We've lived a block or two from here for the past 4 years and we tried them for the first time today. We called for pickup and ordered a meatball parm sub and a BLT Steak and Cheese sub. The food was absolutely delicious! The meatball sub didn't need extra sauce or anything. My significant other kept raving about his sub as well. They're both big enough to eat half now and the other half another time (or later with a good show/movie). The man we spoke to on the phone was very nice and proficient with our order. We've driven by so many times and wondered about this place. It looks small and quaint inside. We'll be sure to try more food soon and let our friends and family know about this place as well! read more

The chicken wasn't crunchy and it wasn't the dry rub lemon pepper I'm use too. The lemon pepper wings are nothing like the bbq ones. They was crunchy and flavorful but the lemon pepper wings are nothing to brag about. I requested well done and they wasn't so that explains the serving. It's a take out place small and the ambiance is what it is. I have a basic simple review of this place. read more

See all

I came by just before closing to pick up some chicken tenders and pizza. This was only my second time here, but Tomato City came highly recommended by my friends who live in the neighborhood. When placing my order, the young man working the counter had a hard time ringing up my order. It took the owner as long to figure out how to run my credit card as it did to make my food. I think there was something wrong with their system, but they didn't actually tell me what was happening, they only apologized for the wait. They prepared my food and packed it to go. Since it was the end of the night, they gave me the slices they had on the counter as a bonus, which was really nice. Their tenders are more like chicken cutlets and they were very saucy (which is my preference) I couldn't decided between blue cheese and ranch, so I paid extra so I could get one of each. The pizza was thick and sort of greasy but it tasted good. The cheese blend is different that other pizza places and the sauce has a real tomato-y bite. While it's not making my top 5 list anytime soon, I wasn't mad at any part of the food. The building is an odd shape because it sits on the corner of a triangular shaped block. There is no seating inside, so food must be taken to go. read more

See all

Pizza is delicious hard-working employees been coming here for 25 years from the old owners to the new owners never disappointed, love the fact that they never changed the sauce recipe read more

Doughy, cheesy, chewy pizza. If you like this kind you'll enjoy it. I love all pizza and don't discriminate. I really like their pepperoni but hear good things about the buffalo chicken so I'll need to make another trip to try. The place is an odd shape with no seating so plan to take food to go. I saw a sign that said coco flan so I'll definitely be back for that soon! Staff is very nice and portions are large. read more

Ok, at this rate with the amount of times I've ordered here through slice I can give an accurate review. Tomato City has the BEST cheese pizza I've ever had. I have search high and low, finally found the holy grail. I also really enjoy their cheese steak sandwich and bakery style pizza. I am NOT a fan of most of their appetizers they don't seem to travel well. By the time they get to my house they're soggy. The tenders have great flavor but also are soggy, which comes with the territory when ordering flavor dipped tenders. Can you guess the common theme... the calzones are also soggy. So after a few trials and errors I have found what I can and can not order here but when it's good...it's dang good. read more

Even after sitting in our corporate kitchen for a few minutes after delivery, this pizza was terrific!!Tasty, buttery, chewy crust, but not too thick! Plenty of cheese and toppings, and a very fresh, balanced sauce. Highly recommend! read more

I ordered deep-dish pizza with pepperoni and sausage for my aunt in North Providence. They delivered pepperoni and something else and refused to change the order. I am very disappointed in them. They would not even return her money. She did not even touch the pizza. read more

A month ago I would have given three stars, but I ordered again and was much more pleased with my meal. This past time I got a pepperoni pizza. I think technically it said it was with extra cheese and pepperoni (some of these delivery apps suck man - I find sometimes there is the option for a cheese pizza but then you can't add toppings and there isn't just a pepperoni pizza?!?!) So yeah, I got the one that was just pepperoni and cheese on the app i was using. I also was feeling indecisive so I ordered some buffaque wings. Both were excellent! Way better than the last time I ordered from them. Now I see on slice where to add toppings. Oh well. The pizza has a great sauce, it's not thin and its generously applied. The one I got didn't seem to have extra pepperoni on it, but I wasn't originally looking for that so I was happy with what I got. A medium was great for dinner, a slice for breakfast, and then lunch the next day. What can I say, it's winter during a pandemic and I had a weekend to myself with snow in the forecast - Pizza became three meals, The wings were also excellent - a great mix of barbecue and buffalo. Not too sweet, not too hot. I had remembered loving them from when my sister used to live in NP and they had a different owner. When I tried them in the fall they were okkkkk but not as I remembered. This time lived up to my expectations and I will definitely order again. read more

Pizza is pretty good but the attitudes are horrendous! One star is one too many. The girl enjoys being nasty to customers and over charging. Won't be ordering anything again and advise anyone to go elsewhere. read more

Living in North Providence- this is my go-to pizza place. The wings are also incredible- always fresh and hefty- certainly not sad frozen chicken! The cotton candy sauce is my favorite. Also my favorite Buffalo chicken pizza in town, and the bakery pizza options are also delicious, especially with the old school Italian sauce. read more

Tomato City Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

Pepperoni pizza is amazing!! Greek salad is gross. +Pepperoni Pizza. They have pizza by the slice, so good. read more

Tomato City Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

All my life I've ordered from here, but the last few times have been less than impressed. Ordering a simple small cheese pizza and waiting well over an hour to get a cold pizza where the cheese isn't even soft and gooey. Guess I'll be looking for a new and better place. There's a spot this literally behind this place called PVD pizza, guess I'll be trying there. What's the point of this post, save your money go elsewhere. This place isn't what it used to be. I don't know if management changed but everything is a little to relax and waiting well over an hour for a small cheese pizza and then it arriving and being less than desirable to eat is overall disappointing! read more

Tomato City Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

Order through doordash and it arrives much faster than promised.... Pizza is very heavy my husband is a fan... nice change from the other local pizza shop that closes at 5 and the other one that has seen the quality go way down hill read more

I just got a large cheese and pepperoni pizza delivered. It was just gross. It had WAY too much cheese on it and the cheese had slid off. FIRST TIME in my life I ever ate barely a few slices of a large pizza then threw the rest away. I am not a picky eater and do not like to complain about local restaurants. But when someone insults you like this, and rips you off with garbage, they deserve the truth to be told... Now I have to cook something anyway... read more

Yum yum yum! I got an XL pizza with half pepperoni supreme and half spicy bbq chicken delivered over the weekend and it was SO GOOD. Timely delivery, friendly driver, order was as expected, and the topping ratio was on point. Will be ordering again soon! read more

Tomato City Pizza - Half Pepperoni Supreme, half Spicy BBQ Chicken XL pizza - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

My fav place to get party pizza! I love that it's warm, crunchy crust and they add some Parmesan! They other toppings i have tried were great too but my fav is def the party pizza! read more

OMG - they have the BEST steak bomb I've ever had in my life - a must have and they also have the BEST cheese/pepperoni spinach pies as well!!! Updated review - the steak bomb is a hit of miss - depends on who is cooking. The last few times it was a definite miss so much that I refuse to order steak bombs anymore... One time my spinach pie wasn't completely cooked all the way - I called to complain and was given a credit for the next time which they did honor and this time the spinach pie was back to perfection!!!! read more

Tomato City Pizza - Small cheese, pepperoni and spinach calzone!!!! Yummy!!! - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

I've had their wings before and they were very good. This time I went with a simple cheese pizza and Caesar salad. Delivery was very fast and accurate. Their Caesar is different then the traditional but it as very good and fresh. The portion was awesome. It fed 3 people :) read more

Great pizza,excellent salads and fast delivery. The price for all menu items are well worth it. I always order delivery from Tomato City and my wife and I are never disappointed. read more

Food was not hot when it arrived. Now I can chalk it up to the driver but asked for The Garbage Pizza (Large) and 10 Piece wings to be well done and crisp but both were soggy. Sauce on the wings was nothing special and fries were ehh. Went be trying again for a while. read more

Good pizza delivered quickly Pepperoni pizza was delicious and fresh out the oven. Have gotten food from here before and it has always been consistently good read more

Always good, always fresh ingredients. Love the take out. This is the garbage pizza with banana peppers. We were so hungry so don't mind the half pizza. read more

Tomato City Pizza - Garbage pizza with banana peppers. - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

I ordered from them on Grubhub, and there was some sort of digital confusion which resulted in it taking literally two hours for the pizza to arrive. They called me though to let me know about this, and I really truly think it was Grubhub mis-specifying their delivery times and zone. The pizza was fantastic. Some of the best I've had in Providence. If my next order is here in less than an hour, I'll amend this to 5 stars. read more

As a native NYC pizza lover - I'm must say Tomato City has some really decent pizza. I usually have to tell the pizza maker "well done". But not at Tomato City - their crust is well done, thin and crispy. Their sauce is generously sweet and toppings are well applied. Their pizza is somewhat greasy - but hey that's what a napkin is for. Their dining area is not impressive - it's actually un-inviting. If you make a decision based on this - you'd walk out. But back to the pizza - it's simply a piece of delightful, greasy work of art that will bring joy to your taste buds. Oh and their garlic knots - be sure to add an order of those. They do deliver, this is a good idea since their dining area is...(read above). Tomato City is not New York City - but they are a delicious 2nd. read more

Just plain awful! Too thick and swam in sauce. Used to be much better back in the day.

Not great. I felt the pizza was under cooked and the cheese was oily. Not worth the money.

Delicious, had never had it before and my coworkers thought I was crazy because of it. Lol Regualar pizza is so good, cheese is thick and crunchy crust just how I like it. but the bakery style pizza is delicioussssss, it is like regular bakery sauce pizza strips but hot with Parmesan cheese sprinkled on top, like nothing I've ever had. If you get anything do yourself a favor and get the bakery style red sauce pizza read more

I ordered delivery and was very surprised at how good the pizza is. I live very close to this location, so it's good to know I have a convenient pizza joint that serves decent pies. The pricing is slightly higher than others, but from time to time, it's worth it for the convenience. The menu is huge and has some pretty creative specialty pizzas, which is cool. I ordered the Italian Classic #3, which has meatball and ricotta. Super tasty -- I didn't even have to ask for a well done crust like I normally do. It was nice and crunchy the way I like it (not dark, just perfect). The guy answering the phone when I ordered was a bit confused and distracted on the phone, especially with my simple order. He took my address down incorrectly, but luckily took the right phone number, since the driver had to call to ask for my address. Overall positive experience. Looking forward to try their wings. read more

Tomato City Pizza - Italian classic number three: meatball and ricotta. Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

So, i ordered a large house special. The box was heavy. I opened the box, the pizza looked great. I cut into the pizza. What i found, raw dough.. i don't think over all the pizza wasn't so bad. Definitely needs some tweeking. Like garlic is a must. Pizza should be cooked all the way though. Would have to be very hungry to order this again. I should not have to go home and cook the pizza and season it. read more

Yummy! Just ordered from Tomato City Pizza after seeing a commercial for a slice app on television, all about supporting local businesses. decided to try it's in my neighborhood Pizza arrived on time fresh hot and delicious some of the best pizza I've had in Providence so glad I found this place Domino's who? .. From the crust to the sauce! read more

I am so happy I have discovered this amazing bakery pizza. It is absolutely delicious. It has the perfect crispness with a perfect sauce. It is definitely top 5 bakery pizzas now. We gave our credit card info over the phone and they brought it out to the car. The eggplant calzone was also yummy. We will definitely be ordering from here often. read more

Came upon Tomato City while searching for lunch at work. If you are from around here you are well aquainted with the pizza strips sold in the local bakeries. A rectangular strip of dough with only red sauce no cheese. As a quick bite on the run it does the job. Well Tomato City has a whole round or rectangular pie that captures the flavor of these bakery strips perfectly. I went with a large round "bakery" pizza some wings and a salad. The pizza was delicious hot and fresh with some grated parmesan sprinkled on top. wow. love it. the Garlic butter wings were cooked spot on and very garlicky. The salad was a salad but it was a good one. TC is now a go to for me read more

If you're looking for good buffalo chicken and garlic knots, this is not the place. The chicken wasn't even completely covered in buffalo sauce, and the pieces were rather small and thin... and just not even that good. I selected the "hot" option, and they were not spicy AT ALL. They weren't "crispy" like the menu claims. The "garlic knots" were not actually the typical knots you would expect... they're just burnt rolls with cheese inside, that drip grease when you bite them. read more

Tomato City Pizza - Cheesy Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

See all

I've had both the chicken wings and the plain pizza. Being the first time ordering, I have done nothing but rave about my food. I won't hesitate to order again read more

Took an hour to receive my order for an Italian sub. They are 3 streets over from me. My sub, was toasted. Wtf toasts an Italian sub? And adds peperoni?????? You toasted an Italian sub. I asked for Mayo. You know what happens to Mayonaise when its heated??????? Smh. read more

Bakery style was burnt black. Should never have left the door. Not interested in ordering from here again.

I ordered a margarita pizza. Typically you would expect pieces of mozzarella cheese with fresh basil and fresh slices of tomato. I got a regular cheese pizza with circles of tomato sauce and sprinkles of dried basil. It was like they didn't have what I ordered and got creative. Kind of laughable. But maybe that's how they do it here? Despite it not being what I wanted it was still a good cheese pizza. And the cheese garlic knots were amazing. read more

I wish I could give this restaurant 0 stars! I ordered mozzarella sticks and chili Thai wings. These are the mozzarella sticks I received. When I called back they sent out another batch of sticks that were cooked golden brown but they still didn't look right. I sent both orders back with the drivers and called them back for a refund just on the sticks. I was told I had to go through Grubhub. I was able to get a full refund plus the tip back through Grubhub! Something is real off with the food from here. read more

Tomato City Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Providence, Rhode Island

I ordered delivery of a large pepperoni, black olives with mushrooms, extra sauce cooked well done. Jocelyn who took my order was fantastic on taking my order and read it back to me correctly. The driver was on time and pleasant. However, the pizza wasn't anywhere near cooked well done! The pepperonis looked as though they weren't cooked at all. I will give them this though, they do not skimp on their toppings. Had they cooked my pizza well done I would have rated them much higher. Update: I called Tomato City Pizza and spoke with Nick, one of the owners. I explained what had happened with my order. Without me asking Nick said, your next pizza is free on us! Great customer service! I've bumped them from 2 stars to 3 stars and will update again once I have my next pizza from Tomato City Pizza. Update: Tomato City Pizza came through with a delicious cooked to perfection pizza just as I had ordered! read more