OMG how have I NEVER tried this place before? Met up with old coworkers here - where a friend was raving about their Stromboli. It's AMAZING. In fact I'm craving it ALL the time. There's something about the ratio of meats and cheese, perfectly baked dough and that SAUCE!!! The cheese was oozing out and I loved that they didn't overstuff with too much meat!! Perfect ratio!! I usually don't eat a lot at lunch but I DEMOLISHED it and had to order another to bring home to hubby to try. I ended up sneaking a sliver/slice off his cause it's SO mouthwatering delicious. Tony's is a small place but you can tell they definitely have their regulars and mostly everyone ordered the Stromboli. Eating it there - definitely having it doused with that delicious sauce - but the one I brought home - I had sauce on the side and that was PERFECTION... It's a bit of a drive for me but a drive I'm willing to do for their Stromboli. Will definitely have to try their meatballs too next time!! read more

Tony Di Maggio’s Pizza - Partially eaten Stromboli! YUM!! - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

This local pizzeria has delicious stromboli and amazing service! We ordered a large stromboli and one ravioli meat. The stromboli had tasty layers of cheese and meat, covered in tomato sauce. The ravioli was also covered in a generous amount of tomato sauce! The stromboli was the highlight of our dinner! The staff were very welcoming and helpful! It's a brightly lit family run business! read more

See all

Such a great place to eat, small and cozy, friendly service and staff. The food was flavorful, highly recommend the cheese ravioli! read more

Tony Di Maggio’s Pizza - Large pepperoni and olive pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

Mmmmmmmmm, still eating my slice of 1/2 veggie 1/2 cheese pizza. It was absolutely delicious. The spaghetti was great too. I can't wait for the boys to get home from a hard day of work to eat the rest of their pizza. Thank you Tony! Can't wait to try my tiramisu. read more

Tony Di Maggio’s Pizza - 1/2 veggie1/2 cheese added pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

See all

Tried Tony Di Maggio's for the first time. Food On the table, there are small condiment jars of red pepper and parmesan cheese. When I asked for a side of ranch, I was told it was an extra $2.00. The menu didn't list any prices, which made ordering a bit awkward since we weren't sure what the total cost would be. Medium Combination Pizza The combo pizza had a nice balance of toppings with a perfectly crisp crust, sliced mushrooms, green bell peppers, and cheese. Large 14" Stromboli The Stromboli was huge, served on a pizza pan, and pizza spatula that is stuffed with ham, cheese, and topped with marinara sauce. Everything came out hot and fresh. Surprisingly, between the two, the combination pizza had more seasoning and flavor. Customer Service I tried to flag down an employee to ask for napkins and he completely ignored me - terrible customer service. However, he was mingling with another table. When he saw a $10 tip was left on the table after my dining experience, he quickly rushed over to greet me goodbye and grab the tip. Please coach and train your staff to provide better service. Took off an additional star because of this experience. Ambiance Old-fashioned pizza spot filled with photos and memorabilia honoring the owners and local sports teams. There are 4-6 seat table tops inside and a few baby high chairs. The only downside while dining in, there were occasional gusts of cigarette smoke that made the experience unpleasant. Location Located in the El Rancho Center strip plaza with Kent's Hair & Nails, A&L Spa, and Planet Vape. read more

See all

Loyal customer for over 20 years. The Stromboli is still the same yummy delicious quality. Glad the family business is going strong!

Stromboli is the best around and if you like cheese don't forget to add it on your garlic bread read more

Tony Di Maggio’s Pizza - Some true comfort food, always come by to get a real Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

An absolute favorite for my hubs. Cheese, meat, and mustard all folded into a little Stromboli made with love! (Mustard, I know! But don't knock it until you try it!) We used to order one after catching a movie at the drive in-makes for a perfect family night out or date night! The owners are amazing and very kind! Parking available and lots of seating indoors. Give This place a try! read more

Yes, they reopened! I love their stromboli, offered in both medium and large sizes. Pictured is the medium. I also like their pizza and pasta. read more

Tony Di Maggio’s Pizza - Medium stromboli with parmesan cheese and red pepper flakes sprinkled on. - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

See all

Holey moley GET THE STROMBOLI!!!! Order a large and save the rest for later. lol Great mom and pop shop. Stromboli was delicious and made with quality. Thank you! read more

Sorry. I know they were out of commission for a year but we tried this old favorite years later. It was not memorable. I wanted to like it. Trust me. It's a cashier service meaning you order at the front and they bring it to you. The red flag was no hard menus just a board with no prices. I didn't want to ruin the moment so a small individual Stromboli (they are known for it) and large two topping. 45 + 10 tip (hey no waiters here...) so $55. See pics. Both tomato sauces were light not rich and robust of before. The crusts on both were really good but the sausage - I mean store bought and cut Jimmy Dean. Shame on yall. The cheese melted weird and it was just an average pie at best. Stromboli was eh. Homemade ham and cheese hot pocket. Hate to beat up a local favorite but had to call them out. The manager/owner was cool but didn't seem to want to be there. Wanted to like this place but moving on.... read more

See all

THEIR FINALLY OPEN !! After 11 long months!! If you guys don't want disappointment come here THERE AMAZING !! My favorite place in San Jose MEATBALLS ARE JUST PERFECT !! Stamboli hands down the best ! San Jose's top food spots !! read more

Tony Di Maggio’s Pizza - BEST FOOD EVER!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

just wanted to get alfredo or buttered noodles for my kid and they didn't have either so I had to basically beg for them to give me plain noodles with olive oil since they said they didn't have butter. Service was meh the man serving us was not happy and seemed annoyed, we had to ask for silverware 2x and they didn't seem thrilled we asked for refills. One and done for me. Options are limited on the menu. read more

STRICT VEGETARIANS: read to the end. Excellent home-style restaurant that hits the spot! I'm usually a fan of deep-dish/pan, but the pizza here -- despite being close to NY style crust (which I usually dislike) -- was delicious: thanks to fresh veggie toppings, sweetish sauce and a stringy melted cheese in the right ratios. Each slice is so weighed down with toppings that you need to eat the bottom of each slice with a fork and knife first (difficult to carry without it falling apart!) - you can lift a slice only after finishing the bottom half. The rigatoni and garlic bread were delicious, but I did see some morsels of sausage in my sauce, despite having ordered fully vegetarian. Maybe the pan they prepare it in wasn't fully clean. So, strict vegetarians - beware! Docking two stars for this. Service was speedy and with a smile. What a joy to see the legendary grandma out in the kitchen too :-) I'd definitely come again, but advise the owners to ensure they start with a fresh pan on vegetarian orders of pasta - or they risk losing customers. Meat cross-contamination, in this day and age, isn't very common at restaurants in this category - so this was disappointing. Otherwise, this would've been a 5-star visit. read more

Tony Di Maggio’s Pizza - Rigatoni dinner - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

See all

Delicious pizza, lasagna, and stromboli with great service. The pizza dough was a 10/10, and my kids couldn't get enough

Tony's is an awesome pizza joint, love their sauce. Cheese bread and pasta is good too, you should give it a shot if you haven't done so yet. read more

Service was quick, pricing was ok, the ambience is mellow but it has an authentic feel to the restaurant. Mid size dining room. I ordered garlic bread and Stromboli pricing came out to $21 which is fair. The garlic bread tastes of only garlic which makes sense lol ... but it could use some kind of herbs. The Stromboli itself was mid.. nothing that stood out flavorwise. read more

See all

Tony's is back! Reopened last Friday after being closed for almost a year after a fire. We couldn't make it out last Friday, but we picked up our pizza and Stromboli to go today. As usual great service and everything we loved about it is still there, down to the pictures on the walls. I missed the Stromboli, my favorite dish from Tony D's and I probably had more than I should have. The pizza, the sauce, everything is so good. Glad your back. No picture to share this time, since we pretty much fell on it and it disappeared. read more

It's back!! Love these guys. They're the only place I've found anywhere that makes this style of Stromboli. So glad to have you back! read more

Tony Di Maggio’s Pizza - Peroni beer - refreshing and pairs well with the flavorful Stromboli! - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

See all

Quality of food! The toppings were sparse. The pasta was over cooked. The sauce was awful & the meat was "spoiled". We all got sick.

The best Stromboli, I am so glad they reopened. I love the atmosphere in there, I wish they had more parking though.

Really enjoyed going back to Tony Di Maggio's. I decided to order stuffed shells with ricotta cheese, delicious except 3 noodles! I walked out hungry. So next time I'll order with a meatball and a Stromboli, that should do it. The garlic bread is outstanding. Will definitely return read more

The pizza is terrible hard crust nasty onions on pepperoni pizza food seems to have gotten worse than when tony was there the sauce tasted different and the food quality has declined don't like the graffiti on the side of restaurant extremely disappointed with this restaurant can't believe it still popular! read more

Service: cashier was awful. She was short and rude with her words. I asked if they could not add the ham to the "famous" Stromboli's that i was spending $80 for 3 on and she was annoyed by my question. It was written all over her face. Food: the Stromboli's they are made the night before(according to the rude cashier they are prepared previously so modifying is impossible)so you cannot add or subtract any ingredients. The Stromboli's have NO MEAT, too much cheese and mid at beast dough around all that cheese. If you don't consume the whole thing right away, you're left with a hard piece of cheese bread. Not how I remember when I was younger. SMH. read more

Quick services, food was amazing and plenty of room to sit. Love that it's family owned! read more

Tony Di Maggio’s Pizza - Stromboli is amazing! The red sauce is home made & tastes delicious! - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

I've been coming to Tony DiMaggio's for over 30 years, and the experience has been consistently exceptional. The food is outstanding every single visit,authentic, flavorful, and clearly made with pride. The service is truly unmatched; the family behind this establishment delivers a level of hospitality and care that you simply can't find anywhere else. The warm, welcoming ambience makes you feel right at home and perfectly captures the charm of this long-standing San Jose gem. Tony DiMaggio's is a rare place where tradition, quality, and genuine customer service come together flawlessly. Highly recommended for anyone looking for unforgettable food and a true neighborhood treasure. read more

The stromboli could have had some shrooms, olives and spinach to it. Not much on the inside. It was okay but I would get the smaller one next time. And don't get the salad if you don't want to pay $8 for a plate of iceberg. read more

Italian food at it's best!! You can't go wrong "The Best Italian Cuisine In San Jose"

Dah. freakin. heck. Ordered large stromboli for delivery. No sauce. Call them. I need to pick it up. wut? It's delivery for a reason, yo. San Jose native here and repeat customer. I can't believe I'm asking DiMaggio's to deliver their "awsome" stromboli with effing sauce??????? That I paid for. Wow. Cool. All good, yo................... Follow-up. I paid over $15 tip. That's jacked. read more

Best stombolis in town for over 30 yrs. Sicilian not Italian. Grandma's still making the sauce. This is an old school place not for the trendy more for the locals. read more

Haven't come here in a while. The workers here are nice and friendly. The first thing you do when you come in is order your food and pay then go seat down at a table or take out. The food here are delicious. Their Stromboli is very good and flavorful with a lot of red sauce on top. I love how they make their spaghetti. The spaghetti is perfect with their large meet balls. The meat balls cost extra though. The spaghetti plate is big and I took it home. They even give free garlic bread. The restaurant is kind of small with limited seating. Located of this restaurant is not the safest at night. read more

See all

Always get the Stromboli, it is great. Ordered the large meatball sandwich, worst attempt at a meatball I've ever seen ! $20 bucks it consisted of maybe three small meatballs of gray meat with a minuscule spatter of sauce on a roll. That's it, Dry AF ! No cheese or flavor. Unbelievable, the pic is only half the sandwich, fed the other half to the Dog. read more

Tony Di Maggio’s Pizza - Half of a Large Meatball sandwich - Pizza Near Me - San Jose, California

So happy to see them re-open after the fire. This place is a San Jose staple and the neighborhood and city just wouldn't be the same without them. The stromboli is my go to. Never disappoints and has always had plenty of meat in it. The old school vibe at Tony D's hasn't changed since I was a kid and that's what I love about the place. Great food, Great people and a great come back story. Highly recommended if you haven't tried it you should. read more

Why didn't I find this place sooner! I gave up on finding a good pizza in Nor Cal years ago as being from the East Coast can't find anything that can stack up to the best. Between the teenagers and myself we didn't leave a crumb. The crust, the sauce, the texture makes this my only pizza place going forward. One word of CAUTION, they put mustard in the Stromboli . That didn't fare well with any of us. It's such a shame you can't customize your order as the sections without mustard were indescribably perfect. Plenty of tables seating 4-6 comfortably inside read more

Ordered the infamous "Stromboli" (large) Didn't have any meat. Basically cheese bread? With a dipping sauce? Outrageous pricing for $25+ Stop skimping.. read more

If you live in the South Bay, and never been to Tony Di Maggio's Pizza, you are missing out! Tony's has been around for over 45 years, and as one of the staff members mentioned, their Nonna is still there making the Stromboli by hand! If there's one thing you come for it's the Stromboli, which comes in small and large sizes. A small is plenty for a regular appetite and large is great for sharing. I got a regular and it was under $11, which is a steal in todays world. I was in the area and on Yelp searching for something eat. I picked a place, got on Monterey Rd and realized Tony's was down the block, so I detoured and went to go get a Stromboli. The dough was crunchy, the cheese was oozing out, and it tasted like it was made with a lot of love. Stromboli is often imitated but this one is never duplicated. I've had Stromboli in other places, and this is the one I keep coming back to. #1 on my power rankings! They were doing some construction so I couldn't eat there. If you do come, eating there is the way to go. Because they'll serve the Stromboli topped with the marinara sauce and the way it's supposed to be eaten. Getting it to go, it's still good, but if you can EAT IT THERE read more

See all

Still closed due to a fire last month :-( hope they reopen soon!!! We love Tony D Maggio's.

We didn't try their famous stromboli, this review is only for the pizza. It was a good pizza, but it's def not NY pizza. We ordered the Tony's combo (small), dining room remains closed so we ate right outside the parking lot. The pizza was still piping hot, the toppings were descent and I have no complaint about the cheese. The pie was thin but the bottom was not crispy like La Bellezza, nor was it soft and doughy like Lil' Frankie's at East Village. There were no burnt blisters on the edges that typified an old fashion NY wood oven pizza. We also ordered a side of meatball, it was tender and the sauce was classic home made Italian delish. Overall the food here were descent albeit overpriced, $23 for small pizza and $5.25 for one single meatball. We have yet to discover a legit NY style pizza establishment in the Bay area. read more

See all

Closed temporarily due to a fire in July. Message left on answering machine. Hope they reopen soon.

College buddies and I used to come here in the 90's for Stromboli and beer. Glad to see DiMaggio's is still open and the Stromboli is as good as ever. Inflation is alive and well though. I got charged $12 for a pint of beer. The profit margin on beer and wine is pretty significant but $12 for a glass of beer in an old Italian restaurant with no table service is ridiculous. I took my son here for nostalgia but I'll think twice about ordering any drinks next time. read more