless they made an important family celebration feel. Graduation days can be hectic and emotional, and The Mill gave us the perfect place to slow down, celebrate, and make memories. Highly recommend for any special occasion. Thank you to Madi and the team for helping make my daughter's graduation dinner such a great experience. read more

The Mill - Hershey - Collage of Small Party Setting for College Graduation Ceremony Dinner - New American Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

The food was delicious, smoked pork belly, surf & turf & vanilla bean cheesecake. VP was our server and he was on point. Very nice place to eat, love the atmosphere. 19th anniversary dinner. Thank you to all the staff for the note read more

See all

Hands down the best dining experience near Hershey, PA! Bryce and Milo were our servers in the two visits we had to this place this weekend. Food was exceptional! Farm to table entree items and excellent vegetable selection. The sweetest carrots we have eaten in a restaurant. The restored mill building is exceptionally clean and superbly decorated. A five-star dining experience twice in a row! Eat here and taste the difference! We went back twice for their great food and service - if we come back we'll book reservations immediately upon arrival. Best food in Hershey! read more

See all

We visit The Mill for dinner each time we are in Hershey. Love this place! You definitely need to plan ahead and secure a reservation because this place is always packed. The floor plan is open, and you're surrounded by wood, so depending on the other parties present, sometimes this place can be a little on the noisy side. The food is always, always delicious. We have never gotten a meal here that we have been disappointed in. Highly recommend! read more

I had a great time dining here before visiting Hershey Park. The burger was really juicy and was cooked medium, which is exactly what I wanted. The servers were friendly and the interior of the restaurant was great. The location has historical significance so it was really cool to be inside the building. read more

The Mill - Hershey - New American Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

has a great quiet ambiance with soft light & warm tones. Offers a full bar. Food is delicious. Gourmet style. Great prompt service. read more

The Mill - Hershey - In house fresh key lime pie will not disappoint. - New American Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

The food was delicious and our service was excellent. We came here to celebrate a birthday and they let us cut our own cake which was nice. read more

See all

Passed through PA for a baseball tournament and ended up at The Mill! Best decision ever. Atmosphere was amazing, customer service is outstanding and the food did not disappoint. Everything was cooked to perfection and our server was the best! If you're in town and looking for great food stop by and check out The Mill! Thank me later read more

Fantastic meal at the Mill! Great first night dinner here in Hershey. My daughter absolutely loved her mac cheese and the perfectly seasoned and cooked carrots she had as a side. I had the elderflower spritz..which was well balanced and super refreshing. For my meal I went with the Mill Burger. Nice fresh tomato and lettuce and the bacon was crisp and not at all greasy. read more

The Mill - Hershey - Elderflower Spritz - New American Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

See all

Solid and standard. We weren't left impressed but had a good meal. The Mill will not disappoint, but we left hoping for more. A evening in Hershey with Trans Siberian Orchestra (amazing show!), entered into an after show dinner at The Mill. We were promptly seated with reservation, and greeted by our server/bartender. He kept with our needs, but appeared rushed and was not engaging. Started with calamari and oysters- crisp calamari, no sog, what you'd want from a calamari. The oysters were fresh, not too large or briny. Accompaniments were nothing of interest. Entrees, if I can find a scallop dish that will typically be a choice. There's a few staples that are judge-worthy of a restaurant and believe scallops are one of those types of dishes. Scallops atop a squash puree and balsamic glaze. The scallops were clean, but needed some more sear. The sear would've been key, since sat on a loose puree, to give texture. Flavors were pleasant, on the sweeter side, just needed dimension. However, my husband loved the duck dish. CRUNCHY!!! He ate it like fried chicken, lololol. Fall, hearty flavors of with the crispy duck on stuffing with carrots. There are no complaints with The Mill, it was a good meal and nice atmosphere....just no stand outs. read more

See all

The Mill is one of my favorite spots in Hershey. The location is beautiful and huge. There is a large outdoor area too. Their cocktails are top notch. But the food. Holy smokes. The food is INCREDIBLE!!! read more

See all

I worked with Nicole, Event Coordinator, to plan a dinner at The Mill as the finale for our annual board retreat, from start to finish the experience was fantastic. Nicole was a pleasure to work with. We had a party of 25 people, we were in the Swarta Room. Our servers for the evening was Ryan and Amy, they were attentive, friendly and made our evening a true pleasure. The food was fantastic and display for our houderves was beautiful, no details were missed. Everyone raved about the food, the spirits were very reasonably priced and delicious and the desserts were so good I brought it back home with me. The portions were ample, several people from our party packed a to go bag and brought their leftovers back to NJ. Everything about our experience was top notch, I can't wait to visit Hershey again and when I do I will be coming to The Mill again. read more

See all

This was my first time at The Mill. You couldn't tell it was a restaurant from the outside, it looks like an old factory/farmhouse. The inside was very trendy, "industrial glam". The service was excellent and quick. We ordered drinks, the blueberry lemon drop lacked blueberry flavor but it was strong. The calamari and the baguette were absolutely delicious. The smoked brisket was tender and flavorful. The wagyu lasagna came highly recommended, however, I felt like it was too much meat in proportion to noodles. The flavor was there but the lasagna texture wasn't, and I was a bit disappointed. We ended dinner with a snickerdoodle crème brûlée that was the perfect combination of sweet and creamy with the classic sugar coating. I enjoyed it and will be coming back to try more menu items! read more

See all

What an absolute waste we went here for our engagement dinner had an amazing day at chocolate world. This was highly rated we went i have a walker went in the bottom there were people at tables but no one to tell us where to check on finally somebody at a table after 20 mins said there's an elevator After sitting at our table i ordered a mich ultra which was skunk couldnt drink and my fiancé ordered an Aperol drink. It was horrible. We asked was the charcuterie board was and was told a whole bunch of good meats and many did cheeses. 27 bucks and when it came i coulda done better with 10 bucks. Who opens and peels a clementine and placed it on a plate walnuts salami manchengo idk what kind of cheese grapes and a hard pretzel. Horrible. For dinner i hat the duck which was so over cooked i almost broke a tooth my fiancés pork chop was so dry she could barely cut it. The wait had come a few times and goes oh yea i feel the same this food isn't good! Besides the food being horrible and it being a sat night in Hershey it was dead empty. Do not recommend this place. read more

The food was good though the atmosphere was a bit more rustic than I expected from the photos. The upstairs dining area is small and they were seating people downstairs in a tent like area. read more

This place is fancy, tasty, and price is reasonable! We went as a group and we loved it. I would definitely come back for sure read more

See all

We had a party of ten before 5PM on Saturday, October 11. We were seated upstairs quickly. Food - Excellent Atmosphere- Excellent Service - Good Where the restaurant fell down, however, was when we were finished eating, but not done chatting, we were asked to clear out for some other group. This is UNFORGIVABLE AND A MAJOR FOUL! Regrettable! read more

Very slow service and atmosphere filled with the screams of children whose parents brought them to a bar. Salty food. Slow service. You can do better in Hershey. read more

We were seated on the lower level in a corner area which provided a bit of privacy. Our server (Shay) was knowledgeable and helpful, as well as a bit entertaining (perfect for this foursome). We started with a signature cocktail each. This was followed by two shared appetizers which were very good. Entrees were ordered, and we enjoyed a 2023 Malbec (Felino) from Vina Cobos. All agreed it was a keeper. Main courses were a hit for all. Two desserts were ordered to share. Both the Snickers Crème Brûlée and the Chocolate Peanut Butter pie were delicious. We would highly recommend this restaurant for a special occasion. read more

The Mill - Hershey - An annual dinner out with 4 friends. - New American Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

See all

A great local farm to table restaurant here in Hershey! We came here for our anniversary and enjoyed our time. There was so much love put in to restoring this Mill to be an accurate account of a mill but it feels clean and cozy. The patio is LOVELY. It's so comfy here and enjoyable to just sit and be. We started with the oysters, which for being in central Pennsylvania were good! We're from the east coast so we're spoiled, they were a bit overly salty and a bit bland compared to what we're used to. But not everyone can get oysters fresh off the bay. We then shared the pear salad which was LOVELY. Expertly dressed and a beautiful show case of a summer salad. We then got the brisket and prime rib. Which were both amazing. Both were absolutely melt in your mouth and delectably seasoned and prepared. The Mac and cheese that paired with the brisket was Smokey and rich and the green beans with the steak was addictive. The crème brûlée was also wonderful. Very creamy and crisp. The food here is definitely where this place thrives. Where I'm really let down by is the drinks. They were really not fabulous. The summer drink was exactly okay. But the espresso martini I couldn't have more 2 sips of. I don't know if it was the bartender that was on tonight? But 4/4 drinks we had were not delicious. But overall, the Mill was definitely worth it! read more

See all

Noah e been here now 3 times and will definitely come back again. The food is very good and the drinks really good as well. We have always had exceptional service and the atmosphere is comfortable and cool. read more

See all

My family took my mother to The Mill for her dinner and we are so glad we did. This restaurant is perfect for a family dinner. Ten of us enjoyed comfortable seating. We had a reservation and we were seated immediately. Even though a few of the people in our party were late, our server, Colin, was so kind and engaging. The service was impeccable. But the best thing about The Mill is that the food rivals a high end steakhouse with its taste, but the prices were more affordable. I ordered crab cakes that were actual sumptuous, jumbo lump crab cakes, not dried and tasteless filler. Nice! My niece had the brisket I was eyeing and she said it was delicious. Everyone in our party loved their meals. I'm looking forward to returning for a visit to The Mill later this year. read more

See all

Wow!!!! Everything was excellent. Our server JJ was amazing and his recommendations were on point. Definitely a place I would visit again if I ever find myself back in Hershey PA. read more

See all

Came for lunch but they surprisingly had brunch offerings. We seated promptly and our server was very nice. Cocktails were good and my husband enjoyed his omelette. Plenty of parking and clean bathrooms. read more

See all

We were looking for a new date night place and the mill popped up in a search. Decided to give it a try based on other reviews and we're so happy we did! Made reservations via Open Table since it looked like it can fill up fast. Entrance is located on the second floor but they do have an accessible entrance on the first floor patio if needed. We were greeted warmly and showed to our table on the third floor. (first floor was patio seating, second was casual bar/lounge and third was more quiet dining.) Atmosphere is unique, like a converted barn so its rustic chic. Our waiter Colin was phenomenal, recommending specials, small plates, drink pairings, everything. I got a house salad with green goddess dressing and filet. Husband got the Caesar salad and brisket over mac and cheese. Salads were very fresh and flavorful while the filet and brisket were cooked to perfection. We got dessert as well, a peanut butter torte and it was the perfect way to end the meal. Over all a great, semi causal place we plan to frequent again for a celebration or date night. Staff especially Colin were all very friendly and helpful. read more

See all

My wife and I had a fantastic meal at The Mill! We drove from New York and planned out a fun weekend of shopping and dining in Amish Country. The Mill was the highlight of our trip. We drove up to this magnificent looking restaurant and found a spot up front. We arrived early, walking inside to a beautiful and rustic dining room. I was told our table isn't ready so we went to the bar and ordered cocktails. The seasonal Fall cocktails we ordered were the Autumn Blossom Sangria and I ordered the Apple Butter Old Fashioned with Basil Hayden Toast Bourbon. Wow! Total fan We're seated downstairs, close to a gorgeous looking fireplace. The menu is farm to table, everything looks delish! I ordered a flatbread to start, Our waiter said we can order a small salad with our meals for a 4 dollar upcharge. I went with the house salad and the house smoked brisket. Both items were very good, the thick cuts of brisket was the star of the evening. The smoke was slight but was still packed with flavor, very tender and juicy. My only issue was the Mac & Cheese, it was a little mushy for my palate. My wife and I split a locally sourced chocolate ice cream, it was a perfect ending to a perfect meal. If you're looking for a great meal in Hershey, I highly recommend The Mill read more

See all

Be prepared to pay NYC prices for unimpressive food. Service is ok. Food is nicely presented and the ingredients are fine, but taste is bland. Owners of the restaurant pay rural PA rent yet charge NYC prices. Ambiance of the restaurant is a nice rustic (hence 2 stars instead of 1). When you are paying the bill, they bring you a device and the tip options are 20, 22, and 24%. No thanks! read more

The service was great and the food delicious. Cocktails are creative like the Spiced Cranberry Old Fashioned. The sliced brisket was amazing. So much food I couldn't finish it. Great look and ambiance. read more

Great restaurant in the area when visiting Hershey. Modern, great cocktails. Loved the variety. Delicious food and wonderful service. Go for the bone in pork chop as its tender and tasty. Good fresh oysters and fresh salads. Friendly and makes us all feel welcome. The wood fired smoked items are the hidden gem. The smoked pork belly or brisket was wonderful. Will be back when in the area. read more

See all

As much as I would love to be a type A traveler, I'm just not. Naturally I did not think restaurants would be jammed the closer to the park you got. If you want a sweet little spot that feels fancy but is off the beaten path and quiet, this is your place. The food was great, I got the mahi and a martini. We sat upstairs and it was lovely, beautiful wooden interior with a full bar. It was winter, but the outside had the cutest covered porch with lights that would be great for warmer weather. I would hit this spot up again to escape the craziness of The Chocolatier. read more

See all

Knocks it out of the park! Everything from service to quality was great. We enjoyed the cheese plate, bruschetta, & oysters to start, and the scallops & pork for the main. All my drinks were great: espresso martini, margarita, French 75. Dessert was an incredible snickerdoodle crème brûlée. Missed a star because we were originally sat in the far downstairs corner behind a loud party of several families. We indicated it was our anniversary on the reservation and they acknowledged it when we checked in. I would hope for a bit of consideration as to the occasion, since it was early in the night and they had lots of open space. However, we asked if we could move somewhere quieter and they happily took us to the top floor. It was a great ambiance up there. Will be back! read more

See all

Sat at the bar for dinner, had the hot honey catfish served with carrots and Mac and cheese and the wedge salad, so good. Rounded out the meal with the peanut butter dessert and it was so good!! read more

Tucked away in a sublime blend of history and culinary artistry, The Mill emerges as an unmissable epicurean sanctuary. The structure is an elegant tapestry of stone and wood, reminiscent of the establishment's bygone mill heritage. The outdoor patio at The Mill is a serene oasis that seamlessly marries modern comfort with rustic charm. As you step outside, the warmth of a fire-lit area beckons you to unwind, its flickering flames casting a soft, ethereal glow on the surroundings. The bar itself is a striking masterpiece, built with a stone facade that pays homage to the venue's historical roots. With comfortable seating and an atmosphere imbued with an unhurried sense of time, it's the perfect space for lingering conversations or simply soaking up the enchanting environment. Whether you're savoring a finely crafted cocktail or simply basking in the firelight, the patio serves as a tranquil backdrop for an evening of relaxed sophistication. The interior gleams with a newly-restored bar with an old time rustic feel, underscoring the notion that tradition and modernity can coalesce in complimentary ways. Descending into the secondary bar and dining room is akin to stepping back in time, while still enveloped in contemporary comforts. The room exudes a wood-fired, living quarters ambience, fortified by the stone and wood foundation--the quintessence of rustic sophistication. The Whipped Brie board was not just a dish but an experience in and of itself. The texture of the whipped Brie defies description--think airy, pillowy clouds of dairy intermingling with the perfect crisp of Brie chips. This exquisite spread was enlivened by homemade Blueberry Jam, a drizzle of fresh farm honeycomb, and a sprinkling of seasonal fruits. The Mediterranean Board was a tour-de-force of flavors. Halloumi cheese--renowned for its high melting point--was fried to a perfect balance of creamy and crispy textures, offering a fragrant juxtaposition. The Lamb Meatballs were a revelation, divested of the customary gaminess but retaining their intrinsic richness. The Spanakopita, a Greek delicacy consisting of spinach and feta cheese wrapped in phyllo pastry, was flaky and flavorful. The dish was brought together by the "Everything Hummus," featuring a harmonious blend of Everything Seasoning, Onion Jam, Crudite, Grilled Pita, and Olives--a Mediterranean orchestra on a plate. Every dish was elegantly presented on wooden spherical trays, the visible tree rings adding an organic touch that echoed the restaurant's natural aesthetic. The House Smoked Pork Belly, adorned with Brussel Slaw and Walnuts, was a triumphant experiment in seasoning and smokiness, while the Braised Short Rib was a culinary sonnet of softness and savoriness, enhanced but not overwhelmed by its accompaniments. Although the Caesar Salad was not the star of the show, it added a subtle, balancing note to the rich ensemble. However, the pièce de résistance was the Five Layer Short Rib Lasagna. Here, every layer was a revelation, woven together by Braised Short Rib, Pepperoni, Tomato Ragout, and Toasted Bread--each bite was an interplay of savory complexity and textural diversity. Concluding the meal with a nightcap of Frangelica and coffee was akin to the closing act in a well-orchestrated symphony, leaving an indelible resonance of satisfaction. In summary, The Mill offers an unrivaled dining experience, harmonizing its rich history with a tantalizing menu that delivers on both innovation and taste. It's not just a meal; it's an evocative journey deserving of acclaim and repeat visits. read more

See all

Went here for dinner on a Wednesday evening. Place waaa very busy and while the atmosphere was nice, food was so-so and service wasn't the greatest. Highly recommend a reservation versus a walk in like we did. Burger was decent, fries were good but we could have done without the queso. read more

The Mill - Hershey - Chorizo Queso - New American Near Me - Hershey, Pennsylvania

See all