My wife and I walked in not knowing they didn't serve pizza but the slice. I convinced her to stay…read moreand order and see how it was. Thankfully we did, because the food was incredible and we were super pleased. I wouldn't say hidden gem, this place is a pizza goldmine! We started with the Caesar salad which was so fresh and delicious. We ordered a small Neapolitan and a small Supreme pizza for dinner & WOW were they delicious. I grew up and Queens & my expectation for pizza is high. This met that and more! The pizza is thin crust & ingredients are so fresh. This is our default "go to" spot in Bay Shore, and we have brought numerous friends and family here. Not one bad meal!

Homey pizzeria, small menu but really good pizza, can bring the entire family. Good wine super…read moreaffordable. Service is excellent. I was craving a salad, the Caesar salad hit the spot. Opted for a glass of Pinot Nior which was fresh. I am a Pinot Nior girl so I can tell when a bottle has been opened for a while. The wine is affordable and does not taste cheap. The garlic bread is a huge portion with a good amount of garlic. I love garlic so it was spot on.

Retired NYPD, Moved to Georgia from Bay Shore, upon returning for a weekend wedding, I said to my…read moreson before returning to Georgia I need the best pizza on Long Island. He immediately said The Pizzeria of Bay Shore. I said "Oh the place where they have those deliciously garlicky garlic knots, yes please I need that". The pizza is so delicious, I wish that they had this in Georgia, but nope not even close. I could eat from there every single day only fresh ingredients used here. I recommend the addictive garlic knots, reg cheese pie, chicken parm,100% you can't go wrong with any menu items. "I'll be back" in Arnold voice.Lol

Skip the Sicilian!!!!…read more Crust was old. Many pizzerias make the Sicilian crust ahead of time and you run the risk of serving dry, stale tasting crust. Our first time trying this place but that's a big deal. I can't even tell you the sauce and cheese were good since the overall taste was ruined.

A pass this establishment every single day It does have some…read morenice parking I was going to order a hamburger but ended up getting the slider lunch deal I really enjoyed it so much. It's like a real barbecue. Taste exactly what you want to taste a little bigger than a slider but not big enough to be a full-blown hamburger. Then I started smelling the area and I now ordered a pizza. I can't say enough check this place out right away. There is no lines they take care of you right away.!! The person that took care of me her name is Debbie , anything that I needed help with She explained.

Great service and love the ambience and vibe…read more I wish I had ordered the burger. I ordered the pizza with vodka sauce which had meatballs, prosciutto and crispy onions. Nice flavor but I did not like the crust. A little too doughy for me. The cauliflower app with spinach hummus was tasty. My girlfriend had the onion soup which looked pretty thick but she's had it before and presumably loved it. My other friend is a regular and is a raving fan. So I was looking forward to it. She had the pizza with the whipped ricotta and Zuchinni. She enjoyed it but was missing an app that was removed, something with blueberries. She said on paper, it didn't sound appetizing but it's a favorite of hers. All around, great experience. Next time I'm going to try a burger.

Food is always excellent when we come, today we tried the Drunken Garlic Knots they definitely hit…read morethe spot and were delicious. Our server Brianna was excellent and sweet, she recommended the homemade tiramisu for desert and it was excellent! Service is excellent, the restaurant itself is very modern clean and nice, and most importantly food was delicious Must try must try must try

Had a nice lunch here today. Everything was delicious as usual. Service is excellent with polite…read moreand professional staff. I ordered the eggplant Parmesan entrée. It came with pasta and was absolutely delicious. My friend had the chicken franchise. She said it was perfect. The best chicken franchise she's had . We will definitely be returning another time and if you are in the area, I would highly recommend you this restaurant.

Here we go, So the reason I love this pizza shop is because…read moreit taste close to the pizza from Jamaica Avenue. Yes they deliver. This pizza shop is located in the shopping mall of Best Buy and Adli in Bayshore off Sunrise Hwy. Local pizza shop which at times I have visited they're pretty busy. When ordering to receive delivery usually wait time is about 45 minutes. Every order I have placed with them has been great. Pizza shop is always clean whenever I visit but I usually receive delivery service. Overall in my opinion if you want pizza that taste close to Jamaica Avenue pizza try this pizza shop. I think you would love it. Happy yelping....

Pizza from here is fine not amazing not bad. Good pizza if you're in the area. They deliver and the…read moreprices are decent.

2 years ago we were in town and my daughter loves the pizza at Angela's so we went. They had…read morechicken sliders, like a mini chicken parm with vodka sauce on a a bun that was like a large garlic knot. We tried it and loved it so much we went back the next day to get it again. We are in town again and I drive straight to Angela's for their "Apps" slice and a chicken slider, eggplant slice and a house salad. SO GOOD!! Their vodka sauce is addictive. Also their house dressing is amazing. Go.To.Angela's.Now. They are making parking in front of the restaurant! Its easy! What are you waiting for?

doesnt matter how good your food is if your customer service sucks!!!!!! not willing to make right…read morewhat they screwed up on an order... the statement was" what do you want ne to do" we are a bug department from a large organization who order frequently ... unfortunately tjis was our first and last time !!!!!

There's enough food for everyone!! When I feel picky of what…read moreI want to eat, I come here and I find out what I want. The food is exactly how you think it would taste.

Best pizzeria on long island in my opinion. Made fresh every time, family owned, quick and great…read morefood in a cozy, pizzeria type of vibe, the food is always wonderful. Service is always phenomenal. "Smiley"

We were able to get a table for 2 on a Friday evening without issue. The drinks were good and…read morestrong. Not pictured is the bread starter and oil which was delicious. Portions are biggg The Sicilian calamari was delicious but my friend didn't know it had a kick to it and she was dying lol. Pasta/entres delicious! Pasta well made. The meat savory. I took most of it home bc I was full from the bread and calamari. Lovely experience and great food.

My wife and I went here on Sat night. Got a table, no problem. The ambience of this establishment…read moreis excellent; with a part of the restaurant semi opened to the street. It's open , airy and gives you a nice feeling. Our server, Zach, was excellent. The drinks were good as well as the food. I had their signature dish, upon the waiters suggestion, the double cut pork chop. It was cooked to perfection, tasty and more importantly, definitely not dry. And did I mention, very large!! My wife had a rigatoni dish, and it was solid as well. If you're looking for a cool date night spot, with great ambience and good food, I would recommend this establishment.

First off, place is very clean and the way the pizza is presented makes you want to order more…read more I had the meatball parm and Genovese slice. Both slices were fresh and tasty with subtle flavors. Very satisfied. Service was also friendly and quick. Will go back.

Eat in with table service, order for pickup, order delivery or look and decide when you get there…read more This place is hopping, busy in a good way. They have 2 ladies just taking phone orders. Lots of regulars know by first names. Food is top quality, portions are great. Plenty of creative slices. Eat here and you'll be happy!

Always great! Whether you stop by for crispy delicious pizza for lunch or come in and sit for…read moredinner, you will be treated like family. The food is fantastic, fresh pasta options often and always homemade cannoli. This is a family owned and operated business since 1977! Truly wonderful people.

Small Italian restaurant in the back and pizza on the front! Food is always amazing! Please try the…read moregrandma's slice...