Attention, Vegetarians: if you're dining at The Toasted Pickle, then do yourself a favor and order the as-seen-on-TV Green Goddess. From here on out, I'll only eat grilled cheese with goat cheese, avocado, and sweet pesto. They're fantastic additions! If you do a full sammie, expect a generous portion. In the future, I may do a half sammie or split it, especially since I know I'll want to pair a cup of tomato soup with it (it comes with a shooter of tomato soup, but I prefer the upgrade). And those beer battered fries? Worth it. Based on this visit, I'll be back and bring loved ones when they visit. read more

Why a cute spot downtown Grand Haven to grab a sandwich, soup or a salad. One thing good to know is that they have online ordering! I ordered a pickup the night before and it was ready to go the next day when I said I would be there to grab it! So easy to do if you have a limited time to grab something to eat during the work hours! I had ordered the Green Goddess sandwich and it was delicious! It even comes with a shot of tomato soup! Parking is a bit of a pain because you have to look for it on the street, so I'm guessing in the summer months that could be a challenge. Even with that inconvenience though, the service was great, food was great, and the atmosphere inviting. Check it out! read more

On the main street in downtown Grand Haven, a very good sandwich shop. Used the walk up window and ate outside with the lovely weather. Really good sandwiches, fresh and flavorful. Great lunch spot to visit read more

Get the pickle poppers! They're so good! Worth the wait! I wish I would have tried the lemonade

Came by as I was in town for the weekend and all I can say is AMAZING!!! Got a BBQ Sandwich w/ sweet and spicy pickles, beer battered fries, pickle poppers, and (another sandwich I can't remember). It was all INCREDIBLE!!!! (Almost makes me want to move to Grand Haven alone...) Took about 45 minutes, but got to walk around the local shops and just had an amazing time. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! read more

The Toasted Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Haven, Michigan

Love that they deliver to Odd Side - such a clever idea. We get the Toasted Pickle every time we go to Grand Haven. The sandwiches are really well put together, many a bit unique, and the fries are fantastic. I always look forward to it. This time I got the Italian Bomber and my wife got the High Nooner. Both were delicious. Would get either again. read more

Some of the tastiest food ever enjoyed! The green goddess dressing on the salad is craveable - in fact I wish they sold it in a bottle so I could have it at home. The pickle poppers and sauce are perfection! The portions are quite generous. If seating is full inside they will close the inside and you order at a window from the sidewalk. There are tables to sit at outside along the street as well. Inside there is an open view into the kitchen where you can see the staff hustling to get the food out. I would drive 2 1/2 hours all over again to enjoy this restaurant! read more

See all

Easiest review ever. The Black Jack was one of the best sandwiches I've ever had the joy of eating. No clue about people, said maybe three words to them. Ordered online, picked up at window after got text/name called out. Indoor seating was closed off so no clue about the ambiance. Yes, go here. Order online like 10-15mins before you'll actually be there. Thank me later. read more

The Toasted Pickle - Full BlackJack - best sandwich ever... prove me otherwise! - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Haven, Michigan

See all

We came to Grand Haven for a wedding. Before the celebration we walked around downtown and decided to eat an early lunch at The Toasted Pickle. To start, there is a walk up window or you can go inside. There are outside sets if you want to go outside. We started inside and moved out. They are okay with it, but ask that you bring the tray back when you are finished. I ordered the Cuban, my son ordered the Bacon Jam Burger, my daughter had the hot dog and Mac and cheese, my wife ordered the BLT(fried green tomatoes and peppered candied bacon!). We also got beer battered fries to share. The staff were friendly, the food was awesome, the environment both in and outside was fun. Totally suggest going here! read more

See all

We came here after a day at the beach. The inside dining area was full but they had the outside window open for ordering. There was a small line but it moved very quickly. We ordered The Italian Bomber, Half Sixie From Dixie, and Kids Mac and Cheese. And of course a large fry to share. They texted us when order was ready. It took about 30 minutes or so. We strolled into some shops along the street while we waited. Overall, our food was pretty good. My sandwich was huge and I forgot how much I used to love fried bologna. I think their fries are pretty amazing and probably the best thing we ate. They had a little bit of outdoor seating. We chose to sit out there but at that time of day, the sun was blazing right on top of us. I will say that halfway through our wait time, I noticed that there was seating available inside. We asked if we could eat our food inside once it was ready. The person at the window seemed confused and said she didn't know. And then they never told us if we could or not. The place seemed pretty popular! I think we will definitely come back, the next time we are at the beach. But I would love to sit inside next time! Very laid back atmosphere with good food! read more

The Toasted Pickle - Italian Bomber - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Haven, Michigan

See all

Great sandwiches with a casual vibe. It'd be nice if they came with fries or chips though.

We saw the memorial plaques, and heard people talk about this place. Well we ordered the pickle poppers. They were like pickle wedges in an egg roll wrap. Excellent!!! read more

See all

As always the food from The Toasted Pickle is amazing. Hubby got the Sixie from Dixie and I got the Nashville Hottie and both were so good! We didn't have to wait a super long time and we even got a sunset dinner out on their patio. I do wish they had umbrellas for their tables outside during the day because the sun can be brutal. 10/10 would recommend! read more

See all

Great food kinda pricey takes a little while to make food but worth it for this gem of a restaurant

For such a small spot, they were really cool! When I went, I just ordered to go from their sidewalk-facing window. I wasn't in a rush so the 45 minute wait didn't bother me. I got to walk around the surrounding shops until I was alerted that my food was ready. It was expensive, but very good. This is definitely a place I would go if I wanted to treat myself. With my sandwich and side order, it came to like $25. They did have really cute outdoor seating that I would like to use next time too! Despite the name, there are plenty of options for those that don't like pickles either! Their menu is well thought out. Anywhere on the main strip in Grand Haven is going to be a walking distance from your parking spot, so just be prepared for that. There is a lot of free public parking in the area, you might just have to drive around to find a spot. read more

The Toasted Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Haven, Michigan

We got there right when they opened and within minutes a lined formed and the inside was packed. It was delicious and is a staple for every grand haven trip! read more

The Toasted Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Haven, Michigan

See all

Love this place for lunch! So many different and delicious options along with the old standby - grilled cheese & tomato soup! The fried pickles are the best! read more

Food was amazing with a good selection of sandwiches to choose from. Located in a great spot of downtown Grand Haven. Casual spot to go grab a quick lunch. read more

The Toasted Pickle - Green Goddess grilled cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Haven, Michigan

Hands down the best burger I've had in my life! Do yourself a favor and get the bacon jam burger with toasted pickle side. read more

The Toasted Pickle - Best burger ever! - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Haven, Michigan

Some of the best sandwiches I've had. Super good location and quick service with a good downtown area to walk around while you get your food. Got the crusty Cuban and it was very good. Highly recommend read more

Situated in downtown Down Haven, is The Toasted Pickle. A very quaint yet busy sandwich shop that adds a pickle twist to most dishes. They have pickle poppers, pickle sauces or you can just order a giant pickle as a side. The inside is busy and pretty tight quarters. They have massive tables meaning they only have space for a few and there is pretty much space for a line to stand to the left of them, and that's it. We decided to check them out because they had pretty good reviews here on Yelp. I ordered the chopped salad (sub blue cheese for cheddar) in a half size, which was more food than I could eat for lunch. So, portions were hearty. The food all seemed fresh and delicious and I would definitely wander back in! I'm glad we tried this place! Service wasn't needed much other than taking our initial order but every interaction with the staff you could feel (or see from afar) their negativity. I could tell the lady up front was really not enjoying her job. She kinda grumped at us when we misunderstood and thought there was a pickup window for our order in the other side of the counter (you go to the cash register to pick up your food). I'll give the benefit of the doubt and say the lady up front was just having a bad day and not blame the restaurant as a whole on this, so I'm only taking away 1 star. read more

See all

My family and I visited in mid July. The to-go window was open where most people were placing their orders. The restaurant had a sign up in the front that said the dining room was closed, but there was a couple waiting in the front so we talked to them and they said they talked to an employee who said she was cleaning off some tables for them despite the sign being up. My family and I waited and we were seated in the front inside. I don't think any other people were seated while we were there even though there were open tables. Restaurant's choice I guess. We were able to place our order inside and our orders took anywhere from 20 to 50 minutes to come out. When food arrived, it was good. I had the fries and the fried chicken BLT. Vanilla milkshake was delicious. read more

The Toasted Pickle - Fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Haven, Michigan

See all

The food is great but the customer service leaves little to be desired. They do their best to deter eating indoors. The restaurant is chained off and is supposedly first come first serve. They do not take your name so customers are left with deciding who is next. This is very confusing at best. Couple this with the fact that one of us is handicapped. This is really just a "to go" place. If you're coming to grand haven to have a sit down meal plan on going someplace else. read more

The sandwiches were amazing. So flavorful and big portions. The service was friendly and quick. It was a great place to eat.

This is a cute little sandwich shop downtown grand haven. We had to park in the street a few blocks away but it was free. We were seated inside (place your order at the window and then they bring it to you). There are only a few tables and it looks like many people take their food to go. The sandwiches were very good, we got the sixie from Dixie (turkey, bacon, tomato, lettuce and mayo on sourdough) and the monte cristo (French toast bread with ham, turkey and Swiss cheese- comes with a raspberry dipping sauce). I wish the description had the powdered sugar because I would have asked to remove it. They told us that our sandwiches would be out in 20, but they came in 10, even though they were super busy. Good service! read more

The Toasted Pickle - Monte cristo Sixie from Dixie - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Haven, Michigan

Amazing food!! The grilled cheese sandwich with tomato soup pesto and avocado is fantastic! I hate tomato soup. But I'll tell you this was so good. Lemonade is definitely fresh and tart. Won't disappoint. We went back the same day again it was so good!!! read more

See all

My husband and I split the Italian Bomber and snitched some of the handmade fries from our grandkids. Our sandwich was filling and flavourful, the fries were outstanding. I was part of a group order, I did not do the pickup for take out or ordering so I cannot review that part of our experience. read more

A trip to Grand Haven wouldn't be complete without stopping by The Toasted Pickle for sandwiches. We've ordered a variety of sandwiches and enjoyed them all, but one of our favorites is the Tipsy Texan. The interior is pretty cramped, but the Pickle navigates that with a street-side order window that always has a line, with some additional seating on the sidewalk. Make sure to come on a nice day, because you'll probably be eating outside --or you can take your order to go. It's a great way to break up your day in Grand Haven! read more

The Toasted Pickle - Half Story & Clark - used to be Full, but I already ate one half before I remembered to take a picture. - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Haven, Michigan

See all

The establishment was clean, well lit and smelled good. The seating was Intimate and wrapped around the room. Service was friendly and fast. Took 5 minutes to whip up my order. The food was hot. I thought the breading/egg roll on the pickle was thick but still very tasty for $6.00. if you are a fan of pickles this is your place! read more

See all

We ordered from the pickup window, and the food was so good I forgot to take a picture of it! The Nashville Hottie sandwich and kettle chips with pimento dip is 10/10. Their lemonade is great too! read more

I got hungry while hanging out at Odd Side Ales' outdoor space over the summer and The Toasted Pickle was just across the street. The online ordering indicated you can tell them your table number at Odd Side and they'd deliver it right to you, but the picnic table we were sitting at outside didn't have a table number. I opted to just order it for pickup, since it was literally 500 yards away. Nate and I ordered the Italian bomber and a side of beer battered fries to split. The online ordering said it would be about 20-24 minutes, and I got a text when my order was done. I walked right up to the pickup window and got our bag of food. Everything was hot and fresh and the sandwich was huge! The romaine lettuce on the sandwich kind of overtook everything but it was also loaded with meat, cheese, and spicy giardiniera. I wish they had cut it in half for us, but we made it work. It was incredibly messy but so delicious! I'm a sucker for a good Italian sandwich, and this was a great one. All the ingredients were fresh including the veggies, and it was pretty stacked for $10. The beer battered fries were amazing! I love this style of fry and theirs were excellent, with a crisp exterior but fluffy inside. They were a bit too salty but the big sea salt flakes wiped off easily so we could enjoy most of the bag. It was a big portion even though I ordered the "regular" and not "share" size - maybe I actually received the share size. Either way, I wouldn't hesitate to get these again. I'm so glad we tried the Toasted Pickle and will make it a regular stop when we're in Grand Haven! read more

The Toasted Pickle - Italian Bomber - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Haven, Michigan

See all

Took an hour to get a sandwich and when asked nicely after 50min how much longer they said snarky did you get a text yet instead of going to check on my sandwich. Overpriced sandwich too. read more

Good decision to go here! Very small but definitely worth it. I had the green goddess grilled cheese. Now I don't like pesto but this sandwich was amazing!! Would go there just to get that sandwich!! Service was fast. Food was all good read more

See all

We decided to come here for lunch and we really enjoyed it! The service took a while but they were very crowded so not too bad. I loved the inside, it was so fun. The food was so good. The truffle fries were seriously the best. I also loved the grilled cheese! Would come back! read more

The Toasted Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Grand Haven, Michigan

We decided to try " The Toasted Pickle" because it looks sooo good! When we arrived, we had to wait a bit since it is a smaller place. They had plenty of selections. It was around lunch time. We ordered the "Full Italian Bomber", along side of Kettle Chips. I think the Kettle Chips were homemade. They were crispy, salty and so good! The sandwich had that signature Italian flavor to it. it was super good! The pickles were great! Everything was really good! read more

See all

Food was good lemonade was fantastic expensive great service nice little building Right downtown you can smell it from a mile away read more

The food is delicious. You can't go wrong with anything on the menu. Everyone is nice and no matter how late you may order they always make you feel they appreciate your business. read more

We were looking forward to trying The Toasted Pickle while visiting but overall it was a let down. The pickles in wontons We're overly chewy. The Monte Cristo was so bland and definitely not sweet and savory. The raspberry sauce just tasted like tart blended raspberries. Forget ordering a kids meal. $5.95 for a single hotdog with no toppings or sides. Such a waste of money. The reason they get two stars is the beer battered fries. Thankfully those saved our meal. I'm glad we ordered the sharable size. read more

I was in GH visiting and decided to stop by per recommendation! I got the Sixie from Dixie which is a turkey, bacon and cheese with mayonnaise on sourdough. It was honestly one the best turkey sandwich I've ever had. So fresh, tasty and everything was just cooked perfection. The fries are insanely good. The service was friendly and fast. Waited maybe 5 minutes and the place was busy with all the coast guard group ordering and eating. Overall a great experience and if or when I'm ever back, I'll for sure to be stopping by read more

Incredible tomato soup. Good tasty sandwiches. Friendly service Has been very consistent over the years read more