The pizza was burnt and you know not fresh! The day was extremely hot and the inside was like an oven. I should have gone with my instinct to leave. Gave the local place the opportunity for my business. Since it was so hot I asked for a cup of ice. I was charged $1.04 for a less than half a cup of ice. If I sat in the restaurant would the water be free? Warning ‼ with all the restaurants on graham- never ever again!! read more

Tony's Brooklyn Pizza - Is is $1.04 large cup where regularly it's $3 fountain soda? - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Tony's has the best pizza with a crispy slice and that sweet sauce and salty cheese. True Brooklyn slices served fresh and delicious. Specialty square slices are what dreams are made of. Get the Sicilian square slice if they haven't sold out of it. Get the spaghetti and meatballs if you want to live forever. read more

this is exactly the place you want to find when you're looking for a quick NYC slice. The place itself is small, but the slices are adequate and packed with flavor. The employees working behind the counter greet you with excitement, but are no nonsense as well. I stopped by for a slice during the World Cup on my way to an event. in that short time, one of the employees had to handle a rude customer and did it with grace. will certainly be back any time i'm in the neighborhood. read more

My fiancé and I were so pleased when we stumbled upon this goldmine of a pizzeria right before a show at Brooklyn Steele. I knew it was going to be an old school vibe the second I spotted the slush puppy machine and a pac man arcade game. Service was exceptionally sweet and helpful when I asked about vegan options! And I really think you should give these honest guys and gals a tip! I got the breadcrumb slice which was vegan and my fiancé got an upside down slice. Tony's is good Italian food for people of all ages and we can't wait to go back and get some pies. read more

Tony's Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

There might be a respectable $35 truffle pizza spot near you, with mood lighting and an acid house soundtrack, but why not try something a bit more old-timey? I won't even ask you to take the Staten Island Ferry or go out to 243rd St. in Queens. Tony's felt like a time machine back to 80's Queens, decades before the Times discovered Razza. The plain slice was the classic, juicy, "politician gets in a major scandal for preferring a knife and fork" type. The surface suggests that the tomato-cheese ratio might just be off by 3 or 4 percentage points but then you bite in and the perfect balance emerges. For that obscure pizza fanatic subculture most interested in crust, this may not be your favorite, but I liked the relatively thin presence as I'm more into the sauce and cheese than the dough. The grandma slice was a fine choice too, with a pleasant basil kick. read more

Tony's Brooklyn Pizza - Grandma Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Sometimes simple is best. Tonight our family shared fettuccine with meatballs and a 12" sausage pizzette. Both choices were excellent. Nothing fancy just comforting delicious food. read more

Tony's Brooklyn Pizza - Fettuccine with Meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Pizza is pretty good. Service is great. Friendly staff. CASH ONLY! Some of the best pizza in Williamsburg. Stop on in if in the neighborhood. You won't be disappointed! read more

See all

Went to Tony's for the first time today and OMG! The baked clams were absolutely delicious! We tried several different pizza slices and each one was better than the next. My ultimate favorite was the vodka pizza! It was so delicious that we ordered an extra pie to bring home! Everyone was so nice and attentive. We will definitely go back! read more

Tony's Brooklyn Pizza - We tried several different slices as well as a Sicilian pie. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The thing with pizza is that when it doesn't blow you away its still pretty good and this is the case with Tony's. I tried their fresh mozzarella slice and vodka grandma square. The crisp on the fresh mozzarella slice was a nice touch but I found that the slice had no flavor. Sauce was just ok. The vodka square was also kind of a let down as well. The vodka sauce was just ok and the dough on the grandma square had a buttery flavor which isn't something you typically find in NY slice. The people here seemed cool but I'd probably get a slice somewhere else next time. read more

Tony's Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I have lived here for over 45 years and have eaten at Tony's more than 1,000 times. Tonight was the last time. My son in law picked up food for us. My sausage and pepper role was a burnt black piece of bread covered in seeds. The cheese was sour to the point of separation and smelled terrible. Yet someone heated up this garbage and put it in my bag. Thanks for nothing. read more

One of my favorite pizzerias in Brooklyn. Buffalo slice is spot on and their hero's are great !!! Love Tony's !!!

Place is consistently great one of the only places that have a sfingione pie definitely try it & one of the best vodka slices around

Hands down best Sicilian pizza in the city...light crunchy airy.... So good I had to go back and bring 2 home ...

We ordered eggplant parm with spaghetti, chicken Marsala, Vodka sauce & a large pie. Everything was so delicious !! read more

Tony's Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is my new go to for delivery. Always fast, cheap and good. The baked ziti only costs $7.95 and is fantastic!! Also obsessed with their large Sicilian slices. Great value. Update: this place is still amazing and I'm so glad they are open during covid. Got my favorite mushroom pizza with extra sauce delivered in 25 min and so good! read more

See all

Local Pizzaria and my brother favorite place. I don't know how long Tony's Pizza has been opened but my family order from this restaurant for long time and sometimes we sit outside the place. Pizza is good, my favorite is spicy oil pizza, simple and original. Sometimes in summer I also get Italian Icey and enjoy the weather. read more

See all

Ive been a Williamsburg native since 1988. Tony's has and still is a big staple in my family. Todays visit was quite uncomfortable and unpleasant. I've been in the hospitality and restaurant management business for over a decade, and calling guests pet names as they're simply trying to cast a quick to go order is something I wouldn't tolerate to keep a business rep shining. Once is fine. I shot him a dark look when he called me "sweety". I know he knew I wasn't with it cause his head recoiled back when I looked up at him. A bit of frustration in my voice, I continued my order. Then the names got more intense and rolling in. "Baby" "My Love" "Honey" What's going on man? This wouldn't happen on Phil's watch so maybe y'all should have a quick meeting before opening tomorrow. My father comes to your establishment every single day as he still lives in the neighborhood. Whoever that tall young man with the braids and wearing a mask is.... he needs to take it down a notch. Women don't like it. Especially 35 year old married women who just want to pay and go. He knew it was bothering and kept egging it on. absolutely disgusting. Pizza was soggy. read more

Love the many pizza options they have. Everything was so delicious here. Cute little spot with tables. It's cash only! read more

See all

embodies a classic slice shop energy. i've lived all over, but after moving to the area, i am proud to report that the best pizza in ny IS in my neighborhood. normal wait time, maybe 5 mins. read more

Incredibly good upside down pan pizza. I'm craving it just writing this review. :) What a gem Tony's is. I'm so glad I took a chance and ordered. Delivery was prompt. My pizza was a little expensive but I am happy to support a local restaurant these days especially when the pie is this good. Also this hearty pizza lasted me for DAYS in the fridge--so it felt worth it. Can't wait to eat pizza from Tony's again. I'm a pizza snob and I regret not going here sooner. The pan pizza is basically deep dish pizza. Loved it. read more

See all

Hands down best slice of pizza I've found in Brooklyn. Their Spicy Vodka blows prince streets out of the water and I love prince street! Very impressed I had to go back and get another slice after I finished my first one read more

Not sure why this place is not rated better. Very good standard slice. Chewy crispy crust like John's Bleecker Street.

Great pizza! We just stopped in for a slice on our way to a party but boy they didn't disappoint! The pizza was flavorful and the crust was crisp, what else could a girl ask for?! read more

Tony's Brooklyn Pizza - Supreme pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Passing through the old work neighborhood warranted a stop by Tony's on Graham just the way you'd expect an NYC slice to be, so a piece or two! The upside-down here is the tops as well. So many choices out here but Tony's is setting the bar in good olde fashion neighborhood pizza. More content here! https://www.instagram.com/p/CFDepeypsGV/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link read more

Tony's Brooklyn Pizza - Classic NYC slice. Brooklyn pizza at it's finest! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

There are A LOT of gourmet pizza spots around Williamsburg. Personally, I am a fan of a classic slice with a crispy thin crust. Although nothing fancy, this place has THE best classic slice. The cheese and sauce ratio is perfect, the crust is sturdy yet thin and crispy. If you're looking for a great OG Brooklyn slice, this is the spot! read more

Great service everyone is so nice!! This burger was delicious and the slices were so good specially vodka slice!! read more

Tony's Brooklyn Pizza - If you didn't know they have the best burgers too!! This was delicious definitely will back to this place - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Pizza is good but oddly always better when you get a pie to go. Not sure how long their slices stay out but they never are as good as an order to go. They do have a great variety of non-pizza items they even includes cookies. A very old school Brooklyn pizzeria. read more

I'm biased. I've been eating Tony's Pizzeria since the EARLY 70's. This is... The BEST pizza in the UNIVERSE. For Over 50 years. Today, I got 2 squares and a minnie pie read more

Owners behind the counter making the food , 2 brothers . great guys . Pizza was great . Best pizza in Williamsburg. These guys got integrity! read more

Tony's Brooklyn Pizza - Vodka slice n cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I'm so happy I found this restaurant on Grubhub. All of my food was delicious. Definitely will order from here again.

I conducted the ultimate taste test in a Brooklyn Pizza Restaurant. I got 1 Cheese & 1 Pepperoni slice. Garlic salt, grated cheese, oregano, and hits. What can I say?Perfect. Perfect Cheese slice, hands down. Can't wait to explore the calzones,etc. read more

Via Vespucci is not a bad place to start craving pizza, as there are so many options to pick from. Words on the charming awning said it was established in 1950 which was part of the reason I picked it. Was dreaming about fresh pizza right out of the oven and this place did not disappoint. We got the sausage and pepperoni pizza and split it between three. The wait for the pizza wasn't too long, and we sat on the bench outside while we waited. As soon as we got the box, the aroma of pizza wafted up and I knew we were in for a good meal. The first thing I smelled was this sweetness that was intoxicating -- that came in the form of the tomato sauce and also the dough. I loved the balance of this sweeter tomato sauce with the umami of the pepperoni and the sausage, mellowed out but the pie. A bite was perfectly balanced. Would definitely come back and order here when I'm in the area as I have no complaints. They do delivery, too. read more

Came here to grab salad and pizza slice. I'm super crazy about expiration and "freshness", but this time I haven't done this and was super relaxed. And off course (bad luck) the salad was extra old. When I started to eat it, I was super far away and didn't want to go back. Everything was beautiful in this salad- old dry and absolutely non eatable, salad was old with black spots. So obviously I garbage it. 2 starts because pizza was eatable. read more

Great pizza and service !! The server was very sweet and the pizza was phenomenal !! Had a great experience at Tony's pizza

Tony's pizzeria has been consistent with their pizzas for years. It has one of the tastiest slices in the neighborhood just a slight edge over it's neighbor across the way (Carmines) Definitely a good slice. read more

Let's start with important part: Tony's is the best slice in New York. Source: A guy who's hosted several food and travel shows, eaten at nearly every pizza joint in the 5 boroughs, and who wants nothing more than for you to experience the best piece of pizza NYC has to offer. And that's what they're serving over at Tony's. Now, there's this thing where every New Yorker claims that their neighborhood joint is actually *the best* pizza spot in town, and I assure you that is not what is happening here. That said, I lived across the street from Tony's for 9+ years... But it's also worth noting that I stayed at that apt. through 4 rent hikes specifically because I didn't wanna live even 1 inch further away from Tony's pizza heaven. In fact, it's quite possible that my refusal to move away from Tony's is the sole reason my last relationship fell apart: HER: I wanna get a new place and move in together. ME: I don't wanna live anywhere that isn't across the street from Tony's. HER: You're saying a pizza place is more important to you than a 3+ year relationship? ME: I'm not saying it is, and I'm not saying it isn't. ...And scene. And let me tell you, Tony's makes some damn fine pizza for getting over a break up. Now the sign out front says "Tony's Pizza; Pasta, Seafood, Steaks, Hero's" but there certainly isn't any steaks or seafood, and you're not here to order pasta or hero's (although I'm sure they're great). What you wanna do is a get a slice of the Margherita, and a slice of the Pepperoni, and a Grandma slice. Or my personal favorite, a slice of the plain cheese, which is so soft and thin you could roll it up like a cigar and smoke the grease. This is the kind of pizza you'd see in the old Ninja Turtles cartoons. Btw what was up with the main bad guy in that show? Krang? He was just like a brain that could talk or something? But he also lived in that tall dude's stomach? And somehow he's also like the boss of Shredder and all those foot soldiers? While living in a dude's stomach?!?!? Uhhhhh-What? read more

Tony triggered my trust issues. After a long day and a whole lot of dreaming about a nice slice of pizza, I was met with Tony's Pizza. After a discussion with a friend about where we were going eat, we decided on this place. Why? I'm not so sure anymore. The delivery was okay timing and the delivery man wished me a good night, thanks man, but when I opened the box expecting to see a glimmering beacon of light, it just brought me back to the sad realities. Once the first bite came, I knew something was wrong. I immediately raided my kitchen for any type of spice or cheese to salvage what was lost. Nothing. Absolutely nothing. I finally gave up. Not even two slices in after hours of hunger, I couldn't do it anymore. Thanks Tony for only making life worse and reminding me to never trust anyone. read more

Tony's Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Definitely our favorite pizza place. If you're going to Williamsburg Brooklyn you definitely need to stop by this place and eat some really yummy italiano dishes.. very conveniently located by the Graham ave on the L train.. read more

See all

TONY!!! I have to say, I have lived around the corner from dear Tony's for nearly half a year now. I walk by it every day on the way to the L. I wave to the Italian guys out front like we know each other but we have only ever exchanged niceties. FINALLY, only the other day did I cross the threshold and enter into pizza kingdom, truly. Of the many things of note to gleefully report: They have carb on carb pizza..as in pasta on a slice of baked dough. Classics are offered as well, like deep dish and thin crust- we ordered two deep dish style (one with bread crumbs on top) and one margarita thin slice and one long and thick cheese LOAF. What is the loaf? It was a cheese slice that brought me back to the elementary school cafeteria pizza in the best way possible- sheets of pizza sliced longitudinally so as to be placed swiftly in one's gullet. AMAZING. The this crust here is truly unparalleled, as I am a crispy and cronchy aficionato, you can take my word for it. Use caution in attacking the pies, they come out of the oven piping hot. Thanks Tony, I will be back soon. read more

Moved to Long Island from Queens and all I can say is when you leave the boroughs the one thing you'll miss is good pizza. I don't quite get why they can't make good pizza on the island. Fortunate for me I'm working in Brooklyn and get to enjoy pizza once again and Tony's will not disappoint. Perfectly cooked crust, the right amount of cheese and delicious sauce are the simple ingredients for any pizza but Tony's takes those things and create a pizza masterpiece. In fact the other day I picked up a pie for my 1 hour commute home and my kid could t believe how delicious it was. My wife had a chicken roll and it also didn't disappoint. I know there are so many pizzerias to choose from in this area but for an old school pizzeria without the fancy gimmicks that Millennials and the Gen Z's need to eat at so that they can over pay but feel fancy, Tony's is the place to go to for absolutely delicious pizza. read more