I'm a big fan of a good deli. We ordered 3 sandwiches. They were pretty large, with a thick piece of lightly toasted bread. I did enjoy the ranch aioli on my turkey bacon ranch and my wife enjoyed her Italian assorted, though the banana peppers were too hot for her to eat. While the sandwiches were big, I think it was due to the amount of bread. While I don't have any negative notes, they are basic. I did not like how the prices on the website did not align with what I paid. They were a couple more dollars per sandwich. I also had to stop at the bank to get cash because they weren't accepting cards at the time. As far as the atmosphere, it seemed very dark, dingy and unwelcoming. I may try again in the future. read more

When I say I am not a cabbage girl, I 100 percent mean it. I hated it growing up. I'll eat the smallest sliver ever now, but when I ordered the corned beef dinner and tried the cabbage from here, it was OUT of this WORLD!!! It is only for a short time, but this deli offers a full course dinner for 21.99 that includes a hefty amount of corned beef, potatoes, cabbage, carrots, with a piece of bread, gf or not, and irish potato soup and a side salad with ranch. The potato soup was so delicious! The corned beef was moist and tender. It was such a good meal. Highly recommend for all your.St Patrick's Day needs and beyond. So good!!! read more

Lancaster's Broadway Deli - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Sandwiches here are amazing. They're huge and the bread and all ingredients on them always taste super fresh!

Great subs lots of variety! I really enjoyed my build your own sub and they've got a ton of different options of things to try! I also got a side of their potato salad which was pretty good as well. They have seating and parking available and prices were good.as well. read more

See all

We used Lancaster's Broadway Deli to cater a party for 25 this weekend. They offer many options and the food was delicious and appealing. Greg was easy to work with when making arrangements. Would definitely use again! read more

Gluten free never tastes THIS good! Growing up an hour outside of NYC, I often had what I call REAL deli sandwiches. Not since then have I had anything remotely close. And now, having to be gluten-free, to not only have GF rye bread, but have it taste SO good! The photo doesn't do it justice. Make your way to Lancaster's Broadway Deli! read more

Lancaster's Broadway Deli - Turkey and Swiss on rye - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, New York

If you have celiac or even a gluten intolerance, this is the place for you! Amazing real beer batter fish fry with gluten-free sides is simply delicious. They can make anything on the menu gluten-free also. Highly recommend read more

My favorite spot to get food from during work! My sandwich never disappoints! Always such large portions as well!

Stopped in to ask: "Give me your best selling, most ordered deli sandwich, please!" Dude behind the counter thought about it for a sec and whipped up this monster of a sandwich! the Voodoo Buffalo chicken sandwich! On a Pretzel bun, this is one massive sandwich. At least 1/2 lb of shaved chicken. I believe bacon was on there. This was nested on top of some sourcream onion potato chips covering the bottom roll with a slice of (yancy's fancy?) hot pepper cheddar. Slice of tomato, lettuce, and a blue cheese kinda spread/aeoli? But wow, this thing was packed full of flavor. Very comfortable quirky atmosphere. Clean. A bunch of theater tickets and play bills under glass on the tables. Artist pictures all over the walls. I can see a tiny dinner theater or some short plays here, as long as they can be done with the limited space I will def come back and try another sandwich. My wife used to get platters from here all the time for her staff. Unfortunately, their palates have changed and just want pizza / wings? Weird. Anyhow.... stop by for a quick sandwich. This thing was GREAT! I give 5 stars NOT because my bill was $500, or the place was dimly lit, or micro-greens were strategicly placed on top with tweezers, etc... I did because the sandwich was great, the dude and I had some good conversation, and the place was CLEAN! Keep on keepin on! read more

Lancaster's Broadway Deli - 2 bites in . Damn!! - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

I'm out in Lancaster for lunch and we ordered take out from here. WOW. I wish I lived 20 minutes closer because this would be my new lunch spot indefinitely. I ordered the Raspberry Smoked Turkey panini (award winning in 2015). I can see why. The perfect panini. I wouldn't think to normally order something like this but so glad I did - YUM! read more

Lancaster's Broadway Deli - Raspberry Smoked Turkey - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Amazing food! The sandwich I got was huge. 10/10 will be coming back again to try the rest of their menu. I got the award winning turkey crasins panini, the Turkey was perfect! Can't wait to try other items. read more

Neat little place where you can listen to Broadway show tunes while enjoying your meal or waiting for your takeout ! When there craving their highly rated fish fry but they ran out at 4:30 ?? But while we were there we tried the panini's, very glad we did!! They were the size of a wide half sub loaded with meat and toasted perfectly! The inside of the roll was fresh and airy! read more

Lancaster's Broadway Deli - Royal - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

I was so in the mood for a fish fry but they were all sold out by 5! I had the Tuscan panini and my husband had a royal. Both were excellent and Hugh! Bread was crusty and ingredients very fresh. Next time I will call ahead for the fish fry! read more

See all

They have the Best Rueben in our area. Would go there regardless of the weather. My wife and I have been going there for years.

I ordered the corned beef Rueben and it was fantastic. Very generous amount of Boars Head meat on it with perfect amounts of sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and Russian dressing on grilled fresh rye bread! I highly recommend this place! read more

Tried this deli on a whim and instantly regretted it. The minute I saw the cheese being melted in the microwave, I knew I was going to be disappointed. Philly cheesesteak was not in fact steak, rather roast beef with a pound of microwaved cheese on top (torched after for color) with a few peppers and neon green horseradish mayo.... The Chicago sandwich had huge chunks of vegetables on it and the bread was soggy with tons of mayo. I am not usually one to write negative reviews but this was just so bad so I felt obligated to let others know not to waste their time. The deli is made to look like a NYC/Chicago deli but is no where near. There are many other good delis in Lancaster/Buffalo and this was not it. read more

The door was unlocked and I tried to order a sandwich. The guy working was extremely rude and said he was only doing catering orders. Like how much effort could it have been to make one sandwich and why have the place open and turn down customers. read more

Food is so fresh and plentiful..you can't miss on any sandwich! Also does catering and breakfast sandwich specials on saturdays

Fast service and exceptional quality food! I ordered the turkey bacon ranch on a pretzel roll with a side of homemade redskin potato salad. Absolutely delicious! Can't wait to go back. I'd love to try the catering as well. read more

Lancaster's Broadway Deli - Turkey bacon ranch on pretzel roll - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, New York

I like the soup and sandwich selection they offer. Everything is very tasty. The owner is a very pleasant person. Ambiance is wonderful. Great music and atmosphere. read more

Absolutely the best Rueben in Buffalo. Corned Beef literally melts in your mouth and the sauerkraut was delicious. This sandwich is huge and also came with a pickle, which was also very tasty. I will eat here as often as I can, I just wish it was closer to my house. read more

Lancaster's Broadway Deli - Corned Beef Rueben - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Been waiting for a chance to stop in this place and I'm glad I did. I ordered the NY Ruben and these guys were worth the wait. The bread was nice and fresh. I'm a big guy and it took me two sittings to finish it. So much meat I could have made another sandwich. Not to mention they use Boars head products. I highly recommend you stop by and grab a bite. They do not disappoint!!!! read more

I had no idea they did fish fry's here and they have gluten free items which makes it easier for some of my family members! We called early and asked if our order could be ready when I got out of work which was right before their closing time on Wednesday, they said no problem! I arrived it was ready and it was warm even after the drive home! Everyone got a different kind of fish fry, they have many to choose from and their prices are perfect! Homemade sides and no problem substituting a salad instead of macaroni salad - they do that with the gluten free choices also! read more

See all

Love, love, love !!! My new go to place. Quality food. Very creative sandwiches. Very affordable prices. Love the family story so glad location is in Lancaster. read more

Who doesn't love a deli sandwich filled with premium deli meat and cheese, fresh vegetables and homemade aioli?  The best part is that they have a gluten-free menu.  There are lots of options for those who are looking to eat gluten-free, a large variety of sandwiches (they have gf breads - and not just cardboard tasting ones), soups, chips, potato salads, coleslaws, and chef salad. I love their deal of $6.99 for any 1/2 sandwich with a side of side (including chips, soup, pasta salad, etc.).  The Voo Doo Buffalo Chicken had the most delicious buttermilk blue cheese on it.  (This is the only sandwich that isn't included in the 1/2 sandwich deal since they don't offer sandwiches on half a pretzel roll.  However, they were super-accommodating and were able to do it on another choice of bread).  For my side I went with the Tuscan bowtie salad.  It had a bit too much Ceaser dressing for me. My mom and kids loved their gf Reuben and Cuban that they shared.  Both were packed with meat and cheese.  They had the chili for their side.  It was more of a tomato soup with lots of peppers and onions, not the greatest. Although the sides weren't our favorite, the sandwiches were top-of-the-line. There were a handful of tables to eat there and hand sanitizer was readily available.  We were there on a Monday afternoon and saw quite a few people come in and grab their pick-up order.  They had a great system and worked in a timely manner. Check out their Facebook page for weekly specials.  I've seen things like a muffuletta and Nashville Hot Chicken Bahn Mi pop up. When we used our credit card we were automatically added to their rewards program.  For every purchase of $9.50 or more, you get a point and when you get to 10 points you get a reward ... I can't remember exactly - maybe a free sandwich? Looking forward to grabbing more sandwiches from here! read more

See all

I saw that they can do GF for their menu items, so I reached out to see if their St. Patrick's Day special was dairy-free too & it was!! They answered right away on their Instagram account and were super friendly ... & of course it was delicious. I will be back! Thanks Lancaster's Broadway Deli for the awesome experience & food. *Plz note that the horseradish & Irish Potato soup was not dairy-free (but I was told ahead of time). Also, I don't have Celiac & I'm okay with butter for some dairy. read more

Lancaster's Broadway Deli - Corn beef & cabbage meal for St. Patrick's Day! - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

I have never been to the Broadway Deli, so I didn't know what to expect. Walking into the Deli, I was blown away. The atmosphere is like no other. The service is quick and workers are friendly. Me and my friends sat down, tried the complimentary popcorn and listened to a variety of songs from different broadway musicals. The whole place is themed like a deli you would find on Broadway in Hollywood. I got the turkey bacon ranch sandwich and it was amazing. I got a bottled cream soda which was the perfect beverage to complete my meal. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for a nice bite to eat. read more

This is the place to go for a deli sandwich! It is my go to place, and I will continue to go on a weekly basis. Their Turkey Ruben is to die for. read more

We love the deli! Everytime I have been the food is amazing quality. The service is fast and the employees are super kind. It is quiet and clean. 10/10 recommend! read more

This is my second experience eating at this deli and I enjoyed both meals Bussin!!!! The service was great one guy doing it. All the ambience was also well clean and maintenance. read more

Lancaster's Broadway Deli - Grilled Steakhouse Sirloin - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Nothing Like an a Italiano I love this place has a New York City broadway musical vibe to it very pleasant place to grab a sandwich on your lunch break read more

Lancaster's Broadway Deli - Italian Assorted - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Wonderful sandwiches. Great atmosphere. I love NYC and Broadway, and these sandwiches are just as good.

Had their chicken caesar salad today! was a very healthy meal with generous amounts of chicken! Highly recommend! Their sandwiches are also amazing! read more

Catered an event for 40 people. They were easy to work with and very responsive. Food was reasonably priced, arrived on time, and was fresh! Would definitely recommend. read more

The Broadway Deli is a hidden gem. Having lived in Lancaster my whole life I'm surprised I have never eaten here but when my buddies said we should go try it I kind of knew it was going to be a wild experience. Walking in the front doors you are greeted by soundtracks from Broadway musicals and walls covered with Broadway stars. The menu is just big enough to have something for everyone without being overwhelming. The young lady taking our orders was very patient and helpful and the older gentleman making the food also was kind enough to welcome us to the shop and thank us for coming. After paying for the sandwiches we each took a bag of the complimentary popcorn (which was totally unexpected) and sat down at one of the booths. The wait was only about 10 minutes and when we opened our boxes we were all pleasantly surprised. $10.99 for sandwiches of this size and caliber is a bargain at the very least! We all washed our food down with some Stewart's Cream Soda which topped of the meal just perfectly. An overall top notch experience because of both the service and the food. Would definitely recommend and will be spreading the word to others in Lancaster. read more

Lancaster's Broadway Deli - Grilled Steakhouse Sirloin, Raspberry Smoked Turkey, and Chicken Parmesan Melt - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Fish fry was delicious. The few sandwiches ive tried were very good. You got your monies worth.

We love this place! The sandwiches are top notch - so good & a nice size too! The atmosphere is great - excellent music at a convenient location. The owner is very friendly - he does a super job with everything! read more

Always fresh, fast and friendly service. Soups, sandwiches and sides are always great

This is my third ordering food from Lancaster's Broadway deli and everything has had so much flavor! I tried their Char-grilled haddock and it was so tasty. All the sides were homemade and the whole meal was a great value. I am looking forward to the next time I can order again! read more

Lancaster's Broadway Deli - Char-grilled Haddock with fries, potato salad, cole slaw, tarter and came with side salad. - Sandwiches Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Broadway Deli's gluten-free sandwiches are excellent! My favorite is their Cranberry Turkey, but everything is very good. Wish they were open until at 6pm on weekdays. read more